• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

reviews

  1. S

    LOTR Exhibition: Sarah's review

    Complete and Total awesomeness! I loved it. I live in the boston area, so I got to get in (today only) for a grand total of $5! They had awesome props and costumes from the movie! There was a part where we could sit in gandalf's cart and be hobbit size or wizard size. I got a pic of me...
  2. Ol'gaffer

    Film reviews and recommendations

    Seen a film lately that you liked, love or loathed? Recommend it here and give it even a shot to review it if you like. I'll start, last night I watched Michael Moores Fahrenheit 9/11 FAHRENHEIT 9/11 Michael Moore is a name that is on everyones lips these days, the one American who...
  3. Turin

    Hobbit 📔Book Review Help

    I have to do a book review on the Hobbit(my book of choice) can anyone help me out? Here are the requirements: Write on the book that you selected earlier this quarter. Background: The editor accepting reviews that grab the reader’s attention with an interesting opening, and then proceed...
  4. David Pence

    Scholarly Review of Tolkien versus Jackson

    The Intercollegiate Studies Institute, a fifty year old educational organization, has published a review of Peter Jackson's movie trilogy of Tolkien's "The Lord of the Rings." It's a three-part series beginning this week. The reviewer, Dr. Bradley J. Birzer, is the author of...
  5. N

    Thread review

    I miss the thread review! In the old VB when you made a new post you could see the posts that other people had made, which was really helpful. Can I set this option somewhere, or is it definitely gone?
  6. G

    Goro's Review (Spoilers)

    Not as bad as I expected. I enjoyed it even though I exclaimed "NOOO!" several times. (Sorry you who sat next to me...) Good: Everyone bows for the hobbits. Not quite what happened in the books, but it gets the point accross. Merry and Pippin are more heroic. Again, not always...
  7. Thorin

    RoTK: A Purist's Review

    Well....Let's see. Let me say that as far as a movie and an adaptation, this movie was the best out of all three and a good movie...*crickets chirp as we hear the clunk of dumbfounded FADs' jaws hitting the floor* This movie had the depth and emotion the other two movies were missing...best of...
  8. N

    The Return of the King Reviews Thread

    ROTK review!!! Am I actually the first to post a review of ROTK here (except those lucky guys who got to see it first)? Well here goes: It was great!!! Why? For lots of reasons: -it stuck closer to the book than the other two movies; at least in the second part, the first part had many...
  9. Legolam

    BBC reviews ROTK

    Here's a link for a no-spoilers review for ROTK, plus lots of interviews with cast members and all the usual fun stuff: http://www.bbc.co.uk/films/lordoftherings/
  10. S

    FFC REVIEW

    Quote Walter Chaw ------ That moments are grand is no question, but the final instalment of Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings trilogy isn't about stories and individuals so much as it's about resolutions. The characters have ceased to evolve in any meaningful way and no significant time...
  11. Thorin

    TTT EE: A Purist's Review

    Well, unfortunately the EE of TTT didn't do what I expected for the theatre version like the FoTR EE did. As joxy pointed out, there are good points and bad points. Like I thought would happen, the amount of footage thrown in can't change the impact of the mess done to the characters and plot...
  12. A

    TTT DVD SE review!!

    Good review, can't wait to pick mine up!! Digital Bits Review: "MY TWO CENTS - 10/28/03 - by Digital Bits editor Bill Hunt Yes... it's true. Matt and I yesterday attended an all-day, marathon screening of New Line's forthcoming The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers - Special Extended...
  13. M

    Film Review: _The Two Towers_

    Film Review: _The Two Towers_ [from December 2002] O.K.: Like _Fellowship of the Ring_, _The Two Towers_ is a breathtakingly marvelous film. The actors are well- cast, their acting is excellent, the scenery is both exquisite and appropriate, and the integration of special effects/...
  14. M

    Film Review: _Fellowship of the Ring_

    Film Review: _Fellowship of the Ring_ [from December 2001] There are three groups of people who will be seeing _The Lord of the Rings_ films: (1) Those, mostly post-Boomers, who haven't read The Trilogy; (2) those, mostly Boomers, who have read The Trilogy and possibly _The Hobbit_, but...
  15. B

    ROTK trailer review.

    I loved the trailer! I can't find anything wrong with it except the Sword reforging scene that was redundant in my opinion. I also like the settings and specially liked the soundtrack. Guess I can't find much fault it...:cool:
  16. Wolfshead

    TheOneRing.Net TTT DVD Review

    I know there's another review from aintitcool already posted, but this is the first one from TheOneRing.Net, and they even sent it out in an email newsletter all by itself :rolleyes: http://www.theonering.net/perl/newsview/2/1060738407
  17. GuardianRanger

    10-minute preview of ROTK reviewed on TORN

    I saw this morning that the 10-minute preview of Return Of The King that is included with the theatrical release has been reviewed. You can find it here. Beware, SPOILERS.
  18. L

    First ever review of TTT:EE!! *MAJOR SPOILERS*

    I've editted out the swear words in this report, by the way, so that's why there's the occasional "XXX". http://www.aintitcool.com/display.cgi?id=15741 THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE TWO TOWERS – EXTENDED EDITION Johnny Bartlett here, taking a break from the 9 to 5 (got me a total of...
  19. FoolOfATook

    Would you be interested in a 📔book review section?

    One of the ideas that I'm becoming increasingly keen on is that I might write a regular piece in the Herald, reviewing books written about J.R.R. Tolkien and his works. I'd focus on new books that come out, but write about older books during periods when no new books of interest are published...
  20. Thorin

    TTT: A Purist's Review

    Okay. Saw it last night with five of my students. Let's just say that I was more disappointed with FoTR then with TTT and it wasn't as bad as most of you were making it out to be. That doesn't mean that there wasn't alot of major flaws that irked me, however. BIGGEST PROBLEMS 1) Faramir...
Back
Top