• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Maeglin vs Snape

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Feb 7, 2023
Messages
4,985
We all know what Maeglin has done and why it was wrong, and I'm not trying to defend a supposed murder and a possible rapist, but I also can't help but find the similarities between his case and Snape's, a beloved character of Harry Potter.

Snape loved Lily, Harry's mother, and Maeglin loved Idril, Earendil's mother. Both of the made deals with the dark lords of their universe to get to be with the woman they loved, or lusted for, some would say.(Mostly for Maeglin's case.)

Maeglin almost killed Earendil, and Snape's action could have led to Harry's death.

If Lily had survived, she would have been Snape's prize for his loyalty to Voldemort, as Idril would have been Maeglin's.

So, it got me wondering how Snape who was just a generally awful person got away with everything he had done, while Maeglin doesn't get the same courtesy?
 
how Snape who was just a generally awful person got away with everything he had done
It's been some time since I read Harry Potter, but I don't recall he got away with everything; obviously, he died in the end by the dark lord's hand. I do know Snape repented of his turning to the dark side, and he acted as a triple agent for good while pretending to still be evil. So I think the key to this is the response. Maeglin never had/took an opportunity to repent or redeem himself, whereas it's stated Snape truly did repent, as was evidenced in his memories when Harry looked into the Pensieve. Harry even named one of his children after Snape in the Epilogue.
Just my two cents. 🙃
 
Interesting comparison! I would say this could be because Tolkien's universe has a stronger and more internally consistent moral framework than Harry Potter. Tolkien carefully thought out the Creator and powers of his world, and developed a set of rules for punishing evil and the like. I can't know for sure whether or not J. K. Rowling thought about the philosophy of her world at that level, but I kind of doubt she's having her character's actions evaluated in-story by a greater power.

But also, The Silmarillion by nature depicts a grim, harsh world where people pay painful consequences for their actions, and next to no one gets a happy ending. Harry Potter, being intended as a children's book series, has a brighter and happier tone, and happy endings are possible, even though the latter books are darker than the earlier ones.

(But I definitely feel you on frustration with the double standard. You know very well of my specific frustrations within the Silm fandom...)
 
Most of Snape's evil actions were in his youth. He had time later on to change his ways and work to thwart the dark lord he had initially followed.

Maeglin kept his betrayal secret after he was released by Morgoth. Part of this may have been his own desire for power, but the presence of Morgoth is likely not easy to forget (while he was in Angband the threat of torture 'cowed his spirit').
This is unlike Voldemort's presence. While he is powerful, he's still a human. Voldemort's followers can do things behind his back without his knowledge (e.g. Snape and Narcissa's Unbreakable Vow), so they clearly don't fear him as much when he's not present.

After Gondolin was overrun, Maeglin laid hands on Idril and Eärendil, then was thrown from the walls by Tuor. There was not much time for him to regret what he had done.

If Maeglin had turned back at the last minute and fought against Morgoth's forces, he might have been looked on more favourably by history. But he didn't, and apparently remained unrepentant to the end.

I won't say Maeglin's fate was all his own fault. No doubt his upbringing left him with an unhealthy view of the world. Eöl was very controlling, and essentially kept Aredhel and Maeglin trapped in their home, so Maeglin might have been under the impression that 'might makes right'. If you have the power, you can do anything you want. He was clearly ambitious, given that one of his reasons for leaving Nan Elmoth was that he had learned all he could from his father and the dwarves, and he wanted more.

I think Maeglin's view of power would only have been confirmed by Eöl trying to kill him (so that Aredhel and Turgon could not keep Maeglin). If you have less power, you are only an object to be owned and used by the more powerful.
And it was confirmed again by Turgon ordering Eöl's death (when Eöl was not even a subject of Turgon's). Idril was probably an object of desire for Maeglin in more than one way. She was a promise of power, and if Maeglin married her, he would become the king's heir.

With this mental state, Morgoth would have found him very easy to exploit. It would not be hard to warp Maeglin's perspective even more.

Maeglin was more damaged than Snape, and far more isolated in many ways. He did not have significant positive influences in his childhood (like Snape did with Lily, for a time). And his experiences as he grew up did not disabuse him of his beliefs. I think a Maeglin redemption story would have to be quite different.
 
All good points from you guys, but I think what I meant originally by my post it that side of Snape might as well have disappeared for the fandom(the audience I was referring to) and just because he becomes a double agent for Dumbledore, nobody remembers that this guy would have easily done what Maeglin would have done to Idril, if things haven't gone that way.

The genz fandom in particular are very unforgiving towards such characters, but for some reason, Snape is safe from their wrath.
 
nobody remembers that this guy would have easily done what Maeglin would have done to Idril, if things haven't gone that way.

The genz fandom in particular are very unforgiving towards such characters, but for some reason, Snape is safe from their wrath.
Most do not really think of the "What If"; it's a focus on what did happen. Snape repented and redeemed himself, and therefore, he is forgiven. One is more likely to think the reverse-- With Maeglin, people could wonder "What if" he did repent... but he didn't. Hence, he remains largely unforgiven.
 
All good points from you guys, but I think what I meant originally by my post it that side of Snape might as well have disappeared for the fandom(the audience I was referring to) and just because he becomes a double agent for Dumbledore, nobody remembers that this guy would have easily done what Maeglin would have done to Idril, if things haven't gone that way.

The genz fandom in particular are very unforgiving towards such characters, but for some reason, Snape is safe from their wrath.
If I recall correctly, there really isn't much focus given in the books to Snape's past self. There are flashbacks to his 'good' moments and his 'repentant' moments, but there aren't any flashbacks to his memories while still a committed Death Eater. Even when he's joined a suspicious friend group at school, all we see is Lily disapproving of it, and they have a bit of a conflict.
The book itself seems to gloss over Snape's more negative characteristics.

And many people would have been influenced by the movies' portrayal of him, where he's far more calm and composed, and is less unreasonable towards his students (in the book, he can lash out emotionally, and often picks on people).
 
Hermione's teeth, Neville's toad, the list goes on and on.

The only content creator I've seen take an approach towards this matter is this German girl Silvia on YouTube. She's...uh, pretty unhinged, let's say, and her content are pretty suggestive and sometimes even inappropriate so I can't share it here, but her sense of humor is great.
 
Snape wasn't an awful person. And he didn't want to get Lily as a prize. He wanted her to be alive
He was actually a pretty awful person. Voldemort had promised to keep Lily alive because he thought that's why Snape wanted her for.(It could have been true or not, that's not the point.)
Before he knew the child was Lily's, he was pretty happy to watch Voldemort kill a child, when he brought him the news of the prophecy.

In the book, he bullied his own student. I think you and I have very different definition of what an 'awful person' is.
 
In the book, he bullied his own student. I think you and I have very different definition of what an 'awful person' is.
Yeah. Neville, who had a lot of trauma since his parents were hospitalized, feared Snape more than anything else in the world, which is super sad if you think about it.
 
He was actually a pretty awful person. Voldemort had promised to keep Lily alive because he thought that's why Snape wanted her for.(It could have been true or not, that's not the point.)
Before he knew the child was Lily's, he was pretty happy to watch Voldemort kill a child, when he brought him the news of the prophecy.

In the book, he bullied his own student. I think you and I have very different definition of what an 'awful person' is.

Congratulations, you didn't understand this book if you think Snape wanted Harry dead. He came to Dumbledore and told that their whole family is in danger, implying Dumbledore must protect whole family.

Bullied? Snape was rude, but he didn't do really awful things. He was a good teacher, his students passed exams really good. It means he was good. I don't deny he was nasty sometimes, but still.
He is a GOOD person in books
 
Congratulations, you didn't understand this book if you think Snape wanted Harry dead. He came to Dumbledore and told that their whole family is in danger, implying Dumbledore must protect whole family.
He only did it because he knew it was Lily's child who would be killed. He was pretty happy watching another innocent baby die.
Bullied? Snape was rude, but he didn't do really awful things. He was a good teacher, his students passed exams really good. It means he was good. I don't deny he was nasty sometimes, but still.
He is a GOOD person in books
Ahem, Neville? His Boggart was literally Snape himself. You might think crazy teachers who dare treat their students however they want is somehow a sign of them being good, but that's not the case for everyone.
 
He only did it because he knew it was Lily's child who would be killed. He was pretty happy watching another innocent baby die.

Ahem, Neville? His Boggart was literally Snape himself. You might think crazy teachers who dare treat their students however they want is somehow a sign of them being good, but that's not the case for everyone.
Find me proofs that he was happy to watch someone die. Oh, they don't exist. Because Snape didn't want to murder anyone. You simply have no proofs

So what? Yes Neville was afraid of Snape but Snape didn't harm him. He just was scared of a strict teacher. And Snape protected Neville in the last book so I guess it counts as a redemption.

Snape saved many people. He is a hero
 
He brought news of the prophecy to Voldemort. What did he expect would happen?

Besides, if your standard for someone being necessarily good or bad is based on their urge to murder people...that sounds concerning a bit, I'm not going to lie.

Fëanorians murdered a lot of people, but you can't say there wasn't any good in them or they were necessarily bad people.(Elrond and Elros, Celegorm saving Cirdan and his people, etc.)
Neither can you say Elu Thingol was a good person.(Hiding in his realm while the Noldor fought his war for him as the King of Beleriand, not allowing Noldor refugees to pass through his realm safely, etc.)

This, my friend, is what we call a morally grey person. Yes, Snape did a lot of good stuff, but he was also a death eater at first, and not all the people he killed was to make Voldemort believe he was still loyal to him.
 
He brought news of the prophecy to Voldemort. What did he expect would happen?

Besides, if your standard for someone being necessarily good or bad is based on their urge to murder people...that sounds concerning a bit, I'm not going to lie.

Fëanorians murdered a lot of people, but you can't say there wasn't any good in them or they were necessarily bad people.(Elrond and Elros, Celegorm saving Cirdan and his people, etc.)
Neither can you say Elu Thingol was a good person.(Hiding in his realm while the Noldor fought his war for him as the King of Beleriand, not allowing Noldor refugees to pass through his realm safely, etc.)

This, my friend, is what we call a morally grey person. Yes, Snape did a lot of good stuff, but he was also a death eater at first, and not all the people he killed was to make Voldemort believe he was still loyal to him.

You sound concerning if you consider murdering people can be ok. You just have no proofs of Snape being a murderer, so you try to put imaginary blame on me for liking this character. The only person he killed was Dumbledore who asked himself for it.

I don't like Feanor and his son, thank you. And I don't view them as good for many reasons.

Give me a list of Snape's crimes first. Oh it does not exist. He isn't morally gray. He is a good and noble person. There are many awful people in Harry Potter but not him
 
You just can't prove your point of view, that's all
This is a discussion thread, not a question and answer one. People are allowed to have different opinions than yours. If you refuse to see my point, then there is nothing I can do to prove it to you, which I wasn't trying to, anyways. Again, have a nice day and kindly, don't spam if you want to continue with this childish argument.
 
This is a discussion thread, not a question and answer one. People are allowed to have different opinions than yours. If you refuse to see my point, then there is nothing I can do to prove it to you, which I wasn't trying to, anyways. Again, have a nice day and kindly, don't spam if you want to continue with this childish argument.
I am allowed to have my opinion too. I refuse because you don't give any proofs and try to blame me for not seeing imaginary crimes of Snape.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top