• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Hobbit:An Unexpected Journey - A Purist's Review

Thorin

LOTR Purist to the end
Joined
Aug 20, 2001
Messages
1,428
The Hobbit:An Unexpected Journey: A Purist's Review

Well. After 9 years of reviews such as these, this dusty old curmudgeon from the First Age of this forum has returned with another. Many of the newbies here don't know my tradition of these types of reviews as I have put one out for all the LotR movies and their extended editions. So for all the newbies and in honor of my ancient friends and foes alike, I dedicate this review to you. :)

(Spoiler Alert)
TH: AUJ - 7/10

Some might be surprised by my score knowing my past history with these films. Unlike LoTR, I went into The Hobbit:AUJ without any expectations. Knowing PJ's tendency to skew the story, characters and dialogue, I went fully expecting it to continue...and it did. However, not on the disastrous scale of much of LoTR. I also knew and accepted that there were many things about TH that would need to be fleshed out, changed and added to make a decent movie (never mind three!) of TH. The tone is more child like, more storybook-like and not so serious as LoTR.

THE GOOD

* Of course visually and authentically, PJ and WETA out-did themselves once again in bringing Middle Earth back to life. From the Shire to Rivendell to the mountains.
* Unlike LoTR, casting for the most part was done well. I did feel that Thorin and a few of the younger dwarves like Fili and Kili were not very Dwarf-looking, but I guess they can't all be coming out of the chute looking like Balin and the others. It just seemed weird to me. They seemed too human.
* References to the grander scope of Middle Earth history. With Elrond talking about the swords of Gondolin and Gandalf about the 5 wizards, it was nice to have those ancient references weaved throughout the story, even though the vast majority of viewers would have missed those references.
* Despite a few minor changes, Bilbo's encounter with Gollum was given a pretty decent go by PJ. As usual these changes were quite unnecessary but that's PJ for you.
*Despite a few changes again, thought the encounter with the 3 cave trolls was done well
* Back flashes to Dwarf history. It was nice to see Dwarfs featured for a change and being shown doing what they do in their kingdoms. LoTR was all focused on Men and Elves, and TH gave us a much better glimpse to the world of Dwarves. PJ portrayed this well.
* I like that PJ used the events surrounding the Hobbit that we find in the appendices of the LoTR and other ME sources to be shown as well. The concept of the Necromancer and the discussion of it by members of the White Council added a back story that was ME authenticated. It's an extra treat for those fans of ME.

THE BAD

* Radagast's role - Of course a complete PJ fabrication in regards to the events of TH. It didn't bother me too much that he did this, but I felt that there was way too much time given to Radagast and that he was made to be much more foolish then he should have been. Something that I felt really could have been left out of the story.
* Gandalf and the moth part II: What is it with Gandalf speaking to butterflies or whatever once again? Twice in a row, PJ??
* Goblin Cave: I felt that too much time was spent in this scene and that the Goblin king was a bit over the top
* Stone monsters: I'm a little perplexed by what exactly this was about and how exactly they are explained in the grand scope of things that live in ME. It seemed bizarre to me and just another way for PJ to flaunt his 'creative' mind in thinking he can wield the story of ME like a kid waving a gun. Seemed stupid to me for some reason
*Azog sub-plot - Like Lurtz before him, Azog seems thrown in there for some sort of arch-villain role. Considering Azog was dead long before this and there was no such grudge match between the orc and Thorin in the book, another one of PJ's long history of adding in his own story thinking he can improve on the greatness of Tolkien's characters. Having said that however, I can't wait for Thorin to take his head off by the end of the movie. :D

THE UGLY
Surprisingly...nothing stood out that couldn't be just considered 'bad'

THE SURPRISING
* Was completely surprised that the dwarves and the plates in Bilbo's house was left in! To me I thought this was a 'childish' scene that would be the first to go. As I said before, I approached this movie from the book Hobbit's perspective and not how it meshed in with PJ's version of LoTR. It seemed out of place for that, but not for a movie portrayal of the book. I enjoyed seeing it. However, having said that, I truly hope that PJ leaves out the spiders of Mirkwood chanting 'attercop' and other such nonsensical phrases. That should fall by the wayside like Bombadil had to happen in LoTR

Well, there it is. Less curmudgeonly than some might have expected, but I suppose time has softened me somewhat. I am looking forward to seeing what PJ can do to make the rest of the Hobbit come to life (Smaug, Battle of 5 armies and Beorn, anyone?) and hope that he doesn't turn it into a schmozzle of Pj-isms and other nonsense fabrications that he is known for. I hold my breath.
 
Last edited:
Spoilers in this reply, just a heads up.

I really liked the movie and I agree with your review almost entirely. I loved the 'That's What Bilbo Baggins Hates' scene, thought it was awesome he kept it in, but thought he'd find it useless as a scene just like he did with Tom Bombadil.
I hated that Azog was there. Let's just resurrect a character that was already dead by this time and add a subplot. Azog was killed in TA 2799 but the events of the Hobbit occurred in TA 2941, 142 years later. If anything, the Orc that was chasing the company should have been Bolg, Azog's son, with a climax in the final battle of Five Armies (where Bolg died in The Hobbit). I mean I understand that directors can't follow their movie's respected novels completely (look at PJ, nuff said), but this is just completely idiotic. At least let the history happen the way it was meant to.
Radagast was good, though a little too bumbling, as you said and I didn't like the sled of rabbits, thought that was kind of cheesy. When he's leading the orcs away while the company is trying to escape, he randomly just disappears when the elves show up.

All in all I liked it, just the Azog part really bugged me the most. I have to say the Dol Guldur scene was cool, though what happened to the Nazgul being invisible? I could clearly see the Witch King. And I do like the way he portrayed Sauron, not just a floating fiery eye.
 
Spoilers in this reply, just a heads up.

I mean I understand that directors can't follow their movie's respected novels completely

Hi Erestor (and Thorin), I have to say I disagree with this. There is absolutely no reason why they can't follow the plot, storyline, history and intention of the author to the letter. I understand entirely that they may need to remove unnecessary content, but they absolutely don't need to re-write their own version of The Hobbit, or for that matter the LOTR's simply because they own the rights and they think it might appeal to the popcorn-munching masses. The work of Tolkien has stood the test of time long before and after these movie's will have been and gone. I have to agree with Ciryaher on the point he raised in another thread that had Guillermo Del Toro been given free reign and a suitable budget this might have been an entirely different film. In fact, I believe Del Toro would have delivered something altogether more in line with the spirit of Tolkien's written work that PJ ever could. Then again, I wonder did studio bosses panic and think Del Toro's version might have appealed to less of an audience as it would likely have been so close to the books, that many of the paying public might not want to see it? I guess that's why they stuck with PJ, he has no scruples, morals or sense of loyalty to the author and as such was perfect to make this cinematically appealing to the masses.

Unfortunately I don't believe any film studio will commit a huge budget to remaking either the Lord of the Rings or The Hobbit in his lifetime, if they do, then I hope Del Toro gets his opportunity to shine.
 
Hi Erestor (and Thorin), I have to say I disagree with this. There is absolutely no reason why they can't follow the plot, storyline, history and intention of the author to the letter. I understand entirely that they may need to remove unnecessary content, but they absolutely don't need to re-write their own version of The Hobbit, or for that matter the LOTR's simply because they own the rights and they think it might appeal to the popcorn-munching masses. The work of Tolkien has stood the test of time long before and after these movie's will have been and gone. I have to agree with Ciryaher on the point he raised in another thread that had Guillermo Del Toro been given free reign and a suitable budget this might have been an entirely different film. In fact, I believe Del Toro would have delivered something altogether more in line with the spirit of Tolkien's written work that PJ ever could. Then again, I wonder did studio bosses panic and think Del Toro's version might have appealed to less of an audience as it would likely have been so close to the books, that many of the paying public might not want to see it? I guess that's why they stuck with PJ, he has no scruples, morals or sense of loyalty to the author and as such was perfect to make this cinematically appealing to the masses.

Unfortunately I don't believe any film studio will commit a huge budget to remaking either the Lord of the Rings or The Hobbit in his lifetime, if they do, then I hope Del Toro gets his opportunity to shine.

Ancalagon I agree with you and that's really what I meant...sorry I didn't word it correctly lol :*D
 
Spoilers in this reply, just a heads up.

I have to say the Dol Guldur scene was cool, though what happened to the Nazgul being invisible? I could clearly see the Witch King. And I do like the way he portrayed Sauron, not just a floating fiery eye.

Sauron has grown up to be a lighthouse yet. :*D

Honestly, they had me there too until the bit about the Witch-king's body & the sword...

Absurd.

The Witch-king's body is buried?

Oh, come now.
 
Re: The Hobbit:An Unexpected Journey: A Purist's Review

* Stone monsters: I'm a little perplexed by what exactly this was about and how exactly they are explained in the grand scope of things that live in ME. It seemed bizarre to me and just another way for PJ to flaunt his 'creative' mind in thinking he can wield the story of ME like a kid waving a gun. Seemed stupid to me for some reason


The stone giants tossing boulders in the mountains was one of the few things actually in the novel that they put in the movie! Their inclusion completely suprised me. I thought for sure they'd be cut out as something too unexplainable and deemed unnecessary.
Of course true to PJ it went over the top with the mountain path splitting apart and that they had actually been walking on one of the giants. That was just dumb.

Unfortunately for me I decided to read the book a few weeks before seeing the movie. It made the movie rather unenjoyable because the whole time I just wanted to see The Hobbit in film form and so from start to finish of the movie basically everything that happened made me think, "that wasn't the way it was in the book...that wasn't the way it was in the book."
The conversation with Gandalf, the way the dwarves arrived, how Bilbo left the Shire, the orcs chasing them, the reason they found the trolls, Bilbo not being silent when sneaking up on the trolls, how Bilbo was discovered by the trolls, how they escaped the trolls, what they did with the troll gold, why they lost their ponies, how they found Rivendell, how the elves behaved, the white council at this point, Radagast, how the dwarves left Rivendell, how they found the cave, how Bilbo discovered Gollum, how Gandalf saved the dwarves, how Bilbo escaped Gollum, how Bilbo escaped the goblins, why the wargs attacked the company, having the orcs instead of the goblins from the cave, Bilbo not needing help to get into the trees, Thorin jumping out of the tree and attacking, Bilbo attacking, why the eagles rescued them, cutting out the Lord of the Eagles, Carrock wasn't in the middle of the river, and many other smaller things. It was a completely different story.
 
Re: The Hobbit:An Unexpected Journey: A Purist's Review

The stone giants tossing boulders in the mountains was one of the few things actually in the novel that they put in the movie! Their inclusion completely suprised me. I thought for sure they'd be cut out as something too unexplainable and deemed unnecessary.
Of course true to PJ it went over the top with the mountain path splitting apart and that they had actually been walking on one of the giants. That was just dumb.

Unfortunately for me I decided to read the book a few weeks before seeing the movie. It made the movie rather unenjoyable because the whole time I just wanted to see The Hobbit in film form and so from start to finish of the movie basically everything that happened made me think, "that wasn't the way it was in the book...that wasn't the way it was in the book."
The conversation with Gandalf, the way the dwarves arrived, how Bilbo left the Shire, the orcs chasing them, the reason they found the trolls, Bilbo not being silent when sneaking up on the trolls, how Bilbo was discovered by the trolls, how they escaped the trolls, what they did with the troll gold, why they lost their ponies, how they found Rivendell, how the elves behaved, the white council at this point, Radagast, how the dwarves left Rivendell, how they found the cave, how Bilbo discovered Gollum, how Gandalf saved the dwarves, how Bilbo escaped Gollum, how Bilbo escaped the goblins, why the wargs attacked the company, having the orcs instead of the goblins from the cave, Bilbo not needing help to get into the trees, Thorin jumping out of the tree and attacking, Bilbo attacking, why the eagles rescued them, cutting out the Lord of the Eagles, Carrock wasn't in the middle of the river, and many other smaller things. It was a completely different story.

Don't forget that PJ also resurrected Azog from the grave
 
Re: The Hobbit:An Unexpected Journey: A Purist's Review

Of course true to PJ it went over the top with the mountain path splitting apart and that they had actually been walking on one of the giants. That was just dumb.

Well put...

This is the point I was making in my review (that nobody reads now, lol).

The whole movie proceeds this way: With one scene after another that is so absurdly unbelievable ~ even in the scope of the world in which the are set, or compared to TLOR, that they just become laughable to think our heroes would survive them.

Therefore, there is no tension, no excitement in the action scenes, the 'chase' scenes so to speak, just a resignation that one more 'can you top this' moment of CGI magic greater than the last unbelievable stunt is about to appear on the screen ad nauseum.
 
Re: The Hobbit:An Unexpected Journey: A Purist's Review

Well put...

This is the point I was making in my review (that nobody reads now, lol).

The whole movie proceeds this way: With one scene after another that is so absurdly unbelievable ~ even in the scope of the world in which the are set, or compared to TLOR, that they just become laughable to think our heroes would survive them.

Therefore, there is no tension, no excitement in the action scenes, the 'chase' scenes so to speak, just a resignation that one more 'can you top this' moment of CGI magic greater than the last unbelievable stunt is about to appear on the screen ad nauseum.


Exactly. Riding the slick rock knees of stone giants on a precariously narrow precipice and never falling off? No problem.
Bilbo who just said he never used a sword in his life then successfully defending himself against a goblin fighter? Totally believable.
Running pelmel across narrow rope and board bridges fighting a vast goblin host and no one gets hurt at all? Amazing.
Bilbo falling down who knows how far onto rocks into a cave far below into some large fungi with no injury? Of course.
The wooden bridge tumbling down slopes and plummeting against cave walls to the depths of the mountain intact? Sure.
The wargs being strong enough to push down all the huge trees yet the one at the end hanging by a root with all 14 of them in it never falls? OK!
 
Re: The Hobbit:An Unexpected Journey: A Purist's Review

Exactly. Riding the slick rock knees of stone giants on a precariously narrow precipice and never falling off? No problem.
Bilbo who just said he never used a sword in his life then successfully defending himself against a goblin fighter? Totally believable.
Running pelmel across narrow rope and board bridges fighting a vast goblin host and no one gets hurt at all? Amazing.
Bilbo falling down who knows how far onto rocks into a cave far below into some large fungi with no injury? Of course.
The wooden bridge tumbling down slopes and plummeting against cave walls to the depths of the mountain intact? Sure.
The wargs being strong enough to push down all the huge trees yet the one at the end hanging by a root with all 14 of them in it never falls? OK!

These observations took me out of the story far more than Azog's resurrection did. It was like watching a computer game rather than a film. The tree would have worked if it had been in any way more substantial than the others; but it wasn't.

PJ did a character amalgamation, keeping the same Orc king from TA2799 through to (I'm presuming) The Battle of the Five Armies; where I'm expecting Dain to despatch Azog the way he should have 150 years previously, instead of Bolg (unless Thorin sees him off before his own demise; or unless Thorin survives until that final battle). I was more concerned that PJ would have characters straying from the personalities Tolkien had given them; and so far I haven't seen that.

I also enjoyed that I really wasn't sure what would happen next. Radagast added a childlike element that existed in the book; but his bunny sleigh was a tad unbelievable. Maybe we were being set up to 'believe' Beorn's household setup in the next film.

I also noticed that The Carrock was bear-shaped. Nice touch.
 
Do you think they will cut out Beorn and Bolg altogether and have the Five Armies battle culminate in a Thorin/Azog fight instead? That would be a massive and unfortunate rewrite of the story of The Hobbit but given what they've done already it seems plausible.

Besides all the silly stuff what I didn't enjoy was how Jackson felt the need to speed up the development of the characters in the first movie rather than letting the arcs play out over the whole story. Making Bilbo way more than he was at the beginning leaves little to develop through the spiders and elves episodes and Thorin completely embracing Bilbo by the end of the first movie seems to leave little need for that development.
 
Do you think they will cut out Beorn and Bolg altogether and have the Five Armies battle culminate in a Thorin/Azog fight instead? That would be a massive and unfortunate rewrite of the story of The Hobbit but given what they've done already it seems plausible.
:
:

I don't think so. I think Azog will be there to die in Bolg's place. But there is a Beorn cast, and I suppose he'll probably show up for the Battle of 5 Armies.
 
My jaw literally dropped seeing a 7/10 from Thorin. Being a FAD, I have to rate it slightly higher, of course, but I agree with the vast majority of the points made.

On the Good and the Ugly, I am in complete agreement.

The Bad:
-Not annoyed with the addition Azog. At all. And this surprises even me, to an extent. From a film perspective, he "works" as a character. From a purist perspective it is an obvious gripe; however, since the LotR movies, I have drifted even further from my Tolkien roots, and perhaps this is why I am not upset. At least it wasn't a Lurtz or a "bulbous orc" or some other completely fictional character. And Azog sounds cooler than Bolg.

In addition to the rest of the Bad, or perhaps in the summation of it, I would add...well, the exact term escapes me at the moment. Overzealous special effects? Over-the-top Hollywood-ization? The Matrix problem? Several people here have already mentioned the scenes in question: riding the goblin scaffolding to the bottom of the cave, riding rock giants, cave floors opening to giant goblin chutes, and one tenacious tree root. These could clearly have been done more concisely and realistically, but I don't see them ruining my movie experience, by any stretch of the imagination.

I know I don't have the book knowledge that I used to, and that even back then it was inferior to many or most here. But I read and reread (and reread) The Hobbit in my childhood and onward, and I cannot shake the fact that this move "feels" like The Hobbit to me, in a way that none of the LotR movies did. So much of the little stuff that made an impression on me as a child reading the novel was brought back to my memory watching this movie that I walked out smiling more than I have in quite a while. I can't wait to see what's coming next.
 
I know I don't have the book knowledge that I used to, and that even back then it was inferior to many or most here. But I read and reread (and reread) The Hobbit in my childhood and onward, and I cannot shake the fact that this move "feels" like The Hobbit to me, in a way that none of the LotR movies did. So much of the little stuff that made an impression on me as a child reading the novel was brought back to my memory watching this movie that I walked out smiling more than I have in quite a while.

I had quite the opposite experience for most of the film, which I've seen twice now.

All the business with 'Azog,' Radagast and the council seems to make the Company's journey quite secondary to the story of the movie. When I read the books I feel like I'm traveling with Bilbo, Gandalf and the dwarves. When they get to Mirkwood in the next movie they're going to be just a tiny element in the story in a framework that we understand a lot better than they do, with the whole necromancer/Sauron insight the viewers have. In the books it's quite different - the reader experiences the new environments and information as the Company does, for the most part. The focus on Thorin's distaste for the Elves etc. also didn't help.

I think they could have done far better having Bilbo impress Balin and the other dwarves as he did in the books with his reappearance after the goblin cave instead of making him into some brave, violent hero when Azog faces Thorin in the trees. That's really going to diminish the worth of the spider scene in Mirkwood. And I'm not looking forward to Thorin when he meets Thranduil and goes on and on about how they supposedly betrayed the dwarves of Erebor.

On a side note - I didn't see the necromancer really bring anyone back from the dead, but it looked like Radagast and Gandalf did :D

I enjoyed watching the movie because I knew what I was getting into, but it's certainly not the experience of The Hobbit for me.
 
All the business with 'Azog,' Radagast and the council seems to make the Company's journey quite secondary to the story of the movie. When I read the books I feel like I'm traveling with Bilbo, Gandalf and the dwarves. When they get to Mirkwood in the next movie they're going to be just a tiny element in the story in a framework that we understand a lot better than they do, with the whole necromancer/Sauron insight the viewers have. In the books it's quite different - the reader experiences the new environments and information as the Company does, for the most part. The focus on Thorin's distaste for the Elves etc. also didn't help.

Well, to each his/her own. Do you think the movie could or should have been filmed without incorporating the larger story? I don't, and I'm enjoying the incorporated backstory if I am going to be perfectly honest.

I think they could have done far better having Bilbo impress Balin and the other dwarves as he did in the books with his reappearance after the goblin cave instead of making him into some brave, violent hero when Azog faces Thorin in the trees. That's really going to diminish the worth of the spider scene in Mirkwood. And I'm not looking forward to Thorin when he meets Thranduil and goes on and on about how they supposedly betrayed the dwarves of Erebor

Almost without exception, a movie could always do something better in regards to text translation. I don't disagree in this case. To those who know the story word-for-word, this could no doubt be detrimental to their enjoyment. Given the length of time between readings, I no longer have that issue. Still, I was actually afraid to see this movie; LotR I enjoy, The Hobbit I love, and I did not want to be disappointed. I ended up going by accident and while I can spot the story deviations and cringe dutifully at the PJ-isms, I am reminded of my first time reading this awesome, awesome story, and that's what matters most to me.

On a side note - I didn't see the necromancer really bring anyone back from the dead, but it looked like Radagast and Gandalf did

Don't get it.
 
Re: The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey - a purist's review

Ancalagon said earlier "There is absolutely no reason why they can't follow the plot, storyline, history and intention of the author to the letter. I understand entirely that they may need to remove unnecessary content, but they absolutely don't need to re-write their own version of The Hobbit, or for that matter the LOTR's simply because they own the rights and they think it might appeal to the popcorn-munching masses. The work of Tolkien has stood the test of time long before and after these movie's will have been and gone. I have to agree with Ciryaher on the point he raised in another thread that had Guillermo Del Toro been given free reign and a suitable budget this might have been an entirely different film. In fact, I believe Del Toro would have delivered something altogether more in line with the spirit of Tolkien's written work that PJ ever could."

I strongly believe that Del Toro should be given a budget of $billions by Bill Gates and then told to spend the next few years creating narratively faithful cinematic versions of The Silmarillion, UT, CoH and tLotR. He can make them as long as he likes - 2, 3, 4 hours, I don't care. 'Nuff said. (LoL! deeply wistful thinking...)
 
Last edited:
It is very hard to be a purist, and a lover of PJ's work at the same time... There are moments when both are done very well in the Hobbit, but then there are some simply horrific changes to the story in the movie...

I approached watching the Hobbit open minded, and was delighted for roughly first 45 min, well scripted and thought out beginning... Sadly it didn't last, with Pj seemingly at any chance using his creative license to butcher the original story.. I felt like there were scenes that simply were so far over the top, and without meaning.. Felt like it was padding!

A couple of big negatives were the fact that several of the dwarves looked way too close to the human race..why?

Too numerous and unrealistic warg/orcs scenes, including the big fight in the Misty Mountains, I just wanted it over with, it was like here we go another fight scene.

The rock trolls, was plain stupid and over the top.. why?

The Rivendell scene, with the antagonistic drawves, not necessary, and inaccurate.why?

Thorin and Bilbo fighting Azog, stupid addition, as was the over the top tree falling scene..

Some positives, the first 45 min, the trolls, the music and scenery,Bilbo's character was quite good (Freeman is great in the role, as he is in other work), link with Dol Guldor/Sauron, Radagast (except for the bunny scenes and the chase away from wargs, silly)..

The riddle scene between Bilbo and Gollum was nicely done, except for why PJ could not stick with Bilbo falling behind the dwarves, rather than falling a country mile down I do not know..Why does he assume that the majority of viewers are idiots and need something big or exciting to happen at each new scene ?? Infuriating.

Ancalagon, I totally agree with you mate...

On a side note, my wife (who has never read the book or even really liked LOTR movies in the past) LOVED the Hobbit, as did my 3 young kids.... So did Pj do a good job for the masses, yes!! For purists, NO..

When PJ follows the book closer in LOTR he does it very well in many parts.. With the Hobbit he lets his imagination run unchecked, and spoils this story. I am hoping that there is an extended edition, perhaps helping out the real Tolkien lovers.
Such a shame, what could have been!
:*down:*down
 
Changed my mind (I have a copy of it and re watching it with kids now)...

Having seen it a second time, I can truly say that this a very,very poor adaptation.. Most definately the WORST of all Tolkien adaptions...

Sorry PJ.. This is beyond ridiculous, such huge inaccuracies in both character and storyline, and intent by Tolkien...

This movie truly is an insult to any purist, and most importantly Tolkien himself!!

The made up sub stories/plots, the meaningless relentless predictable fighting scenes are a mockery of Tolkien...

What were you thinking PJ?

You had a fantastic story to begin with, some minor tweaks for the big screen, whilst honouring Tolkien.. Sadly, u let yourself down.:*:)*:)*:)*(
 
You have a copy of it? Bad, bad boy (or girl)!

Ever since I saw the first Lord of the Rings movie I have found myself developing a multiple personality disorder as far as Tolkien-movies are concerned. I notice everything that differs from the books knowing them almost by heart, but I notice also when the film works as a different medium.

Take Balin, for instance. he is completely out-of-character in the film. In the book he is one of the few, very few, dwarves who gain a distinct personality at all. When he is about to go to battle, Bilbo names four dwarves he obviously cares for: Balin and Bombur, Fili and Kili. Actually, aside from Thorin the most clearly depicted dwarf is Bombur, he also has the most lines. Fili and Kili are just FiliandKili, but Balin sometimes reacts to Bilbo. I think, Tolkien took this hint at some kind of friendship between Balin and Bilbo into The Lord of the Rings. But Balin is one of the younger dwarves. He was 17 years younger than Thorin and a mere toddler at the sacking of Erebor (he was 7). So, to make him into the friendly and sensible grey-beard, the "elder statesman" as he has been called, is certainly out of canon.

Still, for the movie it works. Balin adds to the image of dwarves in general. If there were only Thorin, Dwalin and Gloín the distasteful comparison to Klingons I have read on the web would perhaps even be justified (I don't want to delve into presenting Fili and Kili as eye-candy to the teenage-girls in the audience). Tolkien's dwarves in the hobbit DO resemble garden-gnomes, with their hoods and tassels, and they are more or less a constant plural (the dwarves said, the dwarves did, Bilbo and the dwarves etc. etc.). This works well in a story where even if the acting subject is a plural, something happens. It wouldn't work in a movie. I remember Elrond's Council in the Fellowship where several dwarves were sitting around all looking like Gimli. They were just plain boring. So, for The Hobbit a dwarvish individuality had to created and it couldn't be taken from the book only, because that does not provide it.

Fortunately, Peter Jacksons knows about Unfinished Tales and History of MIddle-Earth, where a more complex picture of the dwarves is available, and let this influence the movie. So, we ended up with 13 individual dwarves which are not entirely in-canon but convey the idea of Tolkien's dwarves better than a one-to-one presentation from the book would have done.

To make a book into a movie is some kind of alchemy. The media are so different, if you try to do it with the book dominating the movie you end up with a slide-show to music and talking (like Harry Potter 1 and 2 which are virtually unbearable). if you let the movie dominate the book you end up with something like "The wizard of Earthsea" (Ursula K. LeGuin) or "The Dark is Rising" (Susan Cooper) which were both butchered into non-recognition. In my opinion, Jackson did neither, which enables me to go on loving the books in their own domain and enjoying the movies simultaneously, and I even keep my inner pictures from reading intact because of the different media used.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top