• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145
no no no, the use of the word icon is to be representative of ANYTHING, be it an ideal, movement, something abstract that you can put an concrete face or person or thing (ICON) to represent it.

the beatles were iconic for leading the British (musical) invasion
 
I won't even bother with Fadhatter anymore, it's like racing in the special olympics, debating with him.

Joxy, I used the word Iconic because that's what it was. Like James Dean as the Rebel without a cause, Kurt Cobain was the icon of the youth in the early 90's. He was their 'voice' so to speak.
 
LOVED IT LOVED IT LOVED IT LOVED IT LOVED IT!!!!!!!!!!!! It was one of the greatest movies that I have ever seen. Evaluated strictly as a movie, it was possibly one of the most fantastic epics of all time on the face of the planet. As a translation of the book, it was alright. Most things that he actually remembered to put in were done extremely well, none of his additions deviated from the original plot in excess, and verything that he didn't do, he should be maimed for. my sister and I decided that he should receive all pay and praise for three to fours years, then be hung from a tree, disembowled, and shot.
 
Well I do not know about what you were saying above beacause I was bored to read all that posts but the movie as a movgie was absolutely great. The bad think is that had a lot of different things from the book but it's OK.
 
The movie was greatbut I like the book better. Sauron did not impress me. He could have been more menancing.
 
As a film I think it is very difficult to criticise it, especially if one hasn't read the book. Visually the film is very impressive and this is bolstered by the fact that the film doesn't just reply on special effects; the performances given by the actors are magnificent.

However, if one has read the book then one might feel a little disgruntled at the changes, but then again it is a film, they were never going to include everything.

All three films are to be enjoyed as films; I don't think a student of Tolkien's works could appreciate them on any other level.
 
(Re: ScotsBoy's sig: )

"I may be drunk my dear woman, but in the morning I will be sober and you will still be ugly." WSC

Maybe this is the same woman who told him, "If I was your wife I'd poison your tea." To which, without missing a beat he replied, "If you were my wife I'd drink it."

Barley
 
Last edited:
@Barley

It is a different lady, the poison lady was Lady Astor and the 'ugly' lady was Mrs Braddock. My signature is a paraphrase, here is the full quote:

[font=verdana,arial,helvetica]“You are drunk Sir Winston, you are disgustingly drunk.”
“Yes, Mrs. Braddock, I am drunk. But you, Mrs. Braddock are ugly and disgustingly fat. But tomorrow morning I, Winston Churchill, will be sober.”

There is a scene at the end of TTT when Gandalf says something along the lines of, "The battle of Helm's Deep is over, the battle of Gondor is about to begin." I can't remember the exact quotation, but is is very reminiscent of Churchill after the fall of France.
[/font]
 
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (Special Extended Edition)

Part 1: The new scenes, audio and video quality.
December 07, 2004 - Well, here it is, the first December in four years without a Lord of the Rings movie to look forward to in theaters. Of all the happy, Hollywood endings we've seen over the years, the story of this movie is probably the best.

It could have been such an abject disaster. Look at some recent novel adaptations that turned into train wrecks -- Dreamcatcher, Timeline, Treasure Island -- just to name a few.

As I said before, when I learned in 1999 that Peter Jackson had gotten a $300 million check to adapt Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings, I thought someone at New Line needed their head examined. Deadalive is a crazy and fun movie, but did he have the capacity for a movie that required grandiosity of Cameron-like proportions?

The irrefutable answer came last February 28, when Steven Spielberg handed a foot-tall golden statue to Peter Jackson for his Best Director award. It's hard to be unhappy with 11 Oscars, a win in every category for which it was nominated, but you could be forgiven for feeling that Sean Astin was wrongly denied.

As with Patrick O'Brian and the Master & Commander adaptation, I've wished J.R.R. Tolkien were alive to see his great work made into a great film, and wondered if he would approve.

Of course, the movies are not a perfect adaptation. No book is ever adapted directly to the screen. There are purists who objected, and there are some points to be made. When he sticks to Tolkien, Jackson is at his best. When he starts to deviate, well, it depends on your viewpoint. Some of his humor borders on demented (especially one new scene on this DVD), other things just don't work.

Jackson made some choices that caused controversy, but they were made for the sake of filmmaking and I found myself in agreement. Moving the hobbit/Shelob confrontation from The Two Towers to this film was one of them. Jackson argued that without it, there was little for the Halflings to do in film three. As for some of the other changes, hey who knows why Hobbits all have permed mullets like the members of Def Leppard back in the 1980s.
...

In this case, these extended editions are Jackson's gift to the fans. He has said that the theatrical cuts are his preferred cuts, and who are we to argue? He's got the gold statue to show for it. Four hours later, I liked the scenes that were added and it didn't feel like a chore to watch a four-hour film.

Merry Christmas from Peter Jackson. Now let's open the presents.

Complete article (six pages!) at http://dvd.ign.com/articles/571/571469p1.html

Barley
 
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (Special Extended Edition)


Sam rescuing Frodo from the tower at Cirith Ungol, their trek across Mordor, marching with the Orcs, that whole episode at Mount Doom..Those poor Hobbits would've been bored outta their minds!

I think Jackson blew it moving the hobbit/Shelob confrontation from the end of TTT to ROTK. What a great cliffhanger that would've been instead of the dribble we were fed at the end of TTT.

Oh well, I still am looking forward to watching the EE of ROTK.
 
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (Special Extended Edition)


I heartily agree. There was a whole lot of material to be incorporated into ROTK, but who knows what was going on inside Peter's pretty little head. Indeed, the Shelob part would've been a marvelous ending for TTT, especially for viewers who had not read the book!
 

My sides still hurt from laughing over these statements!

Denethor..BAD tomato eater..He's a VERY bad man!
 
The Shelob incident (in the book) occurred long after Helm's Deep and the confrontation with Saruman. Requiring PJ to simply 'follow the book' (and remember the division between volumes 2-3 of 'the book' is rather artificial, it was originally intended as 6 books in a single volume) is not as simple as you make it out to be. 'The heart of the matter', i.e. the quest of Frodo and Sam is given 13 chapters after the breaking of the Fellowship, whilst Aragorn, Gandalf & co. get 21 chapters covering the exact same time period.
If PJ had kept the chronology exactly as in the book, then F&S would have gotten the equivalent of 3 chapters of screen time- they would have been completely lost from the story line! This of course would have upset any purist who holds with Tolkien that the 'heart of the matter' is the Frodo and Sam thread.
If, on the other hand, PJ had stuck strictly to the timeline of the books, he could have either ended:
1) In the west after the confrontation with Saruman (March 5th), which would have left F&S just setting out for Ithilien after being denied at the Black Gate- not much drama in the F&S thread for film 2.
2) In the east, after the choices of Master Samwise (March 13th). This would have left the western matter right in the middle of the siege of Minas Tirith, after Faramir was stricken down. Needless to say, this would have left very little interesting material for film 3.
Obviously neither of the above options seems very appropriate, and either one would be decried by some group of purists who object to any meddling with JRRT's works.

PJ chose option 3- meddle with JRRT's timeline, stop short of the end of volume 2 altogether, insert events which 'never happened', and excise some events that did. Unsurprisingly, some people are upset with his choices. I bet PJ would have gotten the same reaction (albeit from different segments of the 'purist' population) had he tried to 'stick to the book' using any of the scenarios outlined above. Oh well. At least I'm reasonably happy with the result.
 
I see what you are saying and agree with your rationale, but IMO from a theatrical point of view ending TTT with Shelob would've been fantastic. It's not the purist part of me that takes umbrage at PJ's moving Shelob to ROTK, it's the part that thinks "Wow, what a GREAT ending that would've been". It probably doesn't help that I absolutely loathe the scene at Osgiliath and aren't fond of how TTT ended. Maybe if that had been more to my liking I'd feel differently.

PJ didn't hesitate to alter timelines throughout the movie(s). In most cases I agree with the changes and understand the thought processes behind them. If the man was so willing to alter things I think he could've worked Shelob in to TTT and provided the middle movie with a great cliffhanger. It's the middle movie with no real beginning or end, so why not make the ending a real nailbiter?

Somehow I still think that there is plenty of material in ROTK for Frodo and Sam. I would've ended TTT with Sam realizing Frodo wasn't dead and pounding on the doors after Frodo was taken by the Orcs. ROTK could've picked up from there. I know the EE includes scenes in Mordor that weren't in the theatrical version so I'm thinking that PJ could've just as easily included them first time out so as to "flesh out" the Hobbit's trek across Mordor, thus giving them more screentime. Plus, I think that the Hobbit's trek across Mordor is really interesting and wouldn't have minded seeing more of it while watching the movie in the theater.

Oh well, I'm not a director so it's entirely possible that it couldn't have been done..But I do like the idea of ending TTT with Shelob. I feel it got lost in ROTK. I will say that I thought PJ did a good job with Sam during the encounter with Shelob. I wasn't fond of Frodo telling Sam to go home though.
 
Barliman Butterbur said:
Jackson argued that without it, there was little for the Halflings to do in film three.
Complete article (six pages!) at....
Did he? Where and when?
If he did, he couldn't have been more wrong, and by being so wrong he shows just how little he knows about the story!
Narsil and Ithrynluin have explained how he was wrong.

And B B, you had me confused there; until that last line I thought that it was "all your own work"!
You could have given us the attribution, as you have always done before, so meticulously.
 
I really enjoy reading the stuff that Barley posts. If he didn't post the links I'd never think to delve in and discover this stuff for myself. Thanks for your time and effort!
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…