• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Who is the oldest? Bombadil or Treebeard

Who is older?

  • Tom Bombadil

    Votes: 14 100.0%
  • Treebeard/Fangorn

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    14
I might be able to add something important though. Back a couple of pages in the debate it discusses wether Tom is living or not. I believe he is not living and this is why. The ring has power over all living things but it has no power over Tom in fact Tom has power over it, this would lead one to believe that Tom is not really living.
 
The fact that Tom may have not been living is a loophole for Tolkien to escape contradiction, although, we will never know it and will never be able to prove it.
 

I think the only thing iron-clad here is your ego and I'm-right-ness...
 

I've been very busy at work ond on vacation. It good to be back, though. There is no place like home.

I do not dispute Grond's (and yours) knowledge of Tolkien, but everybody has a right to their own opinion, and mine shouldn't necessarily concur with that of Grond. Getting to the point, you should be more attentive: I was referring to Encyclopaedia of Arda only to the extent that it provides a link to the essay. If that wasn't clear, I am sorry -- that essay is not a part of E.of A., it is a separate piece of work. The essay is post-humous and so is the EofA. However, The Encyclopaedia seems accurate enough and it itself does present points in both support and rebuke of your theory. I beleive that by 'Tolkien's publications' you mean his letter (correct me if I am wrong) in which he says that Bombadil is an 'intentional enigma'. This definition opens a door to many theories and arguments of what's Tom's origins are. While I recall another letter in which he said something to the effect that Tom represents the [dieing]spirit of the English Berkshire (not a quote, of course), I think this letter is earlier and writer's view of his material changes over time. But even if not, these two statements are not contradictory as mentioning of what someone represents is not necessarily a statements about his/her origins. I still think that you presented an argument (albeit, a good one) but NOT 'clearly shown'.
 
Originally posted by pohuist
I do not dispute Grond's (and yours) knowledge of Tolkien, but everybody has a right to their own opinion, and mine shouldn't necessarily concur with that of Grond.

I agree, I just wasn't expecting it, that's all pohuist.

Originally posted by pohuist
Getting to the point, you should be more attentive:

Uh-uh pohuist, I was attentive enough, you weren't clear on what you were saying.

Originally posted by pohuist
I was referring to Encyclopaedia of Arda only to the extent that it provides a link to the essay.

Exactly, which is why I said my argument was more...

Originally posted by Ulairi
"...iron-clad..."

...then yours. (Someone just shot himself in the foot )

Originally posted by pohuist
...it is a separate piece of work.

I know.

Originally posted by pohuist
However, The Encyclopaedia seems accurate enough and it itself does present points in both support and rebuke of your theory.

I know, however, it is post-humous, whereas Tolkien's Lord of the Rings was not. Therefore, as I have said, the Encyclopaedia of Arda should not be believed as much as the thoughts of Tolkien in The Lord of the Rings.


And that's how the argument ended, at a stalemate. We will never know where Bombadil is from and if he was a 'living creature' or not. Therefore, Tolkien escaped contradiction via loopholes.

Originally posted by pohuist
...but NOT 'clearly shown'.

It is probable that what I have said is the 'clearest' solution that you will find, and you will find that a lot of people would agree with me. The Encyclopaedia of Arda does not give an insightful enough look into the enigmatic Tom Bombadil as The Lord of the Rings does, where I derived my theory from.

Originally posted by Wonko the Sane
"The only thing "iron-clad" is your ego."

Well, at least I have a reason to be egocentric.
 
Last edited:
I never argued with that and I was clear enough on what I argue with
All I was saying that you did not 'clearly show...' and that, in fact, it is impossible to say anything definitive about the origins of Tom. I am glad, you concede it, though
 
I conceded a stalemate, not defeat pohuist. Thanks for the compliment Wonko the Sane.
 
Hey, when you take the time and energy to contstruct a well-developed argument you deserve the props.
 
Re: Who is the oldest?

 
 

My apologies pohuist, I wasn't being attentive. It was late at night and well...you know the drill I'm sure. However, I believe that that argument of which I so carefully came up with cannot be proved beyond reasonable doubt, but it is the most viable solution to the problem, yes, I admit there are holes in it, but it is the best explanation I believe that anyone could come up with.

Originally posted by pohuist
Exactly. And you said it yourself, thus, conceding defeat. So, who shot huimself in the foot?

I concede defeat, but only on the basis that my argument could not be proved beyond reasonable doubt, not by the fact that you defeated me yourself. Therefore, technically, I shot myself in the foot yes, but I believe it was a shot in the foot that showed a little verity in what I was saying.
 
Why has this argument continued on for additional pages? It was apparent over 3 pages ago that no rational determination could be made as to who was the oldest. The entire argument hinges on whether Tom is deemed a "living creature" or not. JRRT in his letters specifically states that he included Tom not because he really fit in with Middle-earth but because he (Tolkien) wanted to. Tom was a character Tolkien had previously developed and he simply found a place for him in the works.

Tom was eldest, Tom was first...yada yada yada. Tom is an enigma who exists yet doesn't exist. On him the Ring has no effect. Nothing appears to hold power over him, not Barrow-wights, not Old-man Willow, not no stinkin Nazgul..... nothing. My opinion continues to be that Tom is something non-human from the mind of Eru. He ain't no Valar, he ain't no Maiar, he ain't no Elar, he ain't no man. I still think he's a Munchkin.
 
Last edited:
Originally posted by Grond
Why has this argument continued on for additional pages? It was apparent over 3 pages ago that no rational determination could be made as to who was the oldest.
Yes and no, I was hoping someone would "pick up" the quote from Of Aule and Yavanna I gave earlier:
and
for this IMO can only mean that the Ents like the Eagles are "spirits summoned from afar" which throws a different light at the topic.
 
Grond, this was exactly what I thought before I stumbled across said passage again and read it more carefully, but now I am no longer sure about it.

Anyway, I have opened another thread in the Silmarillion Forum, maybe this is worth further discussion...
 
Last edited:
Grond, I couldn't agree more. I said that also. But a few ignorant people (not Walter and pohuist and Brent mind you), decided to keep my thread going a little further.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…