CheriptheRipper
just vibing
- Joined
- Sep 19, 2022
- Messages
- 452
I think "gayer" is pretty common in the English language. The other word, although a perfectly valid word, is too close for my comfort. So, in the interest of forum decorum, I think I'll pass on that one. 😊I might as well contribute. If these are commonly used in the english language that's my bad.
978
THE LORD OF THE RINGS
all there drank to them and were glad. "Thus,' said Eomer, is the friendship of the Mark and of Gondor bound with a new bond, and the more do I rejoice.' 'No niggard are you, Éomer,' said Aragorn, 'to give thus to Gondor the fairest thing in your realm!'
&
Farewell!' Last of all Merry and Pippin said good-bye to the old Ent, and he grew gayer as he looked at them. 'Well, my merry folk,' he said, 'will you drink another draught with me before you go?'
Yep...language evolves.On a sidenote, those and a few other words that have changed the last decade were really immersion breaking when I read the books.
It all feels so distant and fantastical until I encounter one of those.
I don't think we need to blank out any words of Tolkien's texts.To maintain forum decorum, this one could be tricky. Maybe a substitution using the letter "x" is in order (or maybe my concern is needless).
Oh I thought it rang a bell, Guillermo Del Toro had a geek show in Nightmare Alley (2021). Very accurate description there, I didn't actually notice it was supposed to have a different meaning.Yep...language evolves.
We use words now that even a hundred years ago meant the exact opposite of the way we currently use them, or had a totally different meaning.
For example , the word GEEK:
We use it interchangeably with NERD; someone who is super tech-y oriented or skilled.
Well, we should have stuck with the word Nerd for that.
I am old enough to recall the epithet Geek being applied to certain types of people that had nothing to do with tech.
Geek was originally an early 20th-century term for a carnival worker who was so unskilled that the only thing the worker could do at the carnival to entice an audience was to bite off the heads of live animals. Essentially, a geek was a socially undesirable person who lacked any skill or ability.
Squint-eyed Southerner said:I don't think we need to blank out any words of Tolkien's texts.
We should try to watch the language in our own posts, though.
Yes "niggard" and "niggardly", especially the latter, are currently in use, in exactly the application that their definitions pertain to, that same definition that was used in Tolkien's time.I might as well contribute. If these are commonly used in the english language that's my bad.
978
THE LORD OF THE RINGS
all there drank to them and were glad. "Thus,' said Eomer, is the friendship of the Mark and of Gondor bound with a new bond, and the more do I rejoice.' 'No niggard are you, Éomer,' said Aragorn, 'to give thus to Gondor the fairest thing in your realm!'
&
Farewell!' Last of all Merry and Pippin said good-bye to the old Ent, and he grew gayer as he looked at them. 'Well, my merry folk,' he said, 'will you drink another draught with me before you go?'
The word monger, and mongery had to do with dealing in a commodity, such as iron, or fish.I added ironmongery and weskit from one of my favorite light-hearted Tolkien quotes.
The Scouring of The Shire: The Gaffer sees Sam and... "What's come of his weskit? I don't hold with wearing ironmongery, whether it wears well or no."
Weskit means vest or waistcoat.
Essentially, ironmongery refers to the type of item you'd have to purchase at a hardware store.
If the majority of those words are considered "archaic or unusual" by the compiler then said compiler has the vocabulary and background knowledge of a fourth grader, if that. Or, what is worse, he thinks Tolkien readers have. Or both....
To get back on topic, this list of archaic words used by Tolkien may be of interest:
Old and Rare Words Archaic or Unusual Words found in Tolkien’s Works
Old and Rare Words Archaic or Unusual Words found in Tolkien’s Works This page lists archaic or unusual words used in Tolkien's works. ...tmasskc.blogspot.com
I added dwimmer-crafty to the list.😊It's not in the book.
I'll add some "dwimmer-" variants:
-- Eomer calls Saruman "dwimmer-crafty"
-- the Haunted Mountain of the Oathbreakers is the "Dwimorberg"
-- Most interesting is Wormtongue's use of the word "Dwimordene" as a disparaging description of Lorien, to which Gandalf responds with a song, beginning with "In Dwimordene, in Lorien". The question is, what's the origin of this song? Ad-libbed by Gandalf? That seems unlikely; many of the songs and poems are "traditional" in some fashion, and that is the impression here -- for me, at least. Since "dwimmer-" words all seem to be Rohirric usages, it must originate there, which is odd, considering the suspicion and fear of the place exhibited by the Rohirrim. I'd suggest its origins may lie in earlier times, and the stories of the coming of Eorl. All speculation, of course.
To get back on topic, this list of archaic words used by Tolkien may be of interest:
Old and Rare Words Archaic or Unusual Words found in Tolkien’s Works
Old and Rare Words Archaic or Unusual Words found in Tolkien’s Works This page lists archaic or unusual words used in Tolkien's works. ...tmasskc.blogspot.com
"Half a sticky mile...."I added dwimmer-crafty to the list.😊
The index in Unfinished Tales has this entry:
Dwimordene: "Phantom Vale", name of Lorien among the Rohirrim.
So, if the syllable "dwim" means "phantom", Eomer is calling Saruman a crafty phantom.
Thanks for posting the list of archaic words. I think I'll refer to it sparingly as it might take some of the fun out of generating my own list here.
While searching for the "dwimmer-crafty" quote, I happened upon a phrase that's defying my meager Googling powers.
As Pippin and Merry are sitting on the bottom step of Orthanc before Saruman's appearance, Pippin says, "Half a stick mile from here to the gate! I wish I could slip off back to the guardroom unnoticed!..."
Have you ever heard the term "stick mile" before?
That makes more sense. My old tattered paperback TTT says "stick mile", but my new hardback says "sticky mile". Sticky makes sense. So, I guess sticky mile is not really an expression. It's just an unusual and colorful choice of adjective for the sentence."Half a sticky mile...."
Sticky: unpleasant; nasty
Which is was; stagnant water clogged with debris.
Reading this as an ignorant youth, I pictured this as some kind of game or contest, or maybe a rope bridge. It was many years before I bothered to look it up.Sam did not laugh. 'I may not be much good at climbing, Mr. Frodo,' he said in injured tones, 'but I do know something about rope and about knots. It's in the family, aa you might say. Why, my grand-dad, and my uncle Andy after him, him that was the Gaffer's eldest brother, he had a rope-walk over by Tighfield many a year.'
Rope-walk has been added.Reading this as an ignorant youth, I pictured this as some kind of game or contest, or maybe a rope bridge. It was many years before I bothered to look it up.
I'd suggest that "dwimmer-crafty" would mean something like "skilled in creating phantoms" rather than "crafty phantom". This seems to have been what appeared to the Three Hunters in Fangorn. But the term may mean skilled in magic practices in general.
I added gore. It's like "fell" in that it's a simple common word with multiple other definitions I did not know.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?