• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

What happened - and why

Oooookay!

1. What Tolkien did has nothing to do with the case. He needed money and his work was worth something. He sold his story to a publisher as well. He did try to help with the first film adaptation but probably to no avail, given your own assessment of the situation. So I believe that continually harping on his actions is pointless for, in fact, they had nothing to do with the quality of the work itself.

2. I don't believe that our expectations were in the beginning all that high although they proved to be unrealistic - and with each succeeding film, that is becoming more the case. Jackson had introduced great visuals and a fine cast. He also insisted that he would make every effort to be faithful to the book. I guess most of us preferred belief to disbelief. However, even after we realized that he had a different story in mind, the first film was quite superior to most of what is produced today in Hollywood and at least we were able to hope that, however Jackson changed the characters and plot, he would continue to provide a good fantasy adventure film. Alas, TTT proved that we were again mistaken.

I use old films to prove that Hollywood does not have to "screw up" if it does not wish to do so. I'm sure that there are many modern films which are also excellent although I am not a film goer (with the exception of Finding Nemo). I hear that Master and Commander is a fine film but I haven't yet seen it.

I hope this addresses some of your comments.
 
1. PJ wasn't picked because he was a terrible director! Am I the only one who has seen Heavenly Creatures? New Line actually took a chance on an independant filmmaker!!! That, along with PJ shouting about being true to the book, means that he's held to a higher standard than your average Hollywood director who's only interested in churning out a product. Yes, after the success of FOTR, PJ seems to have fallen into the Hollywood mindset. But he didn't start out that way...

2. What about the first Matrix? What about FOTR? Excalibur? 2001? Alien? And I think the Harry Potter example is a good one. It may be a "children's" book, but it has a huge adult following as well! Things were left out of the movie...not drastically altered.

3. Lots of books are successfully turned into movies. It ain't rocket science! Never saw Dune thankfully:p

4. Tolkien didn't spend over a decade writing something because he was trying to get rich quick. And of course he wanted to make money. What artist doesn't? One of my favorite quotes... No man but a blockhead ever wrote, except for money - Samuel Johnson

5. However, BW, I do agree that Hollywood is convinced we can't "handle" the subtle or implied...*sigh*
 
Originally posted by Blue Wizard
....Harry Potter which is a children's story for the most part....
It's central character, and some of the others, are children, but that's as far as it goes to being specifically a book FOR children! The two books that have been filmed so far contain some pretty adult stuff, and there's MUCH more to come!
 
Part of the problem is the age of the audience targeted. In the Potter films that wasn't a problem because the younger audience knew, understood and loved the books. That permitted Columbus to be faithful which, in turn, kept the interest of his adult audience while not losing his younger group.

Unfortunately (and we begin to see this in FOTR) Jackson was overly influenced by his c.g. visuals and began to target the audience that just loves battle sequences and doesn't give a fig who's fighting whom! Surely, TTT is specifically pointed in that direction which is made obvious as both the other plot themes - Merry, Pippin and the Ents and Frodo and Sam - are given "short shrift" in the film in order to have just oodles of c.g. action. Furthermore, I think that this particular "focus" was possibly not in the original conception of the film but after the "Moria" and Parth Galen sequences in FOTR, Jackson "saw" a greater interest (and therefore profit) in that type of plot exposition. Hence, TTT underwent many changes in both its conception and its execution. The same can be said for ROTK where we are assured that the two battles in the film will be even longer and more involved than Helm's Deep!
 
Now, one of the things we know from Tolkien is that the orcs were very much anonymous – a “hive” culture very different from any of the free peoples of Middle-earth. Indeed, we only learn the name of a very few orcs in the entire book and interestingly enough, one of those is the leader of Saruman’s Urak-hai: Ugluk. Why, if Tolkien had already provided a name for Saruman’s lead orc, was it necessary for Jackson to choose an entirely different name? Why did Jackson simply not name his character “Ugluk” and thereby maintain at least the appearance of faithfulness to the book? The reason, I believe is that Jackson wanted his own character in the film rather than to simply re-develop Tolkien’s.
This is from Mrs M's first post: sorry to return to it but I hadn't read it before. But I wanted to take issue with you on a point of orc-lore (a subject close to my heart).

I don't find any evidence of a 'hive culture' amongst the orcs. Indeed their rebelliousness is striking, and they have a propensity to disobey orders unless discipline is ruthlessly enforced!

Moreover, many orcs are named in the books, despite the fact that there is relatively little opportunity for orcs to be portrayed closely as individuals. We get the names of Ugluk, Grishnakh, Mauhaur, Shagrat and Gorbag, Azog and Bolg; and probably others beside that I forget (and the ubiquitous, and much maligned snagas!;) ).

Now if you were to argue that Lurtz doesnt sound entirely Tolkienesque as an orc-name, I would agree. But then the Black Speech is under developed, so permutations of the existing vocabulary is limited. Nevertheless creation of more convincing vocabulary by 'twisting' quenya or sindarin or even mannish words would be preferable. However the idea of using Ugluk is not tenable, as clearly Ugluk must survive to lead the Uruk-Hai back across Rohan in TTT. In any event, as the orc name is only used on the packaging for toys, this is not a great tragedy.

To me it seems quite acceptable to depict an orc who was the original leader of this band prior to events at Parth Galen, who then dies at the scene, whereupon Ugluk takes over. There is nothing to contradict this in the book. Moreover, I can't really see that there is anything very heinous about a climactic battle in which this orc is slain by a heroic Aragorn. After all we know that Legolas and Gimli do slay orcs in the book, so what is so awful about Aragorn getting one?

Of all the many issues with the movies, this is one I have the least sympathy with I'm afraid. This is not to necessarily take issue with Mrs M's entire thesis, but merely this issue.:)
 
The "hive culture" to which I allude is not a matter of obedience, but of structure. Orcs apparently don't have families or family ties. They do have "tribes" as the business with the small tracker orc and the larger warrior in Mordor will attest but they certainly do not have the "nuclear family". They are rebellious and untrustworthy as Tolkien asserts and they serve their master with hate and fear rather than any type of fondness or fidelity. Actually, Saruman's Urak-hai seem far more "loyal" to him than do Sauron's orcs to the Dark Lord.

I have no problem with Lurtz's name. The problem I have is that Jackson felt the need to produce an entirely new character with no connection with the book. He could have have used Tolkien's name for his character, but I believe that the "new" name was an effort to "claim" the character as his own, another example of his "co-authorship".

Yes, we do get the odd orc named by Tolkien (I have a bunch of very strange looking bushes and trees which bear those names) but the "comradeship" amongst orcs is limited to the next opportunity for betterment at which time they will sell one another out or kill one another without pause. Consider the conversation in the tunnel between the two orc captains at which time they seem to be rather "chummy" but which ends with a massacre of each other's troops and each other as soon as Frodo's mithril shirt comes to light!
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
I have no problem with Lurtz's name. The problem I have is that Jackson felt the need to produce an entirely new character with no connection with the book.
I agree, of course, that the important thing is that PJ invented a new orc at all,
but there IS a certain amount of significance in the name he chose for his invention.
Lurtz has a distinctly Germanic sound, and Tolkien did NOT use such sounds; the significance is to show yet again that PJ's claims, in this case that he attached great importance to the languages, are apparently unfounded.
 
I read somewhere that PJ will discuss why he changed certain things around in the new TTT extended version. It will be interesting to see.
 
That is not what most people would understand as a hive culture. A hive culture is one where there is a collective consciousness, and selfless actions for the betterment of the 'queen bee'. Additionally I should point out that there are an enormous range of societal forms other than the nuclear family, and a hive culture. Hobbits for example do not exhibit a nuclear family, but an extended family/clan based culture.

The boxes for the toys name the character 'Lurtz' - an orc that gets killed at Parth Galen. That orcs got killed at Parth Galen is not a PJ invention. In addition the lack of comradeship amongst orcs is reasonably well portrayed in TTT, even if the line 'It looks like meat is back on the menu' is out of the 'Lets hunt some orc' phrase book.;)
 
In an insect hive, you do have a single "mind", so to speak, but in the type of hive cultures to which I was alluding, you don't have the maternal bond. The orcs are "hatched" or "born" and then given over to a group that raises them for whatever "duty" they are going to have within the society. This certainly is not the sort of society found among dwarves, men, hobbits and elves! True, orcs are "individual" enough to be completely untrustworthy, but they have no type of cultural structure which might provide them with any hope of being other than orcs!
 
I don't really believe insects to exhibit a maternal bond, as would be understood in mammals.

I also don't recognise where there is evidence that
orcs are "hatched" or "born" and then given over to a group that raises them for whatever "duty" they are going to have within the society.
But I'd be interested to see any.
 
Originally posted by snaga1
I don't really believe insects to exhibit a maternal bond, as would be understood in mammals.

I also don't recognise where there is evidence that But I'd be interested to see any.
They are undoubtedly "born" as are elves and men. After all, orcs are really "destroyed" elves. However, if there were families, it would indicate that orcs were capable of affection and friendship, something that obviously is not the case (remember, Frodo tells Sam after the tracker orc kills his larger "companion" that this constant hatred among orcs is the "spirit of Mordor"). Being raised by a parent indicates a bond that apparently doesn't exist among orcs. Therefore, I surmise that they are "born" and removed from their mothers to be "raised" in a communal setting where the females are taught their duties to the commune and the males, theirs. There simply is nothing in the behavior of orcs to suggest that more personal parental bonds are fostered and maintained. The proof of that is in their behavior as a species even though nothing specific is written about orc husbandry that I know of in any of Tolkien's fictional works.
 
As you say, this is not a topic that is written about by Tolkien. We know nothing at all about female orcs, but there existence is highly probable. I reject the movie version of orcs being born from some sort of spawning pits.

However, as we know nothing of this topic, one could theorise some residual maternal instinct in female orcs, sufficient only to ensure they perform the task of rearing their young until it can fend for itself. This could be instinctual behaviour and not at all linked to affection: this relationship can be found in nature. The emotional development of most animals is limited!

Moreover, a violent and hierarchical orc society might very well force this role upon the female orcs in a highly authoritarian manner.

Of course, this theory is as unprovable as yours.:)
 
Originally posted by snaga1
....even if the line 'It looks like meat is back on the menu' is out of the 'Lets hunt some orc' phrase book.
Back with the subject of language, I am pleased to see this idea that PJ and his family have a phrase-book of their own!
Those two examples show how he regularly dips into that unpleasant volume, as he does right from the start, when Farmer Maggott is said to be "over-reacting".
 
Didn't you know about the phrase book? They are easy to get hold of. If you want it, come and claim it.;)
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top