• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Lack of a theme

An ardent fan of southpark ( cant u tell from the postings? :D ), and there was a time the Simpsons tried to shock people....both equally good and bad at times ( southpark with their morale speeches for endings a la PJ's painful sam gamgee speeches.

But the thing is you get what u pay for in southpark, cheap cartoon with a lot of guttter humour... you cant complain !

But when u put cheap gutter humour into the works of tolkien, its just inexcusible.

Back on topic, the ONLY theme PJ went for in a major way was HOPE....the problem is he never depicted it, PJ just verbalised it thru aragron and arwen.

BAD

1. aragorn telling halas about hope when there are 10,000 uruk-hais at the front door

2. arwen says hope when all daddy is saying is that there is no hope.

3. is there hope for aragorn and arwen? dunno, since we get horse kissing

4. is there hope for a new world? we dont know but for the sam gamgee speech

Gutterfilms and action sounds B grade to me :D
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
....cynicism is often quite funny....I find Jackson's attempts at humor in FOTR and TTT to be the same sort of thing. Not nearly as cynical, of course, but definitely out of phase with the story. He uses modern idioms and "in" jokes....which definitely wrench the audience out of the "era" in which the film is set....
PJ's attempts ARE mildly comic, in the way that a naughty child might try to be "clever" and produce a crude joke;
"cynicism" is too mature a notion to apply to them.
It is that fact, that they are out of phase with - that they clash with - their context, the characters, the location, the era, everything, that makes them inexcusable, and indeed unaccountable, in this setting.
 
Last edited:
Blue Wizard said:
....I desire you and joxy to enjoy the films at least a little, as I am able to enjoy them because this is the only opportunity to see Tolkien's world come to life beyond our imaginations.

The scenery is stunning, the costumes beautiful, the actors (and actresses) that were chosen are perfect. Unfortunately the execution is less than desirable.
Well Aragil: I'm back! :D

To Blue Wizard: I have often said that I enjoy the first two films a lot, and Mrs M has concurred to some extent! We may not have said so in this thread, but the evidence is there in many others, and I hope that seeing that evidence will fully satisfy your desire.

Our views on scenery, costumes, actors, AND execution, are also very similar to yours!

Aragil: I'm still not convinced that PJ even possesses the concept of "themes", but I'm open to persuasion....
 
Last edited:
Alas, alack and aghast! I find that my enjoyment of these films diminished with each succeeding one. I liked FOTR and was willing to put aside JRRT and give my full attention to Mr. Jackson's "version" of the tale simply by virtue of the excellence of the first film. Indeed, on one thread - I don't remember which - I advised a fellow purist to go and see TTT, "forget" Tolkien and simply enjoy. I tried just that and got about 40 minutes into the film before I began to suspect that in order to follow my own advice, I should have left my brain at the door.

Well, I heard nothing but good about ROTK - how it was "the best" of the three films and "closest to Tolkien - so I began to hope once again- but not too much! As Pippin discovered, 'once burnt, twice shy!' Nor was I terribly encouraged when I viewed the EE of TTT. Whatever damage Jackson did to Faramir, his portrayal of Denethor indicated that he wasn't done savaging the family quite yet! And sure enough! Denethor in ROTK is absolutely, 100% awful! He's a slob, something which Tolkien's character never was. Indeed, T's Denethor is an aescetic living mostly on nerves but armed to the teeth. He may even have slept in his mail and weapons! When Pippin meets him, he breaks bread with the Wizard and the hobbit and the repast consists of a few small "white cakes" and some wine. Indeed, the hobbit is much put out by the paltry fare! Contrast this with Jackson's slobbering, ugly lout dripping grape juice down his face while Pippin soulfully sings(!) in the corner! Ghastly!!! And finally, the whole thing is climaxed by what has become a standing joke in my family: Gandalf pontificating: "Thus passes Denethor, son of Ecthelion!" as the poor wretch, ablaze like the Olympic orc's torch, runs the length of several football fields to throw himself off the parapet (and all the while, his erstwhile "guards" stand and watch stupidly!). Oh, please, please! Give me back nasty old Theoden, dim Treebeard and the endless battle of Helm's Deep! Please!!

Sigh..... so much promise..... so much money..... so much talent..... so much time..... so much research and commitment by so many..... Are these films wildly popular? At the moment, yes. Will they remain so? Who knows! Maybe they will. And maybe they even represent the best that our present coarser "culture" can produce even using Tolkien as a starting point. I can't answer that question - and frankly, I don't know anyone else who can either.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top