Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.
Register
Why did Gandalf Not Tell Aragorn, Legolas And Gimli That It Was Eru Who Sent him Back Instead Of Only Saying And I quote " I Have Been Sent Back Until My Task is done" Was He forbidden From Saying That It is Eru who Sent him Back? If yes Why? If Not Why? Also When Gandalf Died Did He go First to...
Mainly because the way i got the impression from reading the Lord of the Rings. Is Gandalf is pretty strict, and Christopher Lee does have that vibe to him. While Saruman is mainly arrogant (Dont know how else to describe him of how i get the imagination from the books)
Hey, I wasn't sure where to write this.
But don't you think the battle between Gandalf and the Balrog should have been sounded by "Carl Orff - Carmina Burana"?
In fact, I had remembered it this way and was very surprised to re-watch the movie and to find out I had been ... fooled ! :D
In the book, the Moria chapters are probably my favorite in the entire book. Among other reasons, it's nice to see the whole Fellowship together in action and, as a consequence, it's sad to have to see them break up. This is also one sequence that didn't really need to be changed much at all...
Would you guys have liked to see Gandalfs journey to confront the Necromancer, then finding Thrain II?
I know Tolkien had no concrete plans for LOTR (and consequently the change that the Necromancer is secretly Sauron), but in hind sight would that have been an enjoyable chapter or two? Or...
I'm quite a big LOTR fan but one of the things I don't understand is why Galadriel (an Elf) is more powerful than Gandalf (a Maia).
Also I don't understand why Elrond, Galadriel and Glorfindel (the high Elves) didn't join the fellowship when they could have made it way easier.
This is a hypothetical I've been wondering about, but I couldn't find a discussion of it anywhere online (partly because it's a hard one to know how to search). It might technically be a question for The Hobbit forum, but it relates more to the plot of LOTR in my opinion.
Let's say that during...
In the book or movie (maybe both, I don't remember), when Gandalf escapes Saruman on the back of an eagle, it's said that he became 'as light as a feather'. This is probably because he faded his physical form and went nearly into pure spirit to help the eagle carry him. But why didn't he do this...
Why theoden said "You have no power here". Why not Gandalf has power there? Is it just a randomly said bossy sentence or not?
In fact It was not told randomly. Yes Theoden was wick. And his mind was poisened by Saruman. But Why Saruman thinks Gandalf the grey does not have any power there...
did gandalf join the fellowship of the ring just because of The durins Bane balrog and the need to protect frodo and the rest of the fellowship from it? or did he join out of an honest desire to help? also how is it that only gandalf from the entire fellowship could destroy durins bane?
if gandalf took the one ring what would have occurred as a result of that? And if saruaman clamed the one ring what would have been the result of that?
If Gandalf was asked about his origins and what kind of being he is and from where he comes by the hobbits or by men would he have revealed openly these things? Also When Gandalf said "I have been sent back until my task is done" if aragorn legolas or gimli had asked him who had sent him back...
I'm probably even bigger a Harry Potter nerd than I am a Tokien nerd (that basically means between the two fandoms and Star Trek, I have absolutely no life) and in the course of this evening I was perusing the Harry Potter fanfiction sites and I stumbled on this story which features Gandalf the...
Hello guys,
firstly I would like to apologise for starting a new thread as there are hundreds of them regarding that particular topic. I am sorry.
Secondly, being just a fan of the Tolkiens work and no expert about the languages created by him, I kindly ask for your help.
Recently the dog I...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.