• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

reviews

  1. Thorin

    Roger Ebert's TTT Review

    Just looked at Ebert's review of TTT....Purist's be justified. Just a few quotes here for the FADs... Hmmm...Hobbits losing their significance? "Spirit" of Tolkien being lost? (That's gotta hurt from a professional movie goer for all those FADs using the whole "spirit" argument)..Lost the...
  2. G

    Just based on the preview...

    1) There are no men in Saruman's army. 2) Saruman seems more under Sauron's thrall-- his personal scheming looks gone. 3) A hobbit is running in fear from an Ent? :confused: 4) The elves (including Elrond) are leaving ME in disgust.... And Elrond seems to be playing a major wet...
  3. F

    Was there a TROTK preview at the end of TTT?

    I just saw TTT & really liked it. Unfortunately, I did not have the courage of staying until the credits were over. I am wondering if there is a TROTK preview at the end of TTT credits (like the preview of TTT at the end of TFOTR credits [when it was in theaters last year]) I need sleep...
  4. T

    The Two Towers Reviews

    In an attempt to save space and help consolidate some of the inevitable discussion, I am starting this thread as a place for members to post thier thoughts and reviews on the film The Two Towers. This will serve two purposes: 1) To serve as a future reference for new members interested in...
  5. T

    TTT Reviews

    I thought we might get one thread where we can post all the reviews we can find for TTT. I'm talking specifically of pre-release reviews. Here are the ones I've found so far: AICN fan-reviews: http://www.aintitcoolnews.com/display.cgi?id=13950...
  6. U

    Two Towers Movie Review - Spoilers!

    * Major Spoilers in Link! * Two Towers Review * Extreme Spoilers * In the end, Frodo, Sam, & Gollum are taken to Gondor where Orcs are already attacking the city. In the aforementioned change of heart that Faramir has, he releases Frodo, Sam, & Gollum back into the wild to...
  7. Thorin

    DVD EE: A Purist's Review (you'll be surprised)

    Well.... Maybe I'm getting soft. Maybe all the discussion over the movie has desensitized. Maybe because I've seen it and know what to expect, it rolled off my back. Maybe I could watch it and appreciate it for a movie rather than an adaptation (AAAAAAAAUUUGH! I sound like Talimon!!). Maybe...
  8. GoldenWood

    New York Times LOTR review

    Very interesting quote (and a lot more to complain about!) from a reviewer of LOTR- FOTR: "Mr. Jackson apparently feels that the way to keep each of the fighting groups separate in the audience's minds is to provide them with hairstyles reminiscent of 1970's bands. The hobbits all have heads...
  9. T

    Extended DVD reviews pouring in

    To be quite honest with you, I am at the moment more excited about the Extended FotR DVD then TTT. Something about all these added scenes feels so right. If you don't care about spoilers then go right ahed to the warofthering.net review, shown here. Note that this review leaves out some scenes...
  10. T

    After Further Review......

    A couple of disclaimers before I get to the meat of things: 1) When I first saw the movie on 12/19, I came away from the theater dizzy - mostly from trying to balance what was different from the book & movie. 2) I went again maybe a week later (I waited that long to get my legs under me...
  11. S

    This review website obviously did no research

    This review website obviously did no research... This review website obviously did no research for their review of the movie. http://www.capalert.com/capreports/lordofrings_fellowship.htm#footnote%202
  12. Sam_Gamgee

    Ttt Preview

    this is really bad quality but its TTT preview none theless for those of you who haven't seen it yet or can't because it stopped playing where you live http://lightsout.bla-bla.com/random/twotowers_full.mov
  13. Thorin

    A Purist's Review: Yes I've finally seen it! All welcome!

    Okay, first off let me say that it was an okay movie. Some of the things that I was worried about did not bother me so much. Others that I didn't have an issue with truly peeved me. Here goes! Characters in General: Though it is difficult to establish deep character development to the...
Back
Top