• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Analyzing outcomes: The Doom of Mandos or The Curse of Morgoth?

If I understand you (Gothmog and Alcuin) correctly, you would mean that the sufferings of the noldor is a "natural" consequence of the deeds of Feanor (i.e. the valar did nothing to worsen the situation of the exiled and that they only unveil the course of future events). I don't see any evidence of this; is there any law given by Eru or other authority which states that deeds similar to those of Feanor lead to consequences similar to those stated in this Doom? The only link given between the evil causes and the afterwards suffering is the curse of Mandos, which is something "active":
Of the return of the noldor said:
Thus because of the curse that lay upon them the Noldor achieved nothing, while Morgoth hesitated, and the dread of light was new and strong upon the Orcs
Just as a vala power can be at work in a blessing (such as Varda blessing the silmarils, or the blessing of Earendil's ship) so too is the power of the valar at work in punishing the noldor
I don't think that reffering to Celebrimbor helps your case very much, as: Celebrimbor repudiated the deeds of his father, knowing that evil followed the oath-takers; after the war of wrath, "the curse was laid to rest"("Of the voyage of Earendil and the war of wrath"); the power rings have nothing to do with "the very treasures that they [the oath-takers] have sworn to pursue".
 
The Valar did not sew the seeds of distrust and betrayal amongst the Noldor. The murder of the Teleri at Alqualondë and the desertion of the followers of Fingolfin at the Helcaraxë did that. In fact, the only part of the Doom of Mandos that operated here was foretelling.

Of the Return of the Noldor said:
Thus because of the curse that lay upon them the Noldor achieved nothing, while Morgoth hesitated, and the dread of light was new and strong upon the Orcs
You ignored the passage immediately preceding this one:
In context, it reads a little differently. Perhaps I am mistaken, but that does not sound like a magic curse to me: it sounds like the inevitable outcome of treachery that old friends and kinsfolk would not trust one another.

Are we to believe that treason and the fear of treason was the work of the Valar? Was it the result of some fiendish curse invoked upon the Noldor by the wicked rulers of Valinor? Maybe it is, but it seems to me that fear of treason was the result of (1) what had actually happened to the Teleri and the followers of Fingolfin, both of whom were betrayed by the partisans who adhered to Fëanor, and (2) betrayal induced by Morgoth, who, as we all know, was actually working as an agent of Manwë’s nefarious plans to rule the world. (Bwa-ha-ha-ha!)

Ah, yes, Maeglin fell under the Curse of Mandos, who doomed him to love his mother’s niece. But you know, that rather sounds to me as if it reflects a decline in the moral and ethical fiber of the Noldor, like the way Celegorm and Curufin treated Lúthien and then attempted to murder Beren, so that Huan the Hound was compelled to rebel against Celegorm, his master, to defend them. Or the way in which Celegorm and Curufin betrayed Finrod, and sought to wrest control of Nargothrond from Orodreth. It would seem that what Maeglin did was worse yet in the eyes of the Noldor (judgmental lot, aren’t they?), and I think that this means that such “a thing strange and crooked in him” was the result not of the magic or malice of the Valar, but of the decline in their own moral fiber. Maybe I’m wrong.

Oops! Just did that one – that’s the betrayal of Finrod at Nargothrond again. But I am certain that someone can tell me how Námo Mandos is responsible for the reprehensible character of the brothers Celegorm and Curufin. Why, Oromë probably tempted Huan to turn against Celegorm in a dream! But maybe, just maybe, that curse was brought upon Celegorm and Curufin by their own actions, and upon the rest of the inhabitants of Nargothrond by their lack of moral courage in refusing to support Finrod.

The paragraph immediately following this reads,
Let us see, what flaws of character do we find here? (1) “Turgon was become proud," (2) “he trusted still in [Gondolin’s] … strength, though even a Vala should gainsay it,” (3) “the fear of treason was wakened in Turgon’s heart.” Why should the fear of treason be awakened in his heart? “the words that were spoken before the departing Noldor on the coast of Araman long ago”? or did those words remind him of Ulmo’s counsel: “‘the work of thy hands and the devices of thy heart; and remember that the true hope of the Noldor lieth in the West, and cometh from the Sea.’”I suspect it is the latter.

Your best argument, I believe, is here, if you can show that Mandos’ words to the Noldor were indeed a curse, and that this is the reason Turgon feared treachery, that for this cause Maeglin “turned to darkness in his heart” and betrayed the people of Gondolin, whom he should have defended with his body and life. But it seems to me that Turgon “rejected the bidding of Ulmo and refused his counsel,” and knew in his heart that by doing so, he risked experiencing the same bad outcome that the rest of the Noldor had suffered: betrayal of Elf against Elf, and treason and treachery within his own walls. At least grant me that Ulmo was not part of this supposed curse upon the Noldor by the Valar! But I cannot see that the Valar cursed Turgon at all: his own rebellion against Ulmo, who had led him to the Vale of Tumladen where Turgon’s people built Gondolin; and that of his twisted and morally defunct nephew, Maeglin, doomed him and his city.

The story of Celebrimbor does not help my case in the superficial sense. But consider this: Celebrimbor was living in Eregion because he rejected the rule of Gil-galad; when Gil-galad denied Sauron-Annatar admittance to Lindon, he gained acceptance in Ost-in-Edhil; and Sauron betrayed Celebrimbor. Was it because of some malediction pronounced by Mandos against the House of Fëanor that Sauron did these things? I argue that it was not: it was Sauron’s own wickedness and treachery. But I also argue that even this Mandos foresaw, not as a “curse” or malediction or overarching malice of the demiurgic powers of Arda: but as the unfortunate but inevitable outcome of wickedness, faithlessness, and a loss of moral character: for the forging of the Rings of Power was based upon a desire by the Eldar that remained in Middle-earth to have their cake and eat it, too: to live in the mortal lands, where they were superior merely by being Elves, without fading, without regret, without the grief of the passage of time. So Sauron the Necromancer ensnared them, and all their works came to naught.

Was all this the “curse of Mandos,” a malediction pronounced upon the Noldor by the Valar? Or was it rather the result of rebellion, of murder, of treachery, of greed, and of pride? And if rebellion, murder, treachery, greed, and pride are wicked among Men and lead to evil fortune, are they otherwise among the Eldar?
 
Having read the latest posts, I think that there might be a little misunderstanding. As Alcuin points out, there is no "curse" of Mandos. Just a "Doom." And at least in my opinion, there is a huge distinction between the one and the other.
 
I would like to know your opinion about this passage I previously reffered to:
All that I have seen so far is how the "curse of Mandos" (an expression which, in the Sil, is used as such in two occasions, and generrally reffered to as simply curse) has actually come into being; nothing contradicts the fact this term was rightfully used by Tolkien; let's look at some definitions of the term:
- an appeal to some supernatural power to inflict evil on someone or some group
- a prayer asking that a god or similar spirit bring misfortune to someone; an imprecation or execration, the opposite of a blessing or charm
- a calling on a god or spirit to visit trouble or evil upon a person
And this idea is futher reinforced in HoME X, Of the first kinslaying and the doom of the noldor:
 
However, as you so rightly point out a 'curse' is:
For such a thing to be from the Valar it must also include the will of Manwe. In the Sil. there is a comment about the High King of Arda
For Manwë was free from evil and could not comprehend it
So how could one who 'was free from evil' do evil knowingly? As is said in the quote Manwe could not comprehend evil, how much chance then that he could do it?
 
Then again, in Morgoth's Ring, Manwe is represented as being the closest to Eru of all minds, and, as said in Osanwe-kenta, Manwe, being ever open to Eru he did His will, and he was bound by the commands and injunctions of Eru, and would do this or abstain from that in accordance with them, always. So, I don't see a problem with his choice, if it was his, anyway.
 
So you are now saying that the 'Curse' came from the command of Eru?

I know that this is said of Manwe and is indeed the reason that he is High King of Arda. However, in all things, even in the case of Melkor and his release, Manwe would not do evil even to prevent evil. And it still stands that the only active parts of the 'curse of the Noldor' can be traced back directly and solely to the acts and words of Feanor and his sons. Either to the oath they swore or to the acts such as the Kinslaying (in which the followers of Feanor were the cause and main participants) or the burning of the ships leaving most of the Noldor with no transport to Middle-earth.
 
So you are now saying that the 'Curse' came from the command of Eru?
I wouldn't go as far as that; the least I will argue for is that Manwe's actions are in accordance with Eru's will/laws, and since Eru is the ultimate instance of good, I see don't see a moral problem here.
 
However, the Valar separated 'Good' and 'Evil' within Arda, something that Eru never did. We do not know what exactly Eru considered 'Good' and what he considered 'Evil' we can only be sure that his views on the matter were different from ours and from the views of the Valar.

In doing Eru's will, Manwe would act according to his own conception of what was 'Good' and what was 'Evil' not Eru's of which he was uncertain at best.
 
(Ahem – Alcuin clears his throat in case he is forced to eat crow, since Thorondor can cite a use of the word “curse” used in the narrative outside character quotations in conjunction with the Doom of Mandos. Not yet willing to concede… He makes a dreaded 2-part post: this is 1 of 2. )


Whether in the actions of Fëanor at the quays of Olwë, or his betrayal of his brother Fingolfin and the rest of the Noldor at Helcaraxë; in the actions of Celegorm and Curufin in assaulting Lúthien and then Beren, or in attempting to seize the throne of Nargothrond; or in Maeglin’s forbidden lust for Idril, and his subsequent betrayal of Gondolin; in the ruin of Doriath by the Sons of Fëanor, and the murder of the sons of Dior, Eluréd and Elurín, at “the hands of the cruel servants of Celegorm”; or the assault upon the camps of the Havens of Sirion by the Maedhros and Maglor, so that Elwing leaped as it were to her death in the sea bearing the Silmaril (she was saved by Ulmo, who intervened again, evil old Vala); or in the murder of the guards in the camp of Eönwë when Maedhros and Maglor took the Silmarils: all of these things were the work not of the Valar, but of the Noldor, so that they brought the greater part of their woes upon themselves, they dared not trust one another; and all their works came to nothing. They trusted themselves, and not to the will of Eru as revealed by the Valar; they rebelled, and they slaughtered one another and even the children of their own folk; they showed a shocking and horrific failure of morals and of character.

That is a real curse: but it is also a self-inflicted wound. It is not the Curse of Mandos. It is the Curse of the Noldor, and they did it to themselves.

The Curse of Morgoth is pretty clearly a malediction. Roget’s II: The New Thesaurus, Third Edition, 1995 defines "malediction" as "A denunciation invoking a wish or threat of evil or injury: anathema, curse, damnation, execration, imprecation. Archaic : malison."

The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language: Fourth Edition. 2000 offers this for maledict.
  • ADJECTIVE: Archaic Accursed.
  • TRANSITIVE VERB: Inflected forms: mal•e•dict•ed, mal•e•dict•ing, mal•e•dicts To pronounce a curse against.
  • ETYMOLOGY: Middle English maladicte, from Latin maledictus, past participle of maledcere, to curse : male, ill; see mel-3 in Appendix I + dcere, to speak; see deik- in Appendix I.
  • From Indo-European Roots,
ENTRY: mel-3
  • DEFINITION: False, bad, wrong. 1. mal-, malice, malign; dismal, malady, malaria, maledict, malefactor, malefic, malentendu, malevolence, malison, malversation, from Latin malus, bad, and male, ill (> malignus, harmful). 2. Perhaps suffixed zero-grade form *m-s-. blame, blaspheme, from Greek blasphmos, blasphemous, perhaps from *ms-bh-mo-, “speaking evil” (*bh-, to speak; see bh-2). 3. Suffixed form *mel-yo-. markhor, from Avestan mairiia-, treacherous. (Pokorny 2. mel- 719, mlo- 724.)
ENTRY: deik-
  • DEFINITION: To show, pronounce solemnly; also in derivatives referring to the directing of words or objects. Oldest form *dei-, becoming *deik- in centum languages.
  • Derivatives include teach, toe, addict, preach, judge, revenge, and disk.
  • I. Variant *deig-. 1. O-grade form *doig-. a. teach, from Old English tcan, to show, instruct, from Germanic *taikjan, to show; b. (i) token, from Old English tcen, tcn, sign, mark; (ii) betoken, from Old English tcnian, to signify; (iii) tetchy, from Gothic taikns, sign; (iv) tachisme, from Old French tache, teche, mark, stain. (i)–(iv) all from Germanic *taiknam. 2. Zero-grade form *dig-. digit, from Latin digitus, finger (< “pointer,” “indicator”).
  • II. Basic form *deik-. 1. Possibly o-grade form *doik-. toe, from Old English t, tahe, toe, from Germanic *taihw. 2. Basic form *deik-. dictate, diction, dictum, ditto, ditty; addict, benediction, condition, contradict, edict, fatidic, herb bennet, indict, indiction, indite, interdict, juridical, jurisdiction, maledict, malison, predict, valediction, verdict, veridical, voir dire, from Latin dcere, to say, tell. 3. Suffixed zero-grade form *dik--. abdicate, dedicate, preach, predicament, predicate, from Latin dicre, to proclaim. 4. Agential suffix *-dik-. a. index, indicate, from Latin index, indicator, forefinger (in-, toward; see en); b. judge, judicial; prejudice, from Latin idex (< *yewes-dik-), judge, “one who shows or pronounces the law” (is, law; see yewes-); c. vendetta, vindicate; avenge, revenge, from Latin vindex (first element obscure), surety, claimant, avenger. 5. deictic, deixis; apodictic, paradigm, policy2, from Greek deiknunai, to show, and noun deigma (*deik-m), sample, pattern. 6. Zero-grade form *dik-. disk; dictyosome, from suffixed form *dik-skos, from Greek dikein, to throw (< “to direct an object”). 7. Form *dik-. dicast; syndic, theodicy, from Greek dik, justice, right, court case. (Pokorny dei- 188.)
It was malediction: Morgoth spoke of bad things to come to Horn, his wife, and his innocent, helpless children. Loverly sentiments, eh?

Let us track the specifics of what Morgoth achieved. Morwen and the children were isolated, and through they were not immediately assaulted by the Easterlings, Morwen moved to get her children to safety, starting with Turin, whom she sent to Doriath.

Okay, bad outcomes can we attribute to Morgoth’s Malediction to mar Morwen’s minor master & maidens. Turin is welcomed by Thingol in memory of Beren, but hated by Saeros is – what? a jerk? a racist? under the influence of the black will of Morgoth? Maybe he’s just a first-class jerk with a phenomenally murderous temper who considered killing Turin and then who lost his footing when for his own revenge Turin set him to run naked through the forest. And Turn, believing he would find either no justice or harsh justice, fled. Sad. But maybe not designed.

Next he falls in with the outlaws, with the faithful Beleg in pursuit (with a curse sword, perhaps?) Turin and Beleg gather some outlaws and begin to assail the orcs, in the process dispossessing Mîm the Petty-Dwarf of his home and his sons. Mîm when captured by orcs in turn betrays them, “Then the Orc-captain laughed, and he said to Mîm: ‘Assuredly Turin son of Húrin shall not be slain.’” Well, the hand of Morgoth at work: he is targeting and deliberately fouling Turin’s plans, seizing him and hauling him off. Beleg follows in pursuit, meets the broken Gwindor escaped (or allowed to escape) from Angband. They find Turin, who wakens in a fright, seizes the sword and kills his best friend, Beleg. I think the death of Beleg counts as a real outcome of the Curse of Morgoth brought about by his wicked will.

Gwindor leads the broken Turin to Nargothrond, where Gwindor’s old beloved, Finduilas, falls madly for Turin, and Turin is … well, not unreceptive. In fact, Turin might be in love with Finduilas,
Does Morgoth sit back and let his curse run quietly? No, not all: he sends Glaurung Father of Dragons to work his wicked will. Glaurung was sent a-purpose: not only to destroy Nargothrond, but to end the romantic relationship of Turin and Finduilas. (Good Heavens! Beren and Lúthien produced Dior, then Elwing, and ultimately Elros and Elrond; and Tuor and Idril produced Eärendil, Elros and Elrond. What might Turin and Finduilas produce? In some of the genealogies, Finduilas is the sister of Gil-galad – a warrior of some renown, as I recall.) I’d call that direct intervention.

Once again, I say that Glaurung was actively seeking to destroy Turin and Níniel. This was part of his primary task:
Then Glaurung bewitches Nienor so that she suffers deep amnesia. Instead of falling in love with Brandir, a gentle man who sought to preserve his people to fight another day, Nienor newly rechristened as Níniel falls in love with Turin and enters an incestuous relationship neither ever intended. I’d call that the result of direct intervention.

Finally, poor old Turin kills Brandir unjustly: “twisted by the Dark Side, he has become.” (Sorry. I gave in…) Then he and Níniel commit suicide – as a direct result of the malice of Morgoth revealed through his servant, Glaurung.

Húrin, set free kills Mîm the Petty-Dwarf in Nargothrond, is arrested by the men of Brethil, and a kind of civil war erupts so that the leadership of the Second House of the Edain is eliminated by fratricide (see “The Wanderings of Húrin” in The War of the Jewels for the full story of Húrin in Brethil); is this not another of the works of the will of Morgoth?
 
Last edited:
(part 2 of 2 - suffering under the Curse of Verbosity. It must be inflicted by Mandos.)

Finally Húrin delivers the Nauglamír to Thingol, and though Melian breaks the hold that Morgoth has upon his mind, Thingol is enchanted by the Nauglamír, falls under a spell of desire, and hires the dwarves of Nogrod to set the Silmaril in it. The dwarves fall under the spell, too, there is a war between the dwarves and the Sindar, and Doriath falls; eventually Beren and the Greenelves and the ents catch the dwarves of Nogrod on the way home, and they who should have been allies slaughter one another at Rathlóriel. This was necessitated by the assault on Doriath, an indirect result of the Curse of Morgoth. Oh, and the Girdle of Melian came down, so that Doriath was open to attack.

What has Morgoth accomplished?
  1. He broke Húrin.
  2. He prevented a union between Turin and Finduilas.
  3. He desecrated Turin and Níniel.
  4. He destroyed Turin, a dangerous enemy.
  5. He destroyed Nargothrond.
  6. He destroyed the People of Haleth.
  7. Húrin worked his will by taking the Nauglamír to Thingol, where Thingol was enchanted.
  8. Thingol is killed by dwarves, ending centuries of friendship and cooperation between these two enemies of Angband, sowing seeds of distrust that still bore fruit between Thorin and Thranduil and between Gimli and Celeborn over 6,000 years and 2 ages of the world later.
  9. Doriath is eventually ruined, and a dangerous impediment to Morgoth’s vile plans is eliminated.
That was, from Morgoth’s accounting, a pretty good investment, despite a requirement for frequent intervention.

What did the Curse of the Noldor accomplish in the interests of the Valar? Can you cite an incident in which the Valar intervened to bring about some bad outcome for the Noldor or their allies? Ulmo intervened several times, risking the wrath of Manwë for defying his will by assisting Elves and Men. But Ulmo intervened to work good; which of the Valar intervened to work ill?

The rivalry, distrust, fratricide, treachery, treason, kidnapping, and murder among the Eldar in Beleriand cannot be attributed to a curse placed upon them by the Valar, in my view. It can be explained by a collapse in the morals and ethics of the Noldor themselves: each bad thing they did made the next bad thing easier, just as it does for men today. Look at the Tragedy of Macbeth by Shakespeare:
Of all men else I have avoided thee.
But get thee back, my soul is too much charged
With blood of thine already.
Each of Macbeth’s murders becomes easier than the one before until at last,
I 'gin to be aweary of the sun
And wish the estate o' the world were now undone.
Maybe Turin feels that way. Maybe Maedhros and Maglor feel that way at the end. But do any of these unfortunates come to their desperate end through a wicked curse imposed against them by the Valar, or as a result of the Curse of the Noldor, the result of their own choice of the easier, wicked path instead of the more difficult, correct one?

Can you cite an example of the Valar taking action to develop a bad outcome upon the Noldor or the Sindar or the Edain as a result of the Doom of Mandos? Is there any sign that they intervened to insure the bad outcome or make it worse? How has this curse operated to be a curse and make the situation worse?
 
Alcuin, given my poor understanding of English when it comes to subtler arguments, I am very prepared to eat crow . Having said that, I see this as a great opportunity to learn from persons who obviously have greater knowledge in all things Tolkien.
Then again, the "interest" of the valar was to punish the exiled. And why would you have me believe that a curse needs active involvment on the part of the curser, for it to follow its course? The very little I know of this matter points to no such necessity.

In HoME II, it is either Mim or Urin who "cursed that gold with a dread curse so that none might enjoy it, and he that held any part of it found evil and death to come of it" and, concerning the na "In this Necklace the Silmaril was set; but the curse of the gold was on him, and he defrauded them of part of their reward". And further:

As we can see:
- the curse layed on the gold was uttered by a dying person (be it Mim or Urin), who had no further involvment in the developing of the events;
- although this can be traced back to a "sorrow sown by the noldor", this curse has a path of its own, it exists as itself.

And, furthermore, this is how Chris compared the version of the curse of Mandos from the Sil with the one from BoLT:
While initially it was "only a foretelling", it became (also) a curse/doom.
What does "doom" signify? Here are some definitions I advance:
- A decision or judgment, especially an official condemnation to a severe penalty
[SIZE=-1]- (to) [/SIZE]condemn to certain destruction or failure (oxford).
In doing Eru's will, Manwe would act according to his own conception of what was 'Good' and what was 'Evil' not Eru's of which he was uncertain at best.
I disagree:
Of the valar said:
Manwe is dearest to Iluvatar and understands most clearly his purposes
Ulmo intervened several times, risking the wrath of Manwë for defying his will by assisting Elves and Men
I disagree again:
Ainulindale said:
And Manwe and Ulmo have from the beginning been allied, and in all things have served most faithfully the purpose of Iluvatar.
 
You dissagree about Manwe being uncertain of Eru's view of Good and Evil and cite
Manwe is dearest to Iluvatar and understands most clearly his purposes
However, understanding his purposes is not the same as understanding his views.
Of the Sun and Moon and the hiding of Valinor
Thus even as Eru spoke to us shall beauty not before conceived be brought into Eä, and evil yet be good to have been.
This shows that Eru had a wider view of what was happening than any of the Valar including the one who 'understands most clearly'. Eru's view of what is good and evil is obviously not the same as the narrow view of one who is in Arda.
 
But this only reffers to events that will happen, which are hidden to the valar, due to the fact that Eru maintains his freedom of action, beyond what was revealed to his "mind offsprings"; none of this implies that not knowing the future equals lack of right values.
 
I would just like to ask, where have I in any post Stated or even Implied that there was any "lack of right values"? I cannot answer further until I know just what you mean by this.
 
Eru's view of what is good and evil is obviously not the same as the narrow view of one who is in Arda.
This is what I had in mind; if my interpretation wrongly reflects your idea, I apologise.

And I think it is important for what the two of us are debating to quote Mandos' answer to what Manwe had stated:
But Mandos said:
- And yet remain evil
. To me shall Feanor come soon.'
which I think proves my idea further: even if something evil might cause good in the future (beyond the knowledge of even the valar), it still remains evil (or, well, at least in this case).
 
The point you have the problem with has nothing to do with lack of Right Values on the part of any charater. It simply shows that what Eru thought of as Good or Evil is dependant on his wider knowledge of creation. Things that from the viewpoint of those in Arda would be evil were to him necessary and contribitory to the glory of the creation and therefore good. It is also possible that some things that from within Arda were good, were infact not contributing to the creation and therefore, if not actually evil, at least not Good.

However, the Valar, (and this was part of their purpose in Arda) give definitions to Good and Evil within Arda based it would seem, on what the harm or otherwise of the acts not on how the they may contibute to creation. So regardless of what view Eru took the Valar and Manwe especialy would work within the framework of what they see as Good.

So the comment by Mandos that the acts would remain evil only works within Arda and it is only by the definitions of good and evil within Arda that we can discuss this matter. Eru's view of the matter is beyond the knowledge of the Valar and of us.
 
Things that from the viewpoint of those in Arda would be evil were to him necessary and contribitory to the glory of the creation and therefore good
But Manwe is aware of this:
Eru's view of the matter is beyond the knowledge of the Valar and of us
So, why bring the subject in the very first place?
 
Yes I agree that Manwe was aware of the difference in view between the Valar and Eru on the matter of good and evil. However, he could only work within the limits that they (the Valar) setup in Arda. He could not use what he saw as evil for good purposes.


I don't know, why did you?

I was simply answering this point in a rather verbose way.
 
However, he could only work within the limits that they (the Valar) setup in Arda
I doubt that whatever rules the valar setup in Arda took precedence over Eru's in Manwe's actions; as I have previously reffered to:
Osanwe kenta said:
Manwe was bound by the commands and injunctions of Eru, and would do this or abstain from that in accordance with them, always
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…