Mrs. Maggott
Home is where the cat is
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2002
- Messages
- 3,463
Oooookay!
1. What Tolkien did has nothing to do with the case. He needed money and his work was worth something. He sold his story to a publisher as well. He did try to help with the first film adaptation but probably to no avail, given your own assessment of the situation. So I believe that continually harping on his actions is pointless for, in fact, they had nothing to do with the quality of the work itself.
2. I don't believe that our expectations were in the beginning all that high although they proved to be unrealistic - and with each succeeding film, that is becoming more the case. Jackson had introduced great visuals and a fine cast. He also insisted that he would make every effort to be faithful to the book. I guess most of us preferred belief to disbelief. However, even after we realized that he had a different story in mind, the first film was quite superior to most of what is produced today in Hollywood and at least we were able to hope that, however Jackson changed the characters and plot, he would continue to provide a good fantasy adventure film. Alas, TTT proved that we were again mistaken.
I use old films to prove that Hollywood does not have to "screw up" if it does not wish to do so. I'm sure that there are many modern films which are also excellent although I am not a film goer (with the exception of Finding Nemo). I hear that Master and Commander is a fine film but I haven't yet seen it.
I hope this addresses some of your comments.
1. What Tolkien did has nothing to do with the case. He needed money and his work was worth something. He sold his story to a publisher as well. He did try to help with the first film adaptation but probably to no avail, given your own assessment of the situation. So I believe that continually harping on his actions is pointless for, in fact, they had nothing to do with the quality of the work itself.
2. I don't believe that our expectations were in the beginning all that high although they proved to be unrealistic - and with each succeeding film, that is becoming more the case. Jackson had introduced great visuals and a fine cast. He also insisted that he would make every effort to be faithful to the book. I guess most of us preferred belief to disbelief. However, even after we realized that he had a different story in mind, the first film was quite superior to most of what is produced today in Hollywood and at least we were able to hope that, however Jackson changed the characters and plot, he would continue to provide a good fantasy adventure film. Alas, TTT proved that we were again mistaken.
I use old films to prove that Hollywood does not have to "screw up" if it does not wish to do so. I'm sure that there are many modern films which are also excellent although I am not a film goer (with the exception of Finding Nemo). I hear that Master and Commander is a fine film but I haven't yet seen it.
I hope this addresses some of your comments.
