The choice of the Half-Elven... and no choice at all

[Gothmog]

It may well be true that there are Half-Elven that we have not been told about who were given the choice. However, even if this is true it does not change my statement that not all Peredhil were given this choice. It could only be those still alive after Eärendil's errend to Valinor who would have this offer. Before Eärendil spoke with the Valar Manwe had not been given this power of Doom for the Peredhil.

 

[Confusticated]

However, even if this is true it does not change my statement that not all Peredhil were given this choice.

I agree.

I was only addressing Lantarion's statement and reference to the quote posted by Tar-Elenion from HoMe 5.

 

[Gothmog]

Originally posted by Nóm
I was only addressing Lantarion's statement and reference to the quote posted by Tar-Elenion from HoMe 5.

I could see that but I felt that it needed to be cleared up in relation to the time line showing from when the choice could be offered.