• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

ELENDIL! I am Aragorn son of Arathorn!

What was Aragorn thinking?


  • Total voters
    30
None of the above!

He is stating this is who I am, this is what I stand for, consider this before you decide how to deal with me. All those who oppose the enemy should unite, not quarrel over trivial matters.

I suppose that fits into the category of stating creds!!!
 
Maybe I should have said "forcefully or assertively stating his credentials."
 
Maybe you should have. When will you ever learn!? Why can there be no harmony?

Oh, and Kelendil, isn't your Aragorn tying himself in knots by threatening Eomer and insisting he wants no quarrels?
 
Wanting no quarrels does not mean he is unwilling to take part if necessary.
 
So this is what I get when I share things "off-forum" -- grr! :mad:

I kid! :p

Anyway ---- I wanted to resurrect this fascinating thread for several reasons: for its intrinsic interest; because at least a couple of the posters are still with us, and I wanted to see if they have new insights to bring; and also (of course :rolleyes:) because I wanted to add my two bits -- somewhat random as they are.

First, it's worth noting that, as the Rohirrim are modeled on Anglo-Saxon culture (except for the horses), their customs and attitudes follow those found in Old English literature; some of the speeches, in fact, are direct translations from Beowulf, as Tom Shippey discusses in his two books

In this case, Eomer is following standard protocol: challenge and response. "Who are you, and what are you doing in this land?".

Or I should say, attempting to; as has been pointed out, rather than following the "correct" procedure, and immediately responding with his right name, lineage, and purpose, Aragorn cautiously "masks" his identity, giving only his nickname (though even here, there are precedents in ancient literature -- and especially folktales); he also witholds his true purpose, saying only that he is "hunting Orcs".

Eomer quite rightly questions this: "That is no name for a Man that you give". But then "correct procedure" is once again derailed, when his thoughtless remark about the Lady rouses Gimli's ire, and challenge. He tries to bring things back on track, pointing out that "the stranger should declare himself first", but bends enough to give his own name, lineage, and title.

Nevertheless, the situation escalates, until Aragorn interposes himself: "Your pardon, Eomer!". The immediate cause is the danger of violence, yet I can't help thinking there is an element, at least, of a recognition by Aragorn that his party, beginning with himself, has not followed customary form. After a further cautious exchange about allegiances ("First tell me whom you serve"), he is ready to declare himself.

As to that declaration, I think it is, in part, a challenge, not merely to "choose sides", though that is important, but also a personal one, man to man. Although Eomer does say "Loth am I to begin a battle of one hundred against three", I wonder if this would not be seen as a cowardly, "unmanly" act.

Be that as it may, the "choosing" is the crux of the episode. Alcuin made a cogent argument for what may have been going on in Eomer's mind: that Aragorn's claim, if true, would make him his sovereign. I'm not totally convinced about this, as he says:

"We shall not forsake our old alliance with Gondor".

And I have to wonder if, in the heat of the moment, there was time to unravel the complex history of Gondor, Arnor, Rohan, and all the conflicting claims, counterclaims, and alliances, to arrive finally at the true relationship.

My own feeling is that the real conflict is one that has structured literature since its beginnings: the conflict between two conceptions of "law".

The overcoming of an absurd or arbitrary law forms the basis of countless comedies -- it does in many of Shakespeare's, for instance -- and the failure to do so, or the destruction caused by it, structures many a tragedy; think of Antigone.

Here we have an absurd law; Eomer says:

"It is against our law to let strangers wander at will in our land, until the the king himself give them leave"

Yet how can strangers obtain "leave" from the king, without "wandering" into his land? And Eomer acknowledges that this was not always so:

"We welcomed guests kindly in better days"

The conflict, then, is between this arbitray law, and the law of good vs. evil. Eomer is torn between the two: "How should a man judge in such times?". And Aragorn lays out the "true" law starkly:

'As he has ever judged. . .Good and ill have not changed since yesteryear; nor are they one thing among Elves and Dwarves and another among Men. It is a man's part to discern them, as much in the Golden Wood as in his own house.'

It could be argued that the law barring strangers is neither arbitrary nor absurd, given the circumstances; "desperate times call for desperate measures". The king's law (or is it Wormtongue's?) could in fact be called a "natural" reaction to the present danger. But this, as I've mentioned before, is a conflict between two conceptions of "natural law": one represents nature as an order, and one belongs to nature as a fallen world.

It's also worth noticing the direct parallel (one of many) between this episode and Frodo's encounter with Faramir and his Rangers: here too we have the same conflict between arbitrary and "higher" law. The stakes are greater, as befits the increasing tension of the plot: not only is the Ring involved, but the consequences for the "decider" are more dire; one feels that, though Eomer says:

"In this, I place myself, and maybe my very life, in the keeping of your good faith"

there is a grave difference from Faramir's words:

'My life will be justly forfeit, if I now choose a course that proves ill for my city.'

Denethor would likely be far less forgiving than Theoden. And the arbitrary law is a more savage one:

'I am commanded to slay all whom I find in this land without the leave of the Lord of Gondor.'

I won't pursue the parallels further; fortunately, in both episodes the higher law is chosen.

I'll end this overlong post by saying that this thread has done what all the best threads here do: cause me to reread the relevant passages with "new eyes".

It makes me feel honored to be a member.

 
Last edited:

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top