• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Leaf by Niggle

I just finished Leaf by Niggle after about three nights reading (I don't get much time to read :(). Anyhow, I can't help but wonder, what is it?

I concur with most people that it is an allegory. I believe that it is a man's journey through life, death, purgatory, and heaven.

His painting (in general, not specifically his opus -- as I shall call it) represents his life. His constant good deeds throughout life -- stopping to help Parish -- are what in the end brings him to the heaven.

The point of his opus was to make himself known and remembered. He seemed lonely. His painting was the story of his life, his autobiography. He wrote it just before the journey that he was supposed to go on.

Then suddenly, death turns up on his doorstep. He comes to take him away, without giving him a chance to pack and set things straight.

He's put through hard work. He needs to prove that he belongs in heaven. His good deeds for Parish are mentioned. My only question is, who are the Two Voices? Perhaps it's Tolkien's fictional representation of God. Instead, the setting is a ditheistic place...

Finally, he gets to heaven. He gets to what he worked on his whole life. His purpose has been fulfilled, and he gets to enjoy it...

I would have to (humbly) disagree with the insinuation that Leaf by Niggle is based on Tolkien's life. As I understand, it was written shortly before WWII, so he would have been in his mid 40s....This would be too early to base an allegorical biography on, don't you agree? He still had another 30 to 40 years in his life.

The point of the single leaf leftover was almost Niggle's headstone. It told what he was dedicated to. It was even marked with his name (put in a museum). Finally, the headstone disintegrated.

So...that's my opinion of Leaf by Niggle. What do you think of it? Who were the Two Voices?

- Mike
Beorn, in a nutshell, got it right.
"...it is a man's journey through life, death, purgatory, and heaven."
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top