>>That's a bold declaration in itself, but, because your knowledge of
THE Ring, and your elegant style of discussion and writing, suggest you are someone whose opinion is worth knowing, I respect and acknowledge it!<<
Deep breath!! And with apologies for the length and any incoherence.
Although
Tolkien’s LOTR obviously has many themes, three lie at the heart of both the book and Tolkien’s own vision of the world. They are both conceptually interconnected and interact decisively at the story’s climax.
1. The fundamental nature of the world and the intentions of its creator (
God, “
the One”,
Eru) are good. Good actions are in harmony with the nature of the world and will tend towards being successful (though not necessarily achieving a precisely envisaged outcome), whereas
evil actions are discordant with the nature of the world, tend to go awry and may even achieve unintended “good” outcomes.
2. Nothing is evil in the beginning (“even
Sauron was not so”). Tolkien is no dualist. Therefore everyone is potentially redeemable. But since God is the only adequate judge of such matters, pity and mercy are a necessary duty for the rest of us.
3. Since we have free will, it is necessary to make choices. The evil of the Ring lies in the fact that it limits free will and removes choice. With the Ring Sauron can dominate the wills of others - that is the power of the Ring. The
Ringwraiths have no will of their own, they are the slaves of the Ring.
Gollum’s will has been almost entirely sapped by the Ring and
Frodo’s will be. The ultimate evil of the
orcs lies not in the fact that they themselves are evil, but in the way that they have been so fundamentally warped by
Morgoth/Sauron/
Saruman that they no longer have the power to choose to be good.
It is only by the interaction of these three themes that the Ring is ultimately destroyed. Frodo, of course, in the end cannot will to destroy the Ring and claims it for his own, and yet Tolkien did not regard this as a failure on his part, because the destruction of the Ring takes place as a result of Frodo’s choice to take the Ring to
Mordor, combined with Frodo’s decision to show mercy to Gollum. Frodo’s pity for Gollum and his freely taken decision to shoulder the burden of the Ring’s destruction created the situation whereby the Ring was in fact destroyed. Not because Gollum is a convenient plot device to resolve a difficult situation, but because, in Tolkien’s view, that is how the world works; Frodo made various choices, which, although they were not in themselves obviously destined for success or even perhaps in Frodo’s immediate or long-term self interest, were good in and of themselves, in harmony with the nature of the world and its creator’s intentions and thus achieved a successful, if unlooked for, outcome.
So how is this view of the world reflected in the film? Well, it is interesting that these three themes are explicity stated or implied together in the
Gandalf’s words to Frodo in the Mines of
Moria. A speech constructed almost entirely verbatim from Tolkien’s own words. Gandalf impresses upon Frodo (1) the importance of
Bilbo’s mercy to Gollum, the fact that he has no right to deal out death in judgement when he cannot also give life (the prerogative of the Creator), (2) that it is necessary for Frodo to choose what to do with the time that is given him, and (3) that Frodo was meant to have the Ring (i.e. that there is a benevolent intention behind many of the apparent chances of the world). It seems unlikely, to me at least, that these three ideas should have been so juxtaposed and given such a prominent place in the film by accident. In fact one of them is re-emphasised at the end of the film as Frodo stands at the water’s edge steeling himself to make the choice he knows he has to make.
Of course the many different changes to the film have been made for many different reasons - pacing, structure, visual effectiveness, director’s whim etc., but several of the major ones and particularly those that have most worried/irritated/annoyed/enraged some fans, if this website is anything to go by, do seem to me to have been motivated by PJ’s (or his fellow scripwriters') desire to emphasise these themes and most of all the theme of choice and free will. For example:
The change to
Aragorn’s character emphasises that he must make a choice to accept his destiny. And as presented in the film, I don't think that he can be accused of moral cowardice (he is clearly no physical coward), rather he is someone who is only too well aware of what will be staked on the outcome of such a choice. He is the heir of
Isildur, and, as is emphasised on several occasions and shown in the scene between Gandalf and
Elrond, it was Isildur's choice not to destroy the Ring that has allowed Sauron to return. Therefore, in the scene with Frodo at
Amon Hen we see Aragorn choose to reject the Ring - our first clear sign that Aragorn may be Isildur's heir but he has not inherited Isildur's weakness, he is his own man.
This of course is also in vivid contrast to
Boromir's attempt to take the Ring moments before. (But note Frodo’s words to Aragorn – “the Ring has taken Boromir” not "Boromir tried to take the Ring" – with the implication that the Ring had robbed him of his free will.) Also it would seem from reviews of TTT that the change to
Faramir has possibly been made in order to emphasise that unlike his brother he chooses to reject the Ring and let Frodo go, by making the brothers more alike than in the book and showing the different choices that each makes when the moment for choice arrives.
Whereas in the book
Galadriel has clearly considered and rejected the temptation of the Ring before Frodo offers it to her, in the film we see her make the choice and be shaken by it.
Even the increased role for
Arwen revolves around the question of choice, for she must choose between the fate of
elves and
men (“I choose a mortal life”) – no simple decision when one way is that of immortality and a certain future while the other leads to death and the unknown. And Aragorn too must choose whether to accept so great a sacrifice and all that either decision will imply.
Whether one likes these changes or not, even whether Tolkien would have liked or approved of them, is another matter, but like them or loath them I don’t think that they stem from a misreading of Tolkien or that they are out of harmony with the themes at the heart of Tolkien’s work. Ultimately I think that the spirit of Tolkien's work remains essentially and intentionally intact in the film, no matter how much of a drubbing is occasionally meted out to the letter. For my part I hope that, whatever else may be the case, these themes continue to be worked out through TTT and brought to fruition in ROTK.