Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.
Register
I was really excited when i was watching them because i only saw the first couple of awards- it was late and my stupid school starts at 7:30 . So, i was like yay! 2 for 4! Through the whole thing i was clapping for FOTR and being yelled at by my dad (QUIET DOWN!- lol)
SO anyway i was really disappointed- Ian McKellen shoukd have won and FOTR should have received best picture-sigh-at least we have two more chances-but don't expect TTT to beat Attack of the Clones!
Well, no Oscars. It was nominated for Sound, Sound Effects Editing and Visual Effects - all of which it lost to The Matrix (a thorn deep in my side to this day).
Okay, now to the real question: Did PJ deserved an Oscar for his work on FOTR? It's true that he undertook a great project, definitely the biggest of all the movies that i competed for the Oscars. He did a great job, he took the necessary steps and patience to make this movie a "work of art". The way ME look was fantastic. To me the dialogues and the interaction between the characters left something to be desired. (Not that it was not good.)
Did he deserved an Oscar for best director?
NO. But that's my personal opinion and I'm "biased" against PJ because of all the "liberties" he took in making the movie. (Ex. Arwen, elven princess by day, warrior enchantress by night).
Well, out of the movies (didn't see Mullholland Drive - saw the rest), it should've been PJ or Altman. Giving it to Howard was just politics. As much as I detest Moulin Rouge, Baz Luhrman should probably have been at least nominated.
If liberties with the book were to be taken into consideration, it should affect the screenplay category and not the direction category.
Since I don't want to write all that stuff all over again, I direct everybody to look at what I wrote about how great Gollum is in the thread here just called Oscars. Yay Gollum! Also, I don't post here much, because like the super scary Thorin dude, I don't think that the movies will ever compare to the books. So ummmm......tell people what I said, okay?
Originally posted by PRH If liberties with the book were to be taken into consideration, it should affect the screenplay category and not the direction category.
But as Greenwood has pointed out, liberties taken from a source material don't even matter in that category. The only people to whom this matters are people like us (non-Academy-voting Tolkien freaks), and even here the amount of liberties taken by PJ is a matter of opinion.
But as Greenwood has pointed out, liberties taken from a source material don't even matter in that category. The only people to whom this matters are people like us (non-Academy-voting Tolkien freaks), and even here the amount of liberties taken by PJ is a matter of opinion.
Wrong. Best Picture, Hmmmmm. Best director "definitely, absolutely" not because of all the "liberties" he took in making the movie. It would have been a shame to reward someone who "cut" certain parts of the book by giving him an oscar.
Actually the amount of liberties Jackson took with the story is quite well documented as we have both the book and the movie available to compare. The Academy couldn't give a dingo's kidney though as to how accurate the adaptation was...
As I have said at the begining of this thread I do not think that he did not win for best picture or director because it is A FANTASY MOVIE Academy Award has always been political right so LOTR did not have a chance with a Beatiful mind