• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring Oscar Results!

Originally posted by baraka

Wrong , it should definitely NOT have won Best Director. With all the "liberties" he took, it would have been wrong to award him with a Best Director trophy.


the man spent years on the film of course he should have won best director, as he did in this country, making a film is different to writing a book he had to make changes. So since you insist that everyone else is wrong, then i have to say that i'm right and you are so wrong.
 
To think that he might have been denied Best Director by the Academy because of liberities he took with the book is completely illogical.
Why is it illogical? What if the people who "vote" for the Oscars were tolkien fans annoyed with the "liberties". (At least some of them). That could be a possibility (remote one) and therefore the premise that "because of the liberties he didn't win an oscar" is not illogical. The term would be improbable.
the man spent years on the film of course he should have won best director, as he did in this country,
Because he spent years on the film he sould have won an oscar, Why? Time spent in a project doesn't translate to quality of the project. I thought the movie was great, but the director didn't deservean "Oscar". It appears I'm not alone in that position.
So since you insist that everyone else is wrong, then i have to say that i'm right and you are so wrong.
Where have i said that everyone else is wrong? Find that quote if you will. That was my personal opinion.
making a film is different to writing a book he had to make changes.
Of course he had to make changes, but did he have to alter some characters that do not go into the spirit of the "book". (Ex: Arwen, elven princess by day, warrion enchantress by night.). Other changes: The name of Bilbo's Book, the omision of Tom. (How about my friend Lindir)
 
I am so dissapointed that lotr did not get Best Director and Best Picture. I thought it would at least get 8 awards...if not more...guess i was wrong. As for peter jackson not deserving an oscar...hmph. Peter Jackson spent seven years on the trilogy and as we have all seen the fotr is now one of the best if not THE best movie of all time. I know people have different opinions so i will not say any more...but to clear up one more thing...has anyone seen Arwen fight? Has she done anything other than ride a horse and wave a sword? Has she joined the fellowship of the ring and has she gone with them to slay some orcs...NO! therefore i do not think she's a warrior princess, as some of you kept on insisting.

All in all, well done to Halle Berry and Denzel Washington! Tough luck for peter jackson and fran walsh...maybe they'll get something next year...let's all cross our fingers!
 
The term is illogical. I grant you that your scenario is possible but I guarantee you that it is not the case. Even though this was a completely improbable scenario you put it forth as the reason PJ didn't get Best Director. That is illogical.
 
Logic

Let's see a definition of logical.
logical

adj 1: capable of or reflecting the capability for correct and valid reasoning.
Source: WordNet ® 1.6, © 1997 Princeton University
probable:

adj 1: Likely but uncertain; plausible.
Source: The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition
I grant you that your scenario is possible
By your own admission, my premise is improbable. My reasoning although "biased" is still logical because is a "valid reasoning" which is highly unlikely.
but I guarantee you that it is not the case.
How do you know that, were you a member of the Academy and knew all the voters? How can you be certain of it? Did someone told you?
guarantee n.
1. Something that assures a particular outcome or condition.
Source: The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition
Where is your guarantee?
you put it forth as the reason PJ didn't get Best Director.
What I said was:
With all the "liberties" he took, it would have been wrong to award him with a Best Director trophy.
In my quote, where do I put it forth as the reason PJ didn't get Best Director. I didn't write that. That is my personal opinion.
 
Re: Logic

Originally posted by baraka
By your own admission, my premise is improbable. My reasoning although "biased" is still logical because is a "valid reasoning" which is highly unlikely.
I don't think you know what you mean. That statement is indecipherable. I'll say this though - regardless of what your definition says, uncertainty (which you changed to 'unlikely') is not a requirement for illogic, as you seem to be implying. A premise is considered logical if it's not necessarily proven but it is likely. Your's was neither.

How do I know? I live and breathe! I know enough about human nature and reasoning that I can personally guarantee you that there were not enough people who voted against PJ for 'your reason' to cost him the award. I can also guarantee you that Jodie Foster is not sitting by her phone right now trying to get up to nerve to call and ask me out!

Originally posted by baraka
In my quote, where do I put it forth as the reason PJ didn't get Best Director. I didn't write that. That is my personal opinion.
With all the "liberties" he took, it would have been wrong to award him with a Best Director trophy.
Maybe you didn't say that WAS the reason but you're suggesting that liberties taken are grounds to vote against PJ for an Oscar. That has nothing to do with the award and the Academy would never vote on that basis.

I weary so of this debate. I declare myself the victor because it would be wrong to declare you as such because of the liberties you've taken with my time debating this.
 
We all have extremely biest opinions, as do I. I had hoped that it might win as high as even 10-11 of its Oscars. Hmmmmm, I wonder when a certain movie-basher is going to come in?!
 
Yes LOTR should have won it.

But then again A beautiful Mind was a very very good film if i may say. It was really sad though
 
Originally posted by Ulairi
We all have extremely biest opinions, as do I. I had hoped that it might win as high as even 10-11 of its Oscars. Hmmmmm, I wonder when a certain movie-basher is going to come in?!



Ahem....

FoTR deserved 7 awards....three of which it did not get.....

Costume
Art Design
Song


That is it.....For someone who hated the movie, I think that is very liberal of me, is it not?
 
Last edited:

I'll tell you how...they don't vote for what kind of work went into the costumes, how much fabric was used or how many costumes were made, they vote for which costumes looked best, best suited the film and made the most impact on the story...


When he said that it "was after all an acting movie" he meant that, having 3 times dialog and none of the action of LotR or Blackhawk Down it was heavily dependent on the actors to carry it. Of the two films, "A Beautifull Mind" and "The Fellowship of the Ring", which do you suppose would have suffered the most with the same effects, cinematography, art direction and all but with slightly less apt actors? Conversely, were you to keep all the same actors and diminish the amount of Action and Effects in both films, which do you suppose would suffer the most?
 
A premise is considered logical if it's not necessarily proven but it is likely.
I grant you that your scenario is possible but I guarantee you that it is not the case.
So, you are saying that my "scenario" is possible, yet you say a "premise" is considered logical if it's not necessarily proven but it is likely. Hmmmmm.
How come is not logical? You, have said it is posible. Have you not contradicted yourself.

! I know enough about human nature and reasoning that I can personally guarantee you that there were not enough people who voted against PJ for 'your reason' to cost him the award.
Ok, I'm a reasonable person, give me some "concrete evidence" of that and i will be pleased.

That has nothing to do with the award and the Academy would never vote on that basis.
I agree with that, what I said was a personal opinion.

I weary so of this debate. I declare myself the victor because it would be wrong to declare you as such because of the liberties you've taken with my time debating this.
I don't know about that. I never asked you to "reply" to my initial statement. I wasn't my fault that you misinterpreted something i wrote. I'm also weary of this pointless debate, but my posts will not be called illogical by anyone.
 
SO sorry, HOW in all of middle earth could enya NOT win her oscar?? ok, her performance wasn't up to scratch, but it's about the movie not the performance!!! And Mckellen?? It is such hollow rubbish, in my opinion the stupid academy didn't know what they were voting for. Have they read the book? I'm willing to bet not!! AND fotr deserved best film, it is by far. At least we have next year too, and the next, but we better win both of those!! Just my humble opinion! (ok, not so humble, perhaps!)
 
You equate possible with likely. No I have not contradicted myself.


Originally posted by baraka
Ok, I'm a reasonable person, give me some "concrete evidence" of that and i will be pleased.
No.

Originally posted by baraka
I agree with that, what I said was a personal opinion.
I agree with what I said too.

Crazy statements need replies. Too late. Illogical is the label. Don't worry, you can tuck it under your clothes.
 
You equate possible with likely. No I have not contradicted myself.
likely
1. Within the realm of credibility; plausible.
Source: The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition

possible:
1. Capable of happening, existing, or being true without contradicting proven facts, laws, or circumstances.
Source: The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition

Here are the definitions. They are "very similar".

Ok, I'm a reasonable person, give me some "concrete evidence" of that and i will be pleased.
What, are you afraid?
Crazy statements need replies. Too late. Illogical is the label.
Prove it!
 
Oh, dear. Look what I've started. *sighs*

I agree that, after all, he did spend a great amount of time with it. I mean, seven years is quite a long time. I would have been nine when he started. And I've waited for the movie for five years now, and I was positivly sure that it would win Best Picture. Although I think that The Two Towers will have trouble next year, because of Star Wars. I remeber when Episode 1 came out. It took home a lot of awards, but you never know. I still hope The Two Towers will win some awards next year.
 
Originally posted by baraka
Here are the definitions. They are "very similar".
No they aren't. They are different points along a spectrum.

Originally posted by baraka
What, are you afraid?
Yes, deathly afraid. Afraid that you might look up another word and contort the definition.

Originally posted by baraka
Prove it!

Originally posted by PRH
To think that he might have been denied Best Director by the Academy because of liberities he took with the book is completely illogical.
There's where I labeled you. There's the proof.
 
To think that he might have been denied Best Director by the Academy because of liberities he took with the book is completely illogical.
There's where I labeled you. There's the proof.
A mere statement is not a proof. Give me some "concrete" and undeniable evidence and you can convince me.
 
Good grief, Baraka and PRH, give it a rest!

Nobody here really cares about how you guys interpret the word "illogical". Change the train of thought or duke it out in private messages!!!!

Let's get back to what really matters....FoTR bashing.
 
Gotta give credit where credit is due

Originally posted by Thorin

Let's get back to what really matters....FoTR bashing.

Although you are on my ultra purist target list and I hardly ever agree with any of you views, I have to admit that is pretty good. But that doesnt mean were friends just yet.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…