• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Uruk-Hai and Free Will

I've been on both sides of this argument. Tolkien theorizes about different origins of Orcs... especially in HoME X but... I'm not sure that what's written there can UNDO what is laid down in the Silmarillion. Regardless of their origin, they are inextricably entwined with the evil will of their creator/perverter. That entity would be my boss, Melkor/Morgoth. In his absence... the leadership role would definately be delegated to his chief Lieutenant... Sauron. If Sauron was indisposed (his out of body experience and all) his chief Lieutenant (in this case Captain) would take command (can we say Witch-king or Lord of the Ringwraiths?).

There is little doubt that with the reoccupation of Dol Goldur in 1100 that they began working (aka putting matters in order) with the Orcs of the Misty Mountains as well as those that were in Moria (can we say AZOG!!??).

As most of you know, I haven't done any real Tolkien research in over a year but... maybe in this case I will. I do remember clearly that Tolkien's "vision" of the Orc (whether common orc or giant Uruk) was one of an inherent corrurpted and unredeemable creature. But... then again, I seem to remember a HoME discussion where he addresses this very issue.

I'll get back to you on this one.

Cheers,

grond (the birthday boy!)
 
HAPPY BIRTHDAY, GROND!

HGR, I'm not exactly able to comment upon the HoME, so I'm basing my Orc theory totally on the Sil. I've never been able to get a good copy of the HoMe. . .or any copy for that matter.
 
Yeah, that's why I thought I'd post that stuff, to clarify things and so people would know some of what was said there. It's quite a mouthful, though, and probably not worth the trouble. Who else do I expect to be obsessed enough to read all that?

But I do think that the thing about Maiar Orc chieftains would explain how there could be independant Orc-societies whether or not they had free will. I can't remember where that's from though, it might actually have been UT also, I don't own any books other than the Sil, so this is based on what I remember from when I got them from the library. I like best the idea that they were mindless beasts myself, because I don't like to think any reasoning people could be so wholly corrupted; if not irredeemable, since God surely could not allow that, then at least closely approaching it. But that's only what I like, not what I think is most probable.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…