Mrs. Maggott
Home is where the cat is
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2002
- Messages
- 3,463
Mrs. Maggott said:No, I'm sorry, Jackson made a hash of many of his characters to the great detriment of the films.
Gandalf White said:Say rather to the great detriment of your enjoyment of the films. Theoden is the only character that comes to mind who is a hash, and detrimental because of it.
When do you interpret "the entire meaning of the tale"? In the beginning of the story, the middle, the end? Most would say 'the end' I think, especially given the use of the term "entire; and by the end of the film Aragorn has fully embraced his heritage, remarkably, JUST LIKE BOOK ARAGORN.Mrs. Maggott said:A frightened Aragorn who detests and refuses his heritage is not just "different" from the book's Aragorn but diametric to him. And as Aragorn is a central character not only plot-wise but certainly with respect to the entire meaning of the tale, those changes are seminal.
Sadly, I will say this again - and it is not intended to be insulting, believe me - but if one cannot see the difference between someone who spends a life of self-sacrifice and service in hopes of eventually gaining his inheritance (and with it, his betrothed) and someone who is dragged kicking and screaming into his inheritance, then there really isn't much to say.Parrot said:When do you interpret "the entire meaning of the tale"? In the beginning of the story, the middle, the end? Most would say 'the end' I think, especially given the use of the term "entire; and by the end of the film Aragorn has fully embraced his heritage, remarkably, JUST LIKE BOOK ARAGORN.
Please explain what fundamental deeper meaning of Tolkien's was lost by this change to the character of Aragorn.
I know the events that transpired. Believe it or not, I even recognize the difference between the two characters. What I don't get is, specifically, what deeper meaning was carried on the back of Aragorn as portrayed in the book and was sacrificed in the movie?Mrs. Maggott said:Sadly, I will say this again - and it is not intended to be insulting, believe me - but if one cannot see the difference between someone who spends a life of self-sacrifice and service in hopes of eventually gaining his inheritance (and with it, his betrothed) and someone who is dragged kicking and screaming into his inheritance, then there really isn't much to say.
Tolkien's Aragorn is a true "hidden king", living a life of service to the people of Middle-earth (most of whom are both ignorant and distinctly ungrateful like the Breelanders). He waits only for the time when he may actually put forth his claim - that is without plunging Middle-earth into war or Gondor into civil war. That opportunity comes with the revelation of the discovery of the Ring when, at last, open war with Sauron must happen. Even then, however, Aragorn does not put forth his claim openly, fearing that to do so would cause discord in Gondor at the height of the crisis. It is only after Denethor's death and Sauron's fall that he is willing to claim what is his by right of lineage. Tolkien's Aragorn does not need Elrond to tell him to "go be what you were born to be..." as does Jackson's character. He is what he was born to be from the first moment we meet him, albeit he does not flaunt that fact.
If that is too fine a distinction between the two, then I simply do not know what to tell you. In fact, it makes worlds of difference in the essential meaning and vision of the story. The fact that both characters wind up in the same place in the end is totally beside the point.
Which circumstances are those exactly? The relative peace and prosperity of Gondor that predates the story, during which time he fails to claim the throne? Or the time of great crisis and need we witness in the story, during which time he also fails to claim the throne? Who is he, Goldilocks?Mrs. Maggott said:He wishes to be king; it is his choice to be so, but it has been denied to him by prevailing circumstances in Middle-earth.
He never would have joined, and later assumed leadership of, the fellowship if this truly were the case. Hell, he never would have made contact with the hobbits at the Prancing Pony if that were the case. "Let's see, help out these little guys faced with some of the most dangerous creatures in Middle Earth and likely get myself killed along the way, or sit here and have another pint and a smoke, - whatever should I do?Jackson's character, on the other hand, is quite content to live out his life in obscurity having no greater demands made upon him than to engage in small skirmishes against the forces of evil. A small life for a small man.
Oh, it's to assuage his conscience! Here I was thinking it was because he loved her and couldn't bear the thought of her dying, and, as a result, was willing to give up the one thing he truly loved because she had avenues open to her that he did not.He rejects his heritage, is terrified of his "weak blood" and, on the whole, wants his erstwhile lover to go into the West to assuage his conscience (that is, so that he won't be responsible for her ultimate mortality). Jackson's Aragorn is a small man who has to grow ten sizes by the last film.
That's what I'm asking; what was he trying to say that the movie skewed to the point of being "diametric"?Mrs. Maggott said:Again, it is possible to excuse Jackson's model using all the arguments that you have done, but they fail to take into account what Tolkien was saying with the character which caused him to act as he did.
Last post on this topic for me - I've done it too often:Parrot said:That's what I'm asking; what was he trying to say that the movie skewed to the point of being "diametric"?
Unlike Jackson, Tolkien was involved with the history of his creation. Aragorn could not claim kingship for two reasons: first, had Sauron learned that an heir of Elendil lived, he would have waged open war against Gondor and the West in an attempt to either forestall Aragorn from actually taking the throne or to capture or kill the descendent of his hated adversary. Aragorn tells Gimli and Legolas that when he revealed himself (as king) to Sauron, the Dark Lord had not known of his existence.Foe-Hammer said:I agree with maggot. The story is changed...for the better. A point I have been making for several months. Jrr's characters would have been flat and contrived on film.
A hidden king? Why does he wait? Why does he allow the Kingdom of Gondor to the rule of the stewards? Lets go into another three hour movie to rationalize THAT in a supposed "willing" king. Naw, people can identify with the fear of the past more than a fairytale character whose behavior is far from anything remotely realistic. Another reason why PJ's film avioded the feel of "willow" et al.
A little matter of living cheek by jowl with Mordor. By the time Aragorn was anything like grown up, Sauron was there, waiting for him. And some foresight of Gandalf's had the Rangers guard The Shire. However, once the One Ring had been found, Aragorn's job was to aid in its destruction. The stage was set for the battles to come: death or glory.Foe-Hammer said:
By 'people' you mean you and Peter Jackson. The Lord of the Rings was supposed to be one big faerie tale. As for realistic, what is that? The books make me cry (still!). The film didn't. Have you read Tolkien's essay on Fairy Tales? I think a copy of it is linked via a post in 'Other Works by JRR Tolkien'.people can identify with the fear of the past more than a fairytale character whose behavior is far from anything remotely realistic.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?