• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145
I don't feel that the film changed all the important stuff from the book in such a great manner. For instance, it left this taste of bitter-sweet, without a lemonade-effect. (or should I say soap - opera effect?) Nothing in the film feels absolutely happy... And as for the revision of characters - let's be honest. What characters? T himself admitted that many of his characters were truly undeveloped! so, if you already have a pale character - why not adding some life into it, again, in your own interpretation! But still, without leaving true essence of the book! <quote Melian La Fey>
But the essence of the characters were changed. They were not just "developed", they were actually changed. This is going to affect the overall meaning of the story, especially if the characters are central to the story. A cynical, bitter Elrond is a far cry from Tolkien's gentle counselor. A frightened Aragorn who detests and refuses his heritage is not just "different" from the book's Aragorn but diametric to him. And as Aragorn is a central character not only plot-wise but certainly with respect to the entire meaning of the tale, those changes are seminal.

True, many of Tolkien's peripheral characters were not developed. For one thing, they didn't have to be. For instance, Glorfindel only appears once in the story as does Tom Bombadil. Most of the time, these characters are only there to fill a need in the story. For the author to have developed them all would have been both extremely time consuming and, frankly, unnecessary. Consider, if you will, in other books how many characters appear and disappear, fulfilling some function in the plot but whom the author never "develops". This is normal in any story.

There was no need for Tolkien to completely develop every character who appears in the book. And, in fact, had Jackson been true to Tolkien, Aragorn certainly did "develop" as a character over the course of the story. He goes from a mere "Ranger" and becomes a king. The difference is, it is our knowledge of the character that develops, not the character himself! And that is the difference.

Then, too, consider the changes that Jackson made to his own characters. Gandalf is "spot on" in the first two films - and becomes an entirely different person in the third! What sense does that make? No, I'm sorry, Jackson made a hash of many of his characters to the great detriment of the films.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
No, I'm sorry, Jackson made a hash of many of his characters to the great detriment of the films.

Say rather to the great detriment of your enjoyment of the films. Theoden is the only character that comes to mind who is a hash, and detrimental because of it.
 
Gandalf White said:
Say rather to the great detriment of your enjoyment of the films. Theoden is the only character that comes to mind who is a hash, and detrimental because of it.

I disagree with your "take" on the matter. I was responding to Ms. LeFay who states that these changes were made "...without leaving true essence of the book!". My "enjoyment" or lack thereof is not what's being discussed. What is being discussed is whether or not Jackson's revisionism changed the meaning of the story. I say that one cannot fundamentally change characters whose motives and actions present the integral meaning of the story without changing that meaning - even if they perform whatever physical actions they were supposed to perform in the plot. Motive is everything! If I accidentally bring about your demise, the State takes a very different view of my actions than it would if I were to "off" you for the insurance money! That's what "motive" is all about. Actions are secondary to the reasons which resulted in those actions. Thus Jackson could have the characters do everything that they did in the book (which, of course, he didn't) and still make such fundamental changes in the motives and personas of his characters as to make them unrecognizeable without their "names".

Let me make an illustration: Jackson's Aragorn eventually becomes king of Gondor, thus fulfilling - at least superficially - what he does in the book. However, not even Jackson's staunchest supporter can allege that the resemblence between the characters - book and film - goes any further than the most superficial actions on the part of both. Their motives are diametric not only with regard to "power" but even with regard to Arwen. Tolkien's Aragorn has sought her, while the lady is the pursuer in the films. I cannot imagine how anyone can say that the character's actions do not fundamentally change the character and his meaning in the story - and hence, the story's meaning as well.

Multiply this by the number of characters Jackson seriously changed including his best character "bookwise" - Gandalf (in the last film) - and perforce you have a change in the meaning and essence of the story. No other conclusion is logical or credible. And again, none of this has anything to do with whether or not one enjoyed these changes.
 
When do you interpret "the entire meaning of the tale"? In the beginning of the story, the middle, the end? Most would say 'the end' I think, especially given the use of the term "entire; and by the end of the film Aragorn has fully embraced his heritage, remarkably, JUST LIKE BOOK ARAGORN.

Please explain what fundamental deeper meaning of Tolkien's was lost by this change to the character of Aragorn.
 
Sadly, I will say this again - and it is not intended to be insulting, believe me - but if one cannot see the difference between someone who spends a life of self-sacrifice and service in hopes of eventually gaining his inheritance (and with it, his betrothed) and someone who is dragged kicking and screaming into his inheritance, then there really isn't much to say.

Tolkien's Aragorn is a true "hidden king", living a life of service to the people of Middle-earth (most of whom are both ignorant and distinctly ungrateful like the Breelanders). He waits only for the time when he may actually put forth his claim - that is without plunging Middle-earth into war or Gondor into civil war. That opportunity comes with the revelation of the discovery of the Ring when, at last, open war with Sauron must happen. Even then, however, Aragorn does not put forth his claim openly, fearing that to do so would cause discord in Gondor at the height of the crisis. It is only after Denethor's death and Sauron's fall that he is willing to claim what is his by right of lineage. Tolkien's Aragorn does not need Elrond to tell him to "go be what you were born to be..." as does Jackson's character. He is what he was born to be from the first moment we meet him, albeit he does not flaunt that fact.

If that is too fine a distinction between the two, then I simply do not know what to tell you. In fact, it makes worlds of difference in the essential meaning and vision of the story. The fact that both characters wind up in the same place in the end is totally beside the point.
 
I know the events that transpired. Believe it or not, I even recognize the difference between the two characters. What I don't get is, specifically, what deeper meaning was carried on the back of Aragorn as portrayed in the book and was sacrificed in the movie?

Yes, movie Aragorn was conflicted, you might even say besieged with doubt, but how does that change the meaning of the story? Do these doubts make his actions in the face of them less noble, or more? Less admirable, or more? Wasn't movie Aragorn also a Ranger of the North? Didn't he also live that life of service and sacrifice, maybe not to gain his inheritance, but just as an end in itself? I am not sure why you find the former so much more noble.

Was Tolkien trying to tell us that great people are born great, always know they're great, and, when not engaged in greatness, just waiting for the right time and place to unleash their wellspring of greatness on an unsuspecting world? They suffer no doubts, take no pause, and always have a clear vision of where they are heading? I never took that from the story personally.

One of the essential themes of Tolkien's LoTR, maybe the essential theme, IMO, is that the greatest of acts sometimes come from the most unlikely of sources, sources who sometimes, even themselves, doubt their own ability to carry out that which is laid before them. See the entire story of Frodo for further clarification on this point. Jackson's changes to Aragorn only accentuate this theme as far as I'm concerned.
 
I have to agree with Parrot, here. Aragorn with doubts feels far more real than perfect Aragorn with a clean agenda. Now, I didn't mean this to sound blunt (is that a right word?), I'm just stating that doubt becomes Aragorn's character! And when I mentioned that Tolkien's characters were undeveloped, I didn't mean the peripheral ones (of course!), but the main characters... I found the real depth was given to Sam and Aragorn, but only in the third book, we can feel the developing arc from the beggining to the end, Gandalf's just Gandalf, one of the best protrayed characters - no comment there, and all others seem a bit pale... But it is when we read the book over and over again, and read the appendices (which are very important in understanding the entire story, IMO) that we begin to see depth of the characters. Like a detail I noticed - that Legolas left ME after Aragorn's death, even though the sea was calling him... why? They were probably very good friends. And I only got that "feeling" after I read the appendix! Not during reading the book! Aragorn's and Arwen's story? In the book all you read is a short glance they share in Rivendell and the wedding in the end! And of course, the banner. Just glimpses of a truly beautiful story. And then we read the appendices and the chapter about them, and realise what a wonderful tale it is. but you cannot expect movie makers to make an "appendix" to the film! so, placing that story, with a changed chronology does seem right to me! What they speak to each other in Rivendell, probably happened 30 years before in Lothlorien, or maybe Rivendell, I'm not sure. the scene of Aragorn's funeral, with Elrond's "cynical" words are straight from the appendices. It doesn't matter that much who said what about their love story, more that it was said. Like, how Arwen spent the rest of her life bound to sorrow under the fading trees...
And Elrond didn't seem cynical to me. He was bitter, yes, but not just bitter. He was about to leave his beloved daughter to die, alone. of course he was going to object that! Of course he was going to say "there's nothing for you here but death". Because he'll try to convince her. He doesn't want to lose her, no parent would like to outlive his children! Not even the wise Elrond. ANd again, it's logical to assume this conversation happened, perhaps years before the war. but it's important it happened. And what is a "gentle counselor"? He lost his brother and probably all his children to the fate od Mankind. Numenor fell to the gread of Men. Isn't there some grief, some bitterness of the cruel fate? I believe this gives him greater depth then to all others. And in the end he reconsiles with this - he takes Arwen to Aragorn and sails away. Like in the book...
 
I'm afraid I have been over this ground at least once before with another FAD. No, Tolkien is not saying that one is "born" to greatness. Aragorn had enough examples in his own race to know that he could go very bad if wished to do so or if he gave in to temptation - such as to take the Ring. After all, the Ringwraiths were all Black Numenoreans, the same blood as Aragorn and Elendil. Indeed, Isildur had already proven to be less than prudent in his decision to keep the Ring.

And, yes, Tolkien's main point with the hobbits at least, was that great deeds could be - and were - performed by the most unlikely of individuals.

That being said, however, it does not change the fact that Aragorn was in fact a "hidden king" - a very powerful mythological and, even more importantly, Christological figure in the story. To make him into a "reluctant dragon" who falls and/or is pushed into his heritage is to deconstruct a large part of the story that Tolkien is telling. Had he wanted Aragorn to be such a figure, he would have written him that way; he did not.

Did it make for better drama? I don't think so, but perhaps you do. That is a matter of taste. But what cannot be disputed is that Jackson's "version" of the character made a great change in the ultimate meaning of the tale despite the fact that both men wind up on the throne in the end. Tolkien's Aragorn's life is one of sacrifice and humility in preparation for assuming his ultimate destiny. He wishes to be king; it is his choice to be so, but it has been denied to him by prevailing circumstances in Middle-earth. Jackson's character, on the other hand, is quite content to live out his life in obscurity having no greater demands made upon him than to engage in small skirmishes against the forces of evil. A small life for a small man. He rejects his heritage, is terrified of his "weak blood" and, on the whole, wants his erstwhile lover to go into the West to assuage his conscience (that is, so that he won't be responsible for her ultimate mortality). Jackson's Aragorn is a small man who has to grow ten sizes by the last film. Tolkien's Aragorn is a giant - another Elendil, "the hope of his people" according to Elrond - who chooses to live in humility, obscurity and service to others until such time as fate provides him with an opportunity to claim his heritage. Indeed, Tolkien's Aragorn is aware that that opportunity might never come, but he continues to serve the free peoples of Middle-earth without honor or praise because it is his duty - a word which Jackson's Aragorn seems to dismiss out of hand.
 
Tolkien's Aragorn was filled with doubts, especially in the FOTR. Jackson missed a "big time" opportunity to "humanize" Aragorn when he failed utterly to include Tolkien's introduction to the hobbits in Bree wherein he admits that he "hungers" for friendship and trust on his own account and not merely as a companion of the known and trustworthy Gandalf. I would suggest if you see Tolkien's Aragorn as a "cardboard", two-dimensional, that you need to go back and read the man's behavior in FOTR.

Aragorn in the book is anything but "absolutely sure of himself". He tells his companions at Parth Galen that they have chosen a bad leader when they tell him that the choice to follow Frodo or M&P is his to make. He argues with Gandalf about the passage over the mountains and admits to fearing greatly to go into Moria because he had been there once and the memory was "very evil". He even admits that he is not happy with the choice to take the Ring to Mordor!

In short, had Jackson the desire - or perhaps the skill - he could have given us our "hidden king" while still having a more than human enough character! It wasn't necessary to deconstruct the man into some sort of "reluctant dragon" in order to avoid a cartoon superhero. All he had to do was read and act accordingly.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
He wishes to be king; it is his choice to be so, but it has been denied to him by prevailing circumstances in Middle-earth.
Which circumstances are those exactly? The relative peace and prosperity of Gondor that predates the story, during which time he fails to claim the throne? Or the time of great crisis and need we witness in the story, during which time he also fails to claim the throne? Who is he, Goldilocks?

Jackson's character, on the other hand, is quite content to live out his life in obscurity having no greater demands made upon him than to engage in small skirmishes against the forces of evil. A small life for a small man.
He never would have joined, and later assumed leadership of, the fellowship if this truly were the case. Hell, he never would have made contact with the hobbits at the Prancing Pony if that were the case. "Let's see, help out these little guys faced with some of the most dangerous creatures in Middle Earth and likely get myself killed along the way, or sit here and have another pint and a smoke, - whatever should I do? " I think I know what a smalll man would do and it was not what Jackson's Aragorn did.

Oh, it's to assuage his conscience! Here I was thinking it was because he loved her and couldn't bear the thought of her dying, and, as a result, was willing to give up the one thing he truly loved because she had avenues open to her that he did not.

Now I see! That selfish little man, wanting her to go off and be immortal without him.
 
Again, it is possible to excuse Jackson's model using all the arguments that you have done, but they fail to take into account what Tolkien was saying with the character which caused him to act as he did. I have already covered all of the issues you raise at least once and I prefer not to do so again. Suffice it to say that you prefer the "modern" view while I prefer the "classic". You see mine (Tolkien's) as stilted, one-dimensional and predictable. I see yours (Jackson's) as weak, vacillating and self-absorbed. So be it. To each his own.
 
Mrs. Maggott said:
Again, it is possible to excuse Jackson's model using all the arguments that you have done, but they fail to take into account what Tolkien was saying with the character which caused him to act as he did.
That's what I'm asking; what was he trying to say that the movie skewed to the point of being "diametric"?
 
Parrot said:
That's what I'm asking; what was he trying to say that the movie skewed to the point of being "diametric"?
Last post on this topic for me - I've done it too often:

1. Tolkien's Aragorn was a hidden king; Jackson's was a king in hiding. Sounds similar but is diametric.

A hidden king has not renounced his duty to his people, he is simply unable to step forward and assume that duty openly. In fact, he has all of the responsibility and hard work with none of the glory. Throughout his life, Aragorn acts as a king to the West in general and to Gondor in particular when the opportunity avails itself (see Thorongil and the defeat of the Corsairs during the reign of Ecthelion). He and his few remaining kinsmen in the North protect the folk living there, something that is not needed in the South where the entire well armed kingdom of Gondor performs that duty. He makes himself available to serve (and that's the operative word here) whenever Elrond or Gandalf or Galadriel - or even he himself - become aware of a need for his service (such as the hunt for Gollum). One small example of this self-effacing service happens at the feast given by Elrond after the hobbits arrive at Rivendell. Everyone is there but Aragorn even though his betrothed Arwen is present. Why isn't he there? Because he needed to hear news brought by Elrond's sons from their journeys; duty before pleasure.

On the other hand, a king in hiding is running from his responsibilities. He is fearful of his birthright. And while he might be the bravest fellow on the battlefield, he is a moral coward when it comes to being willing to assume the place of the guy in charge upon whom all responsibility lies. In the end, Jackson has him assume that role but to me, it is far too late! Aragorn is over 80 when Sauron falls. For him to gain enough courage in the last few months of those 80 years to be what he was supposed to be from the beginning ain't promising! It might make for great drama, but I wouldn't want him for my king! Who knows when he might decide he didn't like the restrictions, duties and obligations and "do a bunk" - again!
 
I agree with maggot. The story is changed...for the better. A point I have been making for several months. Jrr's characters would have been flat and contrived on film.

A hidden king? Why does he wait? Why does he allow the Kingdom of Gondor to the rule of the stewards? Lets go into another three hour movie to rationalize THAT in a supposed "willing" king. Naw, people can identify with the fear of the past more than a fairytale character whose behavior is far from anything remotely realistic. Another reason why PJ's film avioded the feel of "willow" et al.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
Another reason why PJ's film avioded the feel of "willow" et al.
I would say that that feel of PJ's films, RotK in particular, was much closer to Willow than it was to Tolkien's novel.
 
Unlike Jackson, Tolkien was involved with the history of his creation. Aragorn could not claim kingship for two reasons: first, had Sauron learned that an heir of Elendil lived, he would have waged open war against Gondor and the West in an attempt to either forestall Aragorn from actually taking the throne or to capture or kill the descendent of his hated adversary. Aragorn tells Gimli and Legolas that when he revealed himself (as king) to Sauron, the Dark Lord had not known of his existence.

Secondly, Aragorn knew of the problem of Denethor. When Aragorn served Denethor's father Ecthelion as Thorongil, the younger man had been very jealous of the popular leader. Indeed, after the defeat of the Corsairs, when Aragorn learned that Ecthelion was dead and that Denethor ruled in Minas Tirith, he did not return to that City, but instead returned to Rivendell. Gondor had already suffered a vicious civil war (the Kin-Strife) over the right to the throne and Aragorn's ancestor Arvedui had been denied his proper place as king of Gondor by that kingdom's Steward and Council who preferred to choose one of their own from the remaining members of the last king's family. The last thing that Gondor and the West needed was a division between those who supported Denethor and those who supported the new pretender to the throne. Indeed, Aragorn never made an open claim to the throne until Sauron had fallen and Denethor was dead.

And that's why Aragorn remained a "hidden king". Of course, Mr. Jackson either did not know - or, more probably, did not care and so was willing to make his Aragorn into a weak runaway who had to be pushed and browbeaten into his heritage. But if that's your idea of a hero.....
 
Slight correction MM- Thorongil defeated the Corsairs in TA 2980 (when Boromir turned 2!), Ecthelion died in TA 2984.

As another note on accuracy, PJ's Aragorn did all the things that you praise Tolkien's Aragorn for- he served the people of the North with no hope for personal recognition or glory, he aided the people of Rohan and Gondor, he probably helped find Gollum. Movie Aragorn has not left Gondor to be a King in hiding- he was born in Rivendell (apparently) and lay hidden there in the same way as the book character. He was no more running from responsibility than your beloved book character!

And, not to be confused with a defense of the films, I have never liked the fact that Aragorn and Ancestors made no apparent claim on the throne following the death of Earnur. The implication is heavy that having a King in Gondor would have been a boon- "the hand of a healer" and all that. There is a distinct possibility that had a strong King been present, then Mordor would not have remained unguarded, and it would have been denied to Sauron after his departure from Dol Guldur. In that case Frodo's journey would have been reduced to a stroll down to Mt Doom and an attempt to fling the Ring in. Poorer drama, to be sure, but that doesn't excuse the moral responsibility of the heirs of Isildur and Anarion.
 
Perhaps I miswrote or you misread. I don't believe I ever said anything about Boromir, but about Denethor. When Thorongil returns, he discovers that Ecthelion has died and Denethor is Steward. He then refuses to return to Minas Tirith knowing Denethor's hostility and being unwilling to create a division in the kingdom between those loyal to him and those who would be loyal to the Steward.

Yes, Jackson's Aragorn serves in the North, but it is not with any view to claiming the kingship. Elrond says that he has "chosen exile" and, in fact, when he bring Anduril to him, he tells him to "put off the Ranger", something which was certainly unnecessary in the book as the Ranger persona was simply something Aragorn used during his long years in the North. Again, motive is everything: Tolkien's Aragorn always hoped and intended that he would be able to claim the throne of Gondo - and, by the way, his bride with it; Jackson's Aragorn tells Elrond quite vehemently that he "doesn't want it!" that he "never wanted it!" As you can see, there is quite a difference here, if one chooses to see it.
 
Foe-Hammer said:
A hidden king? Why does he wait? Why does he allow the Kingdom of Gondor to the rule of the stewards?
A little matter of living cheek by jowl with Mordor. By the time Aragorn was anything like grown up, Sauron was there, waiting for him. And some foresight of Gandalf's had the Rangers guard The Shire. However, once the One Ring had been found, Aragorn's job was to aid in its destruction. The stage was set for the battles to come: death or glory.
people can identify with the fear of the past more than a fairytale character whose behavior is far from anything remotely realistic.
By 'people' you mean you and Peter Jackson. The Lord of the Rings was supposed to be one big faerie tale. As for realistic, what is that? The books make me cry (still!). The film didn't. Have you read Tolkien's essay on Fairy Tales? I think a copy of it is linked via a post in 'Other Works by JRR Tolkien'.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…