• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Lack of a theme

Sadly enough, Mr. Jackson did not take into account that Tolkien's book - though popularly voted the "best" work of fiction in the 20th century with Tolkien as best author - was generally panned and is still treated with undisguised contempt by the literati and other "elitists". That means that ordinary people loved the book which also meant that Jackson could have followed Tolkien slavishly and been rewarded with the approval of the very people for whom he obvioiusly compromised the story in the first place! Tolkien's story was "loved" and even "understood" (in the main) by the ordinary guy and gal who would comprise Jackson's target audience. He didn't have to do what he did to gain audience approval for his source material would have been more than enough to provide him with all the "popularity" he could have desired!

True, many people "love" these films for various reasons, but one wonders how many more would have loved them had they remained true to Tolkien. Certainly those who love them now would not have found any cause to abandon them and those of us who find ourselves in the other camp would have gladly joined with film lovers in rejoicing that at last LOTR had received a worthy screen interpretation. The saddest words of tongue or pen are the words, "it might have been...." Sad, sad, sad.............
 
Originally posted by aragil
The question then becomes 'Why change Faramir at all'. It would have been far easier to just lift the words from the book. Don't you think PJ had some reason for painting himself into that corner in the first place?
It certainly does become that question, the same question we have asked about many other
PJ-isms: "WHY?" It would indeed have been easier, and very much better, to go direct to the ready-made source material he had the privilege of working on. We get the impression that the "paintings into corners" are simply accidental, bits of carelessness, but we have to admit that
PJ must have had reasons, and BlueW has given us PJ's stated explanation of the Faramir mess:

<....you change things if you think they need to be changed.
We wanted the episode with Faramir in this particular film to have a certain degree of tension.
....very quickly in the book, Tolkien sort of backs away from there....
We wanted to make it slightly harder, to have a little more tension than there was in the book.>

This shows first that PJ has a woefully inadequate understanding, even reading, of the books;
and second that he isn't capable of putting his own ideas into practice effectively.

I have always found the book's Faramir/Frodo/Sam encounters to be full of tension; that is their major characteristic. To consider that they need "a little more tension" shows a remarkable lack of insight into the writing.
For Tolkien's "very quick backing away" substitute PJ's Faramir doing a complete about-turn,
almost without explanation, in a couple of throw-away lines. He seems to think that tension is something you can turn on and off in an instant, like a light switch.
 
No, I think that Mr. Jackson is one of those people for whom dialogue is insufficient as a means of creating tension. He would never do to film say, "The Caine Mutiny Court Martial" or "To Kill a Mockingbird" because the tension in these films is the result of the interplay among the characters without a sword or an axe in sight. He simply could not "see" any tension in Tolkien's scenes with the hobbits and Faramir because they did not contain any of what he would have considered "action"; it was mostly "talk" - and, ergo, lacking in "tension". Perhaps this explains a great deal of Mr. Jackson's "alterations" in these films. Everything has to be "bang, swish and go" for him. It is not enough that the Ring drops to the floor in Bag End with a thud (and doesn't bounce), but Gandalf has to see "the Eye" as he stoops to retrieve it. Why he then needed to go to Gondor is beyond me! That alone should have been enough to enlighten the Wizard as to the identity of the Ring! It is not enough that Frodo "disappears" in the Pony when the Ring "accidentally" slips onto his finger - in a far less believable way than happened in the book to my mind - but we have to have all that nonsense with "the Eye" again.

If these films prove nothing else, it is that Peter Jackson is hopelessly lacking in subtlety - his humor(?) alone proves that! - and that he has yet to learn the truth contained in that old adage which says that "less is sometimes more".
 
Many interesting responses. I think that Blue Wizard and Starflower stated it very efficiently. Jackson was trying to appeal to everybody. (That is not a criticism in itself!). In so doing, he picked some minor themes which he finds appealing to the general public, and put a lot of effort into them; not so with some other themes.

In other words, Jackson's Theme is appealing to the greatest number possible. And no matter how opinions vary as to the extent of his success in that -- I think he was very successful -- the fact still remains that his Theme and Tolkien's Theme are quite different.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
It is not enough that Frodo "disappears" in the Pony when the Ring "accidentally" slips onto his finger - in a far less believable way than happened in the book to my mind - but we have to have all that nonsense with "the Eye" again.

If these films prove nothing else, it is that Peter Jackson is hopelessly lacking in subtlety - his humor(?) alone proves that! - and that he has yet to learn the truth contained in that old adage which says that "less is sometimes more".
MM- for less is more see this post of mine which details some (by no means all) of the instances in which Tolkien uses the motif (or was it nonsense?) of the Eye to cow the heroes (and reader). I'm amazed that someone can be so tolerant of this repeated usage in a book, and yet so critical of it in a movie.
Regarding nobility=lack of free-will. Perhaps we are again at an impasse (i.e. fundamental inability to understand the other's viewpoint). I do not have a problem with noble deeds or heroic actions- I'm all for them. The problem I have in this instance is that in the books it is strongly hinted that Faramir (and yes, Aragorn) are not individuals who act nobly, so much as individuals born to be noble. 'The blood of Westernesse runs nearly true' in them. They are not 'created' on equal footing as mere mortals, therefore praise should not go to them, but to their creator. They are in effect created so nobly that it is more dificult for them to do evil deeds. If there is no real temptation to do evil, then free-will and choice are myths. Compare the relative temptations of Gandalf, Galadriel, Boromir, and even Sam to that of Faramir regarding the Ring (in the books, of course):
‘No!’ cried Gandalf, springing to his feet. ‘With that power I should have power too great and terrible. And over me the Ring would gain a power still greater and more deadly.’ His eyes flashed and his face was lit as by a fire within. ‘Do not tempt me! For I do not wish to become like the Dark Lord himself. Yet the way of the Ring to my heart is by pity, pity for weakness and the desire of strength to do good. Do not tempt me! I dare not take it, not even to keep it safe, unused. The wish to wield it would be too great, for my strength. I shall have such need of it. Great perils lie before me.’
...
`And now at last it comes. You will give me the Ring freely! In place of the Dark Lord you will set up a Queen. And I shall not be dark, but beautiful and terrible as the Morning and the Night! Fair as the Sea and the Sun and the Snow upon the Mountain! Dreadful as the Storm and the Lightning! Stronger than the foundations of the earth. All shall love me and despair! '
She lifted up her hand and from the ring that she wore there issued a great light that illuminated her alone and left all else dark. She stood before Frodo seeming now tall beyond measurement, and beautiful beyond enduring, terrible and worshipful. Then she let her hand fall, and the light faded, and suddenly she laughed again, and lo! she was shrunken: a slender elf-woman, clad in simple white, whose gentle voice was soft and sad.
'I pass the test,' she said. `I will diminish, and go into the West and remain Galadriel.' {also from Letters 246, 'Galadriel's rejection of the temptation was founded upon previous thought and resolve.'}
...
Boromir got up and walked about impatiently. 'So you go on,' he cried. 'Gandalf, Elrond – all these folk have taught you to say so. For themselves they may be right. These elves and half-elves and wizards, they would come to grief perhaps. Yet often I doubt if they are wise and not merely timid. But each to his own kind. True-hearted Men, they will not be corrupted. We of Minas Tirith have been staunch through long years of trial. We do not desire the power of wizard-lords, only strength to defend ourselves, strength in a just cause. And behold! in our need chance brings to light the Ring of Power. It is a gift, I say; a gift to the foes of Mordor. It is mad not to use it, to use the power of the Enemy against him. The fearless, the ruthless, these alone will achieve victory. What could not a warrior do in this hour, a great leader? What could not Aragorn do? Or if he refuses, why not Boromir? The Ring would give me power of Command. How I would drive the hosts of Mordor, and all men would flock to my banner!'
Boromir strode up and down, speaking ever more loudly: Almost he seemed to have forgotten Frodo, while his talk dwelt on walls and weapons, and the mustering of men; and he drew plans for great alliances and glorious victories to be; and he cast down Mordor, and became himself a mighty king, benevolent and wise. Suddenly he stopped and waved his arms.
...
As Sam stood there, even though the Ring was not on him but hanging by its chain about his neck, he felt himself enlarged, as if he were robed in a huge distorted shadow of himself, a vast and ominous threat halted upon the walls of Mordor. He felt that he had from now on only two choices: to forbear the Ring, though it would torment him; or to claim it, and challenge the Power that sat in its dark hold beyond the valley of shadows. Already the Ring tempted him, gnawing at his will and reason. Wild fantasies arose in his mind; and he saw Samwise the Strong, Hero of the Age, striding with a flaming sword across the darkened land, and armies flocking to his call as he marched to the overthrow of Barad-dûr. And then all the clouds rolled away, and the white sun shone, and at his command the vale of Gorgoroth became a garden of flowers and trees and brought forth fruit. He had only to put on the Ring and claim it for his own, and all this could be.
...
But Faramir sat down again in his chair and began to laugh quietly, and then suddenly became grave again.
'Alas for Boromir! It was too sore a trial! ' he said. `How you have increased my sorrow, you two strange wanderers from a far country, bearing the peril of Men! But you are less judges of Men than I of Halflings. We are truth-speakers, we men of Gondor. We boast seldom, and then perform, or die in the attempt. Not if I found it on the highway would I take it I said. Even if I were such a man as to desire this thing, and even though I knew not clearly what this thing was when I spoke, still I should take those words as a vow, and be held by them.
The Ring has a power to play on individual's desires, to make them (at least) momentarily imagine that they can achieve good through use of the Ring. What does it mean if the Ring has no ability to use this Siren call on Faramir? Is there nothing in his character that could be tempted? This is how he appears to be written, and if so then he has no free-will in acting any way other than 'good'.
 
Without trying to get too caught up here in the details, I would like to reassert Bjarki's contentions:
1)PJ does have a Theme (actually a Thematic trinity- fundamental nature of world is good, noone is beyond redemption, free-will makes choice a necessity).
2)PJ's theme comes from the books.

Is anyone going to seriously challenge these assertions? To be honest, so far all I have seen is people either ignoring my points or saying (in various words) that "even if this Theme could be found in the movie, it is not because PJ put it there". No offense intended, but I think we can do better as film critics than simply saying "Jackson's Theme is appealing to the greatest number possible".
 
To answer the last first: Tolkien's theme is that the world is not fundamentally good nor is no one "beyond redemption. Both of these would have been alien to his Catholic beliefs. The world is marred before it is even begun. It is marred by Morgoth who in fact is beyond redemption as is Sauron and later Saruman after him. Arda is fundamentally flawed even as it is created. Nienna brings her lamentation of Melkor's depredations into the very song with which Arda is created. So at least two of Jackson's "themes" are fundamentally flawed and do not reflect Tolkien. The third regarding free will is of course a matter of fact and is part of Tolkien's story. Using free will, Saruman falls while Gandalf stands; Boromir falls while Faramir stands and so forth. That is a "gimme" under the circumstances.

However, to return to the "nobility" theme: nothing could be further from the truth that Aragorn and Faramir are what they are by virtue of their blood. Consider: Denethor is Faramir's father and that blood does "run true" in him - but what is his fate? Like the Kings of Numenor, he renounces "salvation" and "freely chooses" to end his own life in the folly of his hubris (oerweening pride). Certainly the blood of Westernesse ran true in all those Kings of Numenor who became enemies of the Valar and Iluvatar thereby. No, "blood" is/was no guarantor of nobility for either Aragorn or Faramir. Their nobility was a matter of their own choices and although certainly many of the "powers" they possessed (such as very long life) were inherited, their nobility was not.

And finally, as for "the Eye": yes, Tolkien used it, but he never had it appear early on in the story (in Bree, for instance). The Ring's force is far more subtle. It attempts to lure Frodo into putting it on thus revealing himself to the Riders. Do you mean to tell me that this is what happened every time Bilbo put on the Ring to escape unwelcome guests??? Hardly! By making the Ring so powerful that early in the story, it makes it almost impossible to imagine how Frodo could have put it on in Parth Galen even to escape Boromir.

Further, as I said, had Gandalf actually perceived the Eye when he touched the Ring (which he took care not to do in the book, touching only the envelope in which Bilbo had placed it before he left), then what further need would there have been for "research" in Gondor? Unless Jackson's Gandalf is as dense as his Treebeard, the matter would have been settled or at least settled to the extent that the Wizard would have left the Shire immediately with Frodo to seek sanctuary in Rivendell until the identity of the Ring could be explored more fully. As it was, Gandalf merely leaves the thing lying on the floor. For all he knew, Frodo might have walked in the door and accidentally kicked it under the furniture! Hardly in keeping with the "keep it safe, keep it secret" mantra that the Wizard impresses upon the new Bearer as he leaves to research the matter in Minas Tirith!
 
Originally posted by Eriol
Jackson was trying to appeal to everybody.
Jackson's Theme is appealing to the greatest number possible.
Tolkien's work has consistently appealed to the "everybody" that was the greatest reading public of the twentieth century.
PJ had the privilege of receiving that work as the raw material for his product.
Why, then, was he apparently not satisfied that the material as it stood, or the parts of it which could be accomodated within the limited scope of the medium of film, would appeal to "everybody"?
On what grounds do you claim that PJ's supposed theme appeals to that "greatest number", to which I assume you add the implication of "a greater number than Tolkien's works could have provided"?
If there's one quality that PJ all too obviously possesses in abundance it's, as Mrs M says, Hubris.

PS to Aragil : a big thank you for all those great quotations from the books. It's a pleasure to be reminded in these surroundings that TLOTR really is a superb work of literature.
Contrast any of those lines with "no-one tosses a dwarf" and you will see what I mean.
"We boast seldom, and then perform". Are you listening, PJ?
 
The difference between the amount of people it takes to make a successful novel and a successful movie are vastly different. Just because a book is successful does not mean that the corresponding movie will be.

Did PJ blow it by not allowing himself to believe enough in the material he had? Probably.

Did PJ hedge his bet by trying to make a modern action picture out of a fantasy novel? Most definetly.

Is it hubris? I don't think it was when they were making the first film. Making the movies and planning three of them was an enormous gamble. The success of the first film perhaps fed the ego enough to reach the level you're implying, but I don't think anyone went into it that way. I think they were so scared of failing that they tried to appeal to the largest possible audience. Which is what I already pointed out a couple of posts ago.
 
Originally posted by Blue Wizard
The difference between the amount of people it takes to make a successful novel and a successful movie are vastly different.
....they tried to appeal to the largest possible audience. Which is what I already pointed out a couple of posts ago.
You don't mean, do you, that in the case of LTOTR there is a vast difference between the number of people who have read and will read the books and the number of those who have seen and will see the films?
I haven't counted lately, but I don't think there's likely to be such a margin between them.
My question is: what reason had they for thinking that the largest possible audience would not consist of people who wanted to see an accurate representation of the books, as they did, to a large extent, in FOTR?
And I already pointed out my question, several times, several posts ago!
 
Originally posted by joxy
You don't mean, do you, that in the case of LTOTR there is a vast difference between the number of people who have read and will read the books and the number of those who have seen and will see the films?
I haven't counted lately, but I don't think there's likely to be such a margin between them.
My question is: what reason had they for thinking that the largest possible audience would not consist of people who wanted to see an accurate representation of the books, as they did, to a large extent, in FOTR?
And I already pointed out my question, several times, several posts ago!
Absolutely I meant that.

There are three scenarios.

1. People who have read the books and seen the movies.
2. People who only read the books.
3. People who have only seen the movies.

Of the people who only have seen the movies there are two types. Those that would read the books and those that will never read the books.

To maximize the movie audience pool that you can draw from you have to pull from both types from #3. If the FOTR movie was dead letter to the book (except for a few minor agreed upon changes) and it was a dissapointment to my eight year old for example (who absolutely loves the films) that would detract from possible audience. Women (unlike Mrs. M but very much like my wife) love the chick flick aspect. The love story that was strewn in there appeases them (actually my wife falls into category 4 - none of the above, but that is a different issue).

Your question is unanswerable except to speculate which is what we all have been doing. You are so hard headed on this issue that you keep repeating it as if you already know the answer (or are dead set on your opinion) that anyone else's is irrelevant.

If you believe that the films would have been a success if they had stuck to the books entirely, I can't argue with you. We'll never know in our lifetime either because I highly doubt someone would ever attempt such a feat.

If I was to garner a guess, I would say that the reason they felt that the largest possible audience was not possible with an accurate representation of the books was based on sales figures for other films of the same genre. You look at any fantasy film over the years and I doubt you will find one that has enjoyed the cross over audience and appeal that PJ's Lord of the Rings has. I believe they were afraid that if they didn't try and do that they were going to pigeonhole themselves into a smaller audience,
 
Mrs. Maggott's opinion:
To answer the last first: Tolkien's theme is that the world is not fundamentally good nor is no one "beyond redemption. Both of these would have been alien to his Catholic beliefs. The world is marred before it is even begun. It is marred by Morgoth who in fact is beyond redemption as is Sauron and later Saruman after him. Arda is fundamentally flawed even as it is created. Nienna brings her lamentation of Melkor's depredations into the very song with which Arda is created. So at least two of Jackson's "themes" are fundamentally flawed and do not reflect Tolkien.
Tolkien's opinion, as expressed in Letter 153 to Peter Hastings, discussing Orcs:
They would be Morgoth's greatest Sins, abuses of his highest privilege, and would be creatures begotten of Sin, and naturally bad. (I nearly wrote 'irredeemably bad'; but that would be going too far. Because by accepting or tolerating their making – necessary to their actual existence – even Orcs would become part of the World, which is God's and ultimately good.)
To me this means that the World is good, and that nothing is irredeemable. Tolkien wrote this letter to the owner of a Catholic bookstore, one who had claimed that Tolkien had 'over-stepped the mark in metaphysical matters'. If this is how Tolkien explains himself, then I have to assume that you are mistaken by saying these Themes would both 'have been alien to his Catholic beliefs'.
 
Indeed, that is what I also pointed out: that the elitists hated the book and that average people loved it. It would seem to me that if Jackson wished to appeal to "average people", he would have remained as true as he possibly could to the book since all those "average people" loved it enough to consider it the best book of the last century!

This wasn't "War and Peace" or "Moby ****" or some other very deep and difficult story. Admittedly, Tolkien had very subtle threads in his work, but he also had very straightforward themes that even young people could understand. In fact, LOTR is like an onion - layers and layers of meaning. One reads it at 15 and sees one thing, at 20 another, at 30 yet deeper meanings and so forth. Jackson had nothing to fear in remaining true to Tolkien and so I really do not believe that he made the changes he did because he was afraid that his audience wouldn't "understand" or "accept" the story. I think he made them because he thought he could tell the story better - and that really is hubris!
 
Originally posted by Blue Wizard
Absolutely I meant that.

I believe they were afraid that if they didn't try and do that they were going to pigeonhole themselves into a smaller audience.
I was talking about two numbers:
the number of people who have read, in the last fifty years, and will read, Tolkien's books,
and
the number of people who have seen, in the last three years, and will see, PJ's films.
It would theoretically be possible to assess, and extrapolate, the size of these numbers on the basis of the number of books, hardback, paperback, in every language of the world, sold, and of the number of cinema seats, videos, and DVDs sold.
Did you "absolutely mean" that one of these figures would be "vastly different" from the other - and which would be the greater?!

I believe that Mrs M has the true answer to the second point: PJ's reasons for change were much more to do with his hubris than with his pigeons!
 
I guess will have to agree to disagree on how large PJ's ego is. I'll readily admit it is very large, but I don't think it is quite as large as you and Mrs. M think it is.
 
Originally posted by Blue Wizard
I guess will have to agree to disagree on how large PJ's ego is. I'll readily admit it is very large, but I don't think it is quite as large as you and Mrs. M think it is.
You have to admit to one of two things: either Jackson changed the story because he was ignorant about the story itself and the type of people who loved it (ordinary people) or he thought he could "tell it better" and therefore his changes were made with that belief in mind. Given the fact that his changes to the characters were every bit as "subtle" as the original characters - that is, the characters were different, but certainly no easier to understand - then you have to accept one of the above reasons for the changes that he made.

Remember, I am not speaking now of the simplifications that he made (no Tom, Glorfindel, Old Forest etc.) but of his changes to the individual characters of the story which have been rehashed too many times to need restatement here. After all, Jackson's Aragorn is not a "simplified" character, merely a different one. If anything, his character requires more exposition and explanation that did Tolkien's, so it cannot be said that he did what he did for reasons of time constraints. And the same can be said of most of his other changes (and plot deviations) which added not only to the time in and of themselves, but which required additional screen time to "set up" and then "complete".

So in the end, the "article of faith" that most FADs have chanted throughout these discussions - that Jackson made his changes because he was doing film - cannot be supported by the facts.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
You have to admit to one of two things: either Jackson changed the story because he was ignorant about the story itself and the type of people who loved it (ordinary people) or he thought he could "tell it better" and therefore his changes were made with that belief in mind.
Ok, If I have to admit one of these I will go with option 1. I don't believe he thought he could "tell it better".
 
Originally posted by Blue Wizard
Ok, If I have to admit one of these I will go with option 1. I don't believe he thought he could "tell it better".

Fine. But then that calls into question the Director's credibility given that he assured everyone that LOTR was a beloved book for him. Ergo, we have two options again: [1] it wasn't and therefore he was ignorant of it and its "public" as noted in my first "option 1" (and therefore was being untruthful when he said otherwise); or [2] he did know and read the book as he alleged - and chose to do it his own way. But whichever of these two options you chose, in the first instance Jackson's truthfulness and credibility are somewhat tarnished, wouldn't you say? And in the second, we are back to a man who thought he could tell the story better than its creator.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Fine. But then that calls into question the Director's credibility given that he assured everyone that LOTR was a beloved book for him. Ergo, we have two options again: [1] it wasn't and therefore he was ignorant of it and its "public" as noted in my first "option 1" (and therefore was being untruthful when he said otherwise); or [2] he did know and read the book as he alleged - and chose to do it his own way. But whichever of these two options you chose, in the first instance Jackson's truthfulness and credibility are somewhat tarnished, wouldn't you say? And in the second, we are back to a man who thought he could tell the story better than its creator.
I can't analyze it. Perhaps his EGO was so large that he thought he could do it better. I think they got caught up in making a movie. Well, this would be neat, or that would be neat, or how about we do this, or wouldn't it be cool to do that? I had heard that he wanted to try a fantasy film first, and then Lord of the Rings came up second. So, PJ, probably wants to do as much of HIS MOVIE as he can within the context of The Lord of the Rings. I don't think an exacting adaptation was ever a consideration.
 
Please don't get me wrong. Legally, Mr. Jackson could pretty much do as he chose. However, I have been told from the beginning that everything he did was [1] the result of his making a film rather than writing a book - something which turned out to be rather untrue in the main; [2] that he had to do what he did because of time constraints - which never made sense when he added plot elements (warg riders, Osgiliath etc.) to the films; [3] that New Line made him do it or he did it because he didn't think that the original story would appeal to "his" audience - which is nonsense given that LOTR has been ultra popular not among cultural elites, but the same average people for whom Jackson ostensibly targeted the film!

Ergo, it is really not so much Jackson that's the problem in my mind (although, of course, what he did is a problem regarding my enjoyment of the films), but those people who seem to be able to find an excuse for any depradation of the Director's rather than just coming forward and admitting that he made a mistake in doing whatever is under discussion! Or, in the alternative, saying that even though what Jackson did was diametric to the book, they approved of it! Either would have been quite satisfactory for me since it would have admitted that what had been done needn't have. As it is, however, most "purists" are told that we "don't understand" or "it had to be done" or "it's really the same - except that it's different!". All of these particular rejoinders make one feel more than a little inadequate for complaining in the first place.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top