• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Lack of a theme

Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
As it is, however, most "purists" are told that we "don't understand" or "it had to be done" or "it's really the same - except that it's different!". All of these particular rejoinders make one feel more than a little inadequate for complaining in the first place.
I don't think I have ever said that to a "purists". What I have always said was I got better than I expected. I am extremely cynical about movies that are made from "adaptations" of other mediums that I love. They most generally end up being disasters of the 1st order. You have every right to complain, and I have learned a whole bunch from those complaints. I appreciate that.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Please don't get me wrong. Legally, Mr. Jackson could pretty much do as he chose. However, I have been told from the beginning that everything he did was [1] the result of his making a film rather than writing a book - something which turned out to be rather untrue in the main; [2] that he had to do what he did because of time constraints - which never made sense when he added plot elements (warg riders, Osgiliath etc.) to the films; [3] that New Line made him do it or he did it because he didn't think that the original story would appeal to "his" audience - which is nonsense given that LOTR has been ultra popular not among cultural elites, but the same average people for whom Jackson ostensibly targeted the film!
How about a fourth alternative: [4] Jackson had his own idea of how he wanted to tell Tolkien's tale. He therefore decided to change certain characters and events to emphasize Themes in the movie (which were originally present in the book). Anybody care to investigate this possibility?
 
Originally posted by aragil
How about a fourth alternative: [4] Jackson had his own idea of how he wanted to tell Tolkien's tale. He therefore decided to change certain characters and events to emphasize Themes in the movie (which were originally present in the book). Anybody care to investigate this possibility?
Isn't that the same thing as "tell it better"? Less negative way to put it but it is virtually the same thing.
 
Originally posted by Blue Wizard
Isn't that the same thing as "tell it better"? Less negative way to put it but it is virtually the same thing.
"Tell it better" implies judgement on PJ's part that something was lacking in the book version. "Tell it differently" gets away from that- fairly meaningless unless we want to say something about the hubris of the director (which we might).
 
Originally posted by aragil
"Tell it better" implies judgement on PJ's part that something was lacking in the book version. "Tell it differently" gets away from that- fairly meaningless unless we want to say something about the hubris of the director (which we might).
I understand that. I am just trying to reach some common ground on the issue and I think we have for the first time in this thread. I'm a little less inclined to go with the huge "ego" argument that is being put forth, but I can't discount it either.
 
Originally posted by Blue Wizard
I understand that. I am just trying to reach some common ground on the issue and I think we have for the first time in this thread. I'm a little less inclined to go with the huge "ego" argument that is being put forth, but I can't discount it either.
Common ground? Bah!!:)
My ulterior motive is to try and sneak back into discussing Themes- book and movie. I think PJ has at least a moderate ego (you don't try to make something as huge as LotR without a little ego). I also think that PJ is quite proud of WETA etc, and that by making a movie as large as LotR he will be wooing a lot of business away from US companies like Lucas', and this might explain a small portion of the extended troll-fight in FotR, or the warg-fight in TTT. That said, I also think that PJ and the other writers (especially Philipa Bowens) have a huge amount of love and respect for Tolkien's work. I think that changes from the novel result from many things, most prominent of which is a shift in media. Most germaine to this thread, I think that PJ was trying to follow a Theme from the books, and that (ironically) many of his changes reflect this Theme.
 
Originally posted by aragil
I also think that PJ and the other writers (especially Philipa Bowens) have a huge amount of love and respect for Tolkien's work.
If that is the case, then how can they try to pass off dwarf-tossing and orc-hunting as if they were Tolkien's?
The horrible clashing quality of most of the invented dialogue is one of the worst features of the films, and it is made all the worse by the fact that to Tolkien language was specificially of the highest importance.
 
Originally posted by joxy
If that is the case, then how can they try to pass off dwarf-tossing and orc-hunting as if they were Tolkien's?
The horrible clashing quality of most of the invented dialogue is one of the worst features of the films, and it is made all the worse by the fact that to Tolkien language was specificially of the highest importance.
My recollection is that they didn't. Orc-hunting is unattested, but IIRC PB blamed PJ for dwarf-tossing, and tried to distance herself from it. In any case, I have never claimed that linguistic integrity was maintained from book to movie. I have, however, claimed that Thematic integrity is maintained. ;)
 
My dear Joxy, again I must disagree. It is not the appalling dialogue that is the problem really, it is the appalling attitude that is behind the dialogue. Had it been merely an innocent mistake (the result of some local idiomatic usage of the language), it would have been easily forgotten and/or overlooked. But the simple fact is that no sooner does Jackson create a tense or dramatic scene than he has to go and make some "in" joke that ridicules his own script, for heaven's sake! He just doesn't seem to be able to direct a great story as drama; but rather, he seems to continually want to "nudge, nudge, wink, wink" with his audience so that they know that he too is not taking it all that seriously and is therefore "cool" and "with it" (or whatever other modern cliche indicates sarcasm and cynicism). It is this attitude which has destroyed these films for me. It begins slowly and is not terribly noticable in FOTR but it begins to hit its stride in TTT, ruining moments of drama, passion, excitement and true humor as they occur within the films. Doubtless, we will see more of the same in ROTK as it seems to be the Director's hallmark.
 
Originally posted by aragil
I have, however, claimed that Thematic integrity is maintained. ;)
Oh, there's no doubt about that, more's the pity (see the above post). Mr. Jackson has certainly maintained his "theme". Unfortunately, it is not the theme of the original story. Indeed, it seems to be more the type of "theme" that provides a "tongue in cheek" old fashioned high adventure. Great viewing on a rainy Saturday afternoon just before Pirates of the Carribbean and after The Mummy. All visually spectacular, no doubt, all with the same glitzy package and self-deprecating humor. What a package! Unfortunately, that type of film can never be viewed with any degree of seriousness and still less as having anything truly profound and worthwhile to offer. And so we have Peter Jackson's LOTR, another "in joke" for the South Park-Simpsons' set. :rolleyes: :( :mad:
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Unfortunately, that type of film can never be viewed with any degree of seriousness and still less as having anything truly profound and worthwhile to offer. And so we have Peter Jackson's LOTR, another "in joke" for the South Park-Simpsons' set. :rolleyes: :( :mad:
Hmm. Being a lover of the Simpsons and a detester of South Park, I'm not sure exactly what set is supposed to be winking along with PJ's LotR. I watch these movies with a fairly high degree of seriousness, and I found a Theme that has nothing to do with rib-nudging or dwarf-tossing. IMO, nobody in this thread has seriously challenged that Theme, or it's derivation from the books.
 
I too love The Simpsons and can't stand South Park nor understand why it became so popular. It is my belief those guys just got lucky... they have little talent and can not write and so have to resort to using the lowest forms of comedy in almost every case.

Anyhow, I would like to know: What about Simpsons fans?

Mrs. Maggott I do not know why you can not criticize the movies without insulting an irrelevant group of people. One would think, as big of a disgrace as the movies are ;) that you would find enough within them to bash.
 
It was not an insult, but an observation. Let's face it, people who like both or either show(s) are into a rather cynical form of humor. I have watched both (and like neither), but I can understand how many people today with our rather jaded culture get a "charge" out of humor that attacks what used to be considered sterling virtues such as patriotism, faith, etc. In a culture that holds nothing sacred, I am not surprised to find an "appreciation" of what these shows present as humor. This is not an insult by any means. I may not agree with those who like the shows, but I am not insulting them. I merely point out that Jackson's use of less than subtle "in" humor (dwarf tossing etc.) is a play to that same sort of humor and is doubtless appreciated by those who themselves are "in" to it.

My point is that by using such humor, Jackson definitely ruins the "theme" and/or "mood" of the films - and produces something similar to those that use a blend of spectacular visuals, exciting plot and "in" humor such as Pirates of the Carribbean and the two Mummy films. If you doubt me, I suggest that you watch these films carefully and you will see the sort of humor to which I allude ("Keep him busy!" "I deserved that..." etc.). But I think that most LOTR lovers would admit that Tolkien's story is something else again and I personally found that it did not successfully survive this kind of treatment by Jackson. However, again, this is not a criticism but merely an observation.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
My dear Joxy, again I must disagree. It is not the appalling dialogue that is the problem really, it is the appalling attitude that is behind the dialogue.
But the simple fact is that no sooner does Jackson create a tense or dramatic scene than he has to go and make some "in" joke.
He just doesn't seem to be able to direct a great story as drama; but rather, he seems to continually want to "nudge, nudge, wink, wink" with his audience so that they know that he too is not taking it all that seriously and is therefore "cool".
It begins slowly and is not terribly noticable in FOTR but it begins to hit its stride in TTT, ruining moments of drama, passion, excitement and true humor as they occur within the films.
Well, you can try to disagree, but you don't really do so! What I said was that the invented dialogue is "one of the worst" features of the films, and you say it's "appalling" - that's near enough to agreement to satisfy me. Just to emphasise the point again, the inventions are all the worse precisely because quality of language is a vital feature of Tolkien, the philologist - lover of words.
All the rest is also so true: for PJ, every great moment has to have a moment of bathos hanging on its tail; he may pretend for a while that he's a serious artist, but soon he has to demonstrate that he's really a jolly shorts-wearing teddy bear.
You are right, of course, about FOTR, but I have just come from watching anew the first hour of TTT, and there the trait is undeniable. It is actually a magnificent hour in many respects, but the corny phrases and silly jokes are peppered through it, and it ends with the old impression on the mind: "just think what that COULD have been".
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
....I can understand how many people today with our rather jaded culture get a "charge" out of humor that attacks what used to be considered sterling virtues such as patriotism, faith, etc. In a culture that holds nothing sacred, I am not surprised to find an "appreciation" of what these shows present as humor.
As far as I know South Park is unadulterated rubbish, but I've heard it claimed that The Simpsons DOES defend some of the old values. That doesn't prevent it too from being rubbish, and I've no interest in defending it, but if the claims are true then it doesn't deserve to be placed on quite the same low level as the other stuff.
 
Originally posted by joxy
As far as I know South Park is unadulterated rubbish, but I've heard it claimed that The Simpsons DOES defend some of the old values. That doesn't prevent it too from being rubbish, and I've no interest in defending it, but if the claims are true then it doesn't deserve to be placed on quite the same low level as the other stuff.
Please don't misunderstand me. I am not trying to either attack or defend these "cartoons". Indeed, they are not alone in "making fun" of what used to be considered worthwhile and even "sacred" virtues and institutions in the culture. And it may also be the case that one or both from time to time make excellent points in their "humor" - very much the way that wise kings used jesters to "pop the bubble" of pride and pomposity that such folk were apt to assume given their exalted status.

My whole point in using these particular examples is that there can be no doubt that the humor used in both is very much cynicism rather than the good old fashioned "funny stuff" used by Disney or W.B. in their cartoons. Nor yet, is it the gentle poke at our more pompous selves used by the folks who bring us Peanuts or Garfield. Both programs to which I alluded are by their very nature, cynical. Of course, cynicism is often quite funny - but it is a very dark humor and C. S. Lewis was wont to rant against it. I find Jackson's attempts at humor in FOTR and TTT to be the same sort of thing. Not nearly as cynical, of course, but definitely out of phase with the story. He uses modern idioms and "in" jokes (as they did in PotC and TM and TMR) which definitely wrench the audience out of the "era" in which the film is set and make it in and of itself a joke. Of course, this isn't to bad in The Mummy films because they are supposed to not be that "ancient", but in the case of the LOTR films, it is disastrous.
 
As far as I know South Park is unadulterated rubbish, but I've heard it claimed that The Simpsons DOES defend some of the old values. That doesn't prevent it too from being rubbish, and I've no interest in defending it, but if the claims are true then it doesn't deserve to be placed on quite the same low level as the other stuff.
Please don't misunderstand me. I am not trying to either attack or defend these "cartoons". Indeed, they are not alone in "making fun" of what used to be considered worthwhile and even "sacred" virtues and institutions in the culture. And it may also be the case that one or both from time to time make excellent points in their "humor" - very much the way that wise kings used jesters to "pop the bubble" of pride and pomposity that such folk were apt to assume given their exalted status.
I'm afraid I must diverge from the main point to reply to these statements. I've watched only about 20 or so 'South Park' episodes, yet agree with many of the points made in them.

Some of the points made:
-showing the rather obvious stupidity of cultural fads, such as Pokemon.
-making the case that the courts should not be allowed to force others into agreeing with homosexuality
-this is one of the most obvious: children should not be spoiled or given everything they want
-taking drugs is dumb
-etc.

My only problem with it is the obvious scorn for Christianity found in some episodes.

I have never watched the Simpsons, though.
 
My point is that by using such humor, Jackson definitely ruins the "theme" and/or "mood" of the films
With poor humor the mood can indeed be marred, but how can the theme itself be ruined? Surely it will not be as seriously taken (unfortunately) or as moving, but it will be there nonetheless.

Also, please realize that this is not necessarily referring to the LotR films. ;)
 
Originally posted by Gandalf White
With poor humor the mood can indeed be marred, but how can the theme itself be ruined?
A good question Gandalf White, and on-topic too!

An observational note: Mrs Maggott, with no less than "eighteen" terms in quotes in your last three posts (and a rolleye smiley to boot!), one might accuse you of the same cynicism you find so irritating in the films.
 
Originally posted by aragil
A good question Gandalf White, and on-topic too!

An observational note: Mrs Maggott, with no less than "eighteen" terms in quotes in your last three posts (and a rolleye smiley to boot!), one might accuse you of the same cynicism you find so irritating in the films.
I don't quite understand your criticism. I put words in "quotes" because I am referring to something rather than using them in the narrative flow. If I put the word "theme" in quotes, that means I am not using it to mean what it ordinarily means. Jackson's "themes" means that I am calling into question whether in fact there were any "themes" or if what we saw was nothing less or more than the unfolding of the plot in the direction desired by the film maker(s). Jackson follows Tolkien's overall plot. I really would not be in a position to know if he even cared about any "theme" ("quotes" again) that the author intended for the work. After all, how much "theme" is there in most action-adventure-fantasy films except those that are obviously contained within the plot line (the "good guys" win etc.)? I am not convinced that Mr. Jackson had any particular "theme" in mind with these films and that, indeed, his entire concern was their overall appearance and excitement. I suppose he thought that the plot itself conveyed all the "theme" necessary. Of course, had he been more faithful to the book, that indeed would have been the case.

If my observation is "cynical" in your opinion, that is your affair. "I calls 'em as I sees 'em" as one old umpire used to say.

{Post Scriptum: my references to the two "cartoon" shows had nothing to do with any critique of same. I used them merely as a reference to the type of "cynical humor" that I found offensive in the films. No criticism of either show OR ITS VIEWERS was intended.}
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top