• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

How fast is 🐴Shadowfax?

Radaghast

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 31, 2021
Messages
2,842
A question on Quora led me to wonder what the top speed of Shadowfax is. An Internet search turned up an estimate on stackexchange.com of 150 mph, which seems a very high estimate (and I don't understand how it was obtained). Gandalf rides from Isengard to Minas Tirith, a distance of 440 miles (if I'm not mistaken) in four days, with I think one stop. If Shadowfax could run at 150 mph, he could make that trip in less than four hours, not four days.

Anyway, anybody have any insight?
 
But, as a good friend liked to say "great minds think alike" 😁😉
Well, we've been doing equestrian elaborations for over two pages now; and Squinty mentioned Bill the pony earlier ... this isn't exactly like coming up with e=mc² ... 🤓
 
Well, we've been doing equestrian elaborations for over two pages now; and Squinty mentioned Bill the pony earlier ... this isn't exactly like coming up with e=mc² ... 🤓
Einstein  equation.jpg
 
OK, let's compare it to the 18-month existence of the US's Pony Express (April 1860 - October 1861).
The distance from St. Joseph, Missouri, to Sacramento, California, was about 1,900 miles. Covered in 10 days, that meant 190 miles a day ...
But the article in Wikipedia has almost as many inconsistencies as HoMe ... 😳

"In 1860, the roughly 186 Pony Express stations were about 10 to 15 miles (16 to 24 km) apart along the Pony Express route. At each station, the express rider would change to a fresh horse, get a bite to eat, and would only take the mail pouch called a mochila (from the Spanish for pouch or backpack) with him."

"Along the long and arduous route used by the Pony Express, 190 stations were used. To maintain the rigid schedule, 157 relay stations were located from 5 to 25 miles (8 to 40 km) apart, as the terrain would allow. At each "swing station", riders would exchange their tired mounts for fresh ones, while "home stations" provided room and board for the riders between runs. This technique allowed the mail to be moved across the continent in record time. Each rider rode about 75 miles (120 km) per day."

So it appears the riders changed horses on average every 10 miles. For Gandalf's ride, this would have meant 34 changes of horse ...
Then there is the bit about every rider covering about 75 miles a day. To reach the required 190 miles per day, they would have needed about 5 riders per 2 days.

Ah, there's another quote belonging to the first one above:
"Riders, who could not weigh over 125 pounds (57 kg), changed about every 75–100 miles (120–160 km), and rode day and night."

Meaning that the 380 miles (average) covered in 2 days by 5 riders were achieved in 48 hours, or at an average of 7.9 mph ...

As an aside, my great-great grandfather rode for the Pony Express in 1860. His route was between Omaha and Denver. I have a hard time imagining how difficult that job must have been to ride through the barren prairie in all sorts of weather.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top