Originally posted by Eriol
My question is -- do you think Jackson has a theme? Did he pick themes from LotR without any overarching notion? I am thinking about the two movies and I can't see any. I see plenty of themes, some of them from the books even; but no Theme with a capital T, no notion that guides the whole project.
Far and away the best post I have seen on this subject (keeping in mind I'm biased towards enjoyment of the movie) was the long-lost Bjarki's comments, to be found in the link
here. While the only credit I can take for that post is liking it, I can try to add how these themes are carried through in TTT (I believe Bjarki's post was pre-TTT, and so only referred to FotR).
In the same thread (link) I tried to show how Bjarki's/
Tolkien's/PJ's three major themes were played out in the character of
Boromir.
Faramir's characterization in the movie TTT has received a large amount of criticism on these boards. Do any of the changes in his character reflect PJ's emphasis on these three interwoven themes? In order to simplify the linkage problem, Bjarki's claim of the three major themes in both books and movie are:
originally posted by Bjarki
1. The fundamental nature of the world and the intentions of its creator (God, “the One”, Eru) are good. Good actions are in harmony with the nature of the world and will tend towards being successful (though not necessarily achieving a precisely envisaged outcome), whereas evil actions are discordant with the nature of the world, tend to go awry and may even achieve unintended “good” outcomes.
2. Nothing is evil in the beginning (“even Sauron was not so”). Tolkien is no dualist. Therefore everyone is potentially redeemable. But since God is the only adequate judge of such matters, pity and mercy are a necessary duty for the rest of us.
3. Since we have free will, it is necessary to make choices. The evil of the Ring lies in the fact that it limits free will and removes choice. With the Ring Sauron can dominate the wills of others - that is the power of the Ring. The Ringwraiths have no will of their own, they are the slaves of the Ring. Gollum’s will has been almost entirely sapped by the Ring and Frodo’s will be. The ultimate evil of the orcs lies not in the fact that they themselves are evil, but in the way that they have been so fundamentally warped by Morgoth/Sauron/Saruman that they no longer have the power to choose to be good.
Faramir's dilemna (as I see it) is this: In the vicinity of a battle he has captured two
Hobbits. Their origin is of course unknown to him, and Frodo damages their credibility by lying (known to be a lie by Faramir) about Gollum. Frodo claims to have been recently in the company of Boromir, but also claims to have no knowledge of Boromir's death. The
hobbit's are known to be carrying an
item of supreme, if little understood power. Furthermore, they are carrying this item to Mordor- they claim to do this in an effort against Sauron, but they've already damaged their credibility.
Gondor is in a bind- it's military might is much diminished, Sauron is attacking
Osgiliath, and with the death of his elder brother, Faramir is now Gondor's foremost Captain. The laws of Faramir's father are clear- no non-Gondorian is allowed passage through Gondor (
Ithilien still being claimed) without the personal permission of the steward. With all this information Faramir must then make a choice, either to take the Hobbits to his father, as the law demands, or else to listen to the pleas of the Hobbits and let them go.
********Book Spoilers*********
The first theme is not addressed in TTT as pertains to Faramir's choice. In the end he makes a 'good' decision which (it turns out) IS in harmony with the world and ends up being successful- he believes that the Hobbits are indeed trying to thwart Sauron, and because Faramir chooses to let them go they are (one can only imagine based on book knowledge) eventually successful. But again, this is not addressed
per se in the second film.
The second theme- Everyone is redeemable. This I think is actually played up in the movie. Faramir
initially makes a bad decision (though arguably a logical decision based on the information at hand). When given a second chance (and a little more information), Faramir redeems himself
and Gondor, by making the choice that his brother was unable to do- let the Hobbits go. Fantastic stuff, IMO, and it is largely overlooked by purists because they 'know' that Faramir was never supposed to be tempted in the first place.
The third theme- choice is the necessary consequence of free-will (also the evil of the Ring is in it's negation of said free-will). Here PJ out-Tolkiens Tolkien (much to the dismay of the purists)! In the books Faramir's decision is so flippant, that it actually minimizes (IMO) both the importance of making choices AND the true evil of the Ring. PJ's treatment, however, emphasizes both. When Faramir handles the Ring we see a change come over him, much as we saw with his brother on Caradhras. The Ring is denying him his own will- it is after all very powerful in this respect. As an audience this is (or at least should be) very understandable for us, as we have already seen this horribly tempting effect on
Bilbo,
Gandalf,
Galadriel,
Aragorn, and of course Boromir. In the books Faramir gets a 'pass' on this- his innate nobility makes him impervious to the Ring's effects. This not only reduces the power and innate evil-ness of the Ring (as noted by PJ), it also nullifies the importance of choice and hence the 'gift' of free-will. If (as apparently in the books) Eru 'created' Faramir to be so noble that he is not tempted by the Ring, then (IMO) there is no merit in book-Faramir's choice: he was simply created as being immune to the Ring. However, in Jackson's treatment Faramir's
choice becomes much more important because of the fact that he is not immune to the Ring, and the eventual choice is made to be even more noble/altruistic because PJ has changed the circumstances (Frodo's lying, removal of Gandalf's tutelage, urgency of attack on Osgiliath, etc).
I could further say that this same idea is at play in movie-Aragorn (King because of innate nobility or King because of Choice), but I'm afraid that if I press my luck MM will run me off these boards!
So, a quick summary of a long-winded post: I do believe that Jackson has a Theme (actually three inter-related themes combining to become a Theme). I believe that the books also had this as a Theme (assuredly intentioned by the author, but they would still be in the work even if unintended by JRRT). Love it or hate it, the fact that PJ
et al changed many
events from the books in order to emphasize these themes (to me at least) proves that this Theme is considered to be of prime importance by the filmakers.