Why was 🧝Arwen dying?

Wolfshead

Formerly CraigSmith

Joined

May 27, 2002

Messages

1,403

• Dec 26, 2003

• #61

Sauron supposedly showed Aragorn this vision of Arwen in her dying state (the dying that Elrond mentioned). This seems to have occured by her choosing to become mortal. I was saying that I'm mortal, yet I'm not lying anywhere pale and lifeless. Therefore, there's not a logical solution to Arwen seeming to be dying in ROTK.

 

M

MemorableArwen

New Member

Joined

Aug 15, 2003

Messages

19

• Dec 28, 2003

• #62

Arwen dying???????'

I just quoted what i saw in the book. I havent seen the movie yet.

 

Wolfshead

Formerly CraigSmith

Joined

May 27, 2002

Messages

1,403

• Dec 28, 2003

• #63

Ah ha, right. I thought you were quoting from a book that was specifically about the film. Oh well

 

M

MemorableArwen

New Member

Joined

Aug 15, 2003

Messages

19

• Dec 28, 2003

• #64

Ireally dont know anymore what i am talking about. Cause his book(s) has/have pictures from the movie, so ...

 

Wolfshead

Formerly CraigSmith

Joined

May 27, 2002

Messages

1,403

• Dec 30, 2003

• #65

So is the book you have about the LOTR book or film? Because we've seen how certain facts are changed for the film book releases.

 

M

MemorableArwen

New Member

Joined

Aug 15, 2003

Messages

19

• Dec 30, 2003

• #66

Arwen dying??????''

The books are about movies . The books have title: The official illustrated movie companion (All three titles).

 

M

MemorableArwen

New Member

Joined

Aug 15, 2003

Messages

19

• Jan 3, 2004

• #67

Arwen dying???????

The movie is fabulous!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Saermegil

The Starchild

Joined

Nov 14, 2003

Messages

199

• Jan 3, 2004

• #68

Arwen is ill because the ring is not destroyed(dont aks me, aks PJ). Elrond tellas this to Aragorn when he hands him Anduril(no,not at rivendell, when he makes that suprise visit(Hey Aragorn ol' buddy! I was just in the neiborhoud(oh, by the way i have this for you)) at Aragorn's camp).
Now Aragorn has one more reason to destroy sacrifice himself to destruct Sauron so Frodo can destroy the ring. that reason is that Arwen can afterwards liva a happy mortal life with or without her husband. Ooops did I say mortal life? I meant Immortal life in the West. She was heading there, right? (but why was she heading there if she was already mortaL and getting sick?).



This post may well be as confused as a PJ movie!

 

M

MemorableArwen

New Member

Joined

Aug 15, 2003

Messages

19

• Jan 4, 2004

• #69

Arwen dying?????????

Hey Saermegil!

Arwen had made a decision to go to Undying Lands, but then she had a vision of her son on the way to Grey Port. Then she came back to Rivendell and that is all began. Cause she at that point decided (Well she did it when she saw her son in a vision) to become mortal. Remember the book slipping from her hands? It started just right there. At least this is how i interprEted it.

MOVIE IS FANTASTIC!!!!!
I WANT MOOOOOOOOOOREEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!

ARAGORN RULES!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Saermegil

The Starchild

Joined

Nov 14, 2003

Messages

199

• Jan 4, 2004

• #70

Thanks for the explanation,MemorableArwen. I propably missed all that by being shocked by what PJ did to the story, especially regarding Arwen.

 

M

MemorableArwen

New Member

Joined

Aug 15, 2003

Messages

19

• Jan 6, 2004

• #71

Arwen dying?????????

"You are welcome! But maybe others have their interpretation. So mine may be wrong. All the same we are here to discuss this "important" questions.