S
spelling master
Guest
An ardent fan of southpark ( cant u tell from the postings?
), and there was a time the Simpsons tried to shock people....both equally good and bad at times ( southpark with their morale speeches for endings a la PJ's painful sam gamgee speeches.
But the thing is you get what u pay for in southpark, cheap cartoon with a lot of guttter humour... you cant complain !
But when u put cheap gutter humour into the works of tolkien, its just inexcusible.
Back on topic, the ONLY theme PJ went for in a major way was HOPE....the problem is he never depicted it, PJ just verbalised it thru aragron and arwen.
BAD
1. aragorn telling halas about hope when there are 10,000 uruk-hais at the front door
2. arwen says hope when all daddy is saying is that there is no hope.
3. is there hope for aragorn and arwen? dunno, since we get horse kissing
4. is there hope for a new world? we dont know but for the sam gamgee speech
Gutterfilms and action sounds B grade to me
But the thing is you get what u pay for in southpark, cheap cartoon with a lot of guttter humour... you cant complain !
But when u put cheap gutter humour into the works of tolkien, its just inexcusible.
Back on topic, the ONLY theme PJ went for in a major way was HOPE....the problem is he never depicted it, PJ just verbalised it thru aragron and arwen.
BAD
1. aragorn telling halas about hope when there are 10,000 uruk-hais at the front door
2. arwen says hope when all daddy is saying is that there is no hope.
3. is there hope for aragorn and arwen? dunno, since we get horse kissing
4. is there hope for a new world? we dont know but for the sam gamgee speech
Gutterfilms and action sounds B grade to me

