Barahir bowed his head, sick at heart. Many thoughts flew through his head. "This is what
Morgoth loves best, when two who should be united against him fight amongst themselves. Should we
bow to his will, to he who the
Valar cast out three
ages agp? We think he is gone, but we allow him to live by allowing ourselves to be corrupted by pride or power.
Elrond has reason for anger, but why will he not trust the Valar? Surely he does not think
Maedhros could fool
Mandos into freeing him for a dubious cause. Melkors malice works on in the form of the
dragon, which no doubt has been haunting Maedhros' path, trying to thwart his aim. I thought Elrond, renowned for his wisdom, would be able to put aside his grievances and forgive. Hate is long in dying. All my life I have served Elrond, but now our paths must part. I have given my word to Maedhros, and I, like him, will not break my word."
Barahir spoke, "Lord Elrond, if you do not grant forgiveness to this lord to whom I have sworn alleigence, our ways part. I have been honored to be in your following all my life, and am grieved to leave this fair island or peace, but my spoken word, as that of Maedhros, will not be broken. If
Eru wills it, may our paths meet again before you leave this land. If we are to depart, may we reclaim our
weapons? Or do you now not trust any who will forgive an old enemy who has forsaken
evil?" He paused, "I do not wish to appear impudent by my words, lord. I only wish we would not repeat the past by dividing our forces when the foe aproaches. I have a measure of the forsight of my people, at times; this dragon is not the worst enemy you shall find disturbing the peace of
Imladris. Another spirit of Morgoth walks this land, one who seeks the death of more than one elf-lord returned from Mandos. Imladris will not be safe from his malice. Unless all who denounce the Darkness join together, no Light shall survive."
With this, Barahir walked quickly from the room, seeking his weapons and
horse. He had hoped for rest and peace for a while, at least, but Imladris was to be a refuge for him no longer.
(edited to add more dialogue)