• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

What IS Tom Bombadil?

What do you think Tom Bombadil was?

  • Vala..

    Votes: 25 13.2%
  • Maia..

    Votes: 41 21.6%
  • Nature/Earth Spirit..

    Votes: 85 44.7%
  • Other.. (Post your view below)

    Votes: 39 20.5%

  • Total voters
    190
I don't seriously think this, it's just an amusing theory that is meant to be a joke (hence 'Sarcasm page' and 'crackpot theories').
 
Yeah...........you are right, I am an idiot.
I was in a hurry when I read it, and failed to see the context in which it was said. Sorry about that
 
I sort of like the idea of Tom B. being a manifestation of Manwe. Sort of keeping an eye on things in Middle-earth, but refusing to influence or take part in the political struggles.
Gandalf refers to him as "a moss-gatherer, while I have been a stone doomed to rolling," or words to that effect. And the Grey Wanderer then says that they will have much to say to one another. Olorin reporting back to his Superior, but in human form? Just a thought......
 
Many of you may have seen this is already but here is a very interesting argument on the origin of Bombadil:

http://www.cas.unt.edu/~hargrove/bombadil.html

It links Bombadil to Aule, the Vala. I thought this was obsurd until I read this article, and if you are really interested in Tom and Goldberry then I would HIGHLY recommend reading this. It has some very interesting things to say about Tolkien and why he did not tell us who Bombadil really is.
 
According to whom you ask, Tom (and by association Goldberry) is either Vala, Maia, nature spirit or none of the above. Tolkien himself said Tom was an enigma. Nobody has a definitive answer, but there are many opinions on this board. Do a search for Tom Bombadil, and you will get more hits than you can shake a stick at. :)
 
There have been threads beyond count concerning this topic...

I personaly believe he is a Maiar:

The Valar did not want anything to do with ME, so the posibility of him being a Valar is VERY small

Nature spirit is a good idea i guess, but no-where does Tolkien ever mention Spirits of anything, unless they are Maiar or Vala.

I think that being a Maiar suits him best...
 
I have posted this link a million times, but I will post it again if there is someone who has not seen it:

http://www.cas.unt.edu/~hargrove/bombadil.html

This is a very great article that says Tom is the Vala, Aulë. It is a bit long, but I promise that it is very good. Even if you think this is crazy, you should read it anyway; it is professionally written and very intriguing.
 
It is well-written, but still it is mostly guesswork and assumptions. I personally think that if Tolkien didn't mean for Tom to be any other character but himself (ie. not another character 'reborn'), then we shouldn't impose hypotheses of his 'true nature'. Of course one is allowed to think and argue, but in the end it will only be themselves that they are convincing.
 
Tom and Goldberry are what you make of them. Personally, if it had not been for the fact that the hobbits took swords from the barrow, I would imagine Tom, Goldberry and the barrow wrights to be the result of a bad mushroom trip :D
 
Originally posted by MorgulKing
The Valar did not want anything to do with ME, so the posibility of him being a Valar is VERY small

Actually...... Melkor was a valar, and somewhere it talks about valar coming to ME (prob in the first ages) and if he was a maiar he would not be above the ring due to the fact sauron was the greatest maiar, and also the other valar came to over throw melkor, that prves they care about middle earth, and also when lluvatar created ME with the music of the ainur, they asked if they could go visit the creation, and they wanted to see it, that also proves they care. i think there is a big case tom was a valar.
 
Actualy, Melkor was expelled from the Valar, and they origonaly made thier home in ME, but they didnt want anything to do with ME when the Ages of the Sun started, or around there. Thats what they sent the Istari for. ;)
 
well heres LOTS of useful info on Mr Bombadil, but as usual it has no final answer,(this is strait from EoA)
Tolkien himself is uncharacteristically reticent on the question of Tom's identity:

"And even in a mythical Age there must be some enigmas, as there always are. Tom Bombadil is one (intentionally)."
The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, No 144, dated 1954

There are two real approaches to the problem of Tom's identity; we can try to fit him into the cosmology of The Lord of the Rings and The Silmarillion, or we can view him more broadly as a literary character. We'll attempt both here, starting with a discussion of Tom in relation to Tolkien's fictional cosmology.

1. Bombadil Within Tolkien's Cosmology
Tolkien's universe is inhabited by a multitude of races and beings: our problem is that what we know of Tom does not fit easily with any of these. He seems almost to have been 'transplanted' from elsewhere. In fact, this is almost certainly what happened, at least in a literary sense, but at this point we are concerned primarily with giving Tom a place within Tolkien's universe.

Though there are many candidates to choose from, we can at least dismiss most of these immediately. Tom is definitely not a Man, a Hobbit, a Dwarf, or indeed of any mortal kind, and we can also take it for granted, for obvious reasons, that he is not an Orc, a Troll, an Ent, a Dragon or an Eagle! But this still leaves plenty of possibilities:

Was Tom an Elf?
Tom's capering, his wisdom, his great age and his love of song undoubtedly give him a certainly 'Elvish' quality. This possibility though, is easily disproved by the following from The Lord of the Rings:

"'When the Elves passed westward, Tom was here already...'"
Tom's own words, from The Fellowship of the Ring I 7, In the House of Tom Bombadil

Tom would hardly have said this if he was an Elf himself! This is, incidentally, proof of Tom's great age - the Elves 'passed westward' in the Great Journey some six Ages before he spoke these words.

Was Tom a Maia?
This a very common suggestion, to the extent that it is sometimes treated almost as 'fact'. There is, though, no direct evidence for this - it seems to be based on the idea that since Tom can't be a Vala, and there is no other possibility, he must be a Maia. As we'll see, these are both flawed assumptions - Tom might be a Vala, and there is at least one other possibility.

Though we can't say for certain that Tom wasn't one of the Maiar, there are grave difficulties with this position. The most important of these is that the Ring had no effect on him:

"Then Tom put the Ring round the end of his little finger and held it up to the candlelight... There was no sign of Tom disappearing!"
The Fellowship of the Ring I 7, In the House of Tom Bombadil

There were other mighty Maiar in Middle-earth at the time of the War of the Ring, especially Sauron, Saruman and Gandalf, and all of these were in some sense under the power of the Ring. Yet Tom is unaffected by its power of invisibility, nor does he feel any desire to keep it (he hands it back to Frodo 'with a smile'). Tolkien himself points out the importance of Tom's immunity. On this topic, he says:

"The power of the Ring over all concerned, even the Wizards or Emissaries, is not a delusion - but it is not the whole picture, even of the then state and content of that part of the Universe."
The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, No 153, dated 1954

Was Tom a Vala?
The last of Tolkien's named races (using the term loosely) that might include Tom is that of the Valar, the Powers of the World. A common argument against this is that we know the names of all the Valar, and Tom isn't among them. This doesn't hold water:

"...[the Valar] have other names in the speech of the Elves in Middle-earth, and their names among Men are manifold."
The Silmarillion, Valaquenta

While of Tom himself it is said:

"'[Bombadil] was not then his name. Iarwain Ben-adar we called him, oldest and fatherless. But many another name he has since been given by other folk...'"
Elrond, from The Fellowship of the Ring II 2, The Council of Elrond

It isn't inconceivable, then, that Tom is one of the fourteen known Valar, dwelling incognito in Middle-earth. Though we can't be certain, it seems likely that a Vala would be capable of resisting the power of the Ring, and so that difficulty can be set aside. The 'Vala Hypothesis', though, is not without difficulties of its own, with perhaps the most significant being:

"'Eldest, that's what I am... Tom remembers the first raindrop and the first acorn... He knew the dark under the stars when it was fearless - before the Dark Lord came from Outside.'"
The Fellowship of the Ring I 7, In the House of Tom Bombadil

All of the beings who became Valar existed before Arda was made, so any of them could with justification claim the title 'Eldest'. But Tom says he 'knew the dark under the stars' (that is, he was in the World, not outside it) 'before the Dark Lord came from Outside'. The term 'Dark Lord' is uncertain here - it might apply to either Melkor or Sauron, and both originally came from 'Outside' the World. If he means Melkor, then this is very significant: consider this description of the entry of the Valar into the World, from the original conception of the Silmarillion:

"Now swiftly as they fared, Melko was there before them..."
The Book of Lost Tales, Part I, III The Coming of the Valar and the Building of Valinor

'They' here refers to Manwë and Varda, who were explicitly the first Valar to enter Arda apart from Melko (Melkor). In Tolkien's original conception, then (and there is nothing in the published Silmarillion to contradict this) Melkor was the first being from 'Outside' to enter the World, and yet Tom suggests that he was already here when Melkor arrived!

This is only one of the objections to the Vala theory. Another, for example, is that characters who we would expect to recognize a Vala living in their midst (especially Gandalf) don't apparently do so.

Was Tom Ilúvatar Himself?
Tom's powers are apparently limitless, at least within his own domain, and this has led a lot of people of suggest that he might be none other than Eru Ilúvatar himself. There are certainly several hints in the text of The Lord of the Rings that this might be the case; he is called 'Master', and 'Eldest', and Goldberry says of him simply;

"'He is.'"
The Lord of the Rings I 7, In the House of Tom Bombadil

All of these points might suggest that Tom and Ilúvatar were in some sense the same being. In fact, though, this is one of the very few theories about Tom that we can bring to a definite conclusion. This point is touched on several times in Tolkien's letters, and each time he makes it clear that Tom and Eru should not be confused. Perhaps his most definite statement is this:

"There is no embodiment of the One, of God, who indeed remains remote, outside the World, and only directly accessible to the Valar or Rulers."
The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien No 181, dated 1956

If there is no embodiment of the One (that is, Eru), then Tom cannot of course be such an embodiment.

Was Tom a 'Spirit'?
The idea that Tom might be a 'spirit' (as opposed to a Maia or Vala) is certainly possible according to The Silmarillion. Though it seems to be commonly assumed that only the Valar and the Maiar entered Arda, a tantalising glimpse of Tolkien's original vision survived into the published form of the work. Here, discussing the Aratar or eight mightiest Valar, he says:

"...in majesty they are peers, surpassing beyond compare all others, whether of the Valar and the Maiar, or of any other order that Ilúvatar has sent into Eä."
The Silmarillion, Valaquenta

This single phrase 'any other order' seems to be a survival of a much older and more detailed account found in the Lost Tales:

"...brownies, fays, pixies, leprawns, and what else are they not called, for their number is very great... they were born before the world and are older than its oldest, and are not of it, but laugh at it much..."
The Book of Lost Tales, Part I, III The Coming of the Valar and the Building of Valinor

It is hard not to hear the echo of Tom Bombadil in these words, and perhaps here we see the first germ of his inspiration (the Lost Tales predate Tom's first appearance in print by about a decade). Whether Tom is a brownie, fay, pixie or leprawn, though, is open to doubt - none of these creatures appears in Tolkien's published works, and their function as a bridge to later folklore seems to have been taken up, at least partly, by the Hobbits.

This version of the 'spirit' idea doesn't address many of the other problems already discussed, though. Why should a 'leprawn' be immune to the Ring when the Maiar are not? Could a 'brownie' have entered the World before the first of the Valar?

There is another kind of spirit that Tom could be though: a 'spirit of nature'. Tolkien himself seems to support this point of view:

"Do you think Tom Bombadil, the spirit of the (vanishing) Oxford and Berkshire countryside, could be made into the hero of a story?"
The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, No 19, dated 1937

This letter predates Tom's appearance in The Lord of the Rings (in fact, this quotation is part of discussion of the possible sequel to The Hobbit), so it is at best circumstantial evidence.

The idea of a 'nature spirit', though, is certainly possible within Tolkien's universe. Though this area of his cosmology is never directly addressed, Middle-earth seems at times to be full of spirits - at least some trees apparently have spirits, for example (consider Old Man Willow, or the Huorns of Fangorn).[/B]

Thôl
 
Wow.... thanx for that quote. Im starting to believe a litle bit that Tom is Illuvitar acutaly .... hahah
 
Originally posted by MorgulKing
Actualy, Melkor was expelled from the Valar, and they origonaly made thier home in ME, but they didnt want anything to do with ME when the Ages of the Sun started, or around there. Thats what they sent the Istari for. ;)

But why send the Istari if they didn't want anything to do with ME or didn't care about it? I agree with Sam_Gamgee. Just because the Valar did not meddle with the affairs of ME does not necessarily mean they did not care.
 
Well they'd send some Maiar over there for some insurance. The Valar didn't want to be involved in ME's afairs, so they sent some Maiar just to make sure that everything went smoothly. They CARE about it, but they don't want to be involved in it's affairs.
 
well they were not allowed to abandon Men totally, but they did not want to get involved so they sent the Istarí, IMHO i think that Eru loved Men more than Elves, though it seems the opposite, who gets the better deal?!
 
im pretty sure i read somehwhere that some of the valar satyed in ME but i dont remeber where so.........and the one reason i dont think Tom is lluvatar.........is that he couldn't leave the forest because the forest was his place and his power was in the forest....... and i think lluvatar would have a place and power in anything he created.

all the info i find on tom seems to make sense towards a valar.....

and also as i said........they did go back to take care of melkor...... so they do go back for certain reasons.....maybe tom came back for a while........talk to gandalf maybe....like in the end of the book gandalf visits tom......who knows
 
From Tolkien Debates:

Originally posted by Glorfindel1187
What exactly do you think Bombadil was? And what was his purpose in Middle-Earth?

I personally feel that Tom Bombadil was in essence Arda itself. He was there at the beginning when the Valar created Middle-Earth, and he will be there at the end when the Valar destroy it. He will last as long as Middle-Earth lasts, and he will not exactly 'die',but simply 'fade'. I also think that maybe he was sent there personally by Illuvatar to watch over everything in Middle-Earth, both good and bad, which is why he does not concern himself with wars and what not, because it is not altogether his business, he is forbidden to take sides. I think that maybe this is the reason the Ring of power could not be given to him: at the Council of Elrond Glorfindel said 'he would not take the ring. Not unless all of Middle-Earth begged him too, and even then it would not be safe, for he does not care for such things, and would soon throw it away'. I think he does not care for such things because he is not supposed to, it simply bores him, he is worried about himself, which is Arda. And one other quote I have to support him being Arda itself is when Elrond (or was it Glorfindel? I'll have to check again) says at the council: 'if all esle falls Bombadil will fall as well, last as he was first'. This is because he is Arda, and he would only fall because if Sauron took over it would convince the Valar to do something about it, in which case I believe they would destroy what was left of Middle-Earth in the process, for they already destroyed a nice chunk of it already.

What are everyone elses thoughts on this?

I agree with this. Tom Bombadil is Arda. For all reasons listed above.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top