Now, one of the things we know from
Tolkien is that the
orcs were very much anonymous – a “hive” culture very different from any of the free
peoples of
Middle-earth. Indeed, we only learn the name of a very few orcs in the entire book and interestingly enough, one of those is the leader of
Saruman’s Urak-hai:
Ugluk. Why, if Tolkien had already provided a name for Saruman’s lead
orc, was it necessary for Jackson to choose an entirely different name? Why did Jackson simply not name his character “Ugluk” and thereby maintain at least the appearance of faithfulness to the book? The reason, I believe is that Jackson wanted his own character in the film rather than to simply re-develop Tolkien’s.
This is from Mrs M's first post: sorry to return to it but I hadn't read it before. But I wanted to take issue with you on a point of orc-lore (a subject close to my heart).
I don't find any evidence of a 'hive culture' amongst the orcs. Indeed their rebelliousness is striking, and they have a propensity to disobey orders unless discipline is ruthlessly enforced!
Moreover, many orcs are named in the
books, despite the fact that there is relatively little opportunity for orcs to be portrayed closely as individuals. We get the names of Ugluk,
Grishnakh, Mauhaur, Shagrat and Gorbag,
Azog and
Bolg; and probably others beside that I forget (and the ubiquitous, and much maligned snagas!
).
Now if you were to argue that
Lurtz doesnt sound entirely Tolkienesque as an orc-name, I would agree. But then the
Black Speech is under developed, so permutations of the existing vocabulary is limited. Nevertheless creation of more convincing vocabulary by 'twisting'
quenya or
sindarin or even
mannish words would be preferable. However the idea of using Ugluk is not tenable, as clearly Ugluk must survive to lead the
Uruk-Hai back across
Rohan in TTT. In any event, as the orc name is only used on the packaging for toys, this is not a great tragedy.
To me it seems quite acceptable to depict an orc who was the original leader of this band prior to
events at Parth Galen, who then dies at the scene, whereupon Ugluk takes over. There is nothing to contradict this in the book. Moreover, I can't really see that there is anything very heinous about a climactic battle in which this orc is slain by a heroic
Aragorn. After all we know that
Legolas and
Gimli do slay orcs in the book, so what is so awful about Aragorn getting one?
Of all the many issues with the movies, this is one I have the least sympathy with I'm afraid. This is not to necessarily take issue with Mrs M's entire thesis, but merely this issue.