• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Lack of a theme

Eriol

Estel
Joined
Sep 30, 2002
Messages
1,359
I'm not a usual visitor of these halls, so bear with me if this has been raised elsewhere...

Tolkien's book had a very clear theme for Tolkien. While people were making analogies with Stalin and Hitler and the atom bomb, looking for themes and finding plenty, his letters make it clear that his theme was not Power at all; it was Mortality, and God's sole right to divine honor. All conflict stems from these two factors.

So far so good. I have seen some discussions here about whether PJ was able to 'capture the themes' of LotR. My question is not exactly that. I don't know if PJ was aware of the main theme as expressed in Tolkien's words; and of course the theme is only fully expressed when one reads the Silmarillion. I would not be bothered if PJ chose more 'local' themes to be emphasized, like faith, forgiveness, etc.

My question is -- do you think Jackson has a theme? Did he pick themes from LotR without any overarching notion? I am thinking about the two movies and I can't see any. I see plenty of themes, some of them from the books even; but no Theme with a capital T, no notion that guides the whole project.

I can't help but wondering that this is a product of the times... that most movies nowadays lack this, a characteristic that was so present in earlier periods of movie-making history. We had movies made almost entirely of a Theme, with little acting or special effects or screenplay... Now it is harder to find a director with something to say. They want to tell stories; but they don't want to say anything special.

What do you think?
 
Originally posted by Eriol
My question is -- do you think Jackson has a theme? Did he pick themes from LotR without any overarching notion? I am thinking about the two movies and I can't see any. I see plenty of themes, some of them from the books even; but no Theme with a capital T, no notion that guides the whole project.
Far and away the best post I have seen on this subject (keeping in mind I'm biased towards enjoyment of the movie) was the long-lost Bjarki's comments, to be found in the link here. While the only credit I can take for that post is liking it, I can try to add how these themes are carried through in TTT (I believe Bjarki's post was pre-TTT, and so only referred to FotR). In the same thread (link) I tried to show how Bjarki's/Tolkien's/PJ's three major themes were played out in the character of Boromir. Faramir's characterization in the movie TTT has received a large amount of criticism on these boards. Do any of the changes in his character reflect PJ's emphasis on these three interwoven themes? In order to simplify the linkage problem, Bjarki's claim of the three major themes in both books and movie are:
originally posted by Bjarki
1. The fundamental nature of the world and the intentions of its creator (God, “the One”, Eru) are good. Good actions are in harmony with the nature of the world and will tend towards being successful (though not necessarily achieving a precisely envisaged outcome), whereas evil actions are discordant with the nature of the world, tend to go awry and may even achieve unintended “good” outcomes.

2. Nothing is evil in the beginning (“even Sauron was not so”). Tolkien is no dualist. Therefore everyone is potentially redeemable. But since God is the only adequate judge of such matters, pity and mercy are a necessary duty for the rest of us.

3. Since we have free will, it is necessary to make choices. The evil of the Ring lies in the fact that it limits free will and removes choice. With the Ring Sauron can dominate the wills of others - that is the power of the Ring. The Ringwraiths have no will of their own, they are the slaves of the Ring. Gollum’s will has been almost entirely sapped by the Ring and Frodo’s will be. The ultimate evil of the orcs lies not in the fact that they themselves are evil, but in the way that they have been so fundamentally warped by Morgoth/Sauron/Saruman that they no longer have the power to choose to be good.
Faramir's dilemna (as I see it) is this: In the vicinity of a battle he has captured two Hobbits. Their origin is of course unknown to him, and Frodo damages their credibility by lying (known to be a lie by Faramir) about Gollum. Frodo claims to have been recently in the company of Boromir, but also claims to have no knowledge of Boromir's death. The hobbit's are known to be carrying an item of supreme, if little understood power. Furthermore, they are carrying this item to Mordor- they claim to do this in an effort against Sauron, but they've already damaged their credibility. Gondor is in a bind- it's military might is much diminished, Sauron is attacking Osgiliath, and with the death of his elder brother, Faramir is now Gondor's foremost Captain. The laws of Faramir's father are clear- no non-Gondorian is allowed passage through Gondor (Ithilien still being claimed) without the personal permission of the steward. With all this information Faramir must then make a choice, either to take the Hobbits to his father, as the law demands, or else to listen to the pleas of the Hobbits and let them go.

********Book Spoilers*********

The first theme is not addressed in TTT as pertains to Faramir's choice. In the end he makes a 'good' decision which (it turns out) IS in harmony with the world and ends up being successful- he believes that the Hobbits are indeed trying to thwart Sauron, and because Faramir chooses to let them go they are (one can only imagine based on book knowledge) eventually successful. But again, this is not addressed per se in the second film.

The second theme- Everyone is redeemable. This I think is actually played up in the movie. Faramir initially makes a bad decision (though arguably a logical decision based on the information at hand). When given a second chance (and a little more information), Faramir redeems himself and Gondor, by making the choice that his brother was unable to do- let the Hobbits go. Fantastic stuff, IMO, and it is largely overlooked by purists because they 'know' that Faramir was never supposed to be tempted in the first place.

The third theme- choice is the necessary consequence of free-will (also the evil of the Ring is in it's negation of said free-will). Here PJ out-Tolkiens Tolkien (much to the dismay of the purists)! In the books Faramir's decision is so flippant, that it actually minimizes (IMO) both the importance of making choices AND the true evil of the Ring. PJ's treatment, however, emphasizes both. When Faramir handles the Ring we see a change come over him, much as we saw with his brother on Caradhras. The Ring is denying him his own will- it is after all very powerful in this respect. As an audience this is (or at least should be) very understandable for us, as we have already seen this horribly tempting effect on Bilbo, Gandalf, Galadriel, Aragorn, and of course Boromir. In the books Faramir gets a 'pass' on this- his innate nobility makes him impervious to the Ring's effects. This not only reduces the power and innate evil-ness of the Ring (as noted by PJ), it also nullifies the importance of choice and hence the 'gift' of free-will. If (as apparently in the books) Eru 'created' Faramir to be so noble that he is not tempted by the Ring, then (IMO) there is no merit in book-Faramir's choice: he was simply created as being immune to the Ring. However, in Jackson's treatment Faramir's choice becomes much more important because of the fact that he is not immune to the Ring, and the eventual choice is made to be even more noble/altruistic because PJ has changed the circumstances (Frodo's lying, removal of Gandalf's tutelage, urgency of attack on Osgiliath, etc).
I could further say that this same idea is at play in movie-Aragorn (King because of innate nobility or King because of Choice), but I'm afraid that if I press my luck MM will run me off these boards!

So, a quick summary of a long-winded post: I do believe that Jackson has a Theme (actually three inter-related themes combining to become a Theme). I believe that the books also had this as a Theme (assuredly intentioned by the author, but they would still be in the work even if unintended by JRRT). Love it or hate it, the fact that PJ et al changed many events from the books in order to emphasize these themes (to me at least) proves that this Theme is considered to be of prime importance by the filmakers.
 
From what I have read about and seen in the films, Jackson seemed absolutely fixated on the superficial aspects of the story. For instance, in one scene there are runes which appear on the wall in a scene and the Director assured all and sundry that he made absolutely certain that these runes were in fact correct even though just about none of his audience would have noticed the matter even had they understood them! Then there are the stories of Hobbiton being crafted a year before the filming was to begin so that it would have the appearance of something "natural" rather than contrived. This was the case throughout the films. Warriors in the back ranks were not outfitted in cheap imitation armor/mail simply because they would not be seen; they were outfitted in the same armor as those in the front ranks because Jackson wanted to be sure to "get it right". He even fired his Aragorn actor because he was "too young" for the part. He hired the very best special effects people and worked tirelessly with them to insure that the orcs and other monsters created by Tolkien were properly depicted. He was careful as he could be in his depiction of the various places in Middle-earth from the Shire and Rivendell to Moria and Mordor. He oversaw the costumes to be sure that nothing appeared which was grossly out of place. And, of course, he tekked all over New Zealand to film in those areas which were most in keeping with the story. I for one applaud Mr. Jackson's determination to make sure that the films looked right and all the effort, time and expense he expended towards that end.

But alas, Tolkien's story is so much more than its superficialities. In fixating on the skin, Mr. Jackson missed so much of the muscle, blood and bones of the story. Yes, he had most of the characters - but far too many of them were virtually unrecognizeable when compared to their book counterparts. Yes, he had in the main the plot themes, but he took a story which was packed with action, adventure, drama and even a certain comedic touch and determined that it "wasn't enough" (or, conversely, too much) and deleted parts (in some instances understandable for the sake of time but in other instances not), frequently added scenarios all out of keeping with the story and seemingly placed there for "audience appeal"(!) and, worst of all, confused, confounded and in some instances condemned many of the tale's most important "actors" for which cause only Mr. Jackson himself could explain! Of course, for every alteration and change to the "vision" and "themes" of the book, Jackson had to add ever more and new alterations to accommodate those he had already created. Thus what was doubled in FOTR became squared in TTT and its eventual end in ROTK can only be guessed at. Needless to say, by this time, aside from the superficialities, little of Tolkien remains.

Did Jackson "understand" Tolkien's ultimate theme of mortality? I doubt it. Despite his opening statements regarding his "love" for the work, eventually we discovered that he had read it ("once"?) at age 18. I don't know about anyone else, but a first reading of Tolkien's work - even at a more mature age - is not going to reveal all of the depth and subtleties therein. Furthermore, Mr. Jackson does not strike me as a man who appreciates subtleties as his various attempts at rather bumptious humor and out of place "in jokes" (dwarf tossing?) throughout the films plainly reveal.

I believe that Peter Jackson was attempting to "illustrate" LOTR; I don't really know if he was attempting to translate that great work into film except in the most superficial of ways - and in that, he is certainly succeeding.
 
Originally posted by aragil
Faramir redeems himself and Gondor, by making the choice that his brother was unable to do- let the Hobbits go. Fantastic stuff, IMO.
I do believe that Jackson has a Theme.
One minute he is determined not to let them go, the next minute, with very little intervening to explain the reversal, he lets them go. That doesn't count as fantastic, imo; it's more like a casual after-thought.
I believe that PJ wouldn't know a Theme if it was offered to him on a plate. As Mrs M explains so eloquently, he is excellent at putting on a visual show, but there his abilities, and indeed his interests, end.
 
Excuse me... I'm lost here.

I thought PJ's theme had something to do with shield surfing, dwarf jokes, half-elf cynicism, and Ye Great Heroes of Olde who wouldn't make it anywhere in life unless they had a hyperactive supermagical ultra pincess to tell them what to do.


Taking bizare liberties with the relationship between Aragorn, Elrond, and Arwen... watering down the contrast between Theoden and Denethor and between Faramir and Boromir... and overemphasizing the point of view of the Kingdoms of Men at the expense of the Hobbits....

All of this taken together undermines every single one of Tolkien's major themes. The result is merely schizophrenic and incoherent drivel. He takes more Thematic material from Predator and Aliens than he does from Tolkien.

"Put it out, you fool!!!"
 
Hmmm. Well, Bjarki has (posthumously, as it were) given us a Theme (with capital T) from the books. Bjarki has also given us examples of how the movie (FotR) 'alters' events from the book in order to emphasize this theme. I have (perhaps unsuccessfully) tried to give further examples, focusing on individual characters that have been changed from the books also in order to emphasize the Theme.

To summarize what I got out of Mrs. Maggott's, joxy's, and Goroshimura's posts:
MM) PJ has copied 'superficial' aspects of the story, but changed the characters. PJ has not read LotR enough times to catch subtleties in the tale, and is by nature almost incapable of noting these subtleties anyway.
joxy) Faramir's redemption is a throwaway bit, PJ is too daft to have put it in there as part of a Theme, he is in fact too daft to recognize a Theme.
Goroshimura) PJ prefers style to substance. Tolkien's major Themes were: the relationships between Arwen, Aragorn, and Elrond; the contrasts between Theoden & Denethor, Boromir & Faramir; the Hobbo-centric POV of the events ending the Third Age of Middle-earth. PJ's changing of characters/events/emphasis has (intentionally or no) undermined these important Themes.

My responses-

MM- you seem in your post to be confusing characterization for Theme. I know that you are upset about the 'alternate characterization', and I even know about Tolkien's letter stating that he would prefer changes in the story to changes in the characters. However, Theme is the issue here. You can certainly change characters without changing Theme; in fact, I have tried to demonstrate that these 'inexplicable' changes to the characters have been made in order to do just that. This would indicate that PJ (and Fran Walsh, who has read the book at lleast once a year for god only knows how long) is perfectly capable of recognizing and using subtleties in story-telling.
joxy- Frankly, changing characters to emphasize themes makes more sense then changing characters because you are too dull to know any better. Film making is an art, not simply an act of throwing a best-selling-novel and miles of film in the air and using the result, however it may land. If you truly want to enjoy the film, then start giving the film-maker a little credit. Re-read the books, then watch the movies. See if this Theme is present in both media. Then ask yourself if any of the changes between media reflect this Theme.
Goroshimura- First of all, if you are honestly proposing the above as the 'major Themes' of Tolkien's work (and this I doubt), then I disagree with you. I would even disagree with the author if he were to tell me that the major Theme of Lord of the Rings is 'mortality'. Maybe the Sil, but certainly not LotR. I come from the school of literary thought that 'the author is dead' (no pun intended). The themes to be dug out of a work are what resonate with me upon reading the work, not what the author tells me to get out of it (I think Tolkien would agree with me on this). If you would like, I could tell you why I don't think the things you listed comprise the major Themes of the work. Perhaps it would be interesting to discuss whether or not the Theme posited by Bjarki really is the Theme of the books, and whether or not the film makers have done anything to capture this Theme. Otherwise it seems that your (and MM & joxy's) derision (and I do take comparison of the LotR movies to Predator and Aliens as derision) of PJ is premature.
 
I did not say that Jackson couldn't recognize a theme but that either he didn't in this case, or he did not believe it was important enough to the overall story to matter. After all, he was creating an action/adventure/fantasy films and deep themes are not exactly a great necessity. This wasn't going to be To Kill a Mockingbird or On the Waterfront, it was going to be Indiana Jones, Merlin and Luke Skywalker all rolled into one. Who cares about "themes"?

As for the characters, I absolutely, completely, categorically and every other type of "ly" disagree! To change the characters is to change the theme! To make Aragorn or Frodo or Elrond or Gandalf or Faramir or Galadriel or Sam or Saruman or any other of the major characters that which they are not is to change the theme. Yes, leave out Tom Bombadil or Glorfindel or even "build up" Arwen a little (but not, puhleese! into Arwen Warrior Princess!), but do not change the essential nature of the characters for to do so changes the theme/vision/meaning of the story! Frankly, I do not see how you can possibly believe to the contrary, but apparently you do. And as that is the case, then no amount of "explanation" of my point of view is going to change matters. This is one of those situations that is either self-explanatory or else cannot be explained.
 
How can changing a character not change a theme? Well, if a theme of the works is free will and necessity of choice, then changing characters to emphasize free will and choice does not change the themes. IMO, Aragorn and Faramir in the books have less free will and make less choices than they do in the movies. Saruman, on the other hand seems to have/do less of each in the movies relative to in the books. We ourselves have two further choices (as I see it) in this very thread:
1) further discussion of whether you can change characterization without changing themes (interesting but not entirely on-topic).
2) discussion of what precisely is the main Theme in the movie, if one exists.
 
Originally posted by aragil
<joxy> Faramir's redemption is a throwaway bit, PJ is too daft to have put it in there as part of a Theme, he is in fact too daft to recognize a Theme.
Film making is an art, not simply an act of throwing a best-selling-novel and miles of film in the air and using the result, however it may land. If you truly want to enjoy the film, then start giving the film-maker a little credit. Re-read the books, then watch the movies. See if this Theme is present in both media.
Yes, a throwaway, but not daft, just not thought out, a convenient but casual way of getting himself out of a corner, over Faramir, that he had worked himself into; and nothing to do with themes at all. Not too daft to recognise a theme, but simply not interested in themes at all.
Film-making an art? Well, we've been through that one before. I go as far as allowing it's sometimes a craft, though as far as I can see most films are just industrial products.
I, and indeed we, tried hard to give the credit you ask for. The more we saw TTT the more we failed to find the quality that would have deserved the credit.
We are very familiar with the books; we know that Tolkien uses the idea of Theme in the Silmarillion, but I really don't think that FOTR is a matter of themes. T wrote his books as a scenario to take in his invented races, especially the hobbits, and as a vehicle for his invented languages. I am content with that, and don't look or ask for anything grander.
What I do look for in the films is a faithful representation of T's action and characters, and then for a technically proficient product. In both respects, I find the films only "good in parts", like the notorious curate's egg.
 
Originally posted by joxy
Yes, a throwaway, but not daft, just not thought out, a convenient but casual way of getting himself out of a corner, over Faramir, that he had worked himself into; and nothing to do with themes at all. Not too daft to recognise a theme, but simply not interested in themes at all.
The question then becomes 'Why change Faramir at all'. It would have been far easier to just lift the words from the book. Don't you think PJ had some reason for painting himself into that corner in the first place?
 
Originally posted by aragil
The question then becomes 'Why change Faramir at all'. It would have been far easier to just lift the words from the book. Don't you think PJ had some reason for painting himself into that corner in the first place?
Here is Peter Jackson's explanation of why he changed Faramir:

http://www.puddingbowl.org/archives/film/000421.php

"Q: In the book, for example, Faramir is very pure and very noble, but here in the film, he's got this evil touch. He's even tempted by the ring.
"Peter Jackson: For a short time, yeah. We made that change, just to use that example -- and this is really where being a filmmaker differs from being a writer. You make decisions as a filmmaker and, rightly or wrongly, you change things if you think they need to be changed. We wanted the episode with Faramir in this particular film to have a certain degree of tension. Frodo and Sam were captured. Their journey had become more complicated by the fact that they are prisoners. Which they are in the book for a brief period of time. But then, very quickly in the book, Tolkien sort of backs away from there and, as you say, he reveals Faramir to be very pure. At one point, Faramir says, "Look, I wouldn't even touch the ring if I saw it lying on the side of the road."

"For us, as filmmakers, that sort of thing creates a bit of a problem because we've spent a lot of time in the last film and in this one to establish this ring as incredibly powerful. Then to suddenly come to a character that says, "Oh, I'm not interested in that," to suddenly go against everything that we've established ourselves is sort of going against our own rules. We certainly acknowledge that Faramir should not do what Boromir did and that he ultimately has the strength to say, "No, you go on your way and I understand." We wanted to make it slightly harder, to have a little more tension than there was in the book. But that's where that sort of decision comes from."
 
Please explain to me - in depth, if you will - why being noble and heroic indicates some lack of free will. Indeed, it is entirely the other way round. People who are ignoble and cowardly are giving up their free will to act in the way that we with our fallen natures are more inclined to act. It is always easier to establish bad habits than good ones because it follows our natural inclination. Aragorn and Faramir in the book exhibit far more "free will" or at least the consequences of their free will than Jackson's two characters who appear to simply take the path of least resistance in their actions. Furthermore, they make every bit as many - if not more - choices in the book than the films.

In the book, Aragorn chooses to love Arwen. In the film it certainly appears to be the other way around and the Lady is the "suitor", not the Lord! He appears to simply "go along" with the whole thing and initiates nothing.

In the book, Aragorn chooses to labor long years in hardship and obscurity in hopes of gaining his rightful heritage - the throne of Gondor - and thus his betrothed whom he cannot wed without being King of both Kingdoms. In the film, Aragorn's choice (at least so far) is to run as fast as possible from his ancestry, his heritage and just about everything else that isn't a sword fight. In that sort of thing, he does quite well, but it is a limited virtue at best.

In the book, Aragorn hides his identity to avoid arousing the Dark Lord's wrath at finding a living heir of hated Elendil and Isildur and only reveals himself to Sauron in the palantir when he can no longer gain anything by secrecy, needing the knowledge that the stone can provide. Of course, we don't know anything about the palantir so far, so I cannot judge, but I am willing to say that Jackson's Aragorn is not hiding his heritage because of Sauron. Rather, he is hiding from his heritage because he is afraid for himself and not for the folk of Middle-earth.

In the book, Faramir makes an oath to Frodo before he knows the nature of the "heirloom" they have discussed. When he learns of the Ring, it is not that he is "not interested" - although as with Aragorn, he doubtless is aware of the nature of the Ring and the futility of any attempt to use it - but rather that he has taken an oath and would die rather than break it. In the film, Faramir isn't just "a little evil" (which in itself is disgusting), but he is a bully and a rather weak minded one since he could be turned so quickly from his intention of taking the hobbits to Denethor. How this is indicative of "free will" frankly boggles the mind! Jackson's explanation of his "vision" of Faramir only continues to prove my belief that the man has a real problem with nobility of character and is really only happy when bringing darkness to the screen. No wonder his orcs are so good!
 
I can't explain it, and I don't think anyone can. I have decided instead to think of this whole thing another way instead of getting all bogged down in details and character assassinations. See, I consider the human being to be a complex thinking animal with many differing opinions and perspectives. Often when two people read, see, smell, or hear the exact same thing they come to two different conclusions. I have decided (especially after reading Mrs. M's well thought out and valid arguments) that I am no longer watching J.R.R. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings. I also know for a fact (despite being disparaged on this very site for it) that Peter Jackson, and New Line were under no obligation to show us J.R.R. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings.

Even this discussion board makes it pretty obvious:

"Tolkien's 'LOTR' versus Peter Jackson's 'LOTR' "

Certainly that title implies some tension and difference.

Once all that is established then I have to decide a couple of things:

1. What exactly am I seeing?
2. How does it relate to the books I know and love?

I have decided that I am not even watching the books. I know the story, and I know the flow, and I know some (perhaps all) of the Themes. I have decided that what I am watching is someone else's telling of the same mythology. Tolkien did say that he wanted to create a mythology. So I have decided that this version of the story that we are seeing on film is someone else's version. The story will be different in many ways, and the way the characters are portrayed will be different. I don't think there can be any question that some people think I'm a great guy, and some people think very low of me. Thus, I can consider someone seeing Tolkien's characters differently than Tolkien, or a Tolkienologist would see them. This is what I have decided I am seeing.

By doing this I do not rob myself of what I love about the books (the better version by far), I also don't rob myself of enjoying the films either. It's not a better story, it's not a bad story, it's just a different one.
 
Yes, all that you say is true. These films are in fact Jackson's version of Tolkien's story. You say that you are able to enjoy them in that way and that is fine. But what if Jackson's "version" is such that all the things you loved about the story (and, let's face it, I don't know many people who "love" the book simply for the plot line) has been changed; the heroes made weak or cowards or bullies or even villains. Are you still "enjoying" the story? If King Arthur were Mordred or Merlin were Morgan LeFey or dashing Sinbad a fat merchant or Hercules a dork or Tarzan a bureaucrat in a suit and tie, do you mean to tell me that you would find no difference in all of these legendary stories if their heroes were portrayed as suggested? If you are able to do so, then more power to you. I, for one, could not and that is why I cannot simply "translate" Tolkien into Jackson.

When Jackson stood alone as in FOTR, I was able (for a time) to forget Tolkien. But as the man continued his destruction of the people in the story, I have become less and less able to make that distinction if for no other reason than that Jackson's character no longer interest me. If I want to encounter such dark and depressing folk, I'll go read Bram Stoker or watch some Steven King film where there are few if any heroes, but lots and lots of villains and monsters. Perhaps Jackson's desire to appear in cameo roles in his films is a mirror of King's desire to also appear in his. Sometimes I think that if we were to see Jackson when he goes home at night and undresses for bed, we would discover that he is really Steven King in disguise!
 
It's Stephen King. :) (I was and still am a huge fan)

I think the difference between you and I in this instance is that you are a studied scholar of Tolkien where I am not. I have read the books a couple of times, but that certainly is not enough to dissect them as you have. I am reading The Silmarillion now, and all the other Tolkien books when I have time (not so much now because of going back to school to finish my degree.) I perhaps would have the same problem as you if something I loved so much had been butchered in the manner that you perceive Jackson's Lord of the Rings to be. Alas, I am bliss in my ignorance. That is why I never, and would never discredit your arguments. It isn't my place to do so. If anything I desire you and joxy to enjoy the films at least a little, as I am able to enjoy them because this is the only opportunity to see Tolkien's world come to life beyond our imaginations. The scenery is stunning, the costumes beautiful, the actors (and actresses) that were chosen are perfect. Unfortunately the execution is less than desirable.
 
Really, the thing that grieves me most in this whole thing is all that you have said. If Jackson's presentation were lousy, well so what! Or if, given all that he has done to make it right, he had had just a little more faith in his source and done with Aragorn and the rest what he did with Gandalf, Galadriel, Sam, Bilbo and even Boromir and Gollum (that is, got the characters down very well if not perfectly), then it would have been a masterpiece for all time! But the fact is that he came so close at so many points - only to lose courage and try to pander to what he supposed was an audience unable to understand or appreciate Tolkien, and audience who needed anti-heroes, warrior princesses, conflicted and troubled "heroes" etc. THIS is what drives me absolutely crazy! To have come so close only to blow it in the end..... Aaaarrrrgggghhhhhhhhhhhh
 
Originally posted by aragil
If you would like, I could tell you why I don't think the things you listed comprise the major Themes of the work.

Look... I don't mean that the things I listed comprised the major themes of LotR. My point was that messing with that stuff would compromise the major themes!


Tolkiens Theme's are developed and expressed through the following mediums: setting, action, dialog, and character. That's the tools with which he communicates his themes.

PJ scores 85% on setting... 72% on action... 22% on dialog... and 2% on character.

If you fail on the latter two, then there is NO WAY that you can communicate Tolkien's thematic material!!!!
 
Last edited:
Eventually, we have to get back to what themes Jackson was trying to convey in the films - or was he so "wrapped around the axle" with the visuals that he thought that would take care of itself as the plot unfolded! Of course, the main theme is the destruction of the Ring and the victory of "the good guys". The problem is that Jackson has so compromised "the good guys" that he has made them precious little different from "the bad guys". Indeed, in some instances, the bad guys are at least more consistent while the good guys spend all their time waffling about! One might actually find Saruman "strong" (if "wrong") and apparently he serves his Master (Sauron) "wholeheartedly" which is more than can be said for the bickering folks at Elrond's Council.

Furthermore, there is a sort of perverted "affection" between Saruman and his Urak-hai which seems not to appear anywhere on the "other side". Jackson doesn't bother to create that feeling in Rohan (indeed, both Eomer and Grima are sent packing with no sign of either affection or loyalty on the part of any of those involved!). In fact, there is a much greater consistency among the baddies - and a much greater feeling of mutual cooperation which is exactly the opposite of Tolkien's portrayal if one remembers the bit with the two orcs tracking Frodo and Sam in Mordor - than there is among the "free folk". In short, whatever "theme" Jackson wished to promote (if any), he has certainly not conveyed Tolkien's.
 
I think we know what Peter was trying to do. He was trying to be all things to all people. He didn't try to make J.R.R. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings. He instead tried to make a modern action picture without having to come up with an original screenplay.

1. Appeal to women with a tormented love story.
2. Appeal to kids with Gimli humor, skateboards, and Orc Olympic Torch carriers.
3. Appeal to purists with striking visuals, and tremendous casting.
4. Appeal to action movie goers with extra action, an anti-hero, and "Who needs nobility?" (I think Mrs M is right on here).
5. Appeal to non-Tolkien readers with a simple straight forward story where the ring is always evil and always lusted by humans.

I suppose there is more.

Fact is when trying to be all things to all people you come up short on allot of things and end up not taking a chance that your audience is smart enough for the real thing.
 
I think PJ has come against the age-old dilemma, how to please everyone? and the answer is, you can't possibly please everyone. By making a movie directed to the general audience, he has alienated Tolkien fans, but on the other hand, had he made a movie pleasing to us, he would have alienated the common public, and that would mean no revenue thus the production company and the studio would have lost millions.

I personally think that the movies are entertaining as they are, by no means letterperfect comapred to the books, but I think it's got mostly best of both
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top