• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Analyzing outcomes: The Doom of Mandos or The Curse of Morgoth?

And if you can show me the command or injunction from Eru that would cause Manwe to do what he saw as evil in this case I will accept defeat.
 
Osanwe kenta said:
The office of the Elder King was to retain all his subjects in the allegiance of Eru, or to bring them back to it, and in that allegiance to leave them free.
:D .
 
Gee, I don’t know, Thorondor_. I can’t see that the quote from "Osanwe Kenta" shows that ManwĂ« has any mandate or authority to commit or even condone evil in the pursuit of his task of seeing to it that “all his subjects [were] in the allegiance of Eru, or [brought] back to it,” particularly with the stipulation that “in that allegiance to leave them free.” I don’t see how ManwĂ« could force one of the Children of Eru to freely act against that person’s will. In fact, if I am not mistaken (and I could be), the Ainur were specifically prohibited from such an undertaking.

I think the logic that using perverse means to obtain a desirable outcome is rather like the person who robs a bank (and kills or risks killing a teller) to buy food to feed an orphanage. It makes a great story in the movie The Blues Brothers, but that doesn’t make it acceptable behavior. I don’t think ManwĂ« or the rest of the Valar can deliberately propagate evil and claim that the ends justified the means. Nor is it sufficient to argue that because some good was salvaged from evil enough to justify ManwĂ« effectively enslaving Elves and Men to accomplish his goals.

Now, that doesn’t mean that everything the Valar set out to do with good intentions turned out well, or that they didn’t accidentally create problems. In summoning the Elves to Valinor, for instance, the Valar later seemed to have decided that they might have made an error. There is an proverb in English that “The road to hell is paved with good intentions,” and I believe that Tolkien even quotes it at one point in one of his writings (a letter, if I recall correctly). While it is usually quoted with direct reference to its religious merit, it is also used to describe how folks can accidentally create problems – sometimes terrible or even horrific problems – without meaning to. “Accidents” are unintentional harm, but they hurt nonetheless.

All my rambling aside, I don’t see how ManwĂ« could claim that some evil he deliberately inflicted upon someone else should be excused by Eru: since ManwĂ« is Eru’s agent, that would mean that Eru either condones or commits acts of evil, and I believe that – at least by definition in Tolkien’s sub-creation – this just cannot be. Now, if ManwĂ« does or permits something that somehow works out badly by accident (e.g., unchaining Melkor, who proceeds to mar FĂ«anor, kill the Two Trees, murder FinwĂ«, steal the Silmarils, and generally wreck havoc, leaving mayhem in his wake), well, that’s an “Aw, #%@!” situation, but it isn’t the same as purposefully setting out to do something harmful.

How you argue your point is your business, but you might be better off from a rhetorical standpoint to hammer away at Tolkien’s use of the word curse to describe what befell the Noldor, and then seeing if we can fend off the blows. Digging for an evil ManwĂ«, or even one tainted by deliberate malice, is, in my opinion, likely to be a dry well.
 
We’ve touched on whether or not Ulmo was acting in concert with or even in accord with ManwĂ« regarding the exiled Noldor in Middle-earth, and batted about whether he was in conflict with the rest of the Valar or not.

The Valar in particular and the Ainur in general were not some monolithic group: Tolkien depicts them as individuals, usually of good will, usually cooperating to achieve a common goal, with the exception of Morgoth and Sauron and their allies; and the additional exception of Ossë (the sea-storm Maia) and some of the others whose motives were sometimes inscrutable to the Elves.

In particular, Ulmo was the odd man out in the Valar’s collective decision about how to handle Morgoth, the exiled Noldor, the rest of the Elves in Beleriand and Middle-earth, and the Edain. This passage is excepted from “Of Tuor and the Fall of Gondolin” in Silmarillion:
But Morgoth thought that his triumph was fulfilled
 Yet by Sirion and the sea there grew up an Elven-folk, 
 dwelling ever nigh to the coasts of Arvernien, under the shadow of Ulmo’s hand.

And it is said that in that time Ulmo came to Valinor out of the deep waters, and spoke there to the Valar of the need of the Elves; and he called on them to forgive them, and rescue them from the overmastering might of Morgoth, and win back the Silmarils, wherein alone now bloomed the light of the Days of Bliss when the Two Trees still shone in Valinor. But Manwë moved not; and of the counsels of his heart what tale shall tell?

The wise have said that the hour was not yet come, and that only one speaking in person for the cause of both Elves and Men, pleading for pardon on their misdeeds and pity on their woes, might move the counsels of the Powers; and the oath of Fëanor perhaps even Manwë could not loose, until it found its end, and the sons of Fëanor relinquished the Silmarils, upon which they had laid their ruthless claim. For the light which lit the Silmarils the Valar themselves had made.
Two things are happening here. The first one is that Ulmo appears to be alone in arguing that the Valar needed to intercede in Middle-earth against Morgoth sooner rather than later. The second is that the Oath of FĂ«anor somehow complicated matters, as Maglor and Maedhros later debated, because in their madness FĂ«anor and his sons had called upon Eru to witness their oath; at the end, the brothers realized that this had rendered the whole enterprise hopeless, they were casting about for some way to minimize their losses, and they chose badly. This is from “Of the Voyage of EĂ€rendil and the War of Wrath” in Silmarillion:
Maedhros answered that if they returned to Aman but the favour of the Valar were withheld from them, then their oath would still remain, but its fulfillment be beyond all hope; and he said: ‘Who can tell to what dreadful doom we shall come, if we disobey the Powers in their own land, or purpose ever to bring war again into their holy realm?’

Yet Maglor still held back, saying: ‘If ManwĂ« and Varda themselves deny the fulfillment of an oath to which we named them in witness, is it not made void?’

And Maedhros answered: ‘But how shall our voices reach to IlĂșvatar beyond the Circles of the World? And by IlĂșvatar we swore in our madness, and called the Everlasting Darkness upon us, if we kept not our word. Who shall release us?’

‘If none can release us,’ said Maglor, ‘then indeed the Everlasting Darkness shall be our lot, whether we keep our oath or break it; but less evil shall we do in the breaking.’

Yet he yielded at last to the will of Maedhros

So first of all, Tolkien says that a lifetime of many centuries or even a few millennia doesn’t mean the Eldar make better decisions than we mere mortals. (Hippocrates has the correct solution to this dilemma: “First do no harm.” That would give the Maglor the correct solution.) The second element in this passage is that Oath again: it’s mucking up the whole operation.

Ulmo’s dissent from the consensus position was pretty strong. He took some liberties in pursuing his own agenda, to put it mildly, but he insisted that he had better insight into what to do than even ManwĂ« and Mandos in this situation. I suppose if you’re a demiurge, you get to make that claim; real people people claim to be better than their peers in business, medicine, law and politics every day, and sometimes they are. If it’s your profession – or your avocation at TTF – your opinion is as good as anyone else’s!

This passage is from “Of Tuor and His Coming to Gondolin” in Unfinished Tales. Ulmo has arisen out of the sea and is speaking to Tuor at Nevrast:
Ulmo spoke to Tuor of Valinor and its darkening, and the Exile of the Noldor, and the Doom of Mandos, and the hiding of the Blessed Realm. “But behold!” said he, “in the armour of Fate (as the Children of Earth name it) there is ever a rift, and in the walls of Doom a breach, until the full-making, which ye call the End. So it shall be while I endure, a secret voice that gainsayeth, and a light where darkness was decreed. Therefore, though in the days of this darkness I seem to oppose the will of my brethren, the Lords of the West, that is my part among them, to which I was appointed ere the making of the World. Yet Doom is strong, and the shadow of the Enemy lengthens; and I am diminished, until in Middle-earth I am become now no more than a secret whisper. The waters that run westward wither, and their springs are poisoned, and my power withdraws from the land; for Elves and Men grow blind and deaf to me because of the might of Melkor. And now the Curse of Mandos hastens to its fulfillment, and all the works of the Noldor shall perish, and every hope which they build shall crumble. The last hope alone is left, the hope that they have not looked for and have not prepared. And that hope lieth in thee; for so I have chosen.”




And as Ulmo said these things the mutter of the storm rose to a great cry, and the wind mounted, and the sky grew black; and the mantle of the Lord of Waters streamed out like a flying cloud. “Go now,” said Ulmo, “lest the Sea devour thee! For OssĂ« obeys the will of Mandos, and he is wroth, being a servant of the Doom.”
I like this passage for a couple of reasons. First, it is where Ulmo explicitly says, “I seem to oppose the will of my brethren” by helping Turgon. (And don’t forget that Finrod built Nargothrond at the behest of Ulmo, too, in a dream sent to him at the same time Turgon received his dream. So Ulmo was doubly rebellious in helping the Noldor this way.) Next, Ulmo is watching over Middle-earth through the waters, but he is losing his ability to determine what transpires to affect the outcome of affairs by using his power in the waters because of the encroachment of Morgoth. In this, he is similar to Manwë’s watching over Middle-earth (and NĂșmenor, during its existence) using the eagles. Third point – and I rather like this part best – OssĂ« “works” for Ulmo, if you don’t mind the expression, but not only is he insubordinate, he tries to kill the messenger! Ulmo basically tells Tuor, get out of here or OssĂ« will kill you because he knows I’m sending you to warn Turgon.

Finally there is the Doom – or Curse – of Mandos. In this case, Ulmo does say that it’s a “curse”. But again, I ask, how is it that Mandos has cursed the Noldor in the sense of calling down malediction upon them? Morgoth pronounces a malediction upon HĂșrin, and what happens to Turin and Nienor is very clearly and explicitly the result of Morgoth’s malicious attentions, and Glaurung is the instrument he uses to accomplish his vile invective. The Valar blocked the Noldor and their Sindarin allies from sailing back the West by setting up the Enchanted (or Shadowy) Isles to confuse their passage and by sending storms to drive the ships back. And I can’t figure out how to attribute to Mandos – or the rest of the “good” Valar – some act of malice or contribution to malice that must accompany a curse that is a malediction, which indicates to me that this was not a malediction, but a “doom.”
 
Thorondor_, That is only a job description. There is no command, order or injunction in ther to tell Manwe that he must use evil means to achieve good ends. Manwe is required to do what is in the description but allowed to use his own means of achieving it.

In fact, when all means within his view of good have been exhausted, Manwe does not turn to what he thinks of a evil to solve a problem. He hands over control to Eru. This is shown in Akalabeth at the time of the Numenorean invasion of Arda.
 
Now, if ManwĂ« does or permits something that somehow works out badly by accident (e.g., unchaining Melkor, who proceeds to mar FĂ«anor, kill the Two Trees, murder FinwĂ«, steal the Silmarils, and generally wreck havoc, leaving mayhem in his wake), well, that’s an “Aw, #%@!” situation, but it isn’t the same as purposefully setting out to do something harmful.
However, in their mandate, the valar chained persons, imprisoned them, banished them, hurt/killed,.. pretty harmful, wouldn't you say? Why can they do those things?

Given the divine nature of Manwe, I think that this whole "evil means" situation is also addressed in (draft) Letter #212
A divine 'punishment' is also a divine 'gift', if accepted, since its object is ultimate blessing, and the supreme inventiveness of the Creator will make 'punishments' (that is changes of design) produce a good not otherwise to be attained: a 'mortal' Man has probably (an Elf would say) a higher if unrevealed destiny than a longeval one
you might be better off from a rhetorical standpoint to hammer away at Tolkien’s use of the word curse to describe what befell the Noldor, and then seeing if we can fend off the blows
And I can’t figure out how to attribute to Mandos – or the rest of the “good” Valar – some act of malice or contribution to malice that must accompany a curse that is a malediction, which indicates to me that this was not a malediction, but a “doom.”
I would like to ask you, in this situation, what do you see as the significant difference between the terms "doom" and "curse" (sorry if you provided it so far and I missed it)?
Digging for an evil Manwë, or even one tainted by deliberate malice, is, in my opinion, likely to be a dry well
I never argued for an "evil Manwe"; I actually said is that "the least I will argue for is that Manwe's actions are in accordance with Eru's will/laws, and since Eru is the ultimate instance of good, I see don't see a moral problem here."
“I seem to oppose the will of my brethren”
"Seem" isn't much of a strong argument. As I have quoted from the Silmarillion, "Manwe and Ulmo have from the beginning been allied, and in all things have served most faithfully the purpose of Iluvatar". I think that this and my other quote leave little room for your claim that "Ulmo intervened several times, risking the wrath of Manwë for defying his will by assisting Elves and Men". And, as noted of Ulmo in Of Feanor and the Unchaining of Melkor,
But Ulmo was not deceived, and Tulkas clenched his hands whenever he saw Melkor his foe go by; for if Tulkas is slow to wrath he is slow also to forget. But they obeyed the judgement of Manwe; for those who will defend authority against rebellion must not themselves rebel.
OssĂ« “works” for Ulmo, if you don’t mind the expression, but not only is he insubordinate, he tries to kill the messenger
I am not sure what is the point here; the behaviour of Osse is due to his previous association with Melkor:
Of the maiar said:
It is said that in the making of Arda he endeavoured to draw Osse to his allegiance, promising to him all the realm and power of Ulmo, if he would serve him. So it was that long ago there arose great tumults in the sea that wrought ruin to the lands. But Uinen, at the prayer of Aule, restrained Osse and brought him before Ulmo; and he was pardoned and returned to his allegiance, to which he has remained faithful. For the most part; for the delight in violence has never wholly departed from him, and at times he will rage in his wilfulness without any command from Ulmo his lord.
 
Last edited:
Thorondor_ said:
However, in their mandate, the valar chained persons, imprisoned them, banished them, hurt/killed,.. pretty harmful, wouldn't you say? Why can they do those things?
Please give specific examples of these harmful things.

Given the divine nature of Manwe, I think that this whole "evil means" situation is also addressed in (draft) Letter #212
No this refers to what Eru can/will do. The Valar are Far more limited in their actions.

I never argued for an "evil Manwe"; I actually said is that "the least I will argue for is that Manwe's actions are in accordance with Eru's will/laws, and since Eru is the ultimate instance of good, I see don't see a moral problem here.
And as part of the ultimate instance of good is the requirement of evil represented by Melkor and the of good represented by Manwe. However, Eru remains as much as possible outside of Arda so within Arda Eru is not in fact the 'ultimate instance of good' than position is given to Manwe in opposition to Melkor. For Manwe to use means that he considers to be Evil would require a direct order from Eru. Since there is no such order I cannot see how Manwe could be involved in a curse.
 
However, Eru remains as much as possible outside of Arda
I think this is a matter of debate; as Finrod says in "Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth":
"He is already in it, as well as outside,' said Finrod. 'But indeed the "in-dwelling" and the "out-living" are not in the same mode"
an idea which I think is further reinforced by his various known interventions, or implied, when Tolkien reffers to the "freedom of Eru".
Please give specific examples of these harmful things
Chaining, imprisoning, slaying of Melkor; the banishment of Feanor from the city; and hurts/kills inflicted in the wars in which the valar were involved one way or the other.

I think that the following versions will make it clear that we are dealing with a curse, one of "evil fortune":
OF THE FLIGHT OF THE NOLDOR said:
$71. But most of them escaped and continued their journey, some by ship and some by foot; but the way was long and ever more evil going as they went on. After they had marched for a great while, and were come at length to the northern confines of the Blessed Realm - and they are mountainous and cold and look upon the empty waste of Eruman - they beheld a dark figure standing high upon a rock that looked down upon the shore. Some say it was the herald of the Gods, others that it was Mandos himself. There he spake in a loud voice, solemn and terrible, the curse and prophecy which is called the Prophecy of the North, warning them to return and ask for pardon, or in the end return only at last after sorrow and unspeakable misery. Much he fore- told in dark words, which only the wisest of them understood, concerning things that after befell. But all heard the curse he uttered upon those that would not stay or seek the doom and pardon of the Valar, for the spilling of the blood of their kindred at Alqualonde and fighting the first battle between the children of earth unrighteously. For this the Noldor should taste death more often and more bitterly than their kindred, by weapon and by torment and by grief; and evil fortune should pursue the house of Feanor, and their oath should turn against them, and all who now followed them should share their lot. And evil should come most upon them through treachery of kin to kin, so that in all their wars and councils they should suffer from treason and the fear of treason among themselves. But Feanor said: 'He saith not that we shall suffer from cowardice, from cravens or the fear of cravens'; and that proved true also.
Sketch of the mythology with especial reference to the 'Children of Hurin' HoME IV said:
The flight begins.' The Teleri will not join. The Gnomes cannot escape without boats, and do not dare to cross the Grinding Ice. They attempt to seize the swan-ships in Swanhaven, and a fight ensues (the first between the races of the Earth) in which many Teleri are slain, and their ships carried off. A curse is pronounced upon the Gnomes, that they shall after suffer often from treachery and the fear of treachery among their own kindred in punishment for the blood spilled at Swanhaven. They sail North along the coast of Valinor. Mandos sends an emissary, who speaking from a high cliff hails them as they sail by, and warns them to return, and when they will not speaks the 'Prophecy of Mandos' concerning the fate of after days.'
Note on the Noldorin princes HoME IV said:
It is curious that the curse upon the Gnomes, that they should suffer from treachery and the fear of treachery among their own kindred, is separated from the Prophecy of Mandos; but it is not said by whom this curse was pronounced. Nothing is told in S as originally written of the content of the Prophecy of Mandos, save that it concerned 'the fate of after days', but my father subsequently added that it told of 'the curse of war against one another because of Swanhaven', thus bringing the 'curse' into the content of the 'Prophecy', as in The Silmarillion. There is no trace of the old prophecies concerning Turgon and Gondolin), but nor is there any sug- gestion of the nature of the doom of the Noldor as it is stated in The Silmarillion.
ANNALS OF VALINOR said:
In 2993 it is said they came to a place where a high rock stands above the shores, and there stood either Mandos or his messenger and spoke the Doom of Mandos. For the kin-slaying he cursed the house of Feanor, and to a less degree all who followed them or shared in their emprise, unless they would return to abide the doom and pardon of the Valar. But if they would not, then should evil fortune and disaster befall them, and ever from treachery of kin towards kin; and their oath should turn against them, and a measure of mortality should visit them, that they should be lightly slain with weapons, or torments, or sorrow, and in the end fade and wane before the younger race. And much else he foretold darkly that after befell, warning them that the Valar would fence Valinor against their return
 
Last edited:
I think this is a matter of debate; as Finrod says in "Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth":
"He is already in it, as well as outside,' said Finrod. 'But indeed the "in-dwelling" and the "out-living" are not in the same mode"
an idea which I think is further reinforced by his various known interventions, or implied, when Tolkien reffers to the "freedom of Eru".

An Interesting point since as Finrod says in "Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth":

'Now none of us know, though the Valar may know, the future of Arda, or how long it is ordained to endure. But it will not endure for ever. It was made by Eru, but He is not in it. The One only has no limits. Arda, and Ea itself, must therefore be bounded.

Please give specific examples of these harmful things
Chaining, imprisoning, slaying of Melkor; the banishment of Feanor from the city; and hurts/kills inflicted in the wars in which the valar were involved one way or the other.

Ok, as for Melkor, Manwe was under orders to deal with him.

From: Of the Coming of the Elves and the Captivity of Melkor
ManwĂ« sat long in thought upon Taniquetil, and he sought the counsel of IlĂșvatar. And coming then down to Valmar he summoned the Valar to the Ring of Doom, and thither came even Ulmo from the Outer Sea.
Then ManwĂ« said to the Valar: 'This is the counsel of IlĂșvatar in my heart: that we should take up again the mastery of Arda, at whatsoever cost, and deliver the Quendi from the shadow of Melkor.'

The first time they deal with Melkor they chained him and imprisoned him for three ages in Mandos. Not a very evil thing even under the direct orders of Eru himself.

The second time they had to deal with Melkor they had to put right the problems caused by their (or at least Manwe's) mistake of erring on the side of good. It had also reached a point where Melkor's continued inhabitation of Arda posed a direct threat to the existence of Arda due to his dissemination of his power through the substance of Arda and the risk of Melkor totally destroying Arda rather than allow any other to rule. The only way that this could be prevented was for Melkor's physical body to be destroyed allowing his spirit to be removed from the circles of the world with the permission and help of Eru.

As for the hurts/killing during the wars of the Valar vs Melkor, these were the results of the necessity imposed on the Valar at those times by Eru.

In the case of Feanor's banishment, where was the evil/harm caused by the Valar? The evil awoken in Feanor's heart by Melkor caused him to draw sword against close kin. The Valar banished him from Tirion for this evil act but did nothing else to him.


I think that the following versions will make it clear that we are dealing with a curse, one of "evil fortune":

And I think that they would indeed make it clear if we knew which version, if any of those, JRRT would have used. Unfortunately The Sil. was still a 'Work in Progress' when the professor died. So we have the problem of reconciling a Manwe 'who is free of evil' with one who without orders from above uses something that he sees as evil for good purposes. A problem, no doubt that Tolkien himself would have been working on.

Of the versions you cited only one specifically states that the curse was laid on the Noldor by Mandos. Of the others it is not entirely clear just where the curse comes from in that it is uttered by Mandos while giving the Prophecy of the North. During the ongoing work Tolkien did on this story he had already moved away from the great rage and division within the Valar and Elves of Valinor found in BoLT 1 to sorrow for the marring of Feanor in the Sil.

The thing is, the Valar erred on the side of what they thought Good even under the direct orders of Eru. When told to "take up again the mastery of Arda, at whatsoever cost, and deliver the Quendi from the shadow of Melkor." They would not continue the evil of war past the point of capturing Melkor. Instead of retaining the mastery of Arda and clearing the rest of Melkor's servants they called the Quendi to leave Middle-earth for Aman so as to protect them both from the evils of Melkor and the evils of war with Melkor's servants.
 
An Interesting point since as Finrod says in "Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth":
'Now none of us know, though the Valar may know, the future of Arda, or how long it is ordained to endure. But it will not endure for ever. It was made by Eru, but He is not in it. The One only has no limits. Arda, and Ea itself, must therefore be bounded.
I think that the reconciliation between our quotes relies on the fact that Finrod doesn't believe that Eru, Himself, is wholly in Ea, but admits to Him having the possibility to achieve that:
'He is already in it, as well as outside,' said Finrod. 'But indeed the "in-dwelling" and the "out-living" are not in the same mode.'
'Truly,' said Andreth. 'So may Eru in that mode be present in Ea that proceeded from Him. But they speak of Eru Himself entering into Arda, and that is a thing wholly different. How could He the greater do this? Would it not shatter Arda, or indeed all Ea? '
'Ask me not,' said Finrod. 'These things are beyond the compass of the wisdom of the Eldar, or of the Valar maybe. But I doubt that our words may mislead us, and that when you say "greater" you think of the dimensions of Arda, in which the greater vessel may not be contained in the less. 'But such words may not be used of the Measureless. If Eru wished to do this, I do not doubt that He would find a way, though I cannot foresee it. For, as it seems to me, even if He in Himself were to enter in, He must still remain also as He is: the Author without. And yet, Andreth, to speak with humility, I cannot conceive how else this healing could be achieved. Since Eru will surely not suffer Melkor to turn the world to his own will and to triumph in the end. Yet there is no power conceiv- able greater than Melkor save Eru only. Therefore Eru, if He will not relinquish His work to Melkor, who must else proceed to mastery, then Eru must come in to conquer him.
with the comment:
Therefore, since it was unthinkable that Eru would abandon the world to the ultimate triumph and domination of Melkor (which could mean its ruin and reduction to chaos), Eru Himself must at some time come to oppose Melkor. But Eru could not enter wholly into the world and its history, which is, however great, only a finite Drama. He must as Author always remain 'outside' the Drama, even though that Drama depends on His design and His will for its beginning and continuance, in every detail and moment. Finrod therefore thinks that He will, when He comes, have to be both 'outside' and inside; and so he glimpses the possibility of complexity or of distinctions in the nature of Eru, which nonetheless leaves Him 'The One'.
As for the hurts/killing during the wars of the Valar vs Melkor, these were the results of the necessity imposed on the Valar at those times by Eru.
My point is exactly this: that in their actions, the valar are acting in accordance with Eru, even when doing things which, in and of themselves, are evil (quotes from the same source):
- "that Drama depends on His design and His will for its beginning and continuance, in every detail and moment"
- "his attempt to dominate the structure of Ea, and of Arda in particular, and alter the designs of Eru (which governed all the operations of the faithful Valar)"
And I think that they would indeed make it clear if we knew which version, if any of those, JRRT would have used.
However, all versions speak of evil casted upon the elves through this curse.
Of the others it is not entirely clear just where the curse comes from
Hm, I am not sure I understand (or follow the point); in all 3 versions, there is refference to Mandos concerning the curse:

- "Some say it was the herald of the Gods, others that it was Mandos himself"
- "but my father subsequently added that it told of 'the curse of war against one another because of Swanhaven', thus bringing the 'curse' into the content of the 'Prophecy' [of Mandos], as in The Silmarillion"
- "and there stood either Mandos or his messenger and spoke the Doom of Mandos"

the formulation being more or less similar to Sillmarilion:
"Some say that it was Mandos himself, and no lesser herald of Manwe"
 
I think that the reconciliation between our quotes relies on the fact that Finrod doesn't believe that Eru, Himself, is wholly in Ea, but admits to Him having the possibility to achieve that:
Actually it is even easier than that. Looking at the comment you also posted.
Therefore, since it was unthinkable that Eru would abandon the world to the ultimate triumph and domination of Melkor (which could mean its ruin and reduction to chaos), Eru Himself must at some time come to oppose Melkor. But Eru could not enter wholly into the world and its history, which is, however great, only a finite Drama.
So Eru would only do so when it was Necessary. Or as I said earlier
However, Eru remains as much as possible outside of Arda
;)
My point is exactly this: that in their actions, the valar are acting in accordance with Eru, even when doing things which, in and of themselves, are evil
Even when they remove the Elves from Middle-earth were by Eru's will they were placed and intended to live?

When they act in accordance with Eru's express orders they how can they do anything that is in and of itself evil? Eru you say is the ultimate instance of Good. He only does what is good for his creation.

However, in the case of the Rebelion of the Noldor there is no evidence that Eru gave orders to the Valar to over-rule their choice of actions.

Hm, I am not sure I understand (or follow the point); in all 3 versions, there is refference to Mandos concerning the curse:
But only one of them (ANNALS OF VALINOR, HoME IV) specificaly states that Mandos cursed them. In the others he only says about the curse. The Doom of Mandos covered more than just the curse of the Noldor.
"but my father subsequently added that it told of 'the curse of war against one another because of Swanhaven', thus bringing the 'curse' into the content of the 'Prophecy' [of Mandos], as in The Silmarillion"
The Doom of Mandos foretold many things that were to come. The tale of the Curse was Included in the Doom but it was not The Doom, they were not interchangable.
 
Thorondor_ said:
in their actions, the valar are acting in accordance with Eru, even when doing things which, in and of themselves, are evil
This echoes the argument by philosophers that God cannot be good because He tolerates the existence of evil; or alternately that He is, by one means or another, the source of evil Himself. If we pursue this line of argument, dapence will descend upon us at some point and lock closed the thread; but if we stick to Tolkien’s own words, I think we can follow it some distance.

Before I proceed, however, I must pause to point out a couple of fallacies in your argument. Surgeons wound their patients every time they cut upon them: sometimes those wounds are deep and vital, and indeed, without the intense attentions of the surgeon and his assistants, and following that of many other practitioners, they would certainly be fatal. To ascribe to the surgeon some evil intent would be ridiculous: his intent is not to harm but to heal. Slicing open a man or woman with a sharp knife would normally be an action that would entail arrest and imprisonment, but for the surgeon, failure to do so might be malpractice.

It is not the action but the intent that defines whether someone is committing evil. Indeed, evil can arise where no action has yet taken place: it can and does fester in the heart, as it did with FĂ«anor before his jealous assault upon Fingolfin in Tirion in Finwë’s palace. There are times, as in war, in which there is no other action that can be taken that is not destructive unless one wants to be himself destroyed. Those who initiate evil must bear all the consequences of their actions, including the actions of those who are not evil who must kill or destroy to stop them. The police are not charged with violating traffic regulations when they speed after a felon in hot pursuit; nor are soldiers charged with murder for the killing they must do of necessity in combat.

Evil entered into EĂ€ and thus into Arda through the machinations of Melkor even before it came into physical being. From Letter 212 (a draft of an extension of letter 211 to Rhona Beare, 1958):
The Ainur took part in the making of the world as ‘sub-creators’: in various degrees, after this fashion. They interpreted according to their powers, and completed in detail, the Design propounded to them by the One. This was propounded first in musical or abstract form, and then in an ‘historical vision’. In the first interpretation, the vast Music of the Ainur, Melkor introduced alterations, not interpretations of the mind of the One, and great discord arose. The One then presented this ‘Music’, including the apparent discords, as a visible ‘history’.
In this case, Eru did not create the “alterations, not interpretations” that Melkor made, but he translated them into EĂ€ as a literal depiction of the Music of the Ainur as it then existed, alterations and all. The inclusion of Melkor’s discordance is annunciated by IlĂșvatar himself in AinulindalĂ«:
‘Behold your Music! This is your minstrelsy; and each of you shall find contained herein, amid the design that I set before you, all those things which it may seem that he himself devised or added. And thou, Melkor, wilt discover all the secret thoughts of thy mind, and wilt perceive that they are but a part of the whole and tributary to its glory.’
There is no indication in AinulindalĂ« that Eru was pleased with what Melkor had done: in fact, quite the opposite. Melkor’s motive was selfish and usurperous:
[Melkor] had gone often alone into the void places seeking the Imperishable Flame; for desire grew hot within him to bring into Being things of his own, and it seemed to him that IlĂșvatar took no thought for the Void, and he was impatient of its emptiness. Yet he found not the Fire, for it is with IlĂșvatar. But being alone he had begun to conceive thoughts of his own unlike those of his brethren.
By incorporating even Melkor’s discord into EĂ€ and not purging it, Eru demonstrates which of the two of them, Creator or creation, is the Greater, who is the Master, and that all things must eventually work to the will of Eru. This does not mean that Eru either devised evil or sanctioned it, but that those who work evil must find that Eru can master even their wicked deeds and overcome them:
Then IlĂșvatar spoke, and he said: ‘Mighty are the Ainur, and mightiest among them is Melkor; but that he may know, and all the Ainur, that I am IlĂșvatar, those things that ye have sung, I will show them forth, that ye may see what ye have done. And thou, Melkor, shalt see that no theme may be played that hath not its uttermost source in me, nor can any alter the music in my despite. For he that attempteth this shall prove but mine instrument in the devising of things more wonderful, which he himself hath not imagined.’
Melkor must eventually arrive to a conclusion similar to the words set in the mouth of the fiend Beelzebub in Book 2 of Milton’s Paradise Lost in which he acknowledges that the fallen angels cannot be free of their service to God despite their rebellion and consignment to Hell:
And know not that the King of Heav’n hath doom’d
This place our dungeon, not our safe retreat
Beyond his Potent arm, to live exempt
From Heav’ns high jurisdiction, in new League
Banded against his Throne, but to remaine
In strictest bondage, though thus far remov’d,
Under th’ inevitable curb, reserv’d
His captive multitude: For he, be sure,
In highth or depth, still first and last will Reign
Sole King, and of his Kingdom loose no part
By our revolt, but over Hell extend
His Empire, and with Iron Scepter rule
Us here, as with his Golden those in Heav’n.
To attribute to Eru the rebellion of Melkor and his wickedness is to fail to understand the cosmology of Tolkien’s subcreation, I believe. To assign evil motivation to the Chaining of Melkor and his imprisonment in the Halls of Mandos is a wild misinterpretation: to be good does not entail allowing oneself to be enslaved or slaughtered, but like the archangel Michael in Paradise Lost or Tulkas, OromĂ«, and EönwĂ« in Silmarillion, it means to fight back. Aragorn does not submit himself to death or servitude to Sauron, he fights, and he gathers and leads others to war. That he and those he led were willing, if necessary, to sacrifice themselves in hopeless combat at the Black Gate does not lessen in any way his willingness – or indeed the necessity – of fighting back, of imposing evil. But nowhere can I find any reason to ascribe to Aragorn any evil intent, any malice, because he slew and destroyed his enemies and their works.

The passage you quote from “Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth” is part of Finrod’s conversation after Andreth has revealed to him a secret that Men have kept from the Eldar, the “Old Hope”:
‘What then was this hope, if you know?’ Finrod asked.

‘They say,’ answered Andreth, ‘they say that the One will himself enter into Arda, and heal Men and all the Marring from the beginning to the end. This they say also, or they feign, is a rumour that has come down through years uncounted, even from the days of our undoing.’
I think this is a clear-cut case of Tolkien’s Christian faith entering into his subcreation. And I think I will leave this part line of the thread at that, before we all get our mitts smacked.
 
Gothmog said:
The Doom of Mandos covered more than just the curse of the Noldor.
"but my father subsequently added that it told of 'the curse of war against one another because of Swanhaven', thus bringing the 'curse' into the content of the 'Prophecy' [of Mandos], as in The Silmarillion"
The Doom of Mandos foretold many things that were to come. The tale of the Curse was Included in the Doom but it was not The Doom, they were not interchangable.
Thorondor_ said:
I think that the following versions will make it clear that we are dealing with a curse, one of "evil fortune":
For my part, it seems to me that any idea that this was a “curse” was a product of the earlier works, when the Noldor were still the Gnomes, and that as the story became more fully developed, it became more and more a “doom” or “prophecy,” two words that would seem to me interchangeable in this context. In fact, the ultimate fate of the world, in which Morgoth returns to Arda and Turin returns to destroy him in the Dagor Dagorath is called the “Second Prophecy of Mandos,” while this “Doom of Mandos” is the First Prophecy.

In any case, to predict or prophesy or even to confirm as a doom that the outcome of one’s actions are going to be unpleasant, regrettable, repulsive, or even ‘of “evil fortune”’ does not constitute an evil intent on the part of the speaker. I cannot for myself see evil intent in the words that Mandos spoke in Araman; otherwise, would not the followers of Finarfin who returned to Tirion have suffered as well? If this is truly a curse, then why do they not fall to killing and betraying one another? Or are they exempted because they have turned away from following FĂ«anor?

Consider Tolkien’s own words about this matter outside the context of the tales appear in Letter 131 to Milton Waldman, written in late 1951:
The sons of Fëanor take a terrible and blasphemous oath of enmity and vengeance against all or any, even of the gods, who dares to claim any part or right in the Silmarilli. They pervert the greater part of their kindred, who rebel against the gods, and depart from paradise, and go to make hopeless war upon the Enemy. The first fruit of their fall is war in Paradise, the slaying of Elves by Elves, and this and their evil oath dogs all their later heroism, generating treacheries and undoing all victories.
...
The oath of the sons of Fëanor becomes operative, and lust for the Silmaril brings all the kingdoms of the Elves to ruin.

... EĂ€rendil the Wanderer ... is ... a representative of both Kindreds, Elves and Men, is to find a sea-passage back to the Land of the Gods, and as ambassador persuade them to take thought again for the Exiles, to pity them, and rescue them from the Enemy. His wife Elwing descends from LĂșthien and still possesses the Silmaril. But the curse still works, and EĂ€rendil’s home is destroyed by the sons of FĂ«anor. But this provides the solution: Elwing casting herself into the Sea to save the Jewel comes to EĂ€rendil, and with the power of the great Gem they pass at last to Valinor, and accomplish their errand ... The last two sons of FĂ«anor, compelled by their oath, steal them, and are destroyed by them, casting themselves into the sea, and the pits of the earth.

... the Exiled Elves were, if not commanded, at least sternly counseled to return into the West, and there be at peace. They were not to dwell permanently in Valinor again, but in the Lonely Isle of Eressëa within sight of the Blessed Realm.
------------------------------------------
​
Élhendi said:
Which was the most effective? That is which was most fully complete in its intent, The Doom of Mandos or The Curse of Morgoth.
Élhendi’s thread-starter dealt with which of these two pronouncements by a Vala “was most fully complete in its intent.” If I may, let me ask you two direct questions that might perhaps allow us to set aside the issue of “Curse” or “Doom” and return to the original subject of the thread, Thorondor_: Do you attribute the Prophecy of Mandos to malice by the Valar against the Noldor? And would you agree that the Curse of Morgoth on HĂșrin and his family arises out of his malice?
 
Alcuin
This echoes the argument by philosophers that God cannot be good because He tolerates the existence of evil; or alternately that He is, by one means or another, the source of evil Himself. If we pursue this line of argument, dapence will descend upon us at some point and lock closed the thread; but if we stick to Tolkien’s own words, I think we can follow it some distance.
Have no fear on this. Religion can be discussed on TTF so long as it is in relation to Tolkien and/or his works.
 
So Eru would only do so when it was Necessary. Or as I said earlier
However, Eru remains as much as possible outside of Arda
Well, if our positions are reconciled as such, then your previous argument about Eru not being the ultimate instance of good lost its force. While Eru Himself is not in Ea, he also "dwells" in it, and "that Drama depends on His design and His will for its beginning and continuance, in every detail and moment" - and this quote alone should give you the reason why the valar acted the way they did.
When they act in accordance with Eru's express orders they how can they do anything that is in and of itself evil? Eru you say is the ultimate instance of Good. He only does what is good for his creation.
Yes, in the same idea, I previously quoted from the letters that "divine 'punishment' is also a divine 'gift', if accepted, since its object is ultimate blessing". Eru, (or his agents acting in accordance with his will), can do things which are evil in and of themselves, but which ultimately produce good [since "of all His designs the issue must be for His Children's joy" (and his designs "governed all the operations of the faithful Valar")].
But only one of them (ANNALS OF VALINOR, HoME IV) specificaly states that Mandos cursed them
So does "Of the flight of the noldor":
"Some say it was the herald of the Gods, others that it was Mandos himself. There he spake in a loud voice, solemn and terrible, the curse and prophecy which is called the Prophecy of the North"
The Doom of Mandos foretold many things that were to come. The tale of the Curse was Included in the Doom but it was not The Doom, they were not interchangable.
I disagree; in only one instance (Sketch of the mythology with especial reference to the 'Children of Hurin' HoME IV) the curse and the doom are separated.
It is not the action but the intent that defines whether someone is committing evil.
I completely agree, that is why I see no problem with the fact that the valar cursed the noldor - an aspect which you and Gothmog dislike about them.
In this case, Eru did not create the “alterations, not interpretations” that Melkor made, but he translated them into EĂ€ as a literal depiction of the Music of the Ainur as it then existed, alterations and all.
However, as you yourself quoted:
"all those things which it may seem that he himself devised or added"
(again, the "seem" part rather ruins your argument)
"And thou, Melkor, shalt see that no theme may be played that hath not its uttermost source in me, nor can any alter the music in my despite"
Even Melkor does Eru's will, perhaps even when he was singing.
For my part, it seems to me that any idea that this was a “curse” was a product of the earlier works, when the Noldor were still the Gnomes, and that as the story became more fully developed, it became more and more a “doom” or “prophecy,” two words that would seem to me interchangeable in this context. In fact, the ultimate fate of the world, in which Morgoth returns to Arda and Turin returns to destroy him in the Dagor Dagorath is called the “Second Prophecy of Mandos,” while this “Doom of Mandos” is the First Prophecy
I believe that the reconciliation between our positions, one which would be in accordance with Tolkien's writting, is that the will (or doom) of the valar is carried out to its completion by the curse (as an instrument of their will).
To assign evil motivation to the Chaining of Melkor and his imprisonment in the Halls of Mandos is a wild misinterpretation
I think there is a misunderstanding here: where did I say it had an evil motivation?
In any case, to predict or prophesy or even to confirm as a doom that the outcome of one’s actions are going to be unpleasant, regrettable, repulsive, or even ‘of “evil fortune”’ does not constitute an evil intent on the part of the speaker
Same question: where have I argued the valar had evil motivations?
Do you attribute the Prophecy of Mandos to malice by the Valar against the Noldor?
No; it was a "right" "retribution" for what they have done, esspecially in a holy land.
And would you agree that the Curse of Morgoth on HĂșrin and his family arises out of his malice?
Yes.
 
Just one thought on Eru being the ultimate Good:
If he was, how could he have made Melkor as an offspring of his thoughts?

Just a question...

*hides*
 
Élhendi said:
Just one thought on Eru being the ultimate Good:
If he was, how could he have made Melkor as an offspring of his thoughts?
I think the answer is given in Myths Transformed:
Nonetheless this gift of IlĂșvatar to the Valar has its own peril, as have all his free gifts: which is in the end no more than to say that they play a part in the Great Tale so that it may be complete; for without peril they would be without power, and the giving would be void.

He must have grasped with great clarity what even we may perceive dimly: that it was the essential mode of the process of 'history' in Arda that evil should constantly arise, and that out of it new good should constantly come
 
Well, the evil thing is that the thread is closed, though I would have liked to think some of the points were not so correct. For example, there is one instance where Eru is reffered to as Almighty:
The theory of the work said:
In the margin of the text of this page, which ends at this point, my father wrote: 'The Almighty even after the Fall allowed an earthly paradise to be maintained for a while; but the Eledai were bidden to withdraw thither as men spread - if they would remain as they had been: otherwise they would fade and diminish.'
And I think that the degree of determinism is very high in Ea, as pointed previously:
Athrabeth Finrod Ah Andreth said:
that Drama depends on His design and His will for its beginning and continuance, in every detail and moment
and concerning discord (at least some aspects of it):
Myths transformed said:
Out of the discords of the Music — sc. not directly out of either of the themes, Eru's or Melkor's, but of their dissonance with regard one to another - evil things appeared in Arda, which did not descend from any direct plan or vision of Melkor: they were not 'his children'; and therefore, since all evil hates, hated him too
My point was that as long as some of the Ainur became "evil" (Melkor, Sauron, balrogs, etc), and as they are offspring of Eru's thoughts, then I find it hard to believe that Eru was all good.
Why? Just because there is an intermediary step (evil) between two levels of good (one attainable "as it is", and one attainable through struggle against evil, so that evil is a source of more good, beauty and meaning)? Not to mention that "of all His designs the issue must be for His Children's joy" (Atrabeth).
 
Thorondor_ said:
Well, if our positions are reconciled as such, then your previous argument about Eru not being the ultimate instance of good lost its force. While Eru Himself is not in Ea, he also "dwells" in it, and "that Drama depends on His design and His will for its beginning and continuance, in every detail and moment" - and this quote alone should give you the reason why the valar acted the way they did.
Our positions are reconciled in that according to both he does not interfere in Arda unless it is necessary. This does not mean that we agree on the how much interference that amounts to. Eru does not direct every action by the Valar or any other creature in Arda. That would prevent him from giving free-will to any. He set a very broad out-line which had a certain beginning and a certain end, what happened in between was decided in the Music of the Ainur.

The Valar acted in the way they did because Eru gave them free-will to add to his design according to their will and power. Don't forget, while Eru gave the basic theme the Valar added to it in the Music. Eru caused Arda to be according to that combined effort. So while it depends on Eru's will for continuance in every detail, not every detail is from Eru. He also ensures that the details put in by the Ainur are included in his original design.

What your argument results in is a total lack of free-will in Arda. Eru controls everything that happens in Arda. Therefore there can be no good and no evil, all things are exactly as Eru wills it. I am aware that Free-will is limited. It is only the ability to pick without coercion between the choices available. However, if Eru is making all the decisions then there are no choices for the Valar and the Free-will given in the Ainulindale does not exist.


Thorondor_ said:
Yes, in the same idea, I previously quoted from the letters that "divine 'punishment' is also a divine 'gift', if accepted, since its object is ultimate blessing". Eru, (or his agents acting in accordance with his will), can do things which are evil in and of themselves, but which ultimately produce good [since "of all His designs the issue must be for His Children's joy" (and his designs "governed all the operations of the faithful Valar")].

The quote from the letter (212) does not mention his agents
A divine 'punishment' is also a divine 'gift', if accepted, since its object is ultimate blessing, and the supreme inventiveness of the Creator will make 'punishments' (that is changes of design) produce a good not otherwise to be attained:

His agents acting in accordance with his will are incapable of such actions. The "divine 'punishment' that is a divine 'gift' is in the hands of Eru alone. It refers to changes of the Doom of peoples or persons that lie only in the hand of Eru such as changing the fate of LĂșthien from that of Elf-kind to Mortal-kind. The only time that the Valar were given a say in such acts was in the case of the 'Half-Elven' where Doom was given to Manwe

Of the Voyage of EĂ€rendil and the War of Wrath

But when all was spoken, Manwë gave judgement, and he said: 'In this matter the power of doom is given to me. The peril that he ventured for love of the Two Kindreds shall not fall upon EÀrendil, nor shall it fall upon Elwing his wife who entered into peril for love of him; but they shall not walk again ever among Elves or Men in the Outer Lands. And this is my decree concerning them: to EÀrendil and to Elwing, and to their sons, shall be given leave each to choose freely to which kindred their fates shall be joined, and under which kindred they shall be judged.'
However, while Doom (the decision) of what would happen to the 'half-elven' was given to Manwe, the Power to change fates was not.

Letter 153 To Peter Hastings
As for 'whose authority decides these things?' The immediate 'authorities' are the Valar (the Powers or Authorities): the 'gods'. But they are only created spirits – of high angelic order we should say, with their attendant lesser angels – reverend, therefore, but not worshipful ; and though potently 'subcreative', and resident on Earth to which they are bound by love, having assisted in its making and ordering, they cannot by their own will alter any fundamental provision. They called upon the One in the crisis of the rebellion of Numenor – when the NĂșmenĂłreans attempted to take the Undying Land by force of a great armada in their lust for corporal immortality – which necessitated a catastrophic change in the shape of Earth. Immortality and Mortality being the special gifts of God to the Eruhini (in whose conception and creation the Valar had no part at all) it must be assumed that no alteration of their fundamental kind could be effected by the Valar even in one case: the cases of LĂșthien (and TĂșor) and the position of their descendants was a direct act of God. The entering into Men of the Elven-strain is indeed represented as part of a Divine Plan for the ennoblement of the Human Race, from the beginning destined to replace the Elves.


Thorondor_ said:
So does "Of the flight of the noldor":
"Some say it was the herald of the Gods, others that it was Mandos himself. There he spake in a loud voice, solemn and terrible, the curse and prophecy which is called the Prophecy of the North"

No, in the others, including "Of the Flight of the Noldor" Mandos simply speaks about it. There is no statement in there that the Curse came from him or any of the Valar.

Thorondor_ said:
I disagree; in only one instance (Sketch of the mythology with especial reference to the 'Children of Hurin' HoME IV) the curse and the doom are separated.

In the comment you quoted it stated quite clearly that Tolkien at that point Included the curse of the Noldor into the content of the Prophesy of the North. Therefore the two are not the same. The Prophesy includes a statement about the Curse and the statement about the Curse is only a part of the Prophesy.
Thorondor_ said:
I completely agree, that is why I see no problem with the fact that the valar cursed the noldor - an aspect which you and Gothmog dislike about them.

Where have I even hinted that I dislike this about them? For my part I am arguing that they did not curse the Noldor since they could not do so without acting in the same way as Melkor, that is acting contrary to their nature.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top