norrinradd
Member
- Joined
- Jan 26, 2020
- Messages
- 101
Could you answer my above question about the is Khamul an Easterling?Bald, I suppose, is a scale. How bald? Completely?
Gollum/Smeagol was more or less bald, if memory serves from book descriptions. I'd also point out that as a species, Orcs and Goblins generally did not have much in the way of hair.
You didn't specify human characters, after all. Hello, all. *looks wistful* Well, I'm back.
We know that; in UT (Hunt for the Ring, journey of the black riders, note 1) says that Khamul was referred to as nick-name that is ”the Black Easterling” in the rejected version of the present passage of Tale of Years. Therefore, Did Tolkien give the nickname (Black Easterling) to Khamul because of he was actually an Easterling?
Otherwise, Tolkien, as the purpose of using this nickname in his work; Did Tolkien want to explain that Khamul was known with this nickname to other middle-earth cultures, races or people and that Khamul is not actually an Easterling?
Hi Lord again🙏The LotR does not mention any names of the Nazgûl. In the UT we can find the name Khamûl, along with references like "Black Easterling" or "Shadow of the East" (you have found that already), so I think that his eastern origin is sufficiently confirmed.
However, whether this knowledge comes from canon text is debatable. You have mentioned correctly that several versions of the tale “The Hunt for the Ring” are published; Christopher Tolkien himself was not beyond some doubt which parts were to be considered as “final” (if such a word is applicable at all, in JRRT’s literature).
BTW (not related to your question), as regards the origin of the other Nazgûl, their leader was the Witchking of Angmar so we know at least who he was (yet without a name). In TS you can also read this: "[...] it is said that among those whom he ensnared with the Nine Rings three were great lords of Númenórean race."
Do you disagree with me sir Merroe, about my post on my one above commemt (related with what the versions mean)?The LotR does not mention any names of the Nazgûl. In the UT we can find the name Khamûl, along with references like "Black Easterling" or "Shadow of the East" (you have found that already), so I think that his eastern origin is sufficiently confirmed.
However, whether this knowledge comes from canon text is debatable. You have mentioned correctly that several versions of the tale “The Hunt for the Ring” are published; Christopher Tolkien himself was not beyond some doubt which parts were to be considered as “final” (if such a word is applicable at all, in JRRT’s literature).
BTW (not related to your question), as regards the origin of the other Nazgûl, their leader was the Witchking of Angmar so we know at least who he was (yet without a name). In TS you can also read this: "[...] it is said that among those whom he ensnared with the Nine Rings three were great lords of Númenórean race."
Thanks a lot and i want to ask something that is which characters have a dark or swarthy skin in the middle earth? I think Rhun people. But Khamul the Easterling(Second Nazgul) is formerly Easterling soldier but in the movie, all 9 ringwraith is white formerly. I didn’t understand that.
I try to look at the bright side of the Glorfindel issue with respect to these films. . . that he wasn't in them
Although if I recall correctly, were there not some web-mutterings of a person cast as Glorfindel who simply appeared in at least one background scene. Or did I dream this?
I hope I dreamed it.
That said, are you really suggesting you favor Xenarwen? Madam Lisp? She who whines ( . . . )
My "I'm glad Glorfindel wasn't in these films" is perhaps better described as an out of context "silver (golden) lining" . . . in other words, very generally speaking, I might, at least, have felt like ripping out patches of my beard while seeing Jackson's version of what I imagine as a shining paragon of Elven-ness.
And as it turns out, for my imagined version, I cast Arwen way back in the early 1980s -- her name is Joyce Penelope Wilhelmina Frankenberg.
Just the way I feel about Tom Bombadil.I try to look at the bright side of the Glorfindel issue with respect to these films. . . that he wasn't in them
Just the way I feel about Tom Bombadil.
That received arrow was in RoTK, a pirate (Umbar) captain challenging Aragorn with the "you and what army?" bit. Thought I think in might only have been in the EE ...Didn't he "receive" an arrow at Helm's Deep?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?