Mrs. Maggott
Home is where the cat is
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2002
- Messages
- 3,463
I don't feel that the film changed all the important stuff from the book in such a great manner. For instance, it left this taste of bitter-sweet, without a lemonade-effect. (or should I say soap - opera effect?) Nothing in the film feels absolutely happy... And as for the revision of characters - let's be honest. What characters? T himself admitted that many of his characters were truly undeveloped! so, if you already have a pale character - why not adding some life into it, again, in your own interpretation! But still, without leaving true essence of the book! <quote Melian La Fey>
But the essence of the characters were changed. They were not just "developed", they were actually changed. This is going to affect the overall meaning of the story, especially if the characters are central to the story. A cynical, bitter Elrond is a far cry from Tolkien's gentle counselor. A frightened Aragorn who detests and refuses his heritage is not just "different" from the book's Aragorn but diametric to him. And as Aragorn is a central character not only plot-wise but certainly with respect to the entire meaning of the tale, those changes are seminal.
True, many of Tolkien's peripheral characters were not developed. For one thing, they didn't have to be. For instance, Glorfindel only appears once in the story as does Tom Bombadil. Most of the time, these characters are only there to fill a need in the story. For the author to have developed them all would have been both extremely time consuming and, frankly, unnecessary. Consider, if you will, in other books how many characters appear and disappear, fulfilling some function in the plot but whom the author never "develops". This is normal in any story.
There was no need for Tolkien to completely develop every character who appears in the book. And, in fact, had Jackson been true to Tolkien, Aragorn certainly did "develop" as a character over the course of the story. He goes from a mere "Ranger" and becomes a king. The difference is, it is our knowledge of the character that develops, not the character himself! And that is the difference.
Then, too, consider the changes that Jackson made to his own characters. Gandalf is "spot on" in the first two films - and becomes an entirely different person in the third! What sense does that make? No, I'm sorry, Jackson made a hash of many of his characters to the great detriment of the films.
But the essence of the characters were changed. They were not just "developed", they were actually changed. This is going to affect the overall meaning of the story, especially if the characters are central to the story. A cynical, bitter Elrond is a far cry from Tolkien's gentle counselor. A frightened Aragorn who detests and refuses his heritage is not just "different" from the book's Aragorn but diametric to him. And as Aragorn is a central character not only plot-wise but certainly with respect to the entire meaning of the tale, those changes are seminal.
True, many of Tolkien's peripheral characters were not developed. For one thing, they didn't have to be. For instance, Glorfindel only appears once in the story as does Tom Bombadil. Most of the time, these characters are only there to fill a need in the story. For the author to have developed them all would have been both extremely time consuming and, frankly, unnecessary. Consider, if you will, in other books how many characters appear and disappear, fulfilling some function in the plot but whom the author never "develops". This is normal in any story.
There was no need for Tolkien to completely develop every character who appears in the book. And, in fact, had Jackson been true to Tolkien, Aragorn certainly did "develop" as a character over the course of the story. He goes from a mere "Ranger" and becomes a king. The difference is, it is our knowledge of the character that develops, not the character himself! And that is the difference.
Then, too, consider the changes that Jackson made to his own characters. Gandalf is "spot on" in the first two films - and becomes an entirely different person in the third! What sense does that make? No, I'm sorry, Jackson made a hash of many of his characters to the great detriment of the films.

