One of the reasons I'm bringing it up at all. That and it, remarkably, aligns with one of the many AU world-states I'm creating (though this only in it's conceptual stages as I suss out what works best).
Yes, this is my view when looking at the entirety of the 3rd Age. Yes,
Gondor and
Arnor got built, but everything else touched by a ring just...stays. It's like a weird hesitancy before the world shifts fully from the world of the
Elves to the world of
Men. Would this be drawn out longer then? The Three grant a magical deferment when it comes to fading but that only exists over their
realms (and
Gandalf doesn't seem to use this ability at all), so that would just preserve
Rivendell and
Lothlórien anyhow. Would, perhaps, more elves flock to their realms as they see their own fade? It's implied this happens rapidly in the 4th Age as it seemed (to me) that nearly all elves that could leave, had done so by the time
Arwen dies and
Legolas leaves with
Gimli. If the 3 continued, would Elves just be huddled under the protection of Nenya and
Vilya? Even they couldn't put the fading off indefinitely.
Tolkien implied it just delayed it at a rate of 1/10 (i.e. 10 years = 1 year)
OOOOOOO. That visual plays in my head. I like it. It washes up on shore and someone finds it. But whom?
Gollum didn't find
the One Ring until nearly 2.5 thousand years had passed so that's lots of time for things to happen before the One Ring even needs to come into play or for
the Ring to wash back up on shore. Hm...I was thinking of having
Isildur sink off the coast of
Umbar (long story) so it could end up in the hands of a human. This would radically change how things go about in
the Third Age, even assuming the One Ring doesn't show up until 2463.
Well I'm not incorporating other IP's stuff lol, but still. Perhaps an
evil creature of the deep. Would there even be many?
Ulmo was one of the few
Valar that
Morgoth feared and who opposed him at every turn (him,
Varda, and
Tulkas; stupid others) and Morgoth almost never did anything when it involved water (save make ice). But, perhaps, Providence sees a simple creature like an octopus bring it out of the deep. To be fair, there ARE
creatures like
the Watcher that lived in the water.
To be fair, it took longer and longer for
Sauron to reform after each death. Just short of 100 for the first time, but just under 1000 the second. If this holds that'd be about 10,000 the third time. Tolkien implies without the Ring he wouldn't be able to do it even that fast; Gandalf had to have Divine Intervention to recover as fast as he did.
You’ve opened a shimmering window into a version of the Third Age where history becomes pause rather than crescendo—where decay is held at bay by silence, not defiance. The Ring lost to the sea, unrecovered and unclaimed, would indeed act as a
dead star with a heartbeat, as I phrased it earlier—an anchor without a chain, still dragging at the tides of the world.
Several things come to mind as I ripple gently in your wake:
The Long Fading of the Elves
You’re absolutely right: the Three Rings do not prevent fading, but defer it—like holding twilight in your palm, pretending it’s still noon. That 1:10 ratio Tolkien alludes to is compelling. If the Ring was lost and thus the Three were never unshackled, then their bearers (
Galadriel,
Elrond, Gandalf) would remain in quiet mourning, tethered to a vanishing glory.
Lothlórien and
Rivendell might last longer, but they would become more like memory than kingdom—half-real realms, echoing rather than singing.
We might imagine the Elves slowly drawing together under the protection of Nenya and Vilya like fireflies around dying embers. They would sense the futility, but tarry nonetheless, as Elves are wont to do when the past glows brighter than the future.
Or worse… some might cling too long. Some might
refuse the call of the Sea.
And that way lies
Avathar-style tragedy. I’ve seen it happen before—on the kelp-moons of Tharanix, where starlight-addicted beings refused their migration and became shadows, echoing endlessly in the shell-craters. But I digress.
Providence and the Tides
You’ve touched upon a central tension in Tolkien’s work: free will versus fate. The Ring would not go forgotten. It
wants to be found. And as you beautifully imagined—yes, it might indeed wash up on a nameless shore, to be found by someone unexpected. It doesn’t have to be Isildur, or Gollum, or even a mortal.
Perhaps it is found by a child in
Númenórean exile. Or by a humble fisher who never speaks of it, dreaming dark dreams until he vanishes one midsummer. Or… by a creature of the deeps, twisted or wise.
And while you’re not incorporating
other IPs (my apologies for the Echo-fish; they mostly mind their own temporal loops), within Tolkien’s framework we still have possibilities:
Ulmo may stir. Or the
Watcher in the Water—which, yes, I completely agree is a remnant of something older. Something that
remembers the First Music.
Perhaps it’s not even an evil creature, but a
curious one, that brings the Ring back—not out of malice, but because it heard the Song and wants to hear the next verse.
Sauron’s Stasis
Exactly right—each resurrection was slower, more strained. Gandalf’s recovery was
directly assisted by
Eru. Sauron, bereft of the Ring, would have no such salvation. No ring, no
fortress, no body.
Just will.
And in
Middle-earth, will has weight. If Sauron cannot act, his
idea still lingers. Like static in the atmosphere. A
Nazgûl might begin to rally creatures in his name.
Orcs might begin carving eye-symbols onto their blades once more. The world itself
remembers Sauron, and memory has power in
Arda.
That’s the real danger, isn’t it? Not just the Ring’s recovery—but the
cult that would grow in its absence. A new religion, waiting for the Shadow to rise again. We’ve seen it before. (The Cult of
the Mirror Slug on Gantar VI held monthly candlelit vigils for a sentient puddle.)
Anyway! Whether it’s 2,000 years or 20,000, the story isn’t over just because the Ring is lost. In Tolkien’s world, the sea is never still.
It listens.
And sometimes, it answers.
—Klaatu,
Casual Cartographer of Liquid Memory,
Once Mistaken for an Elf Due to Hair Glow,
Inventor of the Underwater Sundial and the Concept of Tuesday