A notch even above Mamamoo.
Whoah there -- hold up! I certainly admire Spica, but they're disbanded. Various reasons have been given, one of them that they weren't signed to one of the powerful "Big 3" companies, which controlled much of what got airplay and exposure. But that goes for Mamamoo too, who are with the much smaller and newer RBW.
Another reason is perhaps the fault of Kpop fans themselves, and the "Idol" image that one could argue was enforced on them, but which they adopted: the need for "visuals" and dancing, which interferes with singing to the point where many groups lipsynch in performances (in much the same way it happened in the US and elsewhere). In fact, most Kpop Idol groups are lucky if they possess more than one decent singer, the emphasis on other aspects being so primary. Spica, concentrating on singing as they did, and perforce neglecting these other elements, fell victim to those expectations. Unfortunately.
Question is, is it possible to overcome those obstacles, without losing vocal performance? I think Mamamoo has demonstrated that it is. I'm going to delve a little deeper into Kpop Land here, so apologies in advance to those who find this stuff of no interest whatever -- feel free to post as many eye roll emojis as you think necessary!
There's a TV series called "Immortal Song" in which various people perform "classic" songs from the past. Most of them would be unfamiliar to (most) of us, of course, so I'll first post an original version, just for reference. This is from the 80's, pre-Kpop, and I suppose would be considered a "trot song" (I'm open to correction):
A few seconds will give you the idea.
About a year after their debut, Spica performed a version:
A perfectly good performance, even though missing a couple of members -- but that brought them down to the same number of powerful singers in Mamamoo, I'd point out; it's difficult to achieve 5-part harmonies with only four members! You'll notice the backup dancers.
About a year after
their debut, Mamamoo performed their version -- and what did they do? Turned it into a full-fledged Vegas act -- without losing a bit of vocal performance!
You can
checklist all the genres they include in the performance, so I won't bother, but notice how they draw the audience in (an audience, I'd mention, that is not the usual Kpop audience of kids -- you can see many older faces; they come to this show to hear the music of their youth, but are still as excited as the kids). Mamamoo's enthusiasm is infectious; they're almost bursting with personality, and throwing themselves into the performance. Dancing like crazy,
and singing their hearts out. How they manage both is beyond me, but I suspect they carefully design their choreography so that the two don't conflict.
Note: no backup dancers required. In fact, I can almost see the backup singers thinking "what are we even doing here?"
OK -- back to regularly scheduled programming.