Foe-Hammer
Member
- Joined
- Dec 20, 2001
- Messages
- 984
Parrot said:
Ravenna said:So are we expected to believe that a single mistake, albeit a rather crucial one, made by a hugely distant ancestor is enough to terrorise movie Aragorn into wanting to abandon his entire future?
Learn from it yes, be aware of the potential pitfalls, yes, but not let it rule his entire life.
chrischarlton said:
I added the bit about Boromir being four at the time because I thought it was interesting, if rather beside the point. The fact remains that Thorongil never returned from defeating the Corsairs- he headed north in TA 2980 without ever coming back to the White City. Ecthelion II died four years later, in 2984, therefore Aragorn did not leave in order to avoid Denethor the steward. He left because "other tasks now call"ed him. In any case, it is strongly implied that the people of Gondor loved Thorongil more than Denethor, and Aragorn had a legitimate claim to the throne of Gondor, whereas Denethor was only a steward. I don't think there would have been a second kin-strife, but then I am not the author.Mrs. Maggott said:Perhaps I miswrote or you misread. I don't believe I ever said anything about Boromir, but about Denethor. When Thorongil returns, he discovers that Ecthelion has died and Denethor is Steward. He then refuses to return to Minas Tirith knowing Denethor's hostility and being unwilling to create a division in the kingdom between those loyal to him and those who would be loyal to the Steward.
I would rephrase that as "if one chooses to see differences, they can always manage to find them." Aragorn's rejection is specific to 'power'- that is important. While Tolkien's Aragorn may have 'hoped' for the Kingship, he did nothing to secure it, at least nothing beyond what PJ's Aragorn did. If, as you say, Aragorn was duty-bound to Kingship, then it is rather glaring to me that he waited for an opportunity that even you admit might never have come, rather than 'seizing the day' when he had the chance. Instead, he chose exile.Mrs. Maggott said:Yes, Jackson's Aragorn serves in the North, but it is not with any view to claiming the kingship. Elrond says that he has "chosen exile" and, in fact, when he brings Anduril to him, he tells him to "put off the Ranger", something which was certainly unnecessary in the book as the Ranger persona was simply something Aragorn used during his long years in the North. Again, motive is everything: Tolkien's Aragorn always hoped and intended that he would be able to claim the throne of Gondor - and, by the way, his bride with it; Jackson's Aragorn tells Elrond quite vehemently that he "doesn't want it!" that he "never wanted it!" As you can see, there is quite a difference here, if one chooses to see it.
aragil said:chrischarlton- The 'hope' element is certainly in the movies. At the Gilraen memorial scene which MM derides Gilraen's last words to her son are engraved on her monument: "Onen i-Estel Edain, ú-chebin estel anim". Or, if you prefer: "I gave Hope to the Dúnedain, I have kept no hope for myself." This is of course repeated in the other scene which MM derides, the one where Elrond gives Anduril to Aragorn.
This doesn't wash. Aragorn's character did not need an arc, it needed a crown. Ian Fleming created an arc-free character in James Bond, and no-one has any problem with that, because there's enough going on around him.Foe-Hammer said:So, I tell you npw's that it would take another three hour movie to develope arragorns character for the movie and that people identify more with a fear of the past and you start explaining the history of arragorns life?
You are illustrating my exact point. There is too much history around arragorn to justify the fairytale charatcer for this movie. A king that fears the past is a much easier concept.
You gotta put the book down. Really.
Eledhwen said:
Mrs. Maggott said:Aragorn, from the book is way too fairytale-ish for film. A fear of following in ones relatives footsteps is an idea that is universally understood, identifiable, and required less setup than the book aragorn.
<quote Foe Hammer>
What you say, my dear F. H., might be quite true although I tend to doubt that the audience would not understand and accept the character as Tolkien wrote him. However, if you are in fact making that statement, then you can no longer make the claim that Jackson has not changed the essence of the story's meaning. For an integral part of the meaning of the tale is the story of Aragorn as Tolkien presented it! If you therefore are claiming that Jackson changed the character and his circumstances so completely, then you must also admit that he has changed the meaning just as completely. You cannot have it both ways!
Jackson's version was consistent with Jackson's story, not Tolkien's. Jackson's character is diametric in his behavior and thinking to Tolkien's. That is simply a fact. To therefore suggest that Jackson retains Tolkien's meaning is simply not credible. If you are arguing for inner consistency in the films, I accept your point. However, if you are arguing for consistency between book and films, that is simply wrong and a blatantly foolish claim given what you yourself have said about the character!Foe-Hammer said:For the puriest, yes it changes the meaning. For me, a regular fan of jrr, it changes nothing. I look at these films as being true to the spirit of jrr. I can accept aragorn in many ways as long as they are done well on film. Aragorn, as a film character was done very well. He portrayed what pj was trying to say and I saw no ambiguity or contradiction that didn't have a realistic basis that explained it.
Mrs. Maggott said:Jackson's version was consisten with Jackson's story, not Tolkien's. Jackson's character is diametric in his behavior and thinking to Tolkien's. That is simply a fact.
Mrs. Maggott said:To therefore suggest that Jackson retains Tolkien's meaning is simply not credible. If you are arguing for inner consistency in the films, I accept your point. However, if you are arguing for consistency between book and films, that is simply wrong, not true, incorrect, false and a blatantly foolish claim given what you yourself have said about the character!
Mrs. Maggott said:If by the term "puriest" you mean those who understand and accept the author's meaning, then certainly Jackson's changes "matter" If they do not "matter" to you, then perhaps you are not willing to accept Tolkien's meaning or it is not important enough and therefore Jackson's changes do not affect you.
Mrs. Maggott said:However, be that as it may, Tolkien's meaning is external to the reader (I think we've argued this point before). The reader may "understand" something other than what the author intended, but that understanding does not change the author's intentions.
No, I don't think Aragorn's character is simplistic, I am pointing out that for a film to work, the character doesn't necessarily need to go through a process of personal improvement (character arc). That is not what Tolkien intended for Aragorn.Foe-Hammer said:Bond does three things....has sex with women....kills bad guys...and has sex with women. Do you really think that aragorn's character is as simplistic? JRR sure didn't think so...and the way he wrote him, I agree.
No. His march towards his destiny was his personal journey, and that would have come out perfectly well in the ten hours provided.Had PJ filmed him the same way, we would have had another 2 hours at least just to make him believable.
But it is not the character that Tolkien invented, and should not have been the character portrayed.Aragorn, from the book is way too fairytale-ish for film. A fear of following in ones relatives footsteps is an idea that is universally understood, identifiable, and required less setup than the book aragorn.
But it is not the character that Tolkien invented, and should not have been the character portrayed.
Foe-Hammer said:
In the film, Elrond makes no demand of Aragorn as is made in the book: that unless he becomes King of Gondor as well as Arnor, they cannot be wed. Therefore, he has no reason to seek kingship nor does she demand that he do so. She is willing to give herself to him even as an exiled Ranger.chrischarlton said:Duty? To get away from Arwen......he knew if he wasn't king he could never have her. So he throws himself in harms way perhaps hoping to find an honorable end? That's my impression. Whereas my impression of Tolkien's Aragorn is he feared the consequences of death, leaving his hopes unfulfilled.
But I would agree that hope of becoming king began to stir on the paths of the dead fro PJ's Aragorn.
Eledhwen said:No, I don't think Aragorn's character is simplistic, I am pointing out that for a film to work, the character doesn't necessarily need to go through a process of personal improvement (character arc). That is not what Tolkien intended for Aragorn. No. His march towards his destiny was his personal journey, and that would have come out perfectly well in the ten hours provided.But it is not the character that Tolkien invented, and should not have been the character portrayed.
Mrs. Maggott said:However, both Aragorns - book and film - do not fear death. They both place themselves in harm's way throughout their lives (we know that this is the case in the book and at least suspect that the same is true in the film).
Mrs. Maggott said:
Mrs. Maggott said:In the film, however, there is no reason to believe that Aragorn and Arwen can't go off somewhere and make a life for themselves (always providing that Sauron doesn't regain the Ring, of course) and live out their lives in relative peace far from the struggles engulfing Middle-earth.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?