Originally posted by aragil
A good question Gandalf White, and on-topic too!
An observational note: Mrs Maggott, with no less than "eighteen" terms in quotes in your last three posts (and a rolleye smiley to boot!), one might accuse you of the same cynicism you find so irritating in the films.
I don't quite understand your criticism. I put words in "quotes" because I am referring to something rather than using them in the narrative flow. If I put the word "theme" in quotes, that means I am not using it to mean what it ordinarily means. Jackson's "themes" means that I am calling into question whether in fact there
were any "themes" or if what we saw was nothing less
or more than the unfolding of the plot in the direction desired by the film maker(s). Jackson follows
Tolkien's overall plot. I really would not be in a position to know if he even
cared about any "theme" ("quotes" again) that the author intended for the work. After all, how much "theme" is there in most action-adventure-fantasy films except those that are obviously contained within the plot line (the "good guys" win etc.)? I am not convinced that Mr. Jackson had
any particular "theme" in mind with these films and that, indeed, his entire concern was their overall appearance and excitement. I suppose he thought that the plot itself conveyed all the "theme" necessary. Of course, had he been more faithful to the book, that indeed would have been the case.
If my observation is "cynical" in your opinion, that is your affair. "I calls 'em as I sees 'em" as one old umpire used to say.
{Post Scriptum: my references to the two "cartoon" shows had nothing to do with any critique of same. I used them merely as a reference to the type of "cynical humor" that I found offensive in the films. No criticism of either show OR ITS VIEWERS was intended.}