I could just link to my earlier post (where this is taken from) but some folks (including Yours Truly) don't like caroming around the forums like a pinball.
So here here is my movie list
redux. (I've added some original Twilight Zone episodes to it)
Village of the Damned (original one, 1960, w/ George Sanders actually playing a good guy😄)
FYI this is a pretty faithful adaptation of the story The
Midwich Cuckoos by John Wyndham (highly recommended )
House on Haunted Hill (w/ Vincent Price)
Fright Night (first one w/ Roddy McDowell and Chris Sarandon) Cheesy but I like it because of the way R-McD character ( a two bit TV actor) masters his "not wanting to get involved" timidity and rises to the heroic.
Cabinet of Dr Caligari (1920 Silent Version)
Freaks (1932)
Invisible Man (1933 with Claude Raines in the title role)
Invasion of the Body Snatchers (original 1956)
The Thing from Another World (1951, not the Carpenter remake)
Bram Stoker's Dracula (
the one with Gary Oldman and, w/o checking, I think Coppola directed. It is also
the one imo most faithful to the book )
Night of the Demon (which made it into Martin Scorsese's list of the top 10 scariest movies), The Studio forced the writer and director to actually include and show a monster, and it's cheesy (the monster). Where the movies excels is in its suspenseful mood. Based on a 1911 short story (in itself very good) T
he Casting of the Runes by M.R. James.
Rosemary's Baby (The book is scarier)
The Innocents (1961)... w/ Deborah Kerr, based on the story
The Turn of the Screw by Henry James (book is very good)
Carnival Of Souls (1962)
The Creature from the Black Lagoon (was that a Hammer film?...can't recall),
The Haunting (1963... and book [The Haunting of Hill House] by Shirley Jackson is far scarier. I read it about every three years, and every time I sleep with the light on for about a week 😬. And I only watch the movie in daylight😬😬) Surprised that no one mentioned it.
Twilight Zone episodes (Original Series)
TZ Living Doll (w/ Telly Sevalas...Bernard Herrmann scored it...never knew that.... great movie score composer)
TZ Nightmare at 20,000 Feet (w/ William Shatner)
TZ The Dummy (w/ Cliff Robertson)
TZ Mirror Image
TZ Night Call
TZ The Invaders (w/ Agnes Moorehead who later played Endora on 'Bewitched'... This is more suspenseful than scary)
OK ...one more consideration but others will have to supply the episodes....
The Outer Limits had some really scary episodes but I don't have any of the DVDs, nor can I recall most of the episodes, scary or not.
Yet I know quite a few were scary as heck. So if anyone has those to add... well, post them. I'd sure like to see someone's recommendations.