Did anyone make copies of any of them, I wonder, for safe keeping outside Iraq (no doubt if they were copied onto local computers, those have gone). I suspect not. Saddam would not have anticipated his downfall (and may have destroyed everything in his wake if he did ... remember the previous Gulf War?). Like Sauron's Ring, he would have thought Iraq was wrapped around his finger.Originally posted by Walter
Eledhwen: Ain't that sad, all these early documents of the Sumerian, Babylonian, Assyrian, etc. cultures now destroyed or lost ...
Those were J.R.R. Tolkien’s words at the beginning of Tree and Leaf, not Christopher Tolkien’s, so the discrepency is between to accounts given by J.R.R. Tolkien..What is still nagging me, though, is that Christopher Tolkien dates the writing of tree and leaf 1938-9, "when the Lord of the Rings was beginning to unroll itself", whereas Carpenter dates it around 1943, when Tolkien seemed stuck with his work on the LotR.
There is a good summary of the history of the scrolls at The Dead Sea Scrolls.Much of the loss (of information, not actual parchment) is, I fear, down to professional greed. I remember the trouble academics had in getting access to the Dead Sea Scrolls, because of the risk of an outsider making a great discovery. I think I remember that someone had to illicitly photograph them.
But then, in a way, Niggle is autobiographical. Certainly, it is Tolkien's reflection on "Everyman", his "here and now" life and its effects upon his "ultimate journey" - and that, perforce, must include the author himself.Originally posted by Walter
Mike, I don't think Leaf by Niggle was ever meant as an "autobiography" when Tolkien wrote that story. Rather, he was stuck during the writing of "The new Hobbit" and probably wondering if he ever would be able to find the time and energy to finish what evenually became The Lord of the Rings and to complete and revise The Silmarillion. Humphrey Carpenter describes this in his Tolkien biography:
Not unless Tolkien had more friendly neighbors than is suggested in his biography! Somehow, I can't see him climbing about fixing anyone's roof, can you?Originally posted by Walter
Of course it is "autobiographical" in an allegorical way, I think, but not an "autobiography" in the sense that it would give a more or less detailed account of his life, works, etc.
Possibly.In either case, Tolkien probably would have finished his legendarium one way or the other, but as it was, he seemed rather frustrated at first, ...
This is very pertinent. And it was not only Christian monks who had problems with older material.
Yes, an incredibly poignant and personal metaphor for himself, this was Tolkien expressing so much.It's my humble opinion that "Leaf by Niggle" is the most poignant book of JRRT and is, in effect, an autobiography. JRRT was obsessed with LOTR and ME (much to our benefit) and, like Niggle, couldn't leave it alone. The "leaf" that he drew became a tree within a field which had a background and mountains and people.
Anyone else out there care to share their thoughts on this theory ?
It's my humble opinion that "Leaf by Niggle" is the most poignant book of JRRT and is, in effect, an autobiography. JRRT was obsessed with LOTR and ME (much to our benefit) and, like Niggle, couldn't leave it alone. The "leaf" that he drew became a tree within a field which had a background and mountains and people.
Anyone else out there care to share their thoughts on this theory ?
Do you really think so? Or is it a joke?It's really a story about his 'smoking addiction' - his little niggling distraction from time to time.
Seems that most fans prefer to make his story more complex than it really is, because they need Tolkien's Leaf by Niggle to appear more sophisticated than it really is.
This interpretation is new to me. And it's interesting to hear of something new. Thanks for sharing. However, what about these qoutes (especially the last one)?No joke. Sorry to say. But Tolkien was a heavy 'piper' and even comments in LOTR about Pippen 'smoking too much'.
Leaf by Niggle is basically about his 'vice'. Surely as The Old Man of the Sea is about Hemingway's own 'addiction' to alcohol and Silence (song) by Delerium (ft Sarah McLachlan) is about the vice of addiction. Read it again, with this in thought and you'll see how everything 'simply' makes sense of the short work.
Just read his 1936 lecture to the British Academy, "Beowulf: The Monsters and the Critics", published by Christopher Tolkien in the collection of essays "The Monsters & the Critics and other Essays" in 1983 by George Allen & Unwin (I have a 1997 paperback by Harper Collins). JRRT without the slightest doubt uses allegory here - strict allegory! What he was allergic to was the all-too-widespread sloppy allegory (as he was allergic to sloppiness in anything that pretended to be philology).So he 'dislikes' allegory, but doesn't really say he didn't use it and sublimely says "its not really or properly..." (an allegory) as if it was in a way. He also says "I tried to show allegorically...". Guess the old pipe smoking compromised his scruple against allegory?
I think we begin to edge up against JRRT's feeling here. I've also read his distaste was for "intentional" allegory - adding my own words, 'the blatant kind that hits you upside the head whether it's necessary to be used or not.'What he was allergic to was the all-too-widespread sloppy allegory (as he was allergic to sloppiness in anything that pretended to be philology).
The only direct statement on allegory by JRRT that I can think of off the cuff is that in the foreword to the Second Edition, where he states his "cordial dislike" for it. There might be more comments in "Letters", but none come to mind spontaneously.I've also read his distaste was for "intentional" allegory -
...
Is there a reference at hand sir Olorgando, regarding his distaste being for 'sloppy' allegory? If so can you provide it? (Or is it to be found in The Monsters and the Critics you spoke of? I've just added that book to my library recently, and can be on the lookout for it if so.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?