The identity of the Lord of the 💀Nazgul

[SpencerC18]

I don't think that you guys should be so defensive on Uliiri, you guys have read the books before so it's not like you can't make up decisions and theories on your own. Everybody makes mistakes (more than once) so calm down. I'm not trying to but in your discussion or anything but I doubt he cares if Greenwood puts Ulairi on his ignore list. lol

 

[SpencerC18]

Oh and also, TOM BOMBADIL is the witch king! Prove me wrong! hahahahahaha

 

[Greenwood]

Originally posted by SpencerC18
I don't think that you guys should be so defensive on Uliiri, you guys have read the books before so it's not like you can't make up decisions and theories on your own. Everybody makes mistakes (more than once) so calm down. I'm not trying to but in your discussion or anything but I doubt he cares if Greenwood puts Ulairi on his ignore list. lol

SpencerC18

Mistakes are forgivable and as you say everyone makes them. However, Ulairi has been caught intentionally misrepresenting Tolkien's writing just so he could sit back and laugh at people arguing over the misrepresentations he has tossed out. That is not a mistake, that is dishonest and malicious behavior. Ulairi enjoys a good discussion, as do most people here. If he sees that people will no longer discuss things with him because they do not trust him, perhaps he will mend his ways and discuss things in an honest way.

 

[SpencerC18]

Im pretty sure if he wanted to be "malicious" he would do something a bit more drastic. lol good lord, chill out, he was wrong give em a break

 

[Úlairi]

Originally posted by Pontifex
Well now that's impossible to say (I'd guess he was one of the Kings or princes of Númenor, dubbed with magical powers by Sauron, but it's just a thepry..), but I will state that he most certainly was not Pallando or Alatar, as has been explained already, I believe. Just to emphasize, A and P were Maiar, and it does say that the Nine Rings were meant for Mortal Men, "doomed to die". But I see my ranting is futile.
I am interested with this 'Herumor-Fuinir'- theory, I have not heard of them before (I have almost finished UT, but I have found no mention of them). I see now that they probably were not Nazgûl, because they arrived too late. Now I fully understand the term "Black Númenórean", thank you Bucky.

Well, I guess I've lost a few friends I thought I'd had, especially you Pontifex. I guess, just as Harad did, I have let my pride be my downfall, and now I guess it's time to patch things up with you guys. Thankyou SpencerC18 for coming to my defence, but I concede the fact that what they are saying is right. I have been like Harad and have disregarded arguments that do not help me win my arguments. From here on in, I will listen to all arguments presented and will pay heed to them. Yes Bucky, I need a piece of humble pie and let me tell you, it doesn't taste very nice.

 

[Greenwood]

Ulairi

No need to compare yourself to Harad. It would have been unthinkable for Harad to post a message like your last one.

 

[Úlairi]

Yes, he never would apologise to anyone would he? In some areas though, I can be compared to Harad, such as pride. His intelligence resulted in his pride, and that is happening to me also. I am considering making a public apology to everyone on the forum.

 

[SpencerC18]

What I really enjoy about this forum is anybody can have a really serious discussion in a mature manner. I don't think I have seen anybody make fun of anybody or even cuss. lol

Hey Greenwood, no hard feelings, I just thought you were a little drastic. lol

 

[Úlairi]

Don't underestimate me SpencerC18, I have, as Greenwood has said, done those things and I wasn't wrong, I knew I was and I got other people arguing with me when I knew what I had said was wrong. I would say that is in a way 'malicious'. This time I was wrong however.

 

[Greenwood]

SpencerC18

No hard feelings. And there will be no hard feelings against Ulairi if he behaves himself.

 

[Úlairi]

I promise from here on in Greenwood. Scout's honour.