Discussion Fellowship of the Ring What If...? The Sea Route

[ZehnWaters]

Here's where we can discuss my RPG campaign/fanfic outline. Do you think I should conjure up two more companions for the Decoy team? How do I get Frodo and Sam into Mordor if they're alone? Should they, perhaps, have a map? Or should Gollum be captured by the Fellowhip while in Tharbad or Lond Daer? Is having the remaining Fellowship in Gondor interesting enough or should I have them be doing something else since the Decoy team is basically following their route from the book?

 

[ZehnWaters]

*bump*

 

[ZehnWaters]

I've added a link so you can readily access the outline.

 

[Hisoka Morrow]

Great works, apart from some detailed combats, such as those against the corsiars, lacking how they underwent. If it's naval battles, then there must be some naval escort from Dol-Amroth Coast Guards or even Gondor Royal navy. If it's ground battles, then where it took places would also affect the battles' procedure a lot, such as battles located at fords would require military amphibious support, possibly greatly needed for Aragorn's expierences due to his records at Umbar.
One of the prefered sources of adaption would be Operation Entebbe despite the material and hardware disparity, just consider my offer

 

[ZehnWaters]

A question has come back up when revising my timeline. If Boromir survives while in the Decoy Fellowship, would he leave with Gandalf to Minas Tirith or go with Aragorn through the Paths of the Dead? If he DID go with Gandalf, would you consider Gandalf's travel to be of supernatural speed/endurance? If so, would Boromir even be able to find a horse to keep up with the dazzling Shadowfax?

 

[Berzelmayr]

I would like to make a map wit the travelings of these fellowships, but reading the outline I'm a bit confused of which is which.