What's new
By:
Filters
  • Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Saruman or 🧙Gandalf the White

Who would win a duel??

  • Gandalf the White

    Votes: 35 97.2%

  • Saruman

    Votes: 1 2.8%

  • It would be a draw

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    36
I meant after he was resurrected. Sorry for any trouble.:)
 
Lol Beorn, I think it's implied that as Gandalf is the White it might be after his resurrection. ;)

Gandalf obviously; well, I say obviously because of what Gandalf himself says, with some authority: something like "No weapon can indeed harm me." And his willpower is shown when he cracks Saruman's staff.
*crack*
;)
 
Gandalf of course!
He defeats Sauraman, and that is that! Why do you ask questions you already know?
But I, King of the Nine, Lord of Morgul, Ruler of the powerful Nazgul, Nay, not even five wizards at once could slay me! Psh... but a foolish hobbit and a handmaiden can! Curse Eowyn and her halfling friend!
 
Gandalf (as The White) would all to easily defeat Sauruman, as is evidenced when he does. You don't really need to ask "Who would win?", when you can clearly read who did. ;)
 
Yes Gandalf the White would definitely win against Saruman after Saruman had turned evil, but here's a better question perhaps: Would Gandalf the White be able to beat Saruman the White before Saruman had even begun to turn to evil? like if Gandalf was the White when Saruman first came to Middle-Earth.
 
Originally posted by Glorfindel1187
Would Gandalf the White be able to beat Saruman the White before Saruman had even begun to turn to evil? like if Gandalf was the White when Saruman first came to Middle-Earth.
Click to expand...
]
Very intersting question but who knows the answer?I think Gandalf would win.He didn't show his power at the beginning.Just remember that he sad he is not good enough to go in ME when the Istari were sent to ME.He was a humble Maia:D :D
 
Originally posted by Glorfindel1187
Yes Gandalf the White would definitely win against Saruman after Saruman had turned evil, but here's a better question perhaps: Would Gandalf the White be able to beat Saruman the White before Saruman had even begun to turn to evil? like if Gandalf was the White when Saruman first came to Middle-Earth.
Click to expand...

On this one, I would have to vote a draw. In regards to the first question, Gandalf, without a second thought.
 
It'd be Gandalf because Saruman had strayed from good. When you are evil you don't have access to the same, broad range of power. At least that's how I think it goes in these things...
 
Originally posted by Éomond
Gandalf definitly. In the book (TTT) Gandalf is kickin' Saruman's butt, and that was only with words:)
Click to expand...

Of course Gandalf kicked his butt with only words. Magic is only words.
And I would say that, they would both be defeated, if Saruman was still pure in heart... No-one can know for sure...
 
Gandalf Vs. Sauron

Ok this is an easy one...GANDALF...no contest, I don't believe Gandalf the White can be defeated, especially not by Sauron.
Apparently you can see I am a bit partial to Gandalf, So I guess my opinion really can't be counted on....O bother...


-Gandalf-
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

Similar threads

Ent
Why is 🧙Gandalf The White indistinguishable from Gandalf the Grey?
    • Like
    • Pondering
Replies
11
Views
4K
Ricardo
R
Backyard Professor
The Color of 🧙Gandalf: Another Look
    • Like
Replies
0
Views
754
Backyard Professor
Backyard Professor
Ent
Why 13? And Why 🧙Gandalf?
    • Like
Replies
11
Views
819
Ent
Ent
Backyard Professor
The Real Shaman of Middle Earth
    • Like
    • Pondering
Replies
2
Views
1K
Klaatu
Klaatu
D
  • Question
Help translating a qoute to Tengwar
    • Like
Replies
1
Views
347
BlueJay of Mordor
B

Today's events

Latest posts

Similar threads

Search Wiki

Share this page

Most viewed threads of 2026

Back
Top