• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Who exactly is Tom Bombadil?

The greatest enigma of all! Tom Bombadil

I thought this thread could benefit from Tom's entry in The Tolkien Society's Character List:-

"Tom Bombadil (and Goldberry)
Bright blue his jacket is, and his boots are yellow. Some believe that Tom's main purpose is to hold up the narrative just long enough to weed out uncommitted readers. Adapters always leave him out of their dramatisations. He seems to have waded in from another story entirely. Don't be fooled. Tom has a few things to say, and wasn't it Tom that found Merry his short sword with the significant runes on it? Tolkien never wrote a multi-layered text-based computer adventure (personal computers did not exist in his time), but he knew a plot twist when he saw one. Tom's lovely wife Goldberry grew up in a river and still wears fish-skin shoes.

The meaning of "Bombadil" is unexplained. "Goldberry" may be from a poetic Middle English name "Goldborow", meaning, presumably, golden city. On the other hand, it may mean a small sweet yellow Arctic fruit used to make jam in Scandinavia."


Did Tom have a foresight that led him to give Merry the sword that brought down the Witch King of Angmar? Did he know the spells that were folded into the forging of it, and the effect they would have? Hmmm.
 
Re: Hey dol! Merry dol! a ring a dong dillo! The greatest enigma of all! Tom Bombadil


I believe that I may have found an indirect reference to these spirits in the published Silmarillion.

It occurs in the Valaquenta - in the final paragraph of the section titled "of the Valar":

"Among them Nine were of chief power and reverence; but one is removed from their number, and Eight remain, the Aratar, the High Ones of Arda: Manwë and Varda, Ulmo, Yavanna and Aulë, Mandos, Nienna, and Oromë. Though Manwë is their King and holds their allegiance under Eru, in majesty they are peers, surpassing beyond compare all others, whether of the Valar and the Maiar, or of any other order that Ilúvatar has sent into Eä."

Who are these other orders of beings (besides the Valar and Maiar) which Ilúvatar sent into Eä if not the various types of nature spirits refered to in the Book of Lost Tales?
 
Last edited:
Re: Hey dol! Merry dol! a ring a dong dillo! The greatest enigma of all! Tom Bombadil

I'm surprised to see how quickly this thread died...

There is so much more of Tom to discuss than just his origins. Who is he to you? Does anyone feel his laughter reverberating through the pages of any other of the published works, such as The Silmarillion? Can Tom be found where we truly haven't looked before...?

Cheers,

Úlairi.
 
Re: Hey dol! Merry dol! a ring a dong dillo! The greatest enigma of all! Tom Bombadil

From Tolkien's poem "Once upon a Time":
Who or what were these "lintips"?

Why would they not talk to Tom?

What (if anything) does Tom's lack of knowledge about these creatures say about his status as "Eldest" and "Master"?
 
Re: Hey dol! Merry dol! a ring a dong dillo! The greatest enigma of all! Tom Bombadil

Tom Bombadill in LoTR I always see as myself. Or at least, what I should be, what I could be, if only I were never distracted by the truly irrelevant but seemingly important distractions of life. Tom is the beautiful sobriety and true understanding of reality you experience coming down from a wonderful journey (wink wink) in the forest
 
Re: Hey dol! Merry dol! a ring a dong dillo! The greatest enigma of all! Tom Bombadil

I've always found it somewhat touching that Tom cared for Merry's ponies and made sure that they got a good home following the events at Bree.
 
Re: Hey dol! Merry dol! a ring a dong dillo! The greatest enigma of all! Tom Bombadil

I've been meaning for quite some time to get to this post as it the myth of Tom's irrelevance is one that deserves to be dispelled.


Perhaps a simple reading of the first sentence is enough to ascertain the extent of Tom's "extraneous insignificance". He is unimportant to the narrative. It would likely be obvious to an eighth-grader that Tom's position within the plotline is somewhat enigmatic to the point that notions of redundancy may arise. Tolkien goes on to futher delineate the nature of Tom's existence within the story, as like it or not Celegorm, he's always going to be there. Tolkien himself appears to grapple what Tom's exact "function" really is, but if you read the quote further:


Tom sees the world through rosy-coloured glasses. His is the physical embodiment of pacifism (but not pure pacifism). However, the pacifism of Tom is inactive rather than active; indifferent pacifism. However JRRT refers to the commentary of Tom in The Council of Elrond to be a commentary on pacifism and that it finds such things to be wonderful and necessary in a world where blind lust for power seeks to dominate and destroy opposition and ultimately freedom. In this context Tolkien explains that Tom holds a mirror to the hideous face of war. Through a commentary on Tom we then derive a commentary on war. Through a glass darkly we can see that war is necessary for the survival of pacifism but clearly Tom's function is that of perfection. Tom is of course, unimportant in the sense that Frodo must bear the Ring through fire, earth and water to conquer the last embodiment of evil within the world, which is indeed the narrative. He still lies on the wayside skipping merrily along and asking us the most important question: why? The Hobbits rest within Tom's abode before marching off to war and Tom pacifistic envelopment of Middle-earth itself becomes a reason to fight for its preservation.

Whilst quoting the movie often makes me cringe I can nonetheless feel that this particular quote conveys quite well what I believe Tom may very well be:

"That there is some good in this world, Mr. Frodo, and it's worth fighting for."


I consider that point to be utterly moot. Tolkien indeed no longer upheld his myth as being a mythology of England, however Tolkien also says of Tom:

The Letters of JRR Tolkien - #153: To Peter Hastings (draft)

... he [Tom] is then an 'allegory', or an exemplar, a particular embodying of pure (real) natural science ...

Tom has become more than just an extrinsic element of unused mythology but is a father (not the Father - see Tolkien's discourse in the same letter of "he is" and "I am" - quite interesting actually) - Father Nature in his majestic glory. The inert function of Tom is representation of the beauty resident within nature itself. We, as the reader through Tom, do not wish to see Middle-earth burn in the fires of malice.


Quite an enlightening analogy there Celegorm and I would have to agree with you until you decided to sever the connection of the cause and the result and thus take it out of its context. Alice "renounced control" through an assertion of her autonomous power but as the protagonist of the story the result of self-realization was climactic. The cause of self-realization effected power over the Queen. The power was simply shifted. Tom's "renounced control" was that of the Ring's assertion of power which failed miserably, and not vice versa. Remember the words of Gandalf. Alice is liberated whilst Tom has remained completely free. Alice "renounced control" but Tom was rather "control renounced". Tom is an autonomous element, but one that was never dropped into the story as his is encased within the flesh of Middle-earth itself and has his own dominion there. Tom resides within all Story. His autonomy comes not through self-declaration but through self-examination. Tom simply "is"; he does not "become" (or more correctly, "becomes" through the reader). Tom, to me, then becomes important as we must seek him as he does not seek us. When we find Tom we see that without him the Shire is just trees, land and hills and not a home worth defending; good worth fighting for.

Come on everyone, let's go find Tom!

Also, let's not forget that Tom indeed did give the hobbits the sword which finally caused the destruction of the Witch-king and that he delivered them from evil twice. Is Tom then truly pacifism - or pacifism to a point? Just read above and you'll see that Tom is more than just an extrinsic commentary but a haven preserving the beauty of nature. He is what we may stand to lose if evil is triumphant. We attribute value to Tom through ourselves as nature becomes important through our love for it. I understand the circular nature of the logic that: "Tom has meaning because we give him meaning". Tolkien also does not believe that Tom requires philosophizing - neither does nature but the inquisitive human mind shall do so nonetheless. He may not have been important to the author or the narrative, but he sure is vital to many readers. How insightful it was of Tolkien through an extrinsic characterization of nature to subconsciously rouse questions of not just why we are fighting this battle, but what we are actually fighting for. "From dust we came and to dust shall we return". Tom, to me, is that all-important first sprinkle of dust - and because of that he is truly beautiful.

But that's simply why I started the thread in the first place...

Cheers,

Úlairi.
 
Last edited:
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…