• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Discussion Discussion for Maitimelia's Story Gifts

Aww, your review made me smile so big! I'm still grinning like an idiot even right now! 😂

Yeah, Maitimo understands suffering for sure. My understanding of Lómion-- our version of him at least-- is he needs somebody who understands the dark side of suffering.

The meeting with Lord Snottington (or Pasta) was hilarious! (Just as his name is)
Love seeing Sarcastimo in action! And reading your description, your comic art of Jim was just a constant image in my mind!
Hehe, very good! I actually didn't have Pasta in mind for his name; I just thought it was funny that Preston, which is a real-life name that sounds kinda pretentious and like it belongs to a pompous English lord, can actually be a Sindarin name. 😂 (Presta + masculine suffix -on). But, he can absolutely be as pasty and noodley as Pasta too!

And of course, the pistachio headcanon! 😂
Or should I say...canon? 👀
Absolutely canon. Change my mind.

And I know we haven't really gotten to the point where Lómion can interact with Timo when he's not injured or at the verge of death, but this characterization of him was spot on! Can't wait to go back on and resuming that story!
Same!! (I was actually rereading a bit of the end of TAtED just now)

The eyeliner was (before I read the title of course) unexpected but very much appreciated! Lómion would ROCK an eyeliner! And so would Kano and Curvo. And they can all judge Tyelko for his blush pink make up! 😂
Absolutely!! I think they'd all look hot in eyeliner, hehe!

(Also, I hope you noticed the reference to Tyelko's trauma from walking in on his parents lol!!)

The cookies! 🥺
Again, loved the lil nod towards our own dynamics! Maitimo must have put a lot of work on them. With just one hand, as Lómion said. 🥺
Dadtimo is the best Timo. And dad.
Very true!!

Fun fact, my sister once told me she learned how to crack an egg with one hand. She worked at a smoothie place for like 3 years and she just found it faster and more convenient to only need 1 hand to crack an egg with. So, I figured Maitimo has the same skill (though I imagine it was quite a learning curve to get him to that point... imagine lots of him lying on the kitchen floor, crying and surrounded by broken eggs 🥺)

AWWW WHAAAAAT I didn't know the willow tree was your favorite!! 🥺 That almost made me cry right there!!! Actually, I was going to make it a fruit tree at first, like an apple tree or cherry tree. But then I had a thought to make sure I read your birthday story for Glorfy all the way through, just to see if there was anything else I could glean from your Lómion (since in TAtED, he was immersed in horrific trauma, and we haven't gotten to explore the more casual side of him much). And then I was like, ope! No pink flowering trees for him! Maybe he'd like a weeping willow because it has Sad Vibes and he can use it to hide from people!

Yeah! And I wanted him to open up about her naturally rather than Timo forcing the issue.

The ending was pure sweetness. Lómion loves his Ada, embarrassing as he is. 🥺
Of course! And Timo loves his Goth Son very much!
 
Dadtimo is the best Timo. And dad.
I would agree. This was very sweet. 🥺

Preston’s bored expression grew slightly more intrigued, as though he had added a fine addition to his collection of gossip.
Hehehe. :>

Lómion smirked and paused his digging to glance up at Maitimo. “Ada, you’re such a sap!”

“Ah, your uncle Curufin would love you forever if he heard you make such a pun!”
Oh absolutely. >_>

Again I say, the whole thing was very sweet. And very well thought out. Lots of little moments that I chuckled at, and others which I found very touching and heartwarming.
 
One year later, Part 2 is up, which brings this story to a close!

Happy Belated Birthday, @Glorfindel Goldtress ! This story was a blast to write, and I hope a blast to read as well! It took me a while to think what our cousin-twins' shenanigans should actually be, but the idea of Glorfindel teaching Tyelko and the twins a silly little lesson jumped out at me (literally), and the characters took the lead from there!

Also, since the situation of Findis' marriage has no elaboration by Tolkien, I had to come up with a name for her husband. Fanyareno means "of the skies," and one reason why I picked that was because of that one art of Glorfindel playing the trust-fall game with the eagle!

I also had fun playing with the subtle differences in Maitimo and Glorfindel's personalities, since they're so alike on the surface but have some important core differences.

Enjoy, and I can't wait to hear your thoughts!
 
THIS IS SO BEAUTIFUL! I am gleefully giddy over every second of it and was grinning the whole time! I loved it so much and laughed so much throughout, hence why I ended up reacting with haha at the end.

I had so many thoughts here and there! (and made so many noises!!)

As hard as it was to stifle his bubbling extrovertedness...
Yep, that is so real. Particularly during sleepovers with cousins in the wee hours...! Which is pretty much into what Glorfindel's headed!

Funny... this gave him a... shiny new idea
Ideas are very shiny. I would know.

Maitimo only hoped there was enough bounce in his step as he socialized with the guests at the ball. How exhausting it already was to pretend to be Laurë even just for an hour!
I could not stop laughing at this for some reason with Maitimo struggling to do the precise opposite.

Okay, this also cracked me up. It's so precious he's so concerned, but I'm just picturing the parents' faces and dying over here.

"You look just like my son. I don’t understand.”
This also cracked me up because Findis is telling us if Glorfindel and Maedhros were to Parent Trap them, it would go off without a hitch.

Laughing here again. Both for the reason you're expecting but also because I think it is hilarious when Elves say some version of "what on Arda", perhaps because I also say it. (And I wondered if perhaps you were making a reference to my frequent usage of such because it happens several times in the story. 😂 )

Glorfy is so sweet and sensitive to Maitimo's tendencies. 🥺

Cracking open the door, he found Tyelko sprawled on his bed—lying on his stomach on top of the blankets, with one leg bent and resting on top of a pillow, one arm hanging off the bed, and his face on the very edge of the mattress.
That killed me. But also the absolute Tyelko-i-est sleeping position ever. Explains why he wakes up so easily.

Trying not to burst out in laughter, he crept closer to the bed… and then pounced on it.
Glorfindel succeeds where I would have failed because I would not have been able to hold it. 😂 I'm not even in the room, and I'm laughing. Then again, I'm not the one who has to try, but I know the feeling all too well.

If I didn’t know any better, I’d almost think you got possessed by our cousin Laurë.”
😂😂😂🧐🧐🧐

Laughing again now at Maitimo as I realized here I was still picturing the pair with their original hair colors sometimes and not noticing. I guess I see they'd really be able to fool everyone then!

Should I see her when I look like this? he wondered, making a vain attempt to smooth out his disheveled locks.
Oop. I was thinking what on Arda will Aranya be thinking if Maitimo-Glorfindel shows up? 🫨

I love your depiction of Asfaloth so much! It's extremely accurate to the books. (I love how he doesn't wear a saddle or bridle here as he has no need for such in Valinor!)

AwK. WaRd. Great way to introduce yourself while looking like a golden doppelganger! I did wonder how you were going to handle it.👀

She stared at him in bewilderment, much like Laurë’s parents had.
... “I like your real color much, much better.”
I admit I was relieved Aranya was not attracted to Maitimo-Glorfindel. That would be doubly AwKwArD.

I love the trope when the person in question appreciates the horse more than the rider.😂😂😂

It's also awkward when you might be picturing someone who isn't your love in front of you because of that hair. *Coughs* But I am also very glad to know Aranya appreciates Glorfindel's hair where it belongs.

Asfaloth took off, swift as the wind.
Again, your depiction of Asfaloth is spot-on! I do wonder if you consulted LOTR because he is literally described like this.

I absolutely LOVE this. I was cackling. Also, Curufin creating Impossible Puzzles is a perfect hobby for him. But HUAN! Why?!

Makalaurë was the only one who had figured out his real identity without any explanation, and he seemed rather unamused with the whole thing, so Laurefindelë was a bit surprised he cared enough to warn him this way
I bet Maglor was a little put out his favorite brother didn't let him in on the plan, hence his unamused demeanor, but he still has a heart! We love our watchful Maggy.

The next morning, the spell of Vána was beginning to fade. When Laurë woke up, he noticed some gold highlights beginning to appear in his auburn curls
This is giving a very mild version of Polyjuice Potion, LOL.

Yesss! I just love the wholesome Glorfindel-Tyelko dynamic. They're just hilarious and precious in their way. I am honored to have risen (*coughs*) to the occasion for our morning hunts. (And you're making me want for my Madhelko back even more! 🥺)

The mental picture of sleep-deprived yet peppy Glorfindel is adorable.🥺

“I must admit, though, I am glad to return to a place where I won’t bathe in dog drool or be in danger of my face being a canvas for food art during supper.”
😂😂😂...Valid.

I both loved and cackled at this literally beautiful moment. TWIN MATERIAL!

They grinned, bowed to each other, and parted ways.
😄You ended it almost identically to last time's.🥺🥺🥺

one reason why I picked that was because of that one art of Glorfindel playing the trust-fall game with the eagle!
I love that you remembered I shared this!!! 🥺🥺🥺 That is an excellent reference.

I also had fun playing with the subtle differences in Maitimo and Glorfindel's personalities, since they're so alike on the surface but have some important core differences
Indeed, and I love my two favorite Elves and their differences very dearly. This fanfic is a lovely representation of it all.

Thank you, mellon vuin, for your absolutely delightful gift to me. I am overjoyed to have another Tolkien twin. *Coughs*

(Also it's fun seeing how many twin things we have collectively come up with-- Fingon-Glorfindel, Aredhel-Maedhros, Fingon-Curufin, and Glorfindel-Maedhros! Who knows what might come about next? 👀)
 
THIS IS SO BEAUTIFUL! I am gleefully giddy over every second of it and was grinning the whole time! I loved it so much and laughed so much throughout, hence why I ended up reacting with haha at the end.
Oh, I'm so glad you loved it!

I could not stop laughing at this for some reason with Maitimo struggling to do the precise opposite.
What's really funny to me about all this is that Maitimo is extroverted too-- but Glorfindel is so extroverted, he makes Maitimo look like an introvert by comparison!

This also cracked me up because Findis is telling us if Glorfindel and Maedhros were to Parent Trap them, it would go off without a hitch.
Ha, yep! If not for their pure consciences, they could have pulled it off!

Asfaloth would have known something was up, though. Maglor too.

Actually, I've been saying "what in all Arda" in my writing for quite some time now! Tis a very funny and satisfying phrase! It adds a great emotional energy to say something like, "what in all Arda is going on here?"

That killed me. But also the absolute Tyelko-i-est sleeping position ever. Explains why he wakes up so easily.
Lol! I sleep in wacky positions too (maybe not that wacky, but still in an ADHD-ish sort of sleep position). I just felt like Tyelko absolutely would!

I love your depiction of Asfaloth so much! It's extremely accurate to the books. (I love how he doesn't wear a saddle or bridle here as he has no need for such in Valinor!)
Again, your depiction of Asfaloth is spot-on! I do wonder if you consulted LOTR because he is literally described like this.
Thank you! I'm pleased you found my Asfaloth accurate! Actually, I didn't consult LotR directly. I looked at the Tolkien wiki to refresh myself on some details. But overall, I guess I was able to write him that accurately because (a) I'm a bona fide Horse Girl with extensive riding experience and (b) I know how Tolkien writes in general, so "swift as the wind" just seemed like something he would say!

I admit I was relieved Aranya was not attracted to Maitimo-Glorfindel. That would be doubly AwKwArD.
It's also awkward when you might be picturing someone who isn't your love in front of you because of that hair. *Coughs* But I am also very glad to know Aranya appreciates Glorfindel's hair where it belongs.
Lol!! Don't worry, Aranya is undyingly loyal to her nér. Glorfindel is cool, but he's Not Maitimo, and anyone who is Not Maitimo is not remotely interesting to Aranya in that way. 😂 And even Maitimo with a different hair color is bordering on Not Maitimo territory.

I love the trope when the person in question appreciates the horse more than the rider.😂😂😂
Lol yes, that's become one of my preferred methods for when Aranya is trolling Maitimo! The only thing that could give him some stiff competition is a horse. 😂

I bet Maglor was a little put out his favorite brother didn't let him in on the plan, hence his unamused demeanor, but he still has a heart! We love our watchful Maggy.
Oh, good observation! I wasn't directly thinking about that, but just trying to read Maglor's mood, and he seemed unamused so I went with it. You correctly identified why, I guess!

This is giving a very mild version of Polyjuice Potion, LOL.
Ha! Glorfy and Timo would have a relatively easy experience with Polyjuice since the only thing they'd need to change is their hair!

Aww, yes, I'm also missing her very much! 🥺

😄You ended it almost identically to last time's.🥺🥺🥺
It was satisfying in its symmetry!

I love that you remembered I shared this!!! 🥺🥺🥺 That is an excellent reference.
Ah, the random things about my friends that my brain chooses to remember!

Indeed, and I love my two favorite Elves and their differences very dearly. This fanfic is a lovely representation of it all.
Same here! Way back in the beginning of my interest in the Silm, Glorfindel almost became my favorite, as you know, so it's been really fun to flesh out my version of him!

Thank you, mellon vuin, for your absolutely delightful gift to me. I am overjoyed to have another Tolkien twin. *Coughs*
You're very welcome, and you deserve it! 😊
 
Reminds me of that meme with the dude:

Blondtimo: 🙅‍♀️

Russandól: 😏
 
Happy Birthday, @Server Room Gremlin ! I have, with some trepidation, tried my hand at writing for Anca, and I hope you find I did her justice! I always grow closer to a character after trying to write them myself, and that was certainly the case here. Anca's practical and down-to-earth, yet caring nature make her a wonderful character! I really had a lot of fun exploring her dry, subtle and very deadpan humor, too.

I hope the message of the story is refreshing to you, and as always, I'm so grateful for your friendship and hope you have a wonderful, and restful, birthday!
 
At first when I saw the title, I was like: is Potatvo going to need rescuing from being launched across the room at Maitimo?? O_O (as happened in my response to that meme you sent a few days ago 😂)

But no, this did not happen, and instead I was taken on a wild ride of hilarious chaoticness. I was reading it while waiting at the train station and then sitting in the train (where I currently am now, heading to work), and I don't think I've stopped smiling the entire time! And occasionally wriggling in my seat with happy/amused energy.

Tecno and his boiled potatoes...! 😆👌


Aranya dropped her embroidery hoop and nearly fell off her chair.
I loved the way everyone's reactions or expressions were described: in-character, but in a slightly exaggerated way so that it seemed light-hearted and cartoonish. My mental images while reading this were top notch. 😸


I have, with some trepidation, tried my hand at writing for Anca, and I hope you find I did her justice!
There is always a bit of trepidation when you try to portray a character created by someone else, where it will be seen by them!
I had the sense that Tancaquárë, seeing no other option that would work, gave in to her inferior Ne (being an ISFJ) and therefore has subtle chaos gremlin vibes as she explains and carries out her plan to get these bros to become potatoes. 😂👌


I hope the message of the story is refreshing to you, and as always, I'm so grateful for your friendship and hope you have a wonderful, and restful, birthday!
Thank you for such a thoughtful story! 🥺☺️🫂 There were plenty of little things I picked up on in the course of reading, and perhaps I might come back and point out more of them.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…