• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

What if 👁️sauron had the simmerals in the ⚔️battle of the last alliance???

In the Silmarils, Feanor had trapped the light of the Two Trees, but otherwise (as far as I know) they held no other innate power. I don't think they would have affected the outcome of the War of the Ring. In fact, I'm pretty sure Sauron's hands would have been considered "unclean" and neither he, nor the Nazgul, nor any of his minions could have possessed the jewels. Heck, they burned the hands of Maedhros and Maglor.
 
On the contrary, they would make Sauron weaker. It would take lot of his strength to carry the silmarils. Silmarils instantly burn everyone evil or with unclean intentions. Melkor's hands were burned by the silmarils. And his iron crown seemed heavy to him. And because he instantly wore it, it made him weaker, because he must put his own strength to endure the heaviness of his crown. When Carcharoth swallowed one of the silmarils, he started to freaking out like crazy, because of tremendous pain caused by silmaril.
 
I do not think the Silmarils are meant for war. However, things meant for one thing may be used for another. Sauron did make use of the Seeing Stones to try and dominate others who used the Stones. Sauron would have to have the gems attached to something so they could not touch him physically as they would burn him, and he was already burned. Think Morgoth and his crown. Speaking of which if the Silmarils could be bent to such ends would Morgoth have worn them to his battle with Fingolfin? I do not think they would have aided Sauron in the war.
 
What we could make sure was that it would make nothing, don't forget when Sauron was still under Melkor command, it brought nothing but seducing the whole Eldar nation into war against Melkor, that's all. Of course it's another matter that Sauron mutated himself thus the Similarion could get rid of being a simple declaration or military bait for him.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top