BalrogRingDestroyer
Member
- Joined
- Feb 19, 2018
- Messages
- 267

I doubt it will ever be solved ...It's the problem faced by every theodicy. I doubt it will be solved here.
There's a passage in (Sir) Peter Ustinov's amazing, and to me brilliant 1990 book "The Old Man and Mr. Smith" (which I have in a 2004 10th printing of the German translation), between the title protagonists (and antagonists) about light needing dark so that a contrast can be seen ...Basically, evil has to exist for good to exist, and vice versa.
I doubt it will ever be solved ...
There's a passage in (Sir) Peter Ustinov's amazing, and to me brilliant 1990 book "The Old Man and Mr. Smith" (which I have in a 2004 10th printing of the German translation), between the title protagonists (and antagonists) about light needing dark so that a contrast can be seen ...
I was thinking about this recently and came to the same conclusion. Melkor was deliberately created to provide opposition to the other Valar [ . . . ] And thou, Melkor, shalt see that no theme may be played that hath not its uttermost source in me, nor can any alter the music in my despite. For he that attempteth this shall prove but mine instrument in the devising of things more wonderful, which he himself hath not imagined.'
Which to paraphrase, essentially is "go ahead and do evil things, because greater good will come of it." And to reinforce the idea, this statement follows shortly after:
It's the problem faced by every theodicy. I doubt it will be solved here.
If theologians of every confession continue to the maximum possible to contort themselves until our sun becomes a Red Giant in several billion years in the future, they do not have the slightest chance of explaining this (away). The basic fallacy of all such "arguments", including Eru's pathetic "explanations" to Melkor, is that you need black to be able to see white in contrast.I doubt it will ever be solved ...
My spontaneous reaction to your post was "bro, you don't know how bad poetry can get unless you've read some of mine!" … 🥴Roses are red,
Violets are blue;
Analogies are imperfect,
And so is this poem.
Not the slightest need to apologize. Translation errors from the ancient Greek that much of the NT was written in abound, and never mind errors in the translation of the Hebrew Bible or Tanach, with confusion thrown in by the Septuagint, translated from Hebrew into the then prevalent Greek a bit before 200 BC.Ah. Sorry, my source was the KJV...which does contain a lot of poor bits of translation. Yours is probably closer to the original.