Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.
Register
When Bilbo disappears right after his long-expected party, and Gandalf's suspicion is roused, he goes off to find out some more... and does. Took him seventeen years to be certain. Well, he had a lot to do, of course. But when he speaks to Frodo in Bag End he says he knew right from the get-go...
"I think it is a sad story," said the wizard, "and it might have happened to others, even some hobbits that I have known." - Gandalf in The Shadow of the Past.
At first glance, Gollum seems prone to evil in that he seems to fall under the Ring's sway pretty quickly and be led to commit murder...
Pippin threw a stone into a hole, and it alerted the orcs down there.
If he hadn't done that,
Orcs wouldn't have come. ..
No balrog attack. ....
Gandalf wouldn't have died.
Seven was enough for the Brothers Grimm and they knew how to tell a tale or two.
Having just finished reading The Hobbit it occurred that not all the dwarfs have fully fleshed out characters and it can be difficult to remember who is who. Do we know why Tolkien chose thirteen?
In Two Towers, “King of the Golden Hall”, Théoden greets Gandalf gruffly, calling him “Stormcrow”:
Wormtongue then adds his derision, insulting Galadriel almost as an afterthought, calling her “the Sorceress of the Golden Wood,” saying that “webs of deceit were ever woven in Dwimordene.”...
How Powerful was Gandalf the Grey?
When I think of Gandalf I think of both Gandalf the Grey and Gandalf the White. But really Gandalf the Grey died, and was given extra power and wisdom by Eru and remade into a new far more powerful Gandalf, Gandalf the White. So thinking of just Gandalf the...
I believe a mistake was made by Christopher Tolkien. I always thought Gandalf a maiar from reading the sillmarillion as Olorin was a Maiar. However, of course , our sillmarillion was not published by J.R.R Tolkien but Christopher and I believe Tolkien left us with the idea of two separate...
Was inspired by a PM I am having:
What would his regime be like after he would eventually turn to evil, if he indeed had taken the Ring when it was offered by Frodo?
Speculate to your Hearts' content!
CL
*Thanks Squint!
Gandalf appears to have died and been born as something else, for he seems to have trouble even recalling what went on earlier or even the name "Gandalf".
Saruman definitely dies as well
I think the Balrog was said to have died as well.
Sauron, even when his Ring was destroyed, was just...
Mr Gandalf: Why is it that you seem surprised on encountering the Balrog in Moria? I would have thought that this creature would have been foremost on your mind before you first stepped through the West-Gate.
Here is what you said to Aragorn outside the Chamber of Mazarbul:
"Then something...
Since Gandalf is a Mair, he's in the second plane, so to speak. Since the "invisibility" of the Ring leads one to the second plane, could, say, Gandalf have seen Bilbo coming in the Hobbit after losing him in the goblin tunnels? (Gandalf acted as surprised as the others, but even in the...
In "Shadow of the Past", Gandalf says that he it was "clear from the first" that Gollum had a Great Ring. And Gandalf says that he KNOWS that a Great Ring is perilous to a mortal.
So, even if he wasn't sure if it was the One Ring, he HAD to have known that it was hazardous to poor old Bilbo...
Gandalf: I was delayed and that nearly proved our ruin. But I don't know, it may have been better so.
How was Saruman delaying him a GOOD thing? What could have gone wrong had Gandalf actually been with them the whole time? The only thing I can think of is that the Nazgul may have had...
Hey guys,
Thought you might enjoy this comedy short I made called "Gandalf's Always Late"! Would love to hear what you think, as a fellow LOTR-obsessive, haha.
LINK:
Thanks!
Gandalf sounded like he suspected that something was amiss about the Ring even when he discovered its existence during the timeline of the Hobbit. It seems odd that he NEVER consulted Saruman, Radaghast, or the Blue Wizards about it. It's not like Gandalf told NOBODY about it either, as I...
Hi!
I want to get a tattoo of Gandalf's quote 'All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us' in elvish font. I keep finding different versions of it, and I'm wondering which one is accurate! Here are some images I have found: if someone can tell me which one is accurate...
Supposing that Mairon HAD repented after Melkor's defeat and that Olorin had, wanting to try prevent the reign of someone like Melkor, come to Middle Earth, at first with good intentions, but eventually bringing in a "tyranny of good" where he tried to make the world right according to his...
Yep, this is fully confirmed:
IAN MCKELLEN would love to reprise Gandalf in Middle-Earth series.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/on-demand/2017/12/18/ian-mckellen-would-love-play-gandalf-amazons-lord-rings-tv-series/
What say thee?
Edit: A Further Spin-Off Series is Considered?? This show isn't...
so I'm saying this off my mind, forgive if I make a mistake.
So Gandalf suspects that Bilbo has a ring, a ring that makes him invisible. That right there should be enough to question bilbos (he finds out during the hobbit). And then again he sees Bilbo invisible again at his 111th birthday. He...