• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Bald Characters

We know that; in UT (Hunt for the Ring, journey of the black riders, note 1) says that Khamul was referred to as nick-name that is ”the Black Easterling” in the rejected version of the present passage of Tale of Years. Therefore, Did Tolkien give the nickname (Black Easterling) to Khamul because of he was actually an Easterling?
Otherwise, Tolkien, as the purpose of using this nickname in his work; Did Tolkien want to explain that Khamul was known with this nickname to other middle-earth cultures, races or people and that Khamul is not actually an Easterling?

The LotR does not mention any names of the Nazgûl. In the UT we can find the name Khamûl, along with references like "Black Easterling" or "Shadow of the East" (you have found that already), so I think that his eastern origin is sufficiently confirmed.

However, whether this knowledge comes from canon text is debatable. You have mentioned correctly that several versions of the tale “The Hunt for the Ring” are published; Christopher Tolkien himself was not beyond some doubt which parts were to be considered as “final” (if such a word is applicable at all, in JRRT’s literature).

BTW (not related to your question), as regards the origin of the other Nazgûl, their leader was the Witchking of Angmar so we know at least who he was (yet without a name). In TS you can also read this: "[...] it is said that among those whom he ensnared with the Nine Rings three were great lords of Númenórean race."
 
The LotR does not mention any names of the Nazgûl. In the UT we can find the name Khamûl, along with references like "Black Easterling" or "Shadow of the East" (you have found that already), so I think that his eastern origin is sufficiently confirmed.

However, whether this knowledge comes from canon text is debatable. You have mentioned correctly that several versions of the tale “The Hunt for the Ring” are published; Christopher Tolkien himself was not beyond some doubt which parts were to be considered as “final” (if such a word is applicable at all, in JRRT’s literature).

BTW (not related to your question), as regards the origin of the other Nazgûl, their leader was the Witchking of Angmar so we know at least who he was (yet without a name). In TS you can also read this: "[...] it is said that among those whom he ensnared with the Nine Rings three were great lords of Númenórean race."
Hi Lord again🙏


What Christopher Tolkien (in UT) meant in the rejected version is about the number of the Nazguls at that time in Dol Guldur. Whether 2-3 Nazgul at there,or Khamul is not there, is not important and nasty (rejected version or other version is already related to how many nazguls are in Dol Guldur); but this is not a note showing that he was not nicknamed “the Black Easterling”. Am I wrong? It is presented in the note that Khamul is referred to by his nickname “Second Chief” and “Black Easterling”, just not by his original name. In this note (about rejected version), ”Second Chief” and ”the Black Easterling” are used together. And in the other text (actual text), we already knew and saw that Khamul was called ”Second Chief”. We understand clearly that the nickname “Second Chief” belongs to Khamul. With this note (about the rejected version) just added a nickname, is “Black Easterling”, to other nickname (Second Chief).

Even if it is on the rejected version,there is no doubt that these two nicknames belong to Khamul by using “Second Chief” and “the Black Easterling” nicknames together, I think that Christopher Tolkien also stated these notes and in last pages of UT (chapther of INDEXS); there are 2 notes that are “the Black Easterling, see: Khamul” and the other one is “Khamul:.... nicknames; Shadow of the East, the Black Easterling, Second Chief”.

Am I right?
 
The LotR does not mention any names of the Nazgûl. In the UT we can find the name Khamûl, along with references like "Black Easterling" or "Shadow of the East" (you have found that already), so I think that his eastern origin is sufficiently confirmed.

However, whether this knowledge comes from canon text is debatable. You have mentioned correctly that several versions of the tale “The Hunt for the Ring” are published; Christopher Tolkien himself was not beyond some doubt which parts were to be considered as “final” (if such a word is applicable at all, in JRRT’s literature).

BTW (not related to your question), as regards the origin of the other Nazgûl, their leader was the Witchking of Angmar so we know at least who he was (yet without a name). In TS you can also read this: "[...] it is said that among those whom he ensnared with the Nine Rings three were great lords of Númenórean race."
Do you disagree with me sir Merroe, about my post on my one above commemt (related with what the versions mean)?
 
Thanks a lot and i want to ask something that is which characters have a dark or swarthy skin in the middle earth? I think Rhun people. But Khamul the Easterling(Second Nazgul) is formerly Easterling soldier but in the movie, all 9 ringwraith is white formerly. I didn’t understand that.

Presuming this was the question you were referring to, all I can say is that I am hardly the person to turn to if you are looking for a defender of the movies. Jackson's interpretation of Lord of the Rings had some merit, but ultimately creative liberty was taken and given that they cast Caucasian men for the roles of each Aragorn, Theoden, and Denethor and his sons, men whom the Wraiths are supposed to be descended from, to cast someone of a different ethnic background didn't make a lot of sense visually. In a nutshell, the movie was whitewashed. I personally find this to be a disservice to the story, but I'm a bit of a purist that way.

Plus side, at least your Khamul made it into the film, whitewashed or not. The same couldn't be said for the likes of Tom Bombadil, among others. He also might have been replaced entirely by a sword toting Xena knockoff who was only a bit part in the book. Yes, I remain a little bitter about Glorfindel. Alright, fine, a lot bitter. 😏
 
I try to look at the bright side of the Glorfindel issue with respect to these films. . . that he wasn't in them :)

Although if I recall correctly, were there not some web-mutterings of a person cast as Glorfindel who simply appeared in at least one background scene. Or did I dream this?

I hope I dreamed it.
 
I try to look at the bright side of the Glorfindel issue with respect to these films. . . that he wasn't in them :)

Although if I recall correctly, were there not some web-mutterings of a person cast as Glorfindel who simply appeared in at least one background scene. Or did I dream this?

I hope I dreamed it.

I'm not certain if he was ever cast for the role ahead of the game or if it was one of those "Well, okay, let's do this thing after the fact", but Jarl Benzon was featured as Glorfindel for the Lord of the Ring Trading Card Game (game made by Decipher) for the Rare Foil Edition card. That same actor, dressed as an Elf, also appeared in Aragorn's coronation scene during Return of the King. Technically speaking, as such, one could argue that Glorfindel, was in Lord of the Rings, even if he wasn't technically credited, and only a super-nerd such as myself would put that together.

That said, are you really suggesting you favor Xenarwen? Madam Lisp? She who whines every time she opens her mouth? The character love interest I didn't even root for in the books, much less the film? Ugh! The single redeeming scene of Arwen's, in my mind, was the scene in where she sees her son and then confronts her father about it. "But there is also life!" - that, I will give Liv, was perfect delivery. I felt that to the core.

Speaking of bald men, how's Hugo Weaving's hairline doing these days? ;)
 
Wow! You certainly knew that answer!

That said, are you really suggesting you favor Xenarwen? Madam Lisp? She who whines ( . . . )


Argh no :)

My "I'm glad Glorfindel wasn't in these films" is perhaps better described as an out of context "silver (golden) lining" . . . in other words, very generally speaking, I might, at least, have felt like ripping out patches of my beard while seeing Jackson's version of what I imagine as a shining paragon of Elven-ness.

In the actual context of the film I would not have Arwen appear as she did, or at all in the scene before Frodo gets to Rivendell. I have a couple of different ideas for this scene, but I won't delve into them here. And as it turns out, for my imagined version, I cast Arwen way back in the early 1980s -- her name is Joyce Penelope Wilhelmina Frankenberg.

💥
 
My "I'm glad Glorfindel wasn't in these films" is perhaps better described as an out of context "silver (golden) lining" . . . in other words, very generally speaking, I might, at least, have felt like ripping out patches of my beard while seeing Jackson's version of what I imagine as a shining paragon of Elven-ness.

As I said, I'm a bit of a nerd. I would concur that Jackson would likely have butchered Glorfindel much like he did a number of other characters. I honestly think the only reason the character of Saruman made it through the films in fairly close to one piece was because Christopher Lee was such an avid fan himself that he advocated for the character's integrity. I think the singular reason Sean Bean was cast as Boromir was because he was going to die, and hey, it's Sean Bean and that's what he does! Really, I might have thought of any number of better options for Boromir. I digress more than we've already digressed, however, and the poor casting choices is an entire discussion to itself. I will simply say here that when you take an obsessive personality and you give that person a childhood not unlike Harry Potter's, and hand them a copy of Lord of the Rings, well, you end up with someone like me. Quick wit, sharp tongue, and encyclopedic knowledge of a number of different nerdy subcultures. Cheers to that, though.


And as it turns out, for my imagined version, I cast Arwen way back in the early 1980s -- her name is Joyce Penelope Wilhelmina Frankenberg.


I may not be as old as you are, but I'm hardly young. I grew up on Doctor Quinn. Very good choice for Arwen. That said, she'd be far too old now. If they were to do a remake, who would you cast now? Personally, I'd go with someone like Summer Glau, especially if the producers/writers/directors were planning on writing up the part again to be more than a bit thing. She can pull the soft spoken, demure thing well, while not sacrificing the radiating power, and she looks elegant in a potato sack. The fact that she can kill you with her brain doesn't hurt either. (Nerd reference for five points...)
 
I can't remember. I blacked out somewhere during the battle because my own dream was employing too much "shakey-cam" to properly view all the fight choreography.

🥴
 
Apparently he played as an extra in all three, just I've never found him in the other two (and could care less if I ever do)
 
Didn't he "receive" an arrow at Helm's Deep?
That received arrow was in RoTK, a pirate (Umbar) captain challenging Aragorn with the "you and what army?" bit. Thought I think in might only have been in the EE ...
Legolas was not aiming to kill, but shooting just off the ear of someone on that ship due to Aragorn mouthing something not heard until perhaps 19th century British navy ...
It was Gimli nudging Legolas's bow that took down PJ - probably to roars of approval by book nerds; though even they may have had needed more than one viewing of the RoTK EE, and most likely the appendices to it where the cameos of PJ and other non-actors were explained.
 
Ah, so it was in there?

I admit, I would have aimed at another part of his anatomy. 😁
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top