Originally posted by HLGStrider
did anyone else really loathe that one scene where Kirk got chased by the yeti beast and the fleshy red beast on the ice planet?
K, so, just a mild, barely a spoiler at all subject in case she accidentally looks back . . . did anyone else really loathe that one scene where Kirk got chased by the yeti beast and the fleshy red beast on the ice planet? I found that scene completely pointless and rolled my eyes through the whole thing. Did they just need something to fill ten minutes? Something for a video game tie in? Something because the CGI guys didn't have enough crazy stuff to do?
edit:
Oh my gosh! I just said crazy. Yay is getting to me.
Actually, the fact that I use the word crazy and automatically assume Yay is getting to me when it is actually a fairly common word I have every right to use without channeling Yay suggests that I simply have been on this forum too long. . .
See, I thought that was what would happen and it would end the sequence. Kirk gets chased by big monster. Big monster is eaten by bigger monster. . .Illuin said:I would have rather seen the big monster graphically (with blood) eat the smaller one (giving it way more to eat than little Kirk), but it reminded me of some of the campy fun in The Original Series.
Originally posted by HLGStrider
Vulcans, too, were a little to mono-chromatic. We all know that there are black Vulcans (Tuvok), so why were all the pod-educated Vulcans little dark haired white boys? That said, I loved that shot. It put you right into the society.
Of course, Fir is right, they had to drive Kirk into the cave somehow. I would've personally had him fall in through a crevice or something while backing up from the bigger monster crunching on big monster bones.
Spock/Uhura thing. Of course, a Kirk/Uhura thing would've been unbearable and I feared that was coming, but still it just didn't seem to fit with the Spock I've always kept in mind. I kind of like how Spock kissing her rather deflated Kirk after all that flirting he had been doing...
. . . and does anyone really buy that that huge thing was once a "Mining Vessel?" When did he have time to refit it like that? Sometime in between Romulus going BOOM and reaching the other side of the black hole apparently.
**SPOILER ALERT**
*spoiler alert*
Although I LOVED Star Trek XI - I think I may need to see it again because I got a bit lost with the time traveling.
Nero went into the past - before the birth of Kirk - destroyed The Kelvin - thinking he would find Spock at that time ?
Then he hung around for 25 years waiting for Spock ? then I got a little lost by Spock traveling to/fro the past/present.
So, history was changed - Kirk's father died when he was an infant and would not be around to encourage him to enter Starfleet as the elder Spock told the young Kirk in the cave??
Anyway - I loved it. I thought Chris Pine did a great job adapting the Shatner/Kirk swagger. And I loved the mention of the Korbiyashi Maru test (from Star Trek II/Khan).
If anybody can clear up the time sequences for me- I would appreciate it
I suspect that by the end of the third movie, older Spock will have returned to his own time, as will Nero, causing history to somehow repair itself and bring Kirk, Spock, and the others to the future that we know as "The Original Series".
Originally posted by HLGStrider
To continue that as a story arch over three movies, to me, would just be cumbersome. Also, they are trying to fix things up with Spock and Vulcan in different ways (the Vulcan settlement and Spock coming to terms with . . . well . . . Spock in that very UnStar Wars, "I am not our father" moment). It seems to me that they are making an alternate timeline for this Star Trek to fit into which will run opposed to the old timeline and therefore they won't need to be so careful getting every single detail exactly right.
Sort of like that alternate universe in the Original series episode that came back in DS9 when Kyra (spelling? It's been awhile) got transported through a transporter accident and found herself faced with herself, or whatever.
Patrick Stewart is the reason Star Trek became huge. He is the reason Star Trek went from being “moderately popular” to being warped into the stratosphere! Kirk, Spock, Data, McCoy, Scotty, Riker, Chekov, Worf, Jorde were all incredible, but Picard brought to life an in-depth character that can not be duplicated. No cinema or TV can ever replace the unique magic of Star Trek (especially “The Next Generation”). One viewing of the episode “The Inner Light” will convert all naysayers.
Originally posted by Bucky
You aren't serious, are you?
Star Trek was HUGE way before Patrick Stewert ever heard the word "enterprise"......
The original casts were legends even before they started making movies soon after Star Wars, which all happened way before Stewart.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?