• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145
This is the greatest movie i have ever seen. There was actually a couple tears in my eyes at the end. In this movie my favorite character was defintely Sam, for all the drama and enthusiasm he put into his role. Every othere character had the drama too, but "Sams" stuck with me. :)
 
Hi Bogus, I can understand anyone saying that LOTR's movies are the greatest, unfortunately, fans of the book have so many incidents where PJ has left a bad taste in their mouth..

I too had tears in my eyes in particular in ROTK, that being said, PJ got so many things RIGHT, yet at times, man, he just left Tolkien and flew solo so to speak.. And PJ crashed!!! The EE's help smoothe out many things, but somethings are hard to forget, let alone forgive (plot changes, character development, language, subetly of the printed word, 21st humour YUCK). Don't misunderstand me, I love watching the movies at home, but in truth they fall short of the book..By a long way!!! Yet there are many moments that PJ got spot on..

The greatestness of PJ's work is ONLY comparable to your love of Tolkien's work. I thought I would never see LOTR done as a film trilogy in my life so I am gratefull to PJ,yet, my expectations for any adaptation of his work would be to the VERY highest order. PJ had the ultimate story, he had wonderful sets,cinematography, solid actors in lead roles, yet the weakness lies solely on PJ and his plotchanges and modenization of Tolkien's work. I think in truth PJ misunderstood on different levels the depth of Tolkien... Lets be honest, Tolkien is not simply a John Grisham novel... There is so much in LOTR, it was not an impossible task, formidable yes, and yet at times PJ DID get it so right, it was moving!!.. Oh well, I'm ranting now, good luck and long life to you Bogus..

PS My frind wants THE BELGARION done next, what do u think his chances are?? Slim to bugger all!!

Peace be with u HH
 
The order will be going in this week, so, if Amazon do their usual good work in delivering promptly, I'll be seeing it on 25 May.
Does anyone know why they're releasing it earlier in the year than they did the other two?
 
joxy said:
The order will be going in this week, so, if Amazon do their usual good work in delivering promptly, I'll be seeing it on 25 May.

Did you see the other two in theatres? And if so, why not RotK?

joxy said:
Does anyone know why they're releasing it earlier in the year than they did the other two?
Probably some marketing strategy, albeit one I haven't bothered to attempt to figure out.
 
No, nor in cinemas.
They're not usually shy to explain their eccentricities; I thought they'd probably explained this one, which, for once, I welcome!
 
They did explain this.

Since there isn't a new LotR movie coming out this christmas, they have more time to complete the dvd's this year, thus resulting into a earlier release.
 
That makes sense; thanks for passing it on, Ol'G.
Next question: when is an EE planned for?
 
I have to admit the return of the king was the best movie i ever seen im my whole life. Words cannot express how good this movie was .
 
Lord of the Rings is the greatest movie. Be it all three or one specific, but just like the books were to be one whole book, the three movies are one whole movie that is number one on my list. By the way, I have to get The Return of the King on DVD now that it is in stores.
 
I know I'm not the most knowledgable in Tolkien-lore, so forgive me if my opinion may seem a bit, er, empty , but I think ROTK was the most brilliant movie I have ever seen in my life. Left me absolutely breathless. I know you guys love to bash PJ about the littlest thing wrong he did with the movie, so then again, why didn't you direct the movie then? Give him credit where credit is due, and this is certainly the time to do it, methinks.
 
Peter Jackson has created one of the most memorable, emotional, powerful spectacles I have ever seen in a movie theater, there is no doubting that. This movie has some of the most spectacualr and mind-blowing sequences. I was sweating the entire time. I knew exactly what was going to happen but I just couldn't bring myself to calm down. The film's emotion got to me, I did feel teary eyed toward the end. Basically, it shook me to my core! Even the most stubborn Tolkien loyalists and purists, no matter the many changes, can't deny the magnificence of this gigantic piece of art. My mind was entirely blown by the last hour. And Sam, Frodo, and Gollum found permanent places in my heart. I was emotionally hooked and intensely excited through everything they endured. The ending(s) were such a great emotional release and ended everything well, depite Jackson's rather long fade-outs that made Tolkien Virgins stand from thier seats only to sit back down and groan/scoff/giggle when the movie continues, which slightly bothered me.

That is what I wanted get out -- no one can deny the superb moments that are featured in the film. But even I, being one who has read the books, I have some nit-picks, but they are so few that I feel no need to go into them.

All the characters are developed so well, I really feel that the audiance has come to care about their out-comes. This is shown so wonderfully in the final battle at the Black Gates, where we how Aragorn has become the great king and leader he was destined to be, Sam and Frodo face the ultimate test of friendship, Legolas and Gimli form a friendship as well. I loved how each character got their own special time to "show off," and all of the stories and adventures were balances so splendidly. Once again, fantastic and utterly believeable special effects took place, and the acting was completely compelling and convincing. The little details don't matter to me. What matters is that this IS the tone, mood, and feel of Tolkien's thematic vision. It is the very spirit and essence of the book. And that's what matters.

This by far completes the best film trilogy to date, and is the best film of 2003.
 
Nerds.Inc said:
What matters is that this IS the tone, mood, and feel of Tolkien's thematic vision. It is the very spirit and essence of the book. And that's what matters.
All you said was fine, up to that point.
These ARE, for the most part, good films, certainly, but the tone, mood, feel, spirit, and essence of Tolkien's thematic vision, as demonstrated in his books, are all too often mixed in with the tone, mood, feel, spirit, and essence of Jackson, which are of a very different, sadly inferior, quality. Yes, Tolkien's qualities ARE what matters; if only PJ had acknowledged them more.
 
Nerds.inc... I got goose bumps from reading that, because I know exactly what you are talking about. It's how I felt with ROTK. Or maybe I got goosebumps because it is cold... or I am a freak, but I still know what you are saying. ROTK is wonderful.

But I do agree with Joxy a little bit too. PJ definitely had great things in his movie, but I dont think all of it had the spirit of Tolkien. Some bits of the movie brought me as far aways from Tolkien as I have ever been. I don't think Frodo telling Sam to go home had the spirit of Tolkien, or the feeling that I got from the books at all.
 
Despite vowing to never watch this film, I finally caved in last night because the wife wanted to watch it. Incredibly I actually quite enjoyed it. Obviously, much of it was embarrassing drivel, but that's taken for granted with PJ. In fact, one of the reasons I enjoyed it was probably because I set out with such low expectations.
However, as a tear-jerker it worked well, and even jerked a few tears from me. Some of the invented stuff was even tolerable.
I did learn three interesting things:
- Denethor is very bad at eating tomatoes, and therefore a bad person.
- The Lord of the Nazgul was made of aluminium.
- The closer a person gets to Mordor, the more of an Irish accent they develop. When Aragorn said his piece at the gates of Mordor the orcs could have been forgiven for thinking the Reverend Ian Paisley had arrived.
Having said that, I would quite like to watch it again, which I certainly couldn't say of TTT.
 
Hurrah! You come sit by me. Have a cookie and snark away. Aluminum---bwahahaha...
 
Heathertoes said:
Despite vowing to never watch this film, I finally caved in last night because the wife wanted to watch it. Incredibly I actually quite enjoyed it. Obviously, much of it was embarrassing drivel, but that's taken for granted with PJ. In fact, one of the reasons I enjoyed it was probably because I set out with such low expectations.
However, as a tear-jerker it worked well, and even jerked a few tears from me. Some of the invented stuff was even tolerable.
I did learn three interesting things:
- Denethor is very bad at eating tomatoes, and therefore a bad person.
- The Lord of the Nazgul was made of aluminium.
- The closer a person gets to Mordor, the more of an Irish accent they develop. When Aragorn said his piece at the gates of Mordor the orcs could have been forgiven for thinking the Reverend Ian Paisley had arrived.
Having said that, I would quite like to watch it again, which I certainly couldn't say of TTT.

Wow, I would never have predicted this! You aren't such a bad fellow after all... ;)
 

Today's events

Back
Top