Thorin
LOTR Purist to the end
- Joined
- Aug 20, 2001
- Messages
- 1,428
The Hobbit:An Unexpected Journey: A Purist's Review
Well. After 9 years of reviews such as these, this dusty old curmudgeon from the First Age of this forum has returned with another. Many of the newbies here don't know my tradition of these types of reviews as I have put one out for all the LotR movies and their extended editions. So for all the newbies and in honor of my ancient friends and foes alike, I dedicate this review to you.
(Spoiler Alert)
TH: AUJ - 7/10
Some might be surprised by my score knowing my past history with these films. Unlike LoTR, I went into The Hobbit:AUJ without any expectations. Knowing PJ's tendency to skew the story, characters and dialogue, I went fully expecting it to continue...and it did. However, not on the disastrous scale of much of LoTR. I also knew and accepted that there were many things about TH that would need to be fleshed out, changed and added to make a decent movie (never mind three!) of TH. The tone is more child like, more storybook-like and not so serious as LoTR.
THE GOOD
* Of course visually and authentically, PJ and WETA out-did themselves once again in bringing Middle Earth back to life. From the Shire to Rivendell to the mountains.
* Unlike LoTR, casting for the most part was done well. I did feel that Thorin and a few of the younger dwarves like Fili and Kili were not very Dwarf-looking, but I guess they can't all be coming out of the chute looking like Balin and the others. It just seemed weird to me. They seemed too human.
* References to the grander scope of Middle Earth history. With Elrond talking about the swords of Gondolin and Gandalf about the 5 wizards, it was nice to have those ancient references weaved throughout the story, even though the vast majority of viewers would have missed those references.
* Despite a few minor changes, Bilbo's encounter with Gollum was given a pretty decent go by PJ. As usual these changes were quite unnecessary but that's PJ for you.
*Despite a few changes again, thought the encounter with the 3 cave trolls was done well
* Back flashes to Dwarf history. It was nice to see Dwarfs featured for a change and being shown doing what they do in their kingdoms. LoTR was all focused on Men and Elves, and TH gave us a much better glimpse to the world of Dwarves. PJ portrayed this well.
* I like that PJ used the events surrounding the Hobbit that we find in the appendices of the LoTR and other ME sources to be shown as well. The concept of the Necromancer and the discussion of it by members of the White Council added a back story that was ME authenticated. It's an extra treat for those fans of ME.
THE BAD
* Radagast's role - Of course a complete PJ fabrication in regards to the events of TH. It didn't bother me too much that he did this, but I felt that there was way too much time given to Radagast and that he was made to be much more foolish then he should have been. Something that I felt really could have been left out of the story.
* Gandalf and the moth part II: What is it with Gandalf speaking to butterflies or whatever once again? Twice in a row, PJ??
* Goblin Cave: I felt that too much time was spent in this scene and that the Goblin king was a bit over the top
* Stone monsters: I'm a little perplexed by what exactly this was about and how exactly they are explained in the grand scope of things that live in ME. It seemed bizarre to me and just another way for PJ to flaunt his 'creative' mind in thinking he can wield the story of ME like a kid waving a gun. Seemed stupid to me for some reason
*Azog sub-plot - Like Lurtz before him, Azog seems thrown in there for some sort of arch-villain role. Considering Azog was dead long before this and there was no such grudge match between the orc and Thorin in the book, another one of PJ's long history of adding in his own story thinking he can improve on the greatness of Tolkien's characters. Having said that however, I can't wait for Thorin to take his head off by the end of the movie.
THE UGLY
Surprisingly...nothing stood out that couldn't be just considered 'bad'
THE SURPRISING
* Was completely surprised that the dwarves and the plates in Bilbo's house was left in! To me I thought this was a 'childish' scene that would be the first to go. As I said before, I approached this movie from the book Hobbit's perspective and not how it meshed in with PJ's version of LoTR. It seemed out of place for that, but not for a movie portrayal of the book. I enjoyed seeing it. However, having said that, I truly hope that PJ leaves out the spiders of Mirkwood chanting 'attercop' and other such nonsensical phrases. That should fall by the wayside like Bombadil had to happen in LoTR
Well, there it is. Less curmudgeonly than some might have expected, but I suppose time has softened me somewhat. I am looking forward to seeing what PJ can do to make the rest of the Hobbit come to life (Smaug, Battle of 5 armies and Beorn, anyone?) and hope that he doesn't turn it into a schmozzle of Pj-isms and other nonsense fabrications that he is known for. I hold my breath.
Well. After 9 years of reviews such as these, this dusty old curmudgeon from the First Age of this forum has returned with another. Many of the newbies here don't know my tradition of these types of reviews as I have put one out for all the LotR movies and their extended editions. So for all the newbies and in honor of my ancient friends and foes alike, I dedicate this review to you.
(Spoiler Alert)
TH: AUJ - 7/10
Some might be surprised by my score knowing my past history with these films. Unlike LoTR, I went into The Hobbit:AUJ without any expectations. Knowing PJ's tendency to skew the story, characters and dialogue, I went fully expecting it to continue...and it did. However, not on the disastrous scale of much of LoTR. I also knew and accepted that there were many things about TH that would need to be fleshed out, changed and added to make a decent movie (never mind three!) of TH. The tone is more child like, more storybook-like and not so serious as LoTR.
THE GOOD
* Of course visually and authentically, PJ and WETA out-did themselves once again in bringing Middle Earth back to life. From the Shire to Rivendell to the mountains.
* Unlike LoTR, casting for the most part was done well. I did feel that Thorin and a few of the younger dwarves like Fili and Kili were not very Dwarf-looking, but I guess they can't all be coming out of the chute looking like Balin and the others. It just seemed weird to me. They seemed too human.
* References to the grander scope of Middle Earth history. With Elrond talking about the swords of Gondolin and Gandalf about the 5 wizards, it was nice to have those ancient references weaved throughout the story, even though the vast majority of viewers would have missed those references.
* Despite a few minor changes, Bilbo's encounter with Gollum was given a pretty decent go by PJ. As usual these changes were quite unnecessary but that's PJ for you.
*Despite a few changes again, thought the encounter with the 3 cave trolls was done well
* Back flashes to Dwarf history. It was nice to see Dwarfs featured for a change and being shown doing what they do in their kingdoms. LoTR was all focused on Men and Elves, and TH gave us a much better glimpse to the world of Dwarves. PJ portrayed this well.
* I like that PJ used the events surrounding the Hobbit that we find in the appendices of the LoTR and other ME sources to be shown as well. The concept of the Necromancer and the discussion of it by members of the White Council added a back story that was ME authenticated. It's an extra treat for those fans of ME.
THE BAD
* Radagast's role - Of course a complete PJ fabrication in regards to the events of TH. It didn't bother me too much that he did this, but I felt that there was way too much time given to Radagast and that he was made to be much more foolish then he should have been. Something that I felt really could have been left out of the story.
* Gandalf and the moth part II: What is it with Gandalf speaking to butterflies or whatever once again? Twice in a row, PJ??
* Goblin Cave: I felt that too much time was spent in this scene and that the Goblin king was a bit over the top
* Stone monsters: I'm a little perplexed by what exactly this was about and how exactly they are explained in the grand scope of things that live in ME. It seemed bizarre to me and just another way for PJ to flaunt his 'creative' mind in thinking he can wield the story of ME like a kid waving a gun. Seemed stupid to me for some reason
*Azog sub-plot - Like Lurtz before him, Azog seems thrown in there for some sort of arch-villain role. Considering Azog was dead long before this and there was no such grudge match between the orc and Thorin in the book, another one of PJ's long history of adding in his own story thinking he can improve on the greatness of Tolkien's characters. Having said that however, I can't wait for Thorin to take his head off by the end of the movie.
THE UGLY
Surprisingly...nothing stood out that couldn't be just considered 'bad'
THE SURPRISING
* Was completely surprised that the dwarves and the plates in Bilbo's house was left in! To me I thought this was a 'childish' scene that would be the first to go. As I said before, I approached this movie from the book Hobbit's perspective and not how it meshed in with PJ's version of LoTR. It seemed out of place for that, but not for a movie portrayal of the book. I enjoyed seeing it. However, having said that, I truly hope that PJ leaves out the spiders of Mirkwood chanting 'attercop' and other such nonsensical phrases. That should fall by the wayside like Bombadil had to happen in LoTR
Well, there it is. Less curmudgeonly than some might have expected, but I suppose time has softened me somewhat. I am looking forward to seeing what PJ can do to make the rest of the Hobbit come to life (Smaug, Battle of 5 armies and Beorn, anyone?) and hope that he doesn't turn it into a schmozzle of Pj-isms and other nonsense fabrications that he is known for. I hold my breath.
Last edited:
