• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

gandalf

  1. How do 👁️Sauron and 🧙Gandalf serve Tolkien's themes and messages?

    Huorn is very interested in your perspectives on what Sauron and Gandalf actually represent to Tolkien, and to his work(s). Huron says no more at this time...just wanting your thinking. (If you have any questions or need any clarification do ask.)
  2. G

    Why Bilbo?

    This has probably been brought up before, but I have not been here long. Anyway, why did Gandalf choose Bilbo to accompany the dwarves on their quest? Did Gandalf even know Bilbo? (I think he knew one of Bilbo's relatives). but why Bilbo?
  3. R

    🧙Gandalf, Great Rings, and counting...?

    Sunday afternoon thought... Gandalf explicitly says that he knew that Bilbo's ring was a 'Great Ring' from the beginning, but didn't know that it was the One ring - so the question is either could Gandalf not count, because 19 of the 20 were acounted for, or was the number of 'Great Rings'...
  4. B

    Why didn't 🧙Gandalf make a Ring?

    I don't mean a Ring to control people like Sauron made (and which may have been the sort that Saruman had made as well), but one more like the Elven Rings, only this time not tied to the One Ring. Gandalf wouldn't have wanted a controlling Ring anyway, but a sort of protection Ring like...
  5. Exploring the meaning behind 🧙Gandalf's words on tears

    Does it mean if you cry just for sake of being sad, then its bad?. Like i made a joke that people who grew up in the 1970s had to make emo movement in 1990s because maybe Mary Poppins 1964 movie was too jolly and whimsical for them, so they made depression culture a thing on purpose. But like...
  6. B

    Why didn't 🧙Gandalf just pretend to join Saruman?

    Why did Gandalf have to outright tell Saruman that he wouldn't join him? Why didn't he play along, "agreeing" with Saruman so that he'd be free to leave Isengard, perhaps feigning to go fetch the Ring for Saruman, and then go find Frodo or warn someone of Saruman's treachery?
  7. B

    How come 🧙Gandalf could escape Dol Guldor on his own but not Isengard

    I know that he got out of Isengard in the end, but that was because of Radaghast sending the eagle and Saruman's plan backfiring. Gandalf outright admits that he couldn't have gotten out on his own. However, in the Hobbit, Gandalf went into Dol Guldor, where Sauron himself was lurking as the...
  8. J

    How did Gollum obtain the Great Ring according to the text?

    Hello! So I stumbled upon something! This quote: "I wondered often how Gollum came by a Great Ring, as plainly it was - that at least was clear from the beginning." Now later in that chapter Gandalf says that fate of Seven and Nine is known. So given that, he should have guessed it is The One...
  9. L

    🧙Gandalf v. Pippin: a Law Student's Analysis

    Gandalf v. Pippin Prompt The estate of Gandalf sued Peregrin Took in Rivendell Court for negligence following an incident in Moria. The Fellowship of the Ring was in a tomb in the mines of Moria, which was known to be overrun by vicious orcs. Gandalf, the leader of the Fellowship, was busy...
  10. B

    Why did 🧙Gandalf tell Frodo to go to Rivendale instead of Rohan?

    I see that Gandalf recommended that he go to Rivendale, but that seems out of the way if he wants to ultimately go to Mordor. The much quicker route, and, it would seem, as far as Gandalf knew, safer route, would have been to go toward Longbottom and the Gap of Rohan and ultimately cross the...
  11. 🧙Gandalf vs Balrog my first painting

  12. Black is mightier still?

    "I am Gandalf, Gandalf the White, but Black is mightier still.'"? What did he mean by this? Is he implying that Sauron is stronger?
  13. D

    🧙Gandalf VS 👁️Sauron at Amon Hen

    On the first few readings of LOTR, I completely missed this duel. It was when Frodo is on Amon Hen hill, wearing a ring, and had a duel inside: Later, Gandalf told Aragorn, Gimli and Legolas about this duel: So, I think, we can pretty safely assume that person talking "Take it of Fool"...
  14. My Tolkien-character looks like ....

    I've read the books before I watched the adaptions by Bakshi and Peter Jackson. These people here come close to my idea of how the characters would look like. Gandalf (the Nessie-researcher Adrian Shine)
  15. How is 🧙Gandalf serving as a Steward?

    In what way, and for whom, is Gandalf serving as a Steward? (Tolkien, J.R.R.. The Lord of the Rings: One Volume (p. 758). HMH Books. Kindle Edition. Gandalf speaking to Denethor II.) Given all we know about Stewards, and that Gandalf is playing directly off Denethor II's comment that he was...
  16. What prompted 🧙Gandalf to seek an audience with Tom Bombadil?

    In chapter 7 ("Homeward Bound") of book 6 in the RoTK we read (Gandalf speaking to the four hobbits): ‘But if you would know, I am turning aside soon. I am going to have a long talk with Bombadil: such a talk as I have not had in all my time. He is a moss-gatherer, and I have been a stone...
  17. Gomez Addams, 🧙Gandalf?

    https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.gamespot.com/amp-articles/lord-of-the-rings-another-actor-john-astin-reveals-he-auditioned-for-gandalf/1100-6503384/
  18. P

    In Fellowship of the Ring, did only 🧙Gandalf recognize the balrog?

    When Gandalf realized they're being trailed by a belrog, was he the only one that knew what a balrog is? In the movie, Legalos seemed to react to Gandalf's proclamation with a slightly knowing look, but maybe I'm just over-reading him. As old as Legolas was, the belrogs preceded him by thousands...
  19. Why were 🧙Gandalf and Aragorn so afraid of Moria?

    We know that after the events of The Hobbit, Balin and a company of dwarves took back Moria and most likely it was well known, at least for a time. I'm sure considering that Aragorn hunted all the way south for Gollum, that he must have been aware of it. However, when the Fellowship was...
  20. J

    Did 🧙Gandalf receive a telepathic message from Manwe?

    How did Gandalf the white know when he could return to the undying lands? did he get a telepathic message from Manwe? Also how did Galadriel know that she had got a pardon from the Valar before she returned to the undying lands?
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…