• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Giants

Giants were the strange stone-giant race that lived in the Misty Mountains towards the end of the Third Age. They’re also found in the North Moors of Middle-earth. The mysterious creatures have an untold origin and had their first encounter with other races in the Third Age.

Giants in The Hobbit

Three giants turned stone.
Two Stone-giants were described to hurl and throw rocks at each other during thunderstorms. It is unclear if it was a game or an actual fight. They had a stone-like physical form, and little is known about them. Gandalf used to tell Bilbo Baggins stories about goblins, dragons, and giants. He also Bilbo about the princesses rescued and the luck of the sons of widows. Gandalf also remarked that he hoped to find a decent giant to hinder the orcs of the caves.

While Bilbo Baggins played the riddle game, he thought about the giants he heard from the stories. Once, Bilbo went up the stream and saw a massive rock on it. He then wondered if the rock was thrown by a giant from miles away. He also mentioned giants when he compared strikes from a crash of battering-rams from forest oaks and being swung by giants.

Giants in The LOTR

The types of giants mentioned in The Red Book of Westmarch [1] were not frequently mentioned in the LOTR trilogy. The popular belief is that Tolkien has intentionally left the giants out of the story as he expanded on Endor’s cosmology.

Giants in the earlier writings of Tolkien

Stone Giants.
In Tolkien’s early writings, he mentioned the giants among the monster-folks that the dark lord Melkor raised and bred during the first centuries of Middle-earth. The dark lord produced monster creatures, including the stone-giants, ogres, and wicked dwarves called Nauglath. In part two of the Book of Lost Tales, the stone giants were mentioned with names, they were Glim and Nan. In other works of Tolkien, there were other named stone giants like Wade and Noroth. During the early drafts of the Hobbit Trilogy, the production of The Hobbit had giants in human-like form.

This was later reviewed and edited to only be mentioned. Gandalf told stories of giants that rescued princesses in the final version that made the publication. There was some connection between the stone giants from Farmer Giles of Ham and the giants of the general tales as used in The Hobbit story. The Giants of Farmer Giles were rude, uncultured, and troublesome folks. They were often referred to as being huge as elms and stupid. Tolkien mentioned them in his early drafts for The Lord of the Ring. He said, “stone giants and trolls were different as they were not dull-witted but cunning and capable of wizardry, although they were not any less malevolent.” Christopher J.R. Tolkien and John D. Rateliff speculated that some of Tolkien’s references to giants are inspired by tales of giants from a different mythology. Some of them are fire-giants, sea giants, storm-giants, and other giants include the frost giants and hill giants.

Portrayal in Adaptations

The Hobbit Film Trilogy

Stone giants were featured in The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey, [2] the first part of Peter Jackson’s production of The Hobbit. The stone giants fought and threw rocks at each other to the amazement and horror of Thorin’s company. These giants appeared as stacks from stone pieces at the size of mountains. This is similar to the depiction of tree-like Ents in the lord of the Rings.

The Hobbit Video Game

In the video game The Hobbit, [3] giants are represented as human-like, but their bodies are made of stone. In the game, stone giants threw stones at Bilbo, and they unintentionally helped him escape.

Battle for Middle-earth II

Stone Giants appear in the game Battle for Middle-earth II. [4] The goblins can recruit these giants along with the cave trolls. Giants have a sort of red tinge and can throw the biggest boulders compared to all the game’s races. Like the trolls, the giants have some alliance with the goblins, even though they were neutral to other species that were not like them. The goblin king, known as Gorkil, promises better targets for the boulders they hurl. The Nazgul leader, the Witch-King of Angmar, convinces mountain giants to fight by their side. In power for Tier 3, the thrall masters can summon two mountain giants in some missions.

The LOTR: War in the North

In this video game, [5] the three heroes face a Mountain giant called Bargrisar, who was influenced by Agandaur. Generally, the stone giants were not dangerous to the beings of Endor. Still, they can be influenced negatively to become evil and dangerous.

The LOTR Online

There are three different races of stone giants. Two of them live in the Misty Mountains - the most humanoid race lives in the Misty Mountains, and the other is based in the High Moor between Eregion and Rivendell. The other race lives in the woods in the northwestern part of Bree. Giants appear in the Misty Mountains. The last race is the Jorthkyn, the giants who live in North Downs, [6] the Lone-lands, and at the edge of the city of Angmar.

Influence

The stone giants in Tolkien’s works were probably influenced by Jotun of the Norse mythology. The Jotun had similar characteristics to the beastly behavior and strength.

Quotes

John D. Rateliff observes in The History of Tolkien’s work, The Hobbit: “... ‘ent’ simply means ‘giant’ in Old English... The Book of Lost Tales had referred to giants as one of the Úvanimor, or monster-folk (BLT I.75), a thoroughly traditional touch on Tolkien’s part; giants have a long, long tradition in the folklore of being extremely dangerous if not downright wicked... Ents are one of the five Free Peoples; giants one of those races which may be called the Children of Morgoth... The stone-giants of The Hobbit do not seem to be aware of the presence of the travelers, but then again there’s no indication that they would have behaved any differently had they known; in short, they are portrayed as a perilous but almost impersonal force, rather like the thunderstorm itself... By contrast, a much more traditional view surfaces in the next chapter – when Bilbo is trying to think of the answer to Gollum’s last riddle (‘This thing all things devours’), his mind is filled with ‘all the horrible names of all the giants and ogres he had ever heard told of in tales’ (p. 158). Here we can see the echoes of such traditional tales as ‘Jack and the Beanstalk’ and ‘Jack the Giant Killer’, with their murderous, man-eating giants...Yet not all giants can be such monsters, for a chapter later Bladorthin casually suggests finding ‘a more or less decent giant’ to block up the goblins’ front gate in the mountain pass. It seems, then, that giant occupies a neutral ground, neither good nor evil as a race but varying from individual to individual. Dangerous, certainly – but as Gandalf points out in speaking of Treebeard, powerful and perilous is not the same thing as evil…”

“All was well, until one day they met a thunderstorm—more than a thunderstorm, a thunder-battle. You know how terrific a really big thunderstorm can be down in the land and a river-valley; especially at times when two great thunderstorms meet and clash. More terrible still are thunder and lightning in the mountains at night, when storms come up from East and West and make war. The lightning splinters on the peaks, and rocks shiver, and great crashes split the air and go rolling into every cave and hollow; and darkness is filled with overwhelming noise and sudden light. Bilbo ... saw that across the valley the stone-giants were out, and were hurling rocks at one another for a game, and catching them, and tossing them down into the darkness where they smashed among the trees far below or splintered into little bits with a bang ... they could hear the giants guffawing and shout all over the mountainsides.”
—Tolkien, The Hobbit, Chapter IV: “Over Hill and Under Hill”.

References

This page has been seen 24,761 times.

    • Created by on
      Last updated by on

Giants

General info

Dominions
Middle-earth, North Moors, Misty Mountains

Physical Attributes

Distinctions
Thick, rocky, massive, powerful, ancient
Height
Gigantic


Discussions

Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…