• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145
I'm assuming that you are all speaking of 'The Lord Of The Rings': The Return Of The King'. I, myself, loved the movie. Actually, I loved all three parts of the trilogy.It's funny, my friend always told me that one day she'd get me to watch it, because in the past, I really had no interest in it. Than when I finally saw it, I loved it.
 
Actually, who wouldn't think that T.L.O.T.R.:The Return Of The King 'isn't a good movie? Than again, not just anyone can do such a stellar job as Viggo Mortensen does in this movie, as to the others as well.
By the way, does anyone know the date for the extended version of 'TLOTR':The Return Of The King' comes out this year?
 
QueenofGondor said:
By the way, does anyone know the date for the extended version of 'TLOTR':The Return Of The King' comes out this year?

That has been the subject of some discussion, which can be found here.

Welcome to the Forum!
 
QueenofGondor said:
Actually, who wouldn't think that T.L.O.T.R.:The Return Of The King 'isn't a good movie?

*raises hand*

I know, not liking RotK makes me evil--but I have cookies!

[EDIT] Wait. *lowers hand* That was a double negative. You didn't ask you would think RotK wasn't a good movie, you asked who wouldn't. Aha!

I go in whichever group didn't think RotK was a good movie. Well, didn't think it was a great movie. It might be okay, if I weren't so bitter about it. But I still have cookies!
 
Ignore GW, he just doesn't love me

To be honest, the primary reason I'm bitter is because I wanted to like RotK, and I didn't. I was bored, I thought the quality of the acting dropped dramatically from the other two films, I thought it was too long, I got sick of one too many CG special effect, I thought that the changes (and more importantly, the additions) to the plot were ill advised and poorly excuted--the list goes on, but I was very, very disappointed. It wasn't what I wanted to see. And I felt betrayed, because I guess I had all of my hopes riding on this last film--I was upset about the changes made to TTT (especially Faramir *flinch*), but I kept trying to withhold judgement until RotK, hoping that it would somehow fix the problems I had with TTT, and it didn't. It just made things worse.

Or, I could just be a bitter and depressed old hag with no sense of proportion, which is distinctly possible But that's my reaction in a nutshell. If you reeeeally want to read all about my reaction to the film, I went on at great length about it earlier in this thread, so I won't repeat everything, so you can either dig backwards until you find my posts, or you can read my very loooongwinded reaction in my livejournal , where I pasted together my comments about it from various forums, including this one. I've cooled down since then, but was very, mm, annoyed at the time, so my comments are very snarky and even a little scathing. So take everything with a grain of salt.
 
Glad you pointed us to your detailed reactions Rhiannon.

For those who haven't had the pleasure of reading them, I offer a vital extract:
"The modernization of the dialogue was I think (on reflection), what really bothered me most, and ruined things for me over all. What draws me to Tolkien most is the elegance of the language, the sheer grace and nobility that you don't find in this world."
You certainly don't find it in Jackson's world.
 
I'm glad you appreciate them, joxy--they weren't particularly well received here, but my friends found them amusing, at least!
 
Rhiannon said:
A cross between Krull, Monty Python and the Holy Grail, and The Empire Strikes Back. It was scary.
Surely such a film would be fantastic.

Return of the King wasn't it though.

Still, I love this trilogy. They are amongst my favourite films ever made. Elsewhere on these boards people have been saying that they aren't as good as the books, they won't be remembered as classics, blah blah blah. Well, people used to say that to me about Nirvana at school. yet Nevermind still comes in the top five of every album review even today. I knew those people at school were wrong, and I know the doubters about the LOTR trilogy are wrong too. My only quibble with the trilogy is that the Extended versions are superior and should have been released in the cinema in the first place. I feel that I can't judge it finally until I've seen the extended ROTK. But the cinema cut of that was probably my fave of the three cinema cuts.

Overall the trilogy encompassed almost evreything I would hope to see in film, with horror, action, love, hate, psychodrama, comedy, suspense, all mixed together.

It is probably one of the greatest achievements in the history of cinema.
 
Like you, I believe the Extended versions are the best. Once viewed, you would not seriously watch the cinema releases again. Whilst ROTK would have to be the most emotional, my preferred one of the three is The Two Towers. I guess it is where the "guts" of the trilogy is.
And I would not care if the viewing times on all three movies was four hours or more! I could watch this story forever. So, I am left a bit deflated and emotional at the end of ROTK...simply because there is no more! But what do I do? I go back and read the books again. And again...and watch the DVD's some more!
Many a day (or night) I have felt "lost", so on goes LOTR on DVD and bingo! I am transported to a time and place so magical, my spirits soar again.
Counting down the days until the EE is released.
 
Joxy, that's scary. Nirvana was one of the most famous grunge bands of the 90's and was incredibly iconic for it's generation. Nevermind was one of their loved cd's and one of the most talked about.
 
OK, I'll admit it: I had vaguely heard of Nirvana as a group of musicians of some sort, though the Nirvana that is something to be achieved by followers of Gautama Siddhartha is better known and much more interesting.
What is grunge and what do you mean by iconic?
 
Grunge is a type of music, which I personally never liked.
Iconic meaning that they supposedly gave face to the 'misunderstood' teens of that generation.
 
comparing NIRVANA to tolkien is a bit idiotic but perhaps very appropriate.

NIRVANA was "iconic" for youth anger; but is it "music" ? only the morons who gave an oscar to PJ would list it in the top 5 albums. and they are the same people exploiting the talents of ICONS like Joan Baez for commercial sales.

is PJ LOTR TRILOGY a tribute to tolkien or cheapassed commercial exploitation

PS. ICONIC = SYMBOLIC......martin luther king jr being iconic for the civil rights movement in the US
 
Fadhatter, I know you have troubles comprehending things, and I know reading long texts is hard. But I'm going to make this really simple for you.


ready?


NOBODY COMPARED NIRVANA TO TOLKIEN
 
hey O'gaffer, i realised that English may NOT be your first language, but let me explain it in terms of "language".

do you know what the term "inference" means??? Coz i get the feeling you dont really know what "debate" means It doesnt mean that different views to yours deserves a locked or deleted thread heh.....

Your eloquence is matched by your diplomatic skills, and that i would guess is the reason that they made you moderator

Don't even bother to decipher that last statement; it might give you a brain tumour
 
Last edited:
This use of the word "iconic" seems odd, and the definition as "symbolic" more so.
An icon is a clear and simple representation of a person, not any form of symbol as a substitute for the person.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…